Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello, everyone. I have hammered this very important notice into the side of Soup Town’s Town Hall which I would like everyone to read

1. Patreon is moving to per-month billing and I don’t have much say in the matter

So at the start of the year, Apple essentially strong-armed Patreon into moving everyone over to a “per month” subscription billing service. You can read about that here

I, unfortunately, don’t have much say in the matter. I’ve kept the Patreon at per creation, and Patreon has badgered me to make the switch. I've delayed it as long as I believe reasonable, but since we’re roughly 7 weeks out from the 1st of November deadline, I wanted to give people enough advance notice of the changes. I’ve got it in my calendar to ping the Discord on the 1st of October and the 8th of October. Because Patreon are weird about it (and assuming I've understood their creator FAQs properly) I'm gonna need to begin the migration on the 15th of October

This post is to make sure everyone is aware the changes are happening, so they’re not blindsided by them, and they can make whatever changes they need or want to with regards to supporting me, and coincides with some other important news (see point 2 for that). But before we get to that important news, I would like to make the following as clear as humanly possible:

YOU ARE UNDER NO OBLIGATION TO STAY. YOUR FINANCIAL WELL-BEING SHOULD TAKE PRECEDENT

IF THE PER-MONTH CHANGE MEANS YOU ARE NOT ABLE OR WILLING TO SUPPORT ME FINANCIALLY, THAT’S FINE

IF THE PER-MONTH CHANGE MEANS YOU NEED OR WOULD PREFER TO DROP DOWN TO A LOWER TIER, THAT’S FINE

The reason the Patreon was until (very recently) the way it is is because I have tried to adhere to the philosophy that you very much get what you pay for. I make things so slowly (and I have a tendency to make what can only be described as tomes), and it doesn’t seem fair for me to vanish for two years and still have money appear in my account, and the per creation structure reflects that ethos. 

I want you to pledge to this because you find the things that I make valuable. You find them funny. You find them interesting. You find them moving. It resonates with some part of you, and you want more to exist

I only want your continued support if you find the things that I make resonant to you, and you have the means to support me. The notice period is there to give you enough time to adjust as you need to. Apparently, I don’t see eye to eye with the folks at Apple on that one. But, since Patreon is making those changes, this brings us nicely to point 2

2. I would like to try and do this whole YouTube thing full-time

Doing this full time was always something in the back of my head, but something I never pulled the trigger on. For the last 4 years, this was something I did on the side. I had a full time job, and I don’t create for the money (although the money is very nice). I create because I have a desire to create things. If no one was watching, I would still write scripts and make things, because the joy for me is in the creation

Somewhere along the way, people found my stuff. And they found it entertaining or moving or compelling in some way. And that feeling was strong enough that some of you felt the urge to pay me to make more stuff. Which is incredibly moving as a gesture. Especially with the last video, which seemed to move a lot of you, your kind words about it mean the world.

Fast forward to 2025. Part of why the second New Vegas video took as long as it did was because of a hard drive failure. It likely would have been out a lot earlier if that event hadn’t happened. That isn’t the entire story, though. The other half of the story is that 2025 was a very rough year. The silver lining to that roughness is that when 2026 rolled in, I left my job and found myself with a degree of financial headroom to (TRY) and take this full time

And I would like to try and take this full time

As a rough breakdown: my current income streams related to this were 

1. YouTube AdSense

2. Patreon 

3. Nebula

4. Sponsorships

I have since taken the decision to no longer do sponsorships for videos that aren’t for Nebula. I dunno if you guys have seen certain videos by Literate Machine. If you haven’t, go watch them. They’re very good. Those videos have also informed part of the reason behind the decision to not do ad reads anymore

That leaves AdSense, Patreon, and Nebula. YouTube AdSense is fickle and variable income. Nebula, in theory, is more sustainable, but that’ll take a bit of time to spin up. 

Patreon, by contrast, is much more developed and actually offers sustainable income. A main channel project can get demonetised, or may not be eligible for monetisation to begin with. It may get struck down the line and you lose a couple weeks of revenue while it gets sorted out. Or, I may want to take creative swings. There may be something I want to use that I know will make it ineligible for AdSense revenue

Patreon as fixed income reduces that risk substantially, and allows me to take more risks. Patreon will be a key part of making this go at it work full time

Part of the transition will, however, involve changing how the Patreon is structured. This is because

3. I can’t stop making tomes! (Or: how my approach to video making will change)

The TL;DR of this section is:

Will there be more frequent videos?

Yes

Will there be regularly released videos?

No

The reason for that is I’ve noticed that I seem drawn to making what can only be described as giga-projects, and when you guys vote on stuff, you also seem drawn to the giga-projects

Those of you who’ve been here a while will be aware of the 250 page script regarding the development of nuclear weapons after the Second World War. In retrospect, chronicling nuclear weapons development between the US, the UK, and the Soviets from 1945 to 1962, with a brief interlude into the present day, is a meaty project at the best of times

But this is not the only giga-project script. By my count, I currently have 4 giga-scripts including the nuclear weapons video

The most current one (which some of you will be vaguely aware of) is a thing I’ve been working on with a friend and co-writer from the world of academia. What started off as a seemingly innocuous observation about a certain science communication YouTuber has ballooned into a 4 part series, and has involved the unearthing of a conspiracy requiring the input of several lawyers (No. That isn’t a joke). Added together, all 4 parts of that single series make up 700 pages and change of script

Naturally, this isn’t conducive to a regular release schedule

To account for this, here’s how things will change:

3.1: Tomes and Mini Breaks

I’m gonna start dividing time between the large scale tomes (the giga-projects) and smaller projects. This will necessarily require removing the voting rights from the higher tiers (See section 4.2.1). As much as I love democracy, the New Vegas video became something of an albatross around my neck because it developed into a tome. 

The one currently being worked on is the first of a few mini-scripts which are in the mould of “Serious Answers To Silly Hypotheticals”. The one currently being worked on tries to answer the question of whether or not the Teletubbies would need to have a TV licence. These will be a bit more in the spirit of the Yellowstone video. A video which was very fun to make, and could be made reasonably quickly 

3.2: Bonus Content

I’ll be making a lot more bonus content. There’s things I have which are essentially full channel videos that, for one reason or another, probably won’t work as a main channel release. They also don’t make much sense as a second channel thing, because they will -- for all intents and purposes --  have the same sort of production value to them as a main channel release. So they live in this sort of liminal space

One of the things I made in between working on the New Vegas video was a quick video on Bojack Horseman not dying in the pool (spoilers) that doesn’t really meet the standards of the main channel, but is too far along in terms of production. There’s about 7 minutes in that video outstanding which just requires me to animate certain pieces. This will likely get released in October as a Patreon/Nebula bonus

There’s a lot of scripts like that. One of them is about the guy who came up with the idea of the TARDIS and his weird son, and the kinda odd poetry between their relationship and the very first serial of Doctor Who

The perk of bonus content is that some ideas will just not be for the main channel. That's fine, and that's okay. It happens. Nature of the game. But if an idea is this liminal space kind of idea, and you realise that too late, that is potentially weeks of work that just goes up in smoke

3.2.1: Bonus Content -- Snippets of the Tomes

The way I have started to structure the tomes has changed. They’re a lot more organised for one. For two, they’re also broken down into much smaller segments. Rather than try and do it all in one go, I’ve instead decided to take the most polished parts of the tomes and convert them into what are essentially sneak previews

One of the ones that would be a sneak peak of the 700 page tome is related to a certain science communication YouTuber and their videos on a certain nuclear disaster, because they’re probably some of the most well developed parts of the tome

3.3: More BTS Content

One of the old perks was letting people read scripts, but unfortunately that puts me at risk of idea poaching given how developed a lot of the scripts are. I have been advised by other YouTube creators I know in real life to amend that into something more akin to actual BTS content. This both protects my precious precious works, and allows me to diversify the kinds of BTS content I make

3.3.1: Bringing Back The Monthly Update

This one is self explanatory. I used to do a monthly update and then I fell out of the habit. I’m gonna bring these back just so I’m touching base with everyone a bit more regularly. I’m gonna propose a monthly BTS style recording as well. Something rough cut but made of things I can show people quick like in an effort to bring you entertainment

3.4: Changes to Content Style

One of the ways I don’t help myself from a production standpoint is the fact I do animations and drawings. While I can Hanna-Barbera a lot of them (read: cut corners by re-using assets and other fun tricks Hanna-Barbera used (like Yogi Bear's collar)), there is a lot of stuff which doesn’t really lend itself to animation, and animation is a massive time sink

Animations won’t go away. They will remain the bread and butter of videos. But I actually have a nice mirrorless camera that is gathering dust. My office is a long room which already has a quasi-set built into it by accident, and I have met a lot of UK based YouTubers now. Some of whom have studios, and are also looking to pool resources to have a shared creators office (like Jreg has for creators in Canada)

All of this is a longer way of saying I might start doing more to-camera stuff in order to speed up production of tomes, take advantage of my nice camera, and honestly try out new things and develop my skills as a creator in different areas 

THERE WILL BE NO SOUP EMPORIUM FACE REVEAL

I value my privacy. I built a mask. This, funnily enough, has had the added benefit of allowing me to do more Hanna-Barbera hijinks. Because it means I can pre-record all audio and essentially dub it over

4. Changes to Patreon Tiers -- Implemented 14th September 2026

4.1: Tiers will be coming down in cost:

This one is simple enough, and should have already gone into effect. I’ve shifted the Patreon to charge in US dollars (Makes sense. Most of you are Americans) and reduced the cost of each tier. Your new costs are as follows:

Cathode Ray Tube Elon Musks: $14.50 → $10

Soup Chefs: $7.50 → $5

Own Brand Soups: $4.50 → $3

Croutons: $1.50 → $1

Cheaper tiers are a thing that begins today so that we can hit the ground running for when monthly billing begins on the 1st of November

4.2: Changes to Tier Perks:

4.2.1: Cathode Ray Tube Elon Musks ($10 tier):

Voting rights are no longer a perk. This is simply because I need to be afforded the flexibility to be able to divide time between various projects. All other tier perks remain the same

4.2.2: Soup-Chefs ($5 tier):

As before (Section 4.2.1) voting rights are no longer a perk. This is simply because I need to be afforded the flexibility to be able to divide time between various projects. All other tier perks remain the same

4.2.3: Own Brand Soup ($3 tier):

Croutons and Own Brand Soup have changed orders. So the $3 is now called Own Brand Soup, and the $1 is now called croutons

I’ve divided out the bonus video content between Bonus Content and BTS content. You will have access to bonus content. So the polished video segments, and the tome snippets. Rougher cut content, behind the scenes content looking at various research rabbit holes, and so on, will now be the purview of the $5 and up tiers. All other perks remain the same

4.2.4: Croutons:

This tier is here for people who want to support, and aren’t in a position to be able to support more. Tier perks remain the same4.3: Other Changes:

The only other change you need to care about isadministrative in nature, and is one that Patreon is rolling out.

From the 1st November, 2026, payments will be taken at the start of the month for everyone who is currently signed up

For NEW sign-ups (after the switch-over), payments are taken on the day you sign up, and will be billed on that day each month thereafter

If you decide to upgrade, you get charged the outstanding amount straight away and unlock access to the higher tier immediately. Your billing date will not change

If you downgrade, you will remain on your original tier until the next billing date

Finally, if you joined via iOS in-app purchases, you will stay at the original price because Apple doesn't let Patreon's pricing tool to adjust those payments

5. Other Means of (Financial) Support

5.1: YT Memberships -- Trial-run 1st November 2026

I’m currently looking into how to do YT Memberships as well. As near as I can tell, they don’t seem to offer the same degree of flexibility that the Patreon does. The perks that you can offer only seem to align with the Own Brand Soup tier. So once the Patreon switches to per-month, I will likely duplicate the Croutons and Own Brand Soup perks over on YT Memberships. The videos uploaded as bonus content get uploaded to YouTube anyway, so it isn’t a massive infrastructure change, and for some people, it may work better for them if they want to keep supporting me to do so via YT than via Patreon

5.2: Nebula

This one is on here for completeness, and I’m offering it because it’s a “more bang for buck” option

The Venn diagram of “people who watch me” and “people who watch other creators who are also on Nebula” has a lot of overlap. I recognise that times are tough for people at the moment, and you may want to continue offering me support financially but aren’t in a position to do it on a per-month basis

Nebula is $6/month, is still a way to support me, and is also a way to support most of the other creators you’re probably watching and also like. Just something I thought was worth a mention. You don’t have to use my sign-up link if you decide to leave Patreon to support me and everyone under the Sun via Nebula instead. But, I mean, I wouldn’t be mad about it if you did

6. Timelines for judging this a success or a failure

This is a bit of a dice roll from me. I have some financial headroom if this doesn’t work out, but not as much as I would realistically need to have to run this long term

If I’ve done my maths correctly, I have up to the end of the tax year (so April 2027) to see if this operation is viable financially as a full time endeavour. It’s currently teetering on the edge of viability, but which way it will tip depends on me making certain assumptions, like the Patreon not losing too many people in the run up to and after it shifts to per month, or YouTube not deciding to nuke my channel from orbit

I’ll probably review things in the New Year (January 2027) to see if I’m on track. Annoyingly, switching to subscription billing is a one-time change and can't be reversed according to Patreon. So, if I get to April 2027 and this proves non-viable (say, my creative process is just at odds with the new reality, or whatever the reason may be), the tier system will get overhauled entirely. I'll re-enter the workforce, and go back to making things in a part-time capacity 

7. There will be some trial and error to all this

I  want the transition to be as transparent as possible, and I’ve tried to make this as detailed as I can. But there will probably be things I missed, and some things are gonna reveal themselves as things which need smoothing after the switcheroo

There’s a discord channel called discord-suggestions. It is a very quiet channel at the moment. But I would encourage people to use it as a means to share ideas and such about other things they’d like to see more of as I make the transition to having the job title “YouTuber”

Anyway, thank you for taking the time to read all of this

All the best

-- Soup 

Comments

Rory Sparshott

Well just to spite you I'm increasing my tier

Noelle Harrison

Excited to be with you on this journey! How do new moneybags get a message to you about their Moop?

Meghan

Rooting for you! Bumping up a tier, hopefully that will even out a couple cancelations.

greenguy

I dropped my tier. I used to pay you $7.50 once every... year or two... Now I'll be decreasing that to $36 a year You'll need to live with these consequences

James Verne

This is how it starts, first they’re forced the upload on a little more regular schedule and dedicate themselves fulltime, then the world finally sees the quality of their wonderful content. Someone’s gonna say Cathode RayTube Elon Musk to me in 2028 and I won’t be ready