Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Chapter 53: Chasing Shadows

Hermione was still arguing with Ron in the Great Hall when Professor McGonagall appeared at her side. 

Ron had just reached the point in their fights where his ears had gone red, and he had ran out of arguments, but out of sheer stubbornness, refused to back down and was spitting every single fact that came to mind, no matter how wrong or made out it was–he stuck by it, driving Hermione crazy. 

“Mr. Granger.” 

Hermione stopped mid-sentence, and Ron, who had opened his mouth to say something, closed it again upon seeing the witch standing behind Hermione. 

"Would you accompany me to the staff table for a moment?" 

"The staff table?"

"Yes."

Ron looked from Hermione to McGonagall, then toward the staff table, where Dumbledore and Shacklebolt were both watching them.

"Er..." Ron scratched the back of his neck. "Is she in trouble?" 

Professor McGonagall looked at him over the rims of her spectacles.

"Not unless you believe speaking to professors is inherently a punishment, Mr. Weasley."

Ron wisely decided not to answer.

Hermione stood, smoothing her robes with nervous hands, and followed Professor McGonagall across the Great Hall. She was very aware of the eyes following her and did her best not to look affected. When they reached the staff table, Dumbledore smiled at her kindly.

"Miss Granger, thank you for joining us."

"Of course, Professor."

Professor McGonagall spoke first.

"We have heard about your study group idea."

Hermione froze for half a second.

"You have?"

"Yes," McGonagall said. "We would like you to explain it."

Hermione glanced briefly toward the Gryffindor table. Ron was watching with open curiosity–same for several of their Housemates.

She turned back to the professors.

"Well," she began, gathering herself, "the issue is that many students are struggling in Defence Against the Dark Arts because we did not learn the required second-year material properly last year. Professor Lockhart..." She hesitated for only a heartbeat. "...didn't exactly teach it." 

A smile tugged at the corners of Professor McGonagall's mouth, and farther away Professor Sprout had to cough to hide her snort.  

Professor Shacklebolt nodded.

"An accurate assessment."

Encouraged, Hermione continued.

"Harry studied the missing material during the summer, which is why he is managing the current work much better than most of us. He has also been helping students with Carpe Retractum, and he is very good at explaining things."

Professor McGonagall’s eyebrow rose, and Hermione hurried on.

"So I thought we could form a study group. Harry could lead it, teaching the second- and third-year students the material Professor Lockhart failed to cover. Other students could help where they were able. It wouldn't interfere with classes. We could use an unused classroom after dinner, perhaps twice a week, and—" 

"No."

Hermione stopped, staring at the Headmaster, her mouth half open. Dumbledore's voice had been gentle, but there had been no room for argument in it. 

"No, Professor?"

Dumbledore folded his hands before him.

"Harry is a student, Miss Granger, not a teacher. He may be talented, and I have no doubt he has already helped many of his classmates, but the responsibility of correcting an entire year’s failed curriculum should not fall upon his shoulders."

Hermione’s face flushed.

"I didn't mean to make it all his responsibility—" 

"I know," Dumbledore said softly. "Your intentions were good. But good intentions can still place unfair burdens upon others."

Hermione lowered her eyes.

Professor Shacklebolt spoke then:

"Miss Granger, I have already noticed difficulties across multiple years. The gap left by last year’s instruction is larger than I expected, and it affects more than your class."

Hermione looked up again.

"All years?"

"Most of them," Shacklebolt said. "Some more than others. The younger students lack fundamental skills. The older ones have developed poor habits, patchy theoretical knowledge, or significant gaps in their practical training." 

Dumbledore inclined his head.

"Professor Shacklebolt and I have been discussing the matter for several days."

Hermione’s expression shifted from embarrassment to intense interest.

"You have?"

"Indeed," Dumbledore said, his eyes twinkling faintly. "The challenge has never been deciding whether something ought to be done, but rather how to do it. Regrettably, even the Headmaster of Hogwarts cannot simply add more hours to the day, however much he might wish to." 

Hermione's brow furrowed. For the briefest moment, she looked as though she were about to disagree before catching herself. She had nearly forgotten–the Time-Turner was hardly something she could mention in the middle of the Great Hall, where hundreds of students could overhear. 

Dumbledore's eyes twinkled. He looked at her over the rim of his half-moon spectacles with a knowing smile.

"Defence Against the Dark Arts lessons will need to be expanded to recover the material lost last year," he continued, "but we must also be mindful of our fifth- and seventh-year students as they prepare for their O.W.L.s and N.E.W.T.s." 

Professor McGonagall inclined her head.

"Any additional instruction must be planned with great care. We cannot remedy the shortcomings in one subject by compromising all the others. That is why we have not announced anything sooner. We are still determining how best to address the problem without placing an unreasonable burden upon our students." 

Hermione nodded.

"Of course."

"However," Dumbledore continued, "your proposal for a study group has considerable merit."

Hermione straightened.

"It does?"

"Very much so." He turned toward Professor Shacklebolt. "Professor Shacklebolt has agreed to establish an official Defence Against the Dark Arts Club."

Hermione's eyes widened.

"An official club?"

"That's right," Shacklebolt said with a nod. "I'll supervise it myself. Students will be able to attend for additional practice, revision, and help with the curriculum. Those who are already confident in the subject will also be welcome to tutor their fellow students under my supervision." 

Dumbledore's smile broadened.

"Those who distinguish themselves by helping others learn shall, of course, be rewarded with House points and, where appropriate, receive bonus marks in Defence Against the Dark Arts." 

Hermione's mind was already racing.

"That would be much safer... and much better organized."

"Precisely," McGonagall said with a nod.

Then another thought occurred to Hermione.

"...And Harry?"

Dumbledore's expression softened.

"Harry may assist if he chooses. But he will not bear the responsibility alone." 

Hermione let out a breath she had not realized she had been holding.

"Thank you, Professor."

"No, Miss Granger," Dumbledore replied gently. "It is we who should thank you. Sometimes it takes a student to notice what the adults should have recognized long before."

Professor McGonagall’s mouth tightened, but she did not disagree. Hermione returned to the Gryffindor table a few minutes later, her expression distant as her mind was miles away. 

Ron leaned toward her almost immediately.

"What happened?"

Hermione sat down before answering.

"They're making it official."

"Making what official?"

"The Defence study group. Well... not exactly. Professor Shacklebolt is establishing an official Defence Against the Dark Arts Club. He'll supervise it himself, and the school is adding extra lessons to cover everything Professor Lockhart failed to teach." 

Ron blinked.

"Huh."

Hermione looked at him.

"What?"

"Makes sense."

"It does."

Ron idly stirred his porridge.

"Didn't expect the professors to actually do something about it, though."

Hermione opened her mouth to object, but no words came out. For a moment she looked offended on behalf of the professors, but then came the uncertainty, and finally her expression shifted into reluctant acceptance. 

"Well," she said at last, "it is their job."

Ron gave her a flat look and Hermione pressed her lips together.

"...Although," she admitted after a moment, glancing toward the staff table, "given the last two years, I suppose seeing the professors deal with a problem proactively does feel... rather novel." 

Ron nodded with complete seriousness. 

"Exactly. It’s weird seeing them actually do their job.”

Hermione sighed, but she did not argue. Instead, she looked toward the doors Harry had disappeared through, still thinking about what Dumbledore had said.

Good intentions could still place unfair burdens upon others.

***

Harry returned to the Great Hall with his mind moving faster than his feet.

The Marauder’s Map had been stolen.

The words kept circling his head. Someone had taken the only complete map of Hogwarts he knew of, one that revealed every person inside the castle and exactly where they were at any given moment.

It had been the single greatest tool he could have used to hunt down the thief. 

The thief had either removed a dangerous obstacle... or stolen it because they intended to use it themselves.

Neither possibility was reassuring.

Harry frowned.

Whoever had taken the Map had known what it was, but how many people knew about it?

The Marauders– his dad and Pettigrew were dead, while Sirius and Remus were both in London– which leaves the twins and himself, but beyond that… He had no idea. 

The Marauders could have mentioned it to trusted friends. Another student might have found it during the years it had been lost before the twins found it, learned its secret, then lost it again. That knowledge could have spread over the years to friends, relatives, lovers,...

There were simply too many possibilities.

Harry couldn't afford to assume that only a handful of people knew the Map existed. If his suspicions were correct, the pool of potential suspects had just become far too large for one person to investigate. Truthfully, even a team of detectives would struggle. 

He let out a slow breath. 

No–speculating about the past would get him nowhere. The thief was almost certainly still inside Hogwarts, and unless the Map had already been smuggled out of the castle, it was here as well.

By the time he reached the Gryffindor table, Ron and Hermione were gone. Lavender Brown was still there, chatting with Parvati over a cup of tea. She looked up when Harry approached.

"Have you seen Ron and Hermione?"

"Ron went outside with Seamus and Dean," Lavender said. "Something about Quidditch."

Harry nodded.

"And Hermione?"

"Library."

Of course.

"Thanks."

Harry left before Lavender could say anything else.

He made his way to Gryffindor Tower, gave the password to the Fat Lady, and stepped into the common room.

It was quieter than usual for a Saturday. A handful of students lounged in armchairs with books open on their laps, though whether much studying was actually taking place was debatable. Two first-years were playing Exploding Snap near the fireplace, while a fourth-year Harry did not recognize had fallen asleep with a Transfiguration textbook covering his face.

Harry crossed the room without drawing attention to himself, climbed the stairs to the boys' dormitory, and shut the door behind him.

For a long moment, he stood perfectly still, listening. He heard no footsteps or voices–no one coming upstairs. Satisfied, he opened his inventory, withdrew the Invisibility Cloak, and draped it over his shoulders, and only then did he activate Angel Mode.

The transformation washed through him with a familiar warmth beneath his skin. Power flowed through his body, settling into his bones and sharpening every sense until the world seemed brighter, clearer, almost impossibly detailed. 

Beneath the Cloak, his hair turned white. Thankfully, he had learned not to manifest his wings unless he wished to–they were almost impossible to hide underneath his cloak, plus they made sneaking a nightmare.

White hair would be difficult enough to explain if he got caught–two enormous wings would be considerably worse.

Harry drew a slow breath and focused on one of his most useful abilities: Mana Perception

He activated the skill and the world around him transformed. 

Harry's awareness expanded in every direction. It was as though he possessed perfect, three-hundred-and-sixty-degree vision; nothing within the skill's range escaped his perception, whether it lay before him, behind him, above, or below.

Focusing on magical energy, he watched invisible currents of mana unfold around him like a vast web woven through reality itself.

Every enchantment possessed its own distinct signature. The protective charms upon his dormmates' trunks shimmered softly. The wards embedded within the castle pulsed through the walls like veins of living light. Even the fading residue of spells cast days earlier clung faintly to furniture and stone.

Magic was everywhere–finding the Marauder's Map amid that sea of enchantments would not be easy.

Fortunately, Mana Perception did not care whether a magical object was hidden beneath floorboards, concealed behind illusion magic, or locked inside a trunk. If it lay within the skill's range, Harry would sense it.

He began searching the tower.

If the thief was a Gryffindor, and if they had hidden the Map somewhere in the tower, Harry intended to find it.

He checked his dormitory first–not because he suspected Ron, Neville, Dean, or Seamus more than anyone else, but because it was the nearest place to start. Friendship was not evidence of innocence, and Harry refused to let sentiment blind him to the possibility, however unlikely, that the thief might be someone he trusted.

He did not search through their belongings like a common burglar. Instead, he let Mana Perception wash over every corner of the room, and yet he did not find it anywhere. 

Harry moved on.

The invisibility cloak did its work perfectly. Students passed within inches of him without the slightest hint of his presence. One second-year nearly walked straight into him on a staircase, stopped abruptly, shivered, and hurried away while muttering something about ghosts. 

Harry searched the boys’ dormitories first, then the girls’.

The stairs to the girls’ dormitory refused to let him pass, of course. They turned into a slide beneath his feet the moment he tried to climb them, nearly sending him back into the common room with a very undignified yelp. Harry remained at the bottom of the staircase for several long seconds, glaring at it.

"Really?"

Not even a Deathly Hallow could fool it? Just how skilled had the founders—or whoever had enchanted this castle—been? The Invisibility Cloak was one of the three Hallows, an artifact crafted by Death itself, yet the staircase had ignored it completely and identified him as a boy without hesitation.

An idea occurred to him–he did not actually need to touch the stairs.

Harry focused his magic and gently lifted himself off the ground. Rather than summoning his wings, he simply hovered a few inches above the enchanted steps. Without his weight ever resting on them, the staircase had nothing to react to.

Slowly, he ascended the stairwell, keeping close to the outer wall. Angel Mode strengthened both his body and his control over magic, allowing him to maintain the delicate spell with little effort. It was slower than walking and considerably more awkward, but beneath the Invisibility Cloak he rose silently toward the girls' dormitory, fooling the enchanted staircase.

Upon reaching the door to the girls' dormitories, Harry shot the staircase a smug grin before slipping inside.

He searched each room carefully.

Harry was extremely careful not to look at anything he did not need to. His eyes remained fixed on trunks, wardrobes, drawers, and other likely hiding places while Mana Perception swept over the rooms. He had absolutely no desire to invade anyone's privacy more than his investigation already required.

The Marauder's Map was nowhere to be found.

He did, however, find several things students had absolutely no business possessing.

The first was love potions. Harry froze, staring at the small pink vial for a long moment before his expression hardened.

Love potions were vile things. 

People treated them as harmless jokes, they laughed about them and exchanged them as pranks. They were sold in shops with pretty packaging and silly names, like some sort of innocent magical curiosity–as though forcing someone’s affection was no worse than slipping them a sweet. 

Harry had never been able to see them that way–especially not after learning about Tom Riddle’s parents and understanding what love potions truly did to someone. Love potions stole choice; they twisted someone's emotions until they were no longer their own. 

The result can not, by any means, be called love–it was a violation of every aspect of a person’s being. 

It was wrong–deeply, horribly wrong.

Harry did not destroy the potion, he simply altered them by mixing them with another potion he took from his inventory. 

During the summer, Lily had insisted on teaching him several methods of protecting himself against love potions. Rich, famous, and young, Harry was exactly the sort of boy someone might decide to ensnare and Lily Potter, dead as she might be, would not allow her son to be defenseless against such schemes. 

His mum taught him that certain potions neutralized one another–a few drops were all it took. The pink liquid fizzed before turning completely clear, its enchantment unraveling into nothing more than harmless sludge.

Harry repeated the process every time he found another one. Afterward, he wrote down the names of the students who owned them. He would leave the list in McGonagall’s office later and let her handle it properly.

Beyond that, most of what he found was ordinary teenage contraband: steamy magazines, firewhisky and other alcoholic beverages, a few joke products from Zonko’s,...

Teens, Harry decided, would always be teens.

He searched for hours until there was not a corner of the Gryffindor Tower he had not checked at least once, and yet the Marauder's Map was nowhere to be found. 

When he finally returned to his dormitory, Harry was exhausted, frustrated, and no closer to finding the thief. He removed the Invisibility Cloak, ended Angel Mode, and sat on the edge of his bed with a heavy sigh.

If the Map was not hidden somewhere inside Gryffindor Tower, then the thief might not be a Gryffindor after all, and that made everything harder.

Students from other Houses visited one another's common rooms all the time. It was hardly encouraged, but neither was it against the rules, provided no one caused trouble. Hufflepuffs, Ravenclaws, and even the occasional Slytherin had all stepped foot inside Gryffindor Tower at one point or another. Harry himself had tutored Hufflepuffs and Ravenclaws in the Gryffindor common room only recently.

Anyone who had visited the Tower could have stolen the Map 

He reached into his trunk for a fresh sheet of parchment.

Starting with the students he had tutored, Harry began writing down the names of every third-year Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff he could remember. When he finished those, he added anyone else from another House whom he recalled seeing in the common room since classes started. The list became depressingly long, and that was only the people he remembered. 

And even then, he could not rule out other possibilities–the thief might have hidden it elsewhere or might have entered the tower undetected. 

Harry stood and crossed toward the window.

Gryffindor Tower rose high above the castle grounds, but high did not mean inaccessible.  Someone could have flown up on a broom. They might have used a climbing charm or some other form of magic to scale the outer wall. A particularly reckless and athletic wizard could even have climbed the stone by hand. An Animagus with an aerial form would have found the ascent easier still.

And getting inside was only half the problem.

There was also the question of concealment.

Harry's Invisibility Cloak was not the only one in existence—only the only one that happened to be a Deathly Hallow. Ordinary invisibility cloaks could be purchased in magical shops. There were enchanted rings and necklaces that bent light around the wearer. Invisibility potions, disillusionment charms, camouflage spells and probably dozens of methods he had never even heard of. 

Harry pressed his fingers against his forehead.

Every time he thought he had narrowed the possibilities, they seemed to multiply instead–there were too many suspects and too many ways the theft could have been carried out.

He let out a weary sigh.

Every school year seemed determined to present him with an entirely new headache. At least this year’s Defence professor seemed competent and—

Harry went still.

The Defence professor! 

His eyes narrowed as he considered the possibility. 

Lockhart had been a complete fraud, but Quirrell had been working with Voldemort. There was a pattern with Defence Against the Dark Arts professors at Hogwarts, a very ugly one that he could not ignore.

 Harry had no reason to believe Kingsley Shacklebolt was anything but exactly what he appeared to be: a capable, sensible professor who genuinely cared about his students. But that was precisely the sort of assumption an investigator could not afford to make.

Could Shacklebolt be involved?

Harry did not like the thought–he had no reason to suspect him, none, yet dismissing the possibility outright simply because he liked the man would be stupid. 

And involvement did not necessarily mean guilt.

What if the man teaching Defence was not Kingsley Shacklebolt at all? Maybe someone else was using the Polyjuice Potion to take his form. The real Shacklebolt could be imprisoned somewhere while an impostor took his place. If someone wanted unrestricted access to Hogwarts, replacing a newly appointed professor would certainly be one way to obtain it. 

Harry let out a groan and flopped backward onto his bed. 

Another lead.

Another possibility.

Another thing to investigate.

His life was not getting any easier.

After a moment, he sat back up and looked down at the parchment covered in names, arrows, guesses, and question marks. He dipped his quill into ink and added one more line at the bottom: Professor Kingsley Shacklebolt?

Harry stared at the name and sincerely hoped he was wrong. 

"Please, God, if you're listening... let me have one Defense professor who isn't either useless or plotting against me." Crowley had told him God was real, so maybe He was listening. 

***

The following morning, the Great Hall buzzed with its usual Sunday morning energy.

Unlike weekdays, students lingered over breakfast instead of wolfing it down before rushing to lessons. Conversations drifted between Quidditch, homework, gossip (especially about a DADA club), and speculation about the Ministry now that Cornelius Fudge had finally resigned. Harry sat between Ron and Hermione, absently buttering a piece of toast while his thoughts remained firmly on one subject: the Marauder's Map.

He had spent most of the previous day searching Gryffindor Tower, only to come away with nothing but a longer suspect list and several more questions than answers.

Whoever had stolen the Map knew what they were doing; that was for sure. 

He had just taken a bite when Professor Dumbledore rose from the staff table.

Almost immediately, the chatter throughout the Hall died away.

Dumbledore surveyed the students with his usual warm smile, though Harry had begun noticing that the Headmaster smiled less these days than he used to.

"Good morning, everyone."

A chorus of sleepy greetings answered him.

"I have several announcements concerning the Defence Against the Dark Arts curriculum. As many of you are already aware," he said, amusement dancing in his eyes as he acknowledged the rumours that had swept through the castle after their conversation with Hermione the previous day, "Professor Shacklebolt and I have concluded that the unfortunate lack of practical instruction during the previous academic year has left a rather significant gap in the education of many of our students."

A ripple of laughter spread through the Great Hall. Even several professors failed to suppress small smiles at the diplomatic way Dumbledore referred to Professor Lockhart's spectacularly disastrous tenure.

Wasn’t you who hired Lockhart? A part of Harry thought bitterly. He still has no idea why Dumbledore hired that fraud. Is it that hard to get someone to teach DADA? 

Dumbledore politely ignored them.

"As Headmaster, I bear the responsibility of ensuring that every witch and wizard who graduates from Hogwarts receives an education worthy of this institution. Unfortunately, that responsibility requires us to address the deficiencies of last year rather than simply pretend they do not exist."

He folded his hands before him.

"Accordingly, beginning tomorrow, the number of Defence Against the Dark Arts lessons will be doubled for every year from Second through Seventh. I should add that our first-year students will be exempt from these additional classes, as they were fortunate enough not to experience last year's... educational shortcomings."

The Great Hall exploded.

"What?"

"Double?"

"When?"

"There aren't enough hours in the day!"

"That's impossible!"

"Our schedules are already packed!"

"We'll never finish our homework!"

The noise swelled into complete chaos as students spoke over one another, disbelief quickly giving way to outrage. Even many prefects looked horrified; even Percy was shocked.  Several seventh-years had already buried their faces in their hands, while younger students turned frantically toward older siblings and friends in search of answers. 

Dumbledore raised a hand, and the Hall gradually quieted.

"I anticipated that concern."

Harry suddenly had a very bad feeling.

"Accordingly, I have obtained special permission from the Ministry of Magic to permit Hogwarts students the supervised academic use of Time-Turners."

For a moment there was complete, absolute silence in the Great Hall, then it erupted harder than before.

"Time-Turners?"

"For everyone?"

"You're joking!"

"They’ll let us use those?"

Harry simply stared at the Headmaster. 

No.

No, no, no.

Dumbledore continued speaking over the commotion.

"Each student requiring additional Defence instruction will receive supervised access according to an individualized schedule. Naturally, such powerful magical artifacts require strict oversight."

Of course they did–when you are not Hermione Granger. 

"To ensure that these safeguards are maintained, the Department of Mysteries has graciously agreed to assist Hogwarts in this endeavour. A team from the Department will arrive tomorrow to oversee the distribution, use, and monitoring of every Time-Turner employed throughout the school year." 

Harry felt his stomach sink.

This was a disaster. 

He had barely begun investigating the theft and now time travel entered the equation; the thief could be attending class while simultaneously breaking into his dormitory. An alibi no longer meant anything–someone could be seen in two places during the same hour without either sighting being false.

Wonderful.

Just wonderful.

As if that were not enough, the Unspeakables themselves would now be wandering around Hogwarts.

People from the Department of Mysteries who were experts in obscure magic–experts who would almost certainly notice someone sneaking around the castle under an invisibility cloak while using strange magic powers.

His investigation had just become significantly more dangerous.

The thief would have to contend with the Unspeakables as well, of course, but that hardly comforted him. The thief already knew what they were looking for, but Harry did not. His opponent possessed the initiative; they knew their objective, and now—thanks to the Time-Turners—possibly an entirely new way of covering their tracks. Harry, meanwhile, was still trying to figure out where to begin.

I hate my life…

Dumbledore waited patiently until the Great Hall settled again.

"There is one final announcement." The murmuring quieted. "Beginning next week, Professor Shacklebolt will also supervise the newly established Defence Against the Dark Arts Club."

Shacklebolt inclined his head toward the students. 

"The club shall be open to any student wishing additional practice, revision, or assistance with the curriculum," Dumbledore continued. "Those already proficient in particular material are warmly encouraged to assist their fellow classmates in mastering them." 

Harry noticed Hermione smiling beside him.

"They will, naturally, receive House points for doing so, as well as bonus points in their Defence Against the Dark Arts final mark."

Harry did not even pay attention anymore; he just rubbed his forehead and cursed Fate under his breath. 

Couldn't he have just one normal year at Hogwarts? Was that really too much to ask?

***

Author’s Note: Yes, Harry, that is far too much to ask. What, would you expect me to bore my readers with nothing but homework and Quidditch practice? They need thrill, mystery, action, and you suffering from time to time. 

Could someone tell me how a chapter that was meant to be 2k ended up being over 4.5K? I swear I am physically incapable of writing short chapters. I fear I am doomed. 

Comments

Aeden Emrys

I agree with your Author’s Note and laugh 😂🤣 all the way! Thanks for another great chapter! It's good to see the teachers actually doing their job and unfortunately for Harry, making his life harder, but more fun for us! I look forward to reading much more of this greatly interesting story of yours 😁!

Platyperry

Yikes, looks like finding the map won’t be as easy as he’d hoped. Probably a Hufflepuff lol, they’re particularly good finders!

Alkole

Imma be real if angel mode can be contained to only change his hair colour then it is no longer an issue cause there are lots of spells that can change someone's hair colour he could even say its a prank spell gone wrong, he was practicing and over did it, hell in the ho world even if it did give him wings he could say he messed up the animagus transformation so really it isnt wven something worth hiding unless it gives him a halo, but wven that can be explained

EdenHawthorne

Yeah, he will eventually use something like that to be in angel mode around people; in fact, it will happen very soon.