Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Chapter 29: Above My Pay Grade

At around three in the afternoon, once the lunch rush had ended, Mattheus began cleaning the pub.

Most of the tables had already been cleared, the dishwasher was half full in the kitchen, and the only remaining customers were two construction workers nursing their coffees near the window.

Mattheus wiped a damp cloth across one of the empty tables, collecting several crumbs and a streak of ketchup left behind by a family whose youngest child had viewed eating as a full-contact sport.

The front door opened.

“Welcome to Cross—”

Mattheus stopped and did a double take.

Jim Gordon entered the pub, followed by another police officer.

Why is the police commissioner in my pub?

That was the first question that passed through Mattheus’s mind.

The second was whether someone had discovered that Crossroads appeared on no property records, lacked several permits and had electricity that seemingly came from nowhere.

Then his brain caught up with the situation.

Right, Hogan.

If Mattheus remembered correctly, Gordon had led the investigation into Otis Flannegan in the comics. He was probably here to ask a few questions about what had happened the previous day.

“Good afternoon,” Mattheus greeted them. “I’ll be with you in a minute.”

Gordon nodded, and both officers took a seat at one of the tables. 

Mattheus finished wiping down the table, gathered the dirty dishes and glasses, then carried everything into the kitchen. He loaded the dishwasher, washed and dried his hands and returned behind the counter.

“What can I get you?”

Gordon had been looking around the pub since he entered, his eyes moving from the TV to the photos and other decorations covering the walls.

“Nice place,” he said. “How long have you been open?”

“A couple of months.”

“Looks like you’ve been here longer.”

“Customers keep bringing me things.” Mattheus nodded toward a framed Gotham Knights photo hanging on one wall (Frank had given him that one as a thank you). “Half the decorations were gifts.”

A small smile appeared beneath Gordon’s moustache.

“Community likes to put its mark on places.”

“So long as they don’t bring me live animals.”

The other officer glanced toward the wall.

“Has that happened?”

“A couple of times.” A few of his regulars’ kids had brought in stray animals they’d found, but as much as Mattheus liked animals, he wasn’t running a zoo. All he could do was feed them and ask around to see if any of his customers were looking for a pet.

So far, he had managed to find homes for four cats, seven dogs, two weasels and a snake.

Gordon picked up one of the menus.

“I’ll have the burger with fries and a Coke.” He paused. “Make that Diet Coke. My daughter’s been pestering me about my health.”

Mattheus glanced at him with a half smile.

“I’m sure choosing Diet Coke completely cancels out the rest of the meal.”

Gordon snorted. 

The other officer looked at the menu for a minute or two.

“What’s pizza alla diavola?”

“Infernal pizza.”

The man looked up. “Infernal?”

“Hot,” Mattheus clarified.

The officer continued staring.

“Spicy,” Mattheus added.

“Why not call it spicy pizza?”

Because it is an Italian dish, and that is its name.

Mattheus almost sighed.

“What would you like?”

The officer looked back at the menu.

“I’ll have the steak sandwich with fries.”

Then why the fuck did you ask about the pizza?

“Coming right up.”

Mattheus disappeared into the kitchen before his expression betrayed him.

He placed the burger on the grill, prepared the steak and started the fries. The two construction workers left while he cooked, leaving Gordon and the other officer—Brook, he heard Gordon call him—as the only customers in the pub.

Mattheus carried their food out a little over fifteen minutes later. Gordon thanked him, while Brook immediately added ketchup to his sandwich without tasting it.

Mattheus tried not to judge him (he failed). 

Neither man mentioned the case while they ate.

Gordon asked about the pub, how Mattheus had ended up in Gotham and whether he supported the Knights. Brook complained about roadworks near the harbour and spent several minutes explaining why the city would never fix them properly.

Mattheus answered their questions, made coffee for himself and cleaned behind the counter while they finished their meals.

They were taking their sweet time.

Perhaps it was a police tactic. Spend money at his business, make conversation and get him comfortable before moving on to the real reason they were there.

Or perhaps Gordon just wanted to eat lunch before interrogating him.

Mattheus preferred Batman’s approach. At least the man had gone directly to the questions.

When both plates were empty, Gordon wiped his mouth with a napkin and leaned back in his chair.

“Mr. Garcia—”

“Mattheus is fine.”

“Mattheus.” Gordon folded the napkin beside his plate. “I imagine you already know why we’re here.”

Mattheus nodded.

Brook removed a small notebook from his pocket.

“We need to ask you a few questions about what happened yesterday.”

“Sure.”

Mattheus sat on the stool he had behind the counter and told them everything he had already told Batman. 

He described hearing Hogan in the alley, finding him crawling away from the sewer and calling the ambulance. He explained what the man had said, how the rats had emerged and how he had carried Hogan away before Batman pulled them onto the roof.

Brook occasionally interrupted to clarify a detail, but Gordon mostly listened and nodded.

“How many rats did you see?” Brook asked.

“I wasn’t exactly counting.”

“An estimate.”

“Hundreds.”

Brook wrote something down.

“Did you see anyone else in the alley?”

“No.”

“Did Mr. Hogan say anything apart from ‘rats’ and what you called Flanneg–something”

“No.”

“Did you enter the sewer?”

Mattheus stared at him with an incredulous look on his face.

“Really?”

Brook’s pen stopped.

“I need to ask.”

“If I had willingly climbed into a sewer in Gotham after finding an injured man crawling out of it, Batman should’ve taken me to Arkham instead of home.”

Gordon’s moustache twitched.

Brook wrote something else in his notebook.

The questioning lasted another ten minutes. Most of it covered details Mattheus had already told them.

Eventually, Gordon closed his own notebook.

“That should be everything.” He hesitated. “There is one more matter.”

Of course there was.

“What?”

“The man, Wyatt Hogan, woke up a couple of hours ago.”

Mattheus straightened slightly.

“How is he?”

“Stable. Malnourished, dehydrated and suffering from several injuries, but the doctors expect him to recover physically.”

Physically, that single word carried a great deal of weight. Being tortured for five years… poor bastard. 

“That’s good,” Mattheus said.

“It is.” Gordon looked at him for a moment. “Mr. Hogan has asked to see the man who saved him.”

Mattheus frowned.

“Me?”

“You were the first friendly face he saw after several years in captivity,” Gordon explained. “You saved his life, risking your own in the process. The doctors believe he’s formed an attachment to you.”

Mattheus had heard about that sort of thing before. People rescued from traumatic situations sometimes latched on to their rescuers, doctors or anyone else who made them feel safe after prolonged abuse.

He could understand it but that did not mean he wanted any part in it.

“We were hoping you would come to Gotham General with us,” Gordon continued. “Hogan has only given us limited information. He may feel safer speaking to us if you’re present.”

Mattheus looked at Gordon for several seconds.

“No.”

Brook’s eyebrows rose but Gordon’s expression barely changed.

“No?” Brook repeated.

“I’m not going.”

“Mr. Hogan spent five years imprisoned underground,” Brook said. “You’re the only person he’s asked to see.”

“I understand that.”

“We suspect there may be more victims, so his speedy cooperation is vital.” 

Mattheus’s jaw tightened.

It might be true. Hogan might speak more freely with Mattheus beside him, and whatever he revealed could help the police rescue the others faster but that still did not make Hogan Mattheus’s responsibility.

“I’ve already told you everything I know.”

“We’re not asking you to venture into the sewers,” Brook said. “We’re asking you to sit beside an injured man for a few minutes. Considering what he’s been through, I don’t think that’s unreasonable.”

Mattheus felt his irritation grow.

Brook was trying to make refusing sound selfish. Perhaps emotional pressure worked on frightened witnesses and reluctant civilians, but Mattheus did not appreciate being manipulated.

“Yo no pinto nada allí,” he said flatly, then took a breath and repeated himself in English. “I’ve got no business being there.” 

Brook opened his mouth, but Mattheus continued before he could speak.

“I saw an injured man and lent him a hand because that’s what a good man does. I’m glad he survived, and I hope you catch the bastard who did that to him, but I’m not getting involved beyond that.”

“You’re already involved,” Brook said.

“No, I’m a witness. That is where my involvement ends.” Mattheus rested both hands against the counter. “I’m not a police officer, a superhero or a therapist. If Hogan needs comfort, he should get it from his family. If he needs someone to help him process what happened, he should speak to a professional. I’m neither.”

Brook frowned.

“He trusts you.”

“He doesn’t know me.”

“That hardly matters to someone in his condition.”

“It matters to me.”

Silence settled across the pub.

Mattheus released a breath through his nose and forced some of the anger out of his voice.

“I feel terrible for him. I do. But I’m a bartender. The only thing I can offer is a drink or two if he ever wanders into my pub after he leaves the hospital. Anything beyond that is above my pay grade.”

Brook appeared ready to argue again, but Gordon raised one hand.

“That’s enough.”

The officer closed his mouth.

Gordon regarded Mattheus from across the table. There was no anger in his expression, only tired understanding.

“You have every right to refuse,” he said. “I apologize if we made you feel otherwise.”

Brook shifted in his seat, and Mattheus nodded.

“Thank you.”

Gordon reached into his coat and removed a business card. He stood, approached the counter and placed it in front of Mattheus.

His name, title and contact information were printed across the front.

“If you remember anything else, or see anything suspicious, call me directly.”

Mattheus picked up the card.

“You think the kidnapper might come after me?”

“We have no reason to believe he knows about your involvement in Hogan’s escape,” Gordon said. “But we can’t disregard the possibility. I’ve arranged for a few additional patrols in this area over the next several days.”

Mattheus supposed that was useful, even if a patrol car would accomplish very little against several thousand rats.

He really hoped the potion he bought yesterday would do its job.

“I appreciate it.”

“Be careful when you’re outside, especially at night. Don’t investigate strange noises, don’t approach open sewer accesses and call us immediately if you see anything unusual.”

“In other words, behave like someone with common sense.”

“You’d be surprised how rare that is in Gotham.”

Mattheus snorted. “I’ve lived here for a couple of months. I wouldn’t.”

Gordon smiled faintly.

He returned to the table, collected his coat and gestured for Brook to follow him. The younger officer stood without comment.

Gordon paused near the door.

“That was a great burger.”

Mattheus looked pointedly at the empty plate.

“I wouldn’t let your daughter find out. She might be happy with your decision to order Diet Coke, but I doubt she’ll approve of everything surrounding it.”

Gordon opened the door.

“The burger will remain confidential between us.”

Mattheus placed a hand over his chest.

“Bartender-customer privilege.”

Gordon laughed and stepped outside, Brook following behind him. Mattheus watched them walk away and looked down at Gordon’s business card.

First Batman’s doctor, now the police commissioner.

At this rate, he was going to have half of Gotham’s emergency contacts in his pocket before the end of the year.

Mattheus slipped the card into his Inventory, then he gathered the officers’ plates and carried them into the kitchen.

He hoped Wyatt Hogan recovered. He hoped Gordon found the other prisoners, Batman caught Ratcatcher and every person trapped beneath Gotham made it home alive.

He truly did, but none of that made it his responsibility.

Mattheus had opened a pub, not a rehabilitation centre for traumatized victims or an unofficial headquarters for Gotham’s vigilantes.

He loaded the plates into the dishwasher and closed it.

The front door opened.

“Welcome to Crossroads,” Mattheus called as he returned to the counter. “What can I get you?”

NOTE:

Some readers (just a couple in Webnovel) have asked about moving on to the next world. While I’m far from done with DC—I could probably write another 1,000 chapters with the sheer number of characters and storylines DC has to offer—I thought I’d ask what everyone thinks.

Should I introduce the next world?

This wouldn’t mean leaving Gotham behind. Crossroads would still be open there, and the DC side of the story would continue. I’m just considering introducing a second world alongside it.

A few possibilities I have in mind:

Harry Potter: Crossroads appears in Hogsmeade and only opens there on weekends. I’d change the lore slightly so Hogwarts students can visit Hogsmeade every weekend rather than only a few times per year. This would let me introduce the world without taking too much time away from Gotham.

Fate: Crossroads temporarily closes in Gotham for a small renovation, which gives Mattheus an excuse to spend some time in another world. The arc would take place during one of the Holy Grail Wars, most likely the Fourth Holy Grail War.

Naruto: Same idea as Fate—Crossroads closes in Gotham for a small renovation while Mattheus spends some time in the Naruto world. I have a few possible points in the timeline in mind, but my main idea right now is the Land of Waves Arc.

So, what do you guys think? Stick exclusively with Gotham for a while longer, or introduce the next world? And if you want another world, which of these three would you prefer?

Comments

Delltree100

The mc have a very normal reaction and the best one for not be a new target.

Artman

Harry Potter or Fate. Naruto annoys me.

Jonathan Oelrich

I've liked it so far. But if you add a new world, I'd be in favor of your Harry Potter suggestion.

Jordan Parker

harry potter is the best choice, he could potentially learn magic

MrMunchiez

Harry potter would be the best choice for now. Fate could end very badly in many ways.

Toasters

Harry potter gets my vote! :D

Nazarickk

Thanks for the chapter