Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Chapter 64: The Butler’s Prerogative

Dobby had been waiting for several hours when Hedwig fell from her perch.

He had spent most of that time seated in the living room, a silver pocket watch resting in one hand and a book lying open upon his lap. He had not turned a page in some time.

Master Harry had promised to return before breakfast.

The sun had barely risen, and breakfast remained more than an hour away, but Dobby had learned that promises concerning the hour of Master Harry’s return were best interpreted with a degree of flexibility. His young master possessed many admirable qualities (courage, compassion, intelligence, determination, and a sense of responsibility far beyond what ought to be expected of any thirteen-year-old boy) but a reliable appreciation for schedules was not among them.

Still, Dobby was worried.

Master Harry had departed Ashford beneath his Invisibility Cloak before sunrise, intending to investigate Cedric Diggory. He had refused assistance, assured Dobby that he wouldn’t enter the house or confront Cedric, and promised to call immediately if he encountered danger.

Dobby had not believed him 

He had nevertheless remained at Ashford, because a proper butler trusted his master’s judgement—even when that judgement was demonstrably appalling (unfortunately, Harry had a near-suicidal conviction that every dangerous situation he encountered should be handled alone). 

The house-elf adjusted the cuffs of his immaculate black coat and looked at the pocket watch again.

A proper butler did not fret.

He remained calm, anticipated his master’s needs and prepared for every eventuality. His role model as a butler was none other than the great Alfred Pennyworth, of whose existence Dobby found out in one of the comics his master enjoyed.

Alfred Pennyworth would not pace, so Dobby had therefore not paced.

He had merely inspected every room on the ground floor four times, checked the breakfast preparations twice, polished three perfectly clean pieces of silver, and verified that the emergency medical supplies were fully stocked.

Then a cry came from the library.

Dobby vanished from the armchair before the book could strike the floor.

He reappeared amid rows of towering shelves, one hand already extended ready to use his magic to face any intruder (unlikely as that was due to the wards protecting the estate).

“Hedwig?”

The snowy owl lay upon the carpet beneath her perch with one wing stretched awkwardly across the floor, and her talons clawed at the rug as her body convulsed. Her feathers stood on end. Each breath came as a thin, broken rasp, and her golden eyes were wide with pain and terror. 

Dobby rushed to her side and dropped to his knees.

“Madam Hedwig, please remain still.”

His hands passed carefully over her wings, breast and legs, searching for an injury. Hedwig snapped at his fingers—not with real hostility, but with blind distress—and tried to force herself upright but her legs gave way beneath her.

Dobby caught her before she struck the floor again.

“Hedwig is not injured,” he murmured to himself.

The owl’s golden eyes found his, and the pain within them made Dobby’s blood run cold—he had seen this before.

Months earlier, when Master Harry fought the wraith within the estate, Hedwig had become frantic. She had beaten her wings against the windows and shrieked until Dobby feared she would injure herself. Every wound inflicted upon Harry had echoed faintly through the bond between wizard and familiar.

After the explosion at Hogwarts, Hedwig had again felt his distress. She had remained in the cottage, refusing to hunt and barely sleeping until Harry returned home. His sorrow had become hers, even when his injuries had not; such was their bond.

But this was worse—far worse.

“Master Harry.” 

Dobby’s expression went still. Master Harry was in danger, no—if Hedwig could feel this much pain through their bond, the danger had already found him. 

Dobby’s ears lowered.

“He lied.” The words emerged very softly.

Hedwig gave another pained cry.

“Master Harry promised to call the moment danger arose.”

Dobby rose, carrying Hedwig with him.

“That reckless, heroic boy will be the death of me.”

Hedwig snapped her beak in furious agreement.

Dobby placed her upon the long reading table and hurried to the locked cabinet at the far end of the library. A click of his fingers opened it and rows of potions rose from their padded compartments, rearranging themselves until a small blue vial flew into his hand.

He measured three drops into a shallow silver dish and diluted them with water.

“A mild Sleeping Draught,” he explained as he returned. “It will ease the pain transmitted through the bond and allow you to rest until Master Harry is safely home.”

Hedwig struck the dish from his hand. It spun through the air, but Dobby caught it before a single drop could stain the carpet. He looked at her and Hedwig stared back, then she spread her wings and attempted to launch herself from the table. She dropped less than a foot before Dobby caught her.

“No.”

Hedwig struggled in his arms, weak but furious.

“Absolutely not. You are in no condition to fly, much less enter a battle.”

She twisted her head towards the nearest window. Dobby’s grip remained gentle but unyielding.

“I know what you want.” Her talons tightened around his sleeve. “And I cannot permit it.”

Hedwig hissed.

“The young master’s present condition is unknown. So is the nature of his opponent. Hedwig would become a liability—”

Her beak struck him directly upon the nose, and Dobby recoiled.

“—a dearly valued liability,” he amended, “but a liability nevertheless.”

Hedwig glared at him with such offence that a lesser house-elf might have retreated, but Dobby had faced Lucius Malfoy; he had survived Bellatrix Lestrange many years past (when his former mistress’s sister was still a free witch and often visited the Malfoy manor)—he would not retreat before one angry owl.

“You will remain here.” She snapped her beak. “And you will drink the potion.”

She turned her head away, and Dobby moved the dish into her line of sight. Hedwig turned in the opposite direction. He moved it again and so did she.

Dobby’s ears lowered.

“Hedwig is being most unreasonable.”

The owl looked towards the door. Dobby followed her gaze, then looked back at her, with understanding dawning upon his eyes.

“Madam Hedwig intends to remain awake until Master Harry returns?”

A low hoot answered him.

“Very well.”

Hedwig looked at him again.

“No potion. But Hedwig will remain here and conserve her strength while I retrieve Master Harry.”

Her feathers settled, and Dobby carried her to the leather armchair nearest the fireplace. The flames rose at a gesture, spreading warmth through the room. A folded blanket floated from the nearby sofa and arranged itself beneath Hedwig’s body.

The owl sank onto it, still trembling.

Dobby rested one hand lightly upon her head.

“I shall bring him home.”

Hedwig gave a low hoot, and the house-elf straightened his coat.

Alfred never panicked when Bruce Wayne disappeared into Gotham and returned with several broken ribs. He assessed the situation, prepared the medical equipment, and, when necessary, went to retrieve the reckless man himself. 

He smoothed one sleeve, then disappeared.

***

He appeared beside a narrow country lane south of Ottery St Catchpole.

The village remained asleep beneath the first light of the day. Smoke rose from only a handful of chimneys, and the windows of the nearby cottages were dark. No one witnessed the house-elf emerge from empty air, and Dobby did not remain long enough to risk discovery.

Another pop carried him to the edge of a copse east of the village.

He knew the area well.

Ronald Weasley was one of Master Harry’s closest friends. Consequently, Dobby had surveyed Ottery St Catchpole and the surrounding countryside several months earlier—knowing the surrounding roads, properties, residents, and possible threats was part of Dobby’s responsibilities. 

This was not spying.

A proper butler took a professional interest in his master’s acquaintances and their surroundings, and Dobby had not entered anyone’s home—that would have been an appalling breach of etiquette. He had merely compiled names, locations, habitual routes, known magical abilities of the wizards and witches living in the area and a modest assessment of potential threats.

Entirely different.

Cedric Diggory’s house stood several miles east of the village.

Dobby could have Apparated directly into its orchard, but doing so would be foolish. If Master Harry’s opponent had any skill at detecting magic, the arrival of a house-elf would be noticed right away. Instead, Dobby travelled in short jumps, never approaching closer than necessary. He crossed the countryside until he stood atop a distant wooded hill with an unobstructed view of the Diggory estate.

No wards touched the hill, and no magical eye watched it. Dobby reached into his coat and withdrew a brass telescope.

Wizards possessed an unfortunate tendency to underestimate Muggle ingenuity. They created charms for seeing across great distances, enchanted mirrors to observe remote locations, and numerous devices that announced their use to anyone sufficiently sensitive to magic, but a Muggle telescope did none of those things—it was glass, brass, and careful craftsmanship.

Dobby extended it, raised it to one eye, and looked towards the Diggory orchard.

Broken trees filled his vision.

He adjusted the focus.

Much of the orchard had been destroyed. Trees lay uprooted across the earth. Craters scarred the field, sections of ground had been compressed into smooth stone, and debris covered hundreds of yards.

So much for avoiding danger, he thought. 

Dobby moved the telescope slowly over the devastation, looking for his missing master.

There: Master Harry lay unconscious within the largest crater.

His clothes were torn and covered in dirt, while blood darkened the fabric in several places. One arm rested at an unnatural angle, his face was bruised, and Dobby could see no movement in his chest. 

Dobby’s fingers tightened around the telescope.

Cedric Diggory knelt beside him.

The older boy had also been injured. His robes were torn, his face bloodied tho he could not see any bruise (maybe he used a healing potion or spell?), and ugly burns marked the side of his neck (they were slowly disappearing—a healing power?). 

One hand rested upon Harry’s chest, and a pale light shone beneath his palm.

Dobby almost Apparated into the orchard. Only years of survival beneath the Malfoys—and several months studying the conduct expected of a distinguished gentleman’s gentleman—held him still.

Cedric was not attacking Harry, he noticed; he was healing him.

Through the telescope, Dobby watched the unnatural bend in Master Harry’s arm slowly correct itself; some of the bruises covering his exposed skin were slowly clearing in color, and his breathing became steadier. 

That should have been reassuring—it was not.

Harry had gone to investigate Cedric’s connection to the explosion, and now he lay unconscious at Cedric’s feet with their surroundings destroyed. The conclusion was unpleasantly clear: Cedric Diggory had caused the young master’s injuries.

Quite possibly, Cedric Diggory—or whatever now occupied his body if Harry’s theory was correct—was also responsible for the explosion at Hogwarts, so whatever reason he possessed for preserving Master Harry could not be benevolent. 

Every instinct in his body demanded that he act immediately, but interrupting the healing would only harm Master Harry. 

Dobby lowered the telescope.

Master Harry had lost the fight, and master Harry was, in Dobby’s entirely objective and unbiased estimation, the finest young wizard in Britain and would shortly become the finest wizard in the world.

Any opponent capable of defeating him so decisively could not be challenged carelessly.

Dobby considered his options.

House-elf magic would allow him to penetrate the Diggory wards, reach Harry and escape before Cedric reacted, but if Cedric had defeated Master Harry while he was using Angel Mode (and that was likely the case; Harry would not enter a serious fight without using his best ace), his reactions and senses were unlikely to be ordinary.

A direct confrontation was therefore inadvisable.

Fortunately, a proper butler had no obligation to fight fairly.

Dobby opened his coat.

A narrow space within had been expanded until it contained enough equipment to fill a warehouse: potions, emergency Portkeys, knives, enchanted rope, Peruvian Instant Darkness Powder and assorted firearms waited in carefully labelled compartments.

Dobby withdrew a sniper rifle.

Muggle weapons had greatly impressed him.

Wizards dismissed them because they lacked magic, but Dobby considered that their greatest advantage. No magical light announced the bullet, no spoken incantation warned the target, and no surge of power revealed the attacker’s position.

Alfred Pennyworth had demonstrated their effectiveness on numerous occasions.

The weapon had been an awkward purchase. Muggle shopkeepers asked an unreasonable number of questions, and proper documentation was difficult to obtain, but thankfully Crowley had arranged matters through one of his less reputable acquaintances.

Dobby had practised extensively upon targets at the far end of Ashford Estate, away from Harry’s sight—the young master could get so overly worried when he mentioned some of his new pastimes, so he chose not to worry him unnecessarily (his reaction upon hearing about Dobby’s interest in funeral etiquette was strangely exaggerated. That was a knowledge they had needed to give the people who had died on the estate a proper send-away, and one did not know when they would need to prepare for another funeral—that had made Harry look at him even more strangely). 

He lowered himself behind a fallen log and unfolded the bipod. A Cushioning Charm ensured the weapon would remain perfectly stable after shooting, while a modified Silencing Charm surrounded the muzzle. He had already loaded the rifle and cleaned it after his last practice session.

One must care for one’s equipment.

Dobby settled the stock against his shoulder and looked through the scope.

Cedric remained bent over Harry, continuing to heal the worst of his injuries.

The crosshairs rested against his temple, and Dobby waited (a proper butler chose his moment).

Moments later the light beneath Cedric’s hand faded, and as he withdrew it from Harry’s chest and began to rise, Dobby pulled the trigger.

The bullet crossed the fields faster than sound.

Cedric’s head turned, and for the briefest fraction of a second, his cold eyes stared directly towards the approaching projectile—then he vanished, and a stone appeared in his place.

The bullet struck it and shattered it into fragments.

Dobby did not hesitate. His finger tightened again, and he looked for his target: Cedric reappeared several yards away.

The second bullet reached his chest, but he exchanged places with another stone.

Dobby fired a third time and Cedric vanished again.

He was not using Apparition—that much Dobby could tell even from the distance: the boy was exchanging his location with nearby objects using a power unknown to him. Maybe a unique ability like Harry’s Angel Mode, maybe an artefact or spell.

Cedric looked across the fields, searching for the shooter, but he did not look towards Dobby. The house-elf’s eyes narrowed.

He had detected the bullets, Dobby thought, but he had not detected the shooter. How Interesting.

Cedric extended one hand and the air around the orchard distorted. Loose stones and broken branches rose from the earth, circling him in a slowly expanding spiral.

Dobby packed the rifle away and disappeared.

He reappeared upon another hill almost directly opposite his first position, several miles from Cedric and no closer to Harry.

The rifle returned to his hands; Cedric was still searching the wrong direction when Dobby fired. The bullet approached from behind, but again, Cedric reacted at the last possible instant. His body exchanged places with a section of broken fencing, which exploded beneath the impact.

Dobby fired twice more, carefully observing the response. 

The first bullet passed within sight of Cedric but elicited no reaction until it came close. The second approached from outside his field of vision, and Cedric still sensed it in the last possible moment.

Not sight, then. 

Dobby vanished before Cedric could determine the angle and appeared within a barn farther north. A hole in the roof provided a narrow view of the orchard.

He shot again and observed the teen’s reaction. 

Cedric’s expression had changed.

The mild interest was gone. He now stood perfectly still at the centre of the devastation, eyes moving across the distant landscape while stones, branches and clods of earth continued circling him.

Dobby fired at one of the orbiting stones.

The bullet shattered it, and Cedric did not react until the debris struck his cheek.

Dobby’s ears lifted slightly, and he changed position again. The next bullet passed two metres to Cedric’s left.

Nothing.

A second passed somewhat closer and Cedric turned only after it crossed an invisible boundary around his body. A third entered from behind. Cedric vanished when it came within slightly less than a metre of his back.

There was the limit, Dobby thought as he adjusted his tie. Cedric could sense threats within approximately three feet of his body.

That left another question: was he consciously detecting the bullets, or was some instinct warning him?

At that distance, a rifle round would cover the final metre in considerably less than a hundredth of a second. A human nervous system could not recognise the danger, decide upon a response and act quickly enough.

Either Cedric possessed superhuman reactions, or his magic defended him instinctively, and neither possibility was encouraging.

Dobby fired again, but this time, Cedric did not exchange places. The bullet stopped in the air before his forehead. For an instant, the metal hung suspended as though pressed against an invisible wall—then it shot backwards, following the exact trajectory.

Dobby Apparated before it reached the barn and the bullet tore through the wooden wall where his head had been a mere second ago.

“Spatial exchange and some manner of force manipulation,” he murmured upon arriving at his next position. “How troublesome.”

Cedric turned towards the barn, but Dobby had already moved, and he continued doing so.

He fired from a dry-stone wall, a wooded ridge, the upper branches of an old oak and a distant field concealed beneath morning mist. He never remained long enough to allow Cedric to trace more than the general direction.

Each shot forced the boy to move, defend himself or split his attention between the unseen attacker and Harry’s motionless body.

After several minutes, Cedric stopped trying to locate the source, and he raised both hands. 

The ground around the orchard trembled.

Dobby watched through the scope as hundreds of stones rose into the air. They hung for one heartbeat, then launched in every direction. Trees splintered, and earth burst apart beneath the impacts.

A stone moving as swiftly as a cannonball struck the hill below Dobby and ripped through several feet of soil, and he Apparated away, but another stone crossed the location before the air had finished closing behind him.

Cedric could not see him, but he did not need to if he intended to destroy everything surrounding him. 

Dobby allowed the next shot to come from closer than the others. Cedric turned towards it and exchanged himself with a stone at the very edge of the orchard.

Dobby fired again from the east and Cedric moved east.

The next shot came from the northeast, and Cedric followed. Gradually, almost imperceptibly, Dobby drew him away from Harry. It was a simple method. Each attack came from a position slightly farther from the crater, forcing Cedric to choose between remaining near his captive or pursuing the unseen threat.

Cedric chose pursuit.

Perhaps he believed Harry too badly injured to escape, perhaps he thought the attacker intended to kill him.

He was correct about the second part.

Dobby would have preferred to eliminate him (after seeing Harry’s state… very few people had made him so furious), but he had already accepted that this was unlikely.

He could not kill him but Dobby only needed to keep Cedric’s attention, guide him towards a prepared location and reach Harry before Cedric understood the deception.

A good butler adapted to any situation and always prepared for the unexpected.

Dobby appeared in the centre of a small wood north of the orchard.

He had visited it ten minutes earlier, between shots, and placed several gifts among the roots and undergrowth.

Some were Muggle explosives, others were Weasley products Dobby had acquired after recognising the twins’ considerable potential in unconventional warfare, and several were of his own design.

He stood beside a tree, rifle raised, and fired again.

Cedric exchanged places with a fragment of stone fifty yards closer to the wood.

Dobby fired a second shot.

Cedric stopped it in the air and sent it back.

The house-elf tilted his head—the bullet missed his ear by inches and buried itself in the tree.

Dobby did not move and awaited his target to draw closer. Cedric did not disappoint; he vanished, and a fallen branch appeared where he had stood.

Dobby felt the magic behind him and turned.

Cedric Diggory stood less than twenty feet away, one hand raised.

His robes were ruined. Blood stained his collar, and the side of his face had been cut by flying stone. Those cold eyes fixed upon Dobby with something between irritation and curiosity.

“A house-elf,” he said. “The annoying one obsessed with Harry? What was your name? Dorry?”

Dobby placed the rifle inside his coat.

“Dobby, sir.”

Cedric looked him over, taking in the formal attire.

“You… are not what I expected.” He muttered. “What else has that boy changed in such a short span? Even his house-elf has turned into some sort of Sebastian wannabe…” 

Dobby’s expression remained politely neutral.

“Master Harry employs me; he does not own me.”

“Employs?”

“The distinction is important.” Harry had taught him the importance of freedom. He loved his young master and would gladly die for him (to Harry’s horror, when he spoke the words aloud his master paled and begged him not to, Dobby did, but if the situation came… he might break his word), but Dobby was not Harry’s property; he was his own person. 

Cedric’s gaze shifted towards the empty woodland.

“You have been remarkably troublesome.”

“Thank you, sir.”

“It was not a compliment.”

“I am afraid I already accepted it as one.”

“Cheeky little thin—”

Dobby decided that was the moment to act, so he snapped his fingers, and the wood exploded. Fire erupted from beneath the earth. Trees broke apart, flames surging skywards as the Muggle explosives detonated in sequence. The first blast triggered the second, the second ignited the Weasley products, and enchanted fireworks screamed from the ground amid a storm of smoke, sparks and shattered timber.

The explosion may not be sufficient to kill Cedric, but Dobby had never expected it to be—it was sufficient to blind him.

Dobby disappeared in the instant after the ignition and reappeared beside Harry. 

The young master lay exactly where Dobby had last seen him. Up close, his condition was worse. Healing magic had repaired the most immediately fatal injuries, but dried blood covered his clothes, bruises darkened much of his visible skin, and his breathing remained far too shallow. His magic was almost completely exhausted.

Dobby dropped to one knee and pressed two fingers to Harry’s throat—a pulse. Weak, but steady.

Relief nearly buckled his legs.

“There will be ample opportunity to discuss broken promises later, young sir.”

He gathered Harry carefully into his arms. The instant Dobby touched him, magic surged in the distant wood: Cedric had escaped the trap.

Dobby did not wait to discover how. 

He disappeared with Harry and emerged upon a wind-scoured cliff in northern Scotland, Dobby Apparated again before his feet fully touched the ground to a deserted beach in Wales and then again to an empty moor in Yorkshire, then a rocky island off the coast of Cornwall, then a rain-soaked field in Ireland,...

Dobby changed direction with every jump, crossed seas, doubled back and passed through locations surrounded by enough ambient magic to confuse any attempt at tracking.

Harry remained limp in his arms.

“Nearly home, sir.”

Dobby made three more jumps, then appeared in Master Harry’s bedroom and laid him upon the bed. The sheets pulled themselves aside, pillows moved beneath his head and a wooden case flew from the cabinet into Dobby’s waiting hands. 

Hedwig’s cry echoed from the library as the distance between her and Harry diminished.

“He is alive!” Dobby called. “Master Harry is home.”

The answering hoot was weak with relief.

Dobby removed Harry’s torn coat and shirt with magic so as not to hurt his young master more than he already was.

Bruises covered his chest and abdomen. Several ribs had been repaired poorly or only partially, while ugly red marks encircled his arms as though some tremendous force had attempted to crush them. His left shoulder remained dislocated. Blood matted the hair above one ear, and the magical exhaustion alone would have left an ordinary wizard unconscious for weeks.

Dobby’s mouth became a thin line and he began working.

The shoulder came first. A measured spell guided the joint into place while another prevented Harry from moving. Bone-mending potion followed, then Blood-Replenishing Potion, a diluted restorative and three drops of an elixir intended to stabilise magical exhaustion.

Dobby resisted the temptation to give him more since too many potions interacting at once could be as dangerous as the injuries themselves.

He cleaned each wound, checked Harry’s pupils, monitored his breathing and cast every diagnostic charm he knew. A quill recorded the results upon a sheet of parchment, comparing each new measurement to the last.

Only when Harry’s pulse strengthened did Dobby allow himself to breathe properly.

A flutter of wings came from the doorway as Hedwig stumbled inside.

She had flown from the library despite her own exhaustion, striking the wall at least once along the way. Before Dobby could reprimand her, she crossed the room and landed unsteadily beside Harry’s pillow.

Her legs almost collapsed again.

Dobby lifted her and settled her against Harry’s uninjured side. Hedwig pressed her head beneath his chin—Harry did not wake, but his breathing eased and so did hers.

Dobby pulled the blankets over them both, and for several moments, he stood beside the bed in silence.

Master Harry was alive.

He was home.

Cedric Diggory was not dead, which Dobby considered deeply regrettable, but the morning had not been a complete failure. The house-elf looked down at the bruised, unconscious boy and his expression became stern.

“Master Harry promised.”

Harry offered no defence.

“Master Harry specifically promised to call before fighting a dangerous adversary, breaking any bones or losing half his blood.”

Still nothing.

Dobby folded his hands behind his back.

“The young master will find unconsciousness offers only a temporary reprieve from this discussion.”

Hedwig opened one golden eye.

“Do not look at me in that manner. Madam Hedwig will also be spoken to regarding the reckless flight to Master Harry’s bedroom.”

Her eye closed again.

Dobby adjusted the blanket around her, then turned towards the door.

He paused upon the threshold and looked back. His fingers curled behind his back as he glanced at Harry’s pale face.

Cedric—whoever he was—had nearly killed Master Harry, and that was unacceptable.

A proper butler managed his master’s household, guarded his dignity and anticipated his needs. Occasionally, he also dealt with people threatening his master.

Dobby closed the bedroom door softly behind him.

***

Author’s Note: Dobby to the rescue! The tiny butler can be quite unhinged and a menace; I hope I did portray that well. As things are, this volume has 2 chapters left- at least that is how I have it outlined. Things do not always follow the script.

Comments

Alkole

Yh icl dobby was showing more tactical knowledge then harry🤣😭😭

Alex Delgado

Damn Dobby learning from Alfred "Double Tap" Pennyworth

Erbs

Dobby the GOAT as always

The_reader'_'

... so the long list of "good luck chucklefuck" butlers has gained another entry.