Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

We were watching the blu-ray version of the finale, well it turns out about halfway in we realized that all 3 parts are combined into one episode. So during this, we have a paused moment where we discuss our course of action which we decide is to resume and finish the series in that sitting.

What resulted is one video for all 3 episodes, there are 3 ways we can edit this for you as a community and we want your opinion.

1) One episode, release it as is this Friday

2) Split it in half, one part has no discussion but this may allow for more content to be included ( like the Firefly movie)
3) Split it into 3 portions, same as above.

Obviously 2 and 3 allow for more videos but we prefer your enjoyment! Let us know!

I'm leaning towards #2 with the first part ending with a "to be continued" like how when episodes end.

Comments

Kevin Valera

As long as you're watching the extended finale, I'm good with however you want to release it. 😂

Azure_Sentry

For those w/o access to the full lengths 2 or 3 seem best and option 2 might be the best compromise of editing time and included content. As someone who watches the full lengths, I'd like to see it ASAP lol

732ReviewCrew

Option 2 may be what I do BUT I also may just drop the entire episode on patreon for patrons and YouTube viewers get it in parts.

Brina Blue

Could you just give us Patreon folk the whole thing the first week and then no video when YouTube gets Part2.

732ReviewCrew

Decision ; YouTube gets multiple parts. Patreon gets it all Friday

ck_sidekick

I'm down with the entire thing for Patrons. 3 episodes for Youtube.

Ratmandu82

Are you going to watch The Plan?

Konrad Dawid Wojsław

I wouldn't mind the first option, but it's up to you if you'll go with the option 2. But where's the 18th episode? Which is Islanded in a Stream of Stars (S04E18). It has an extended version. Also, you're missing a few episodes in the YouTube playlist for BSG. I've sent to you an email (the last one) in that regard. Firefly? I don't follow.

732ReviewCrew

18th episode is tomorrow! Extended indeed. Patreon gets option 1. A few episodes missing? I checked our last email was August so I will take a look into the Playlist to fix what is not there.

Martin Nicholls

I did mention this a few weeks ago so you'd know :) Also incredibly unlikely as far as full length anybody has the non-combined version, AFAIK it doesn't exist, this is how it is meant to be watched. Edited, do as you please :)

Ken R

One big final movie length reaction might be fun. Go that!

Konrad Dawid Wojsław

For some reason I thought you've missed it. The email from Sep.19th. But I see you've added the missing episodes already. Great. If you can and have time, you could list them by their name starting with the Miniseries (S01E00). Full list 👉 https://archive.today/mYgCH I'll email you one last time (I'll try to be brief), or write here (might be less brief then) if you'll add a post to comment for all. After The Plan. Because I’m wondering if youse figured out what actually happened. Dots to connect (cause SyFy mercilessly cut short the series - and ~two plots suffered because of that). The Plan has a small portion giving additional context (probably as an afterthought, but allowed me to have a head canon for ~one thing that bugs enough people). Hopefully you'll watch Caprica and BSG: Blood and Chrome when Joe has time to join you two again. Regards.

Konrad Dawid Wojsław

Just watched your BSG editing issues YT video. Split the Finale in three parts then if better. People can watch all three after the third is uploaded. And consider not uploading the Finale until you resolve copyright issues with S04E18. Tho I see the first upload is still up. I might be wrong, but I thought YouTube has an option of editing an already published episodes. Cheers.

732ReviewCrew

When you edit copyright episodes on YouTube thur submit a counter claim and they can deny it. Takes maybe 3o days

Konrad Dawid Wojsław

Not good. And I forgot how long it can be. And when fast they (robot or a random tech guy) can just click away the appeal. That's how I've lost my YT account. Overreacting algorithms during a typical login. Well, not 100% typical. I use two SIM cards. Used not the one I've logged from. So I switched SIM cards while login in to receive my SMS code. Yeaah... never do that. My appeal was rejected... with a standardized reply.

732ReviewCrew

Exactly. I'd rather edit out a bit of the footage and re submit, worse case I host discussion on YouTube and patreon has the reaction