Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Over the past month, I've spent a lot of time thinking author stuff. Like what sort of presence I want to have in harem, how and when to end my series, should I even really care too much about this stuff if I have fans and I'm not trying to be the next MSE (as seems to be the goal of half the folks in harem sometimes).

This post is purely about one shard of those thoughts: How to end Heretic Spellblade. The name is about the fact I'm at a crossroads (with a sort of half-assed way to resolve it on the side).

Do not read this post unless you've read Spellblade 6. I can't guarantee that it's spoiler free.

Also, if you don't want any spoilers or hints about future content or paths of the series, don't read this. You can get a pretty good vibe of where the series will go from this, even if I don't outright spoil or state anything.

Background

If you've paid attention to some of my past ranting, you'll know there are a few major points where the series' trajectory changes. These are:

Book 1. I had a loose plan for 4 books, with ideas for how I could add 2 more in. The idea was for each book after the first to cover a country: the Federation, the Empire, and then Falmir. The extra books would be the Spires and Arcadia.

The aftermath of Book 2. I reworked much of the plot of the series, including major background elements, and settled on the plot you're largely seeing now. It hasn't changed much, although it has expanded. I came up with the dueling prophets, the final scene of the series, Nathan's long-term arc, thematic conflicts around revolutions etc.

The aftermath of Book 4. It did really well, so I decided to expand the series to 7 books. This also cemented the series as epic fantasy, and everything became much bigger and larger. I've struggled to get away from this decision, because there's so many plot threads that it's difficult to sever them (as I know they'll trash the quality of the series).

In isolation, these decisions look a lot like the typical "make the series longer because it's successful" approach that's often criticized ("every series should only be 3 books long because everything else is filler"). That's true - to an extent - but as I said at the very beginning, I had plans for a longer series from the start if it was successful enough.

When I started Heretic Spellblade, I was in a moment of life where I was about to change career paths again out of frustration. Emperor had flopped hard. While it took off and enabled me to go full time, there are many other ways it could have gone. The series grew to become an epic because I had the opportunity, but it's always had an ending in sight.

Rather, the decisions I've made to expand the scope have primarily been because I want to make the dream "epic fantasy series" that I've always wanted to. Selfpub is pretty hostile to epic fantasy, as while there are exceptions, the vast majority of what succeeds in any genre caters to a demographic that devours simpler stuff that doesn't require much investment and can be forgotten about the moment the book is closed. Even some of the bigger and better series picking up in litrpg and progfantasy fall prey to this, with lots of dungeoncore and strategy-esque series crippling fantastic ideas with more "grounded" or "relatable" elements that drive away fans of the core premise. Hence why Spellblade doesn't really move into the actual epic fantasy until late Book 2, but even the hints of it annoy lots of people by then (the rare times I check out reviews of the earlier books - my god, the amount of whining about "politics").

Book 5 has arguably cemented my current problem with the series: it's too big. I spent an entire book setting up the conflict for Books 6 and 7, including establishing Trafaumh, Sofia, Charlotte, Nathan's godhood arc, the duelling prophets, and the threat of the outer beings.

Just listing all those elements should make it clear how much is going on. I saw somebody comment after Book 5's release that it had more plot arcs than entire other series, and I'm feeling that while writing Spellblade. This is the "epic" in epic fantasy. Book 6 lived in the shadow of Book 5 and was effectively one half of what I intended, with much of the battle against Falmir itself shunted into Book 7 so that Trafaumh could be given the limelight.

Which brings us to the problem...

A Big Decision

There's a lot of anticipation that Spellblade will end with Book 7, partly because I've said that would be the final book. What seems to be have been missed is some comments I made around the start of the year was that I planned to split Book 6 into two due to its scope and to experiment with shorter books (HA!). I posted the Book ? cover of Artemis because I had a pretty strong feeling I'd need a Book 8 due to that decision.

To further set the backdrop, I've been publicly grumpy about the genre and my current situation. This has led to me considering when and how to end the series, and probably some suspicions that it will end sooner. As mentioned in the recent Patreon update, I'm still thinking about where I sit regarding everything aside from writing in a new genre next year, but otherwise I don't know.

But onto the decision.

Books 5 and 6 were supposed to cover the dueling prophets arc. Instead, Book 5 covered the buildup to Trafaumh, Book 6 the fallout from that, and Book 7 will be Falmir.

Book 6 answered a lot of questions and is establishing some firmer guidance of where the story is going, but it's also raising the stakes regarding Nathan and Messengers. If you recall the earlier books, there were players manipulating events, and Nathan pushes closer and closer to the manipulators. After defeating Torneus, he became involved with the Spires and Imperial politics, leading to the civil war. Afterward, the dueling prophets is about international unification. But as Tarako has outright stated, civilizations still fall when unified behind a goddess.

Kadria's plan is very much one of those old meme templates, where there are a bunch of "????" before the profit stage. Even once Nathan defeats Charlotte and establishes Fyre as the true prophet, has he actually won? What about Atlas's weird meddling? What's going on with Nathan's own power?

So, yeah, there are huge plot elements overhanging here. These aren't filler or random things I've made up, but core series elements. Some of these date back to the Book 4 pivot from war between mortals to the war between immortals, when Nathan stepped above the internal conflicts.

This is what Book 8 is intended to resolve. I frame it as an epilogue book of sorts, because it will allow me to handle some fun stuff like Nathan potentially having kids at the same time it resolves the final major plot elements.

The downside is that the Book 7 climax is going to be decisive. A lot of people can already tell there's a huge buildup taking place here for a showdown between Nathan and Charlotte. In much the same way I think I saw a loss of readers after Book 4 because it was a pretty definitive win, a lot of people will tune out after Book 7, even if I end it on a tease for another book. Some people may also think it may just be a neater ending, particularly with what Book 8 will involve (although it will tie into hints over Books 4-6).

So I'm left with a couple of options for how to progress.

Path 1 - 8 Books

The "easy" option. Write Book 7 as planned, end it with a tease for Book 8, and then return to the series in late 2024 for the true final book.

As mentioned above, I expect this will see a pretty sharp decline in readers that return, as lots of people expect Book 7 to be the end and it will likely feel that way. Others will be annoyed that the series won't truly end when they think it should, particularly with the sheer amount of people complaining about any series over 3 books in the genre right now.

One risk is that Book 8 will end up being monolithic, given everything it might potentially contain, and split into two books itself. Realistically, I'd have to handle that with back-to-back releases and finally, truly ending the series. But it's a problem that will may rear its head.

Path 2 - 7 Books

If I decide to cut the series short, I think the best approach is to resolve the remaining plot elements. Unfortunately, some of these are difficult to do. And, simply to avoid the book being massive and because I want to get it out this year, there are going to be some plot hooks that would never get followed up on.

My gut feeling about how I'd handle this would be to tack on an extra 40k-50 words, because I can't imagine integrating this any other way. Unfortunately, that would still make the book the biggest thing I've written by a large margin, given Spellblade 6 ended up overshooting the mark by that amount already. I don't have a team of folks writing stuff for me while I slap my name on it and claim huge page counts, so I genuinely don't know how this might work out.

On the other hand, I'm worried about attempting this approach without expanding the book. Many of the series' plot elements are big enough to need dedicated time to handle them, and that might then detract from all the other stuff that needs to happen in Book 7 (the Spires; the wedding; Nathan meeting Adam; Deverese/Ester fallout; post-Trafaumh stuff; war with Falmir on multiple fronts; Oliver and Nathan; multiple character arcs, including Astra's - the list goes on).

Path 2.5 - 7 Books, soft ending

The source of the post title. Probably a controversial choice, and one I'm wary of making.

As mentioned above, Book 7 will have a rather decisive climax. One possibility is to use that to effectively end the series, but make it clear that while Nathan's dealt with many problems, Doumahr's still at threat from demons etc.

The problem is that it's blatantly against the theme established by Kadria in Books 1 and 4 - her plan was to escape her employer's grasp and to create a new archetype. That needs to be resolved in some way, as it's been the thread tying the entire series together. A soft ending is basically a "I'm done for now, but might come back when I feel like it." After some thinking, I want to do better for Heretic.

So while this is an option, I'd rather pick one of the earlier two paths. Either a decisive decision to come back in 12-18 months, or just a big climax.

Final Thoughts

Honestly, part of me thinks there isn't going to be anyone happy about whatever choice I make. The genre's developed the attention span of a gnat outside of a few older authors and the amount of whining about long series has made the community incorrigible, as if every single series is one of those ghostwritten monoliths that goes on until it's no longer profitable, producing a counterweight of ghostwritten trilogies with the substance of cotton candy.

On the flip side, if I end the series on Book 7, I'm worried that it will just burn me out. Book 6 was an exercise in writing something that somehow felt incredibly huge while simultaneously small. Adding an extra plot arc would be a horrendous amount of effort.

Anyway, I'm interested to hear thoughts. I'll need to finalize my decision on this shortly.

Comments

Joseph Carrington

Personally? I am so ok with 8 books. More HS means a happier me 😂

Oscar Leon Robbins

I’m going to be no help at all. I’d love as many as you want to write. I will buy and read them all. And I will happily read your next series too! There! All settled! 👌👏

CinnamonHawk263

Damn, no real good way is there. It seems to me that no matter what you do you will upset a lot of people. If you do 8 books some people will complain that the series is “long” or “drawn out” or something along those lines, on the other hand if you end the series with quick ending or some sort of half ending you’ll piss off the people who consider themselves true fans of your work because it will feel half assed and rushed. Quite the problem.

Just Add Water

I feel the frustration...the whole situation is odd to me. I am used to waiting for the annual release of the latest piece of a series. I don't understand why people are so impatient...but I really enjoy sci Fi/space opera, and those are epic, with political drama and other unpopular elements. I thought one of the neat things with "harem" was that it isn't a genre so much as a character development style. Instead of a main character making friends over time, they're finding partners/mates/cuddle buddies! Yeah...I wrote that. Anyway. To me, the series should go as long as you feel it needs to for a satisfying ending. I love epic stories, and Heretic Spellblade has become one. If you end it on 7, regardless of what that looks like, I'll probably harbor a faint hope for a sequel or two. If it takes more than a couple more books to resolve, I'll be a long for the ride. :)

KiwiHermit

To be frank, I fully blame Eric Vall and Logan Jacobs as the two most prolific trash pumpers in this genre. They are the dark side of long series books and have well and trully poisoned the well. On the flipside you have authors like Jan Stryvant with his whopping 18 book Valen's Legacy series that I absolutely enjoyed to the very end; as well as Arrand's Marvel'esque Runnerverse. I hold you to the latter two's standards so would be one of the apparent minority that wouldn't mind you going to 8 books. Edit: but I must emphasize my hope that you do what you feel is best for YOU. As I mentioned a couple years back on the haremlit fb page, I have seen too many authors that I cared about literally DYING because they pushed themselves to hard to try and meet fan demands to the detriment of their own health.

Eric Arthur Blair

If you are leaning towards leaving haremlit entirely, my preference would be to see you finish HS in all its glory with the full 8 books. A lot of issues you raised about the readers who have become so toxic they are killing the genre they claim to enjoy as well as declining revenue from KU/algorithmic recommendations are only getting worse as time goes on. If that means we never finish DT that's a shame, but I would like to see Heretic Spellblade finished the way you think it will fully resolve everything you have set up. One completed series would be preferable to two unfinised or ended prematurely. That said if there is one thing fantasy readers should be used to, it's series ending up being longer than originally planned. People who claim to want trilogies are just dumb, I have read only a couple haremlit series that are even decently developed over just 3 books. There is just a lot of ground to cover developing a distinct world with multiple narrative and romantic arcs in them, and thats not even including the level of complexity to HS that essentially nobody else in Haremlit is attempting, nevermind pulling off. It's sad watching a genre I have been really loving for the past few years crumble, but ultimately haremlit's death will be a largely self inflicted wound.

GhostPhil

If I am honest I would prefer the 8 book path, mainly because I think the scope HS is so big that it deserves all the lenght it can get. And I also think a book 7 ending just might be to apprupt with the risk of an ending that isn't satisfying. In my opinion a "bad" unsatisfying ending can also be rather bad for the whole series. It certainly happened to my favourite fantasy series. (A German non Haremlit Fantasy series) But if you think a book 8 would actually blout the story and still has the risk of not addressing all the important plot point than I am also fine with it. Though it would be a shame not to get both covers. Looking back I still remember how the 4th Eragon book released and it opened more plotpoints than it answered with a pretty bad ending in my opinion. So that would be something to avoid. But I am certain you would master any of the paths. Maybe for the book 8 option there needs to be a different approach to advertise it. (Not that I can think of a way, but I am sure there are a lot of inteligent people with great ideas in this Patreon 😊)

Ibram Skyheart

At the end of the day you have to do what's best for you. HS is the series that got me into haremlit so personally I'd love to see you go all out and finish it off with your original vision, especially if you're considering leaving haremlit behind. If nothing else you could move HS to a side project, and finish it off over a longer period of time while working on new(er) projects.

Paul Matson

Well to echo some others I think 8 books leaves you more flexibility rather than end with an overly stuffed and possibly disappointing book 7.

Ash Goetz

In my opinion this needs a minimum of 8 book. This is a epic book series. So much goes on in each book. Lots of arcs to see through. You have Falmir and don't forget Arcadia the fairies and elves (as an option would like to see Nathan distroy the demons in the desert and retake Kuri and reactivate the binding stones there.) Asta and Nathan haven't had their time. Ester most definitely needs to join Nathan and his crew. Each book has got better Nathan and his crew stronger. Would love to see him and his crew get to a point where it is pointless for messengers to come through because they will be crushed and as for their boss and partner abandoned this Domar because they can't have. Somehow it needs to be seen how they stop the outer beings or slow them to a crawl in this Domar where Nathan can manage all the gates on Domar. I don't know so many options so many ways you can go. Me personally this series has been one of my favorite harem series because it has a great story and little of no fluff writing like I said this series gets better and better as it goes reading this series feels to me the build up keeps rising because at the end of the day Nathan needs to able to repail the outer beings.

Mustafa

I’m down for path 1 with 8 books especially if you think doing 7 will burn you out, take your time with it too honestly, write whichever series you want in between cause they’re all great. Whatever helps

Bob Bryan

I also agree with everyone and hope you do go for the full 8, or 9 if you want to split the last in half like this one. In my opinion it's better to end the series in a better and definitive way then cutting it early and making it leave a sour taste for everyone but the haters. Also I'm not on any Facebook groups so I have no idea how anyone acts on there

Ryuuma

I think the latter 2 (or I guess 1.5) options will be really unsatisfying for the series overall, even if it eventually gets revisited. That said, while I'd definitely push for book 8 and having a nice conclusion, I feel like some of the issues you mention will just be exacerbated by having such a long gap between books 7 and 8. With roughly a year between releases, based on the late 2024 timeline, I worry that book 8 will not perform well regardless of content, and that can feel disheartening even if it's otherwise an excellent conclusion.

Steve

To me it’s mostly a matter of finishing out everything with the level of effort that does it justice. There’s a distinct difference between a “long” series that is just an author shitting out literature because it’s a cash cow and a series that is long enough to fully paint the picture the author intends to paint. Give me 8, give me 18… whatever it takes to make the work look and feel complete. Timelines are never a concern in my eyes. I’m more than happy to wait around for the good stuff than have constant access to subpar crap.

Vixryn

I'm really, really hoping for the first option that contains the most books. This series is epic and large has so many important details that go into it that it just wouldn't do it justice not to take the time to finish up all the hanging threads large and small with enough attention that they highlight the series as its ending instead of taking away from the finale having the story missing little bits and pieces that readers have been following along with the story up until now. As you stated there are just so many parts left, I don't see how a satisfactory ending could be reached at the end of book 7. A soft ending is better than cutting the series off at 7 books. But if I'm honest, I'd really like a book thats like an epilogue of sorts. One where we get to see Nathan finishing things up while also enjoying everything he's accomplished. Just between the resolution of conflict of the outer being and Nathan and the wedding there seems like too much for one book. It seems important to note too that letting it draw out a little more would potentially save you from burn out. I just love the series alot and while I know it has to end it feels like this epic series should have an epic ending and to hell with the haters

Alin Simionoiu

"...there isn't going to be anyone happy about whatever choice I make..". I totally agree with that. So...may as well do whatever makes you happy (fulfilled may be a better word here) without total burnout. If that means adding more books after 7 I say go for it

Bring

Don’t rush it please!

M. Ryan

Funny everyone wants to be the next MSE when his writing is on the level of Jacobs or Vall (and he might actually be one of them or both of them too who knows. Or at least use the same writing team). Sad the genre wants these book a week bland as cardboard books. Money talks I suppose so cant blame the ghost authors for wanting $. Only IMO for destroying the genre. I wonder if Amazon's Algorithm reinforces that. Its shocking when a new release from an author is buried pages deep in the book list while book a week authors and webnovel eastern translations dominate the first couple pages. As far as your books KD, you have to do what is best for you. Im sure trying to make a living on something as fickle as book income is tough. I can say as a reader who loves your work I would love to see Spellblade get the full complete treatment to finish it out. I worry, unless you are planning on leaving the genre entirely, how another (after Emperor) series not getting a concrete finish would affect all future books. That said if they stop making money....I get it. Tough spot to be in and I wish you all the luck. One of a half dozen authors in the genre I still read.

Direwolf1618

I honestly don't see how a non-rush ending could happen with book 7, sure the Falmir situation can be resolved, great fantastic, but the over arching big bad situation is still there, and it would feel... rushed... I guess my biggest concern is the amount of small threads that make this epic fantasy and how much I love it. You only get one shot at a great ending, and a botched ending to a beloved series is... uhgg, just had that in the past couple of weeks and I don't want to contemplate that for this as well.

Yawn

I think a full and complete ending would be best with how much there is to cover. The detail that you have put into this series is what made this series amazing. Please don’t do a soft ending. End of the day though, do what you must cause I’ll still buy the book(s).

Ant

You have dedicated so much work to this series and it wouldn’t do you any justice to rush the ending. If you feel the ending needs another book then it probably does. There’s other option as well. Look at what Dakota krout made, some plot point are solved in books focusing completely on side characters. You can also do it similar to a light novel with a 7.5 book that could basically be an - not as serious - epilogue, though I don’t know how it would be seen.

John Smith

I don't really consider Heretic Spellblade haremlit. If people were less quick to judge it or epic fantasy had a broader audience that's how I'd pitch it. But despite many people asking me for epic fantasy some of the horniness becomes a LoadRunner for stories like this. But those same people dislike Dresden Files for the same reason. It's a hard path to navigate..

George

I've bought and read every book you've come out with and have not been disappointed once. My firm vote is that if you think you need 8 books to tell the story you really want to tell, especially without burnout, then do the 8 books. I'd also love to see what your work would be like as a non-harem. My big thing is I'm just over slow-burn romance where the big romantic climax is them kissing at the end of the series. I like to see the relationships built up. But your plots are phenomenal, absolutely love them.

Jesse

I'm fondest of the epic fantasy/epic sci fi series overall, and the authors I follow most tend to fall into that category. Most of them with the 5-10 books to a series; though a few exceptions exist. It's definitely uncommon though.

Socratic Don

I think you should go for 8 books but firmly decide to stop it there. I think that leaving the series on a unsatisfying note will burden you with a lot of regret. On the flip-side I really hope that after finishing spell-blade you find some relief in writing outside the harem genre. It seems like the genre is just causing you a lot of stress for no real return. A writer as good as you deserves better, both emotionally and financially.

Dakoda Stevens

Let me preface this with, I would definitely preferer the 8 book route, or even 9 if that is what you need to finish the story in a satisfying way. The series has been phenomenal, and I would hate to see it go out in an unsatisfying way, but I also completely understand you have bills to pay, and that might not be what is best for you. With that out of the way, I get why people want shorter book series in this genre, the longer harem titles go on the worse they tend to get for several reasons, mostly having to do with character bloat and power scaling, but these are also problems your books rarely struggle with. I personally think this is for a lot of reasons, a fair amount of it comes down to you are either a better writer or just spend a lot more time with writing (I also don't want to judge other authors too harshly with the pace the algorithm seems to push you guys to produce at). A lot of your characters have there own things going on, they feel like very distinct characters, they can very naturally go in and out of the plot as they are needed, they feel more like actual people (The women in particular, especially compared to some/alot of the other authors in the space). Your stories tend to have a much stronger overarching narrative and focus a lot on telling a compelling story as opposed to just a power fantasy (Like, a lot of authors it feels like there books are power fantasies first, and the story is just a vehicle for this, yours have never felt that way). Few of your characters ever feel left out or forgotten as the stories go on, and you never feel like you put in more characters then you can reasonably handle. I am eagerly awaiting the conclusion of this series and hopefully the others you have started (Especially Demon Throne I adore that series), as well as your adventures in the non harem genre.

sweetbrother

All I can say is that I have throughly enjoyed this series. So if you write an 8th book I'm definitely coming back for it. This series has really been a pleasure and in the sea of progression/haremlit/ litrpg that encompass this genre this one has been a real stand out. I have always valued the level of depth and development afforded to this series so even if it takes a bit I can wait.

Caleb Rankin

I would personally like to see a full and proper finish to this series. Spellbinding was the first series I read of yours, and had about as much fun reading it as I did with the wheel of time series that I had just finished prior. I then got to see you start writing out Demon's Throne and enjoyed the that thoroughly as well, so i continued reading all of your books. I think it would be as much a shame for readers eveywhere for any/all of your series to go unfinished as it would be for say The Lord of the Rings to only have 2 books, or for Brandon Sanderson to not complete his next Stormlight Archive novel. Regardless I wish you the best.

Socratic Don

On a entirely different note, if and when you do consider branching out of Harem, may I recommend Progression Fantasy and Rational Fiction as potential genres for you to consider. There is some of overlap with what you’ve do so far, so they are potential genres to research a bit.

Jim Payne

Didn’t read the post but wanted to give a shout out after finishing 6. It was fantastic, and while I can selfishly hope to see it reach its conclusion far in the future, I’m sure you’ll do it well. Thanks!!