4.28 Take Me to Church - Hozier (4:01) (Patreon)
Content
Z3ke (Original Poster)
Hey DeadReckoning, ETA on that ninth door? I don’t want you to think I’m being impatient over here but…I’m kinda being impatient over here.
Hoffman.Judy99
Dayum Zeke, give the man some time to breathe. He’s only been gone about thirty minutes. He’s not going to unlock a magical door, walk through it and figure out where it lets him out, and then come back to this thread with a report, all in the scant few minutes he’s been gone.
Z3ke (Original Poster)
Yea. You’re probably right. That’s okay. I guess I’ll work up on setting up my little hovel over here. I’ve gotta find a good spot for that.
I’ve got some food stashed away in my storage space which means I can camp out in this place for a while. That’s something I learned from the Deadlands and The MIZ: if you’ve got access to dimensional storage space, carrying enough supplies to survive in uncertain situations is a must.
I’ve got my snacks, my water, a bedroll, and a handful of books to keep me entertained. Reading some of the History/Lore stuff should keep me from getting too bored until Dead and the rest of you guys figure out how to unlock the ninth door.
BitcoinOperated
Zeke, you kind of remind me of a child on Christmas with how eager you are. Need I remind you that you can’t live in the waystation. Just because you’ve got enough food for a few days doesn’t mean that the place is safe or comfortable.
MushroomCleric
^Bitcoin. Zeke, you’re the only person in that room right now, so of course you’re going to think that it is safe enough to let your guard down. But we don’t know that for sure. We don’t know if anything else can make its way through the Kindling door. We don’t know if anything can come through the other eight doors in that place. Hell, we don’t even know if anyone else knows about the waystation. You’ve got zero information going for you right now.
Warden_Actual
If I were Zeke, I’d be much more worried about whether the Kindling have the means to keep the waystation open. They’re a Living Story, not a building maintenance crew. What if keeping it open takes up a ton of energy? What if that energy runs low or it gets increasingly unstable as time passes?
Zeke, you might be camping out in the safest magical bus station in Emberveil. Or you might be camping out in the middle of a building that only works under very unique and special circumstances. We just don’t know.
Z3ke (Original Poster)
Yeaaa, look, I appreciate your guys’ concern and everything but you’re all operating under the impression that this is a decision you can talk me out of. This door might be the only way I can get back home. I’m waiting here until DeadReckoning or one of the rest of you figures out how to unlock that ninth door and then tells me what’s on the other side.
Gormommie
Zeke, can I ask a question without you flipping out on me and going for the throat?
Z3ke (Original Poster)
Is it “why are you staying at the doorway?” Because if so, I’ve already answered it.
Gormommie
No no no. It’s more about your whole reason for doing all this. Why are you so locked in on getting back to New York?
You said it yourself that there isn’t much waiting for you back there. You had your two friends who you said “betrayed you.” Plus, it’s clear that you’ve been enjoying Cliffhaven and Lashings. There are other cities like that we can point you too, and you said that you wouldn’t have been able to see something like that back on Earth. So why go back at all?
Before you say that the world is dangerous, I’ll agree that things haven’t exactly been safe for you since this whole thing started. But can you really stand there and tell me that you would have done half of what you’ve done over the past few months if you were still stuck behind the bar at that restaurant of yours?
You’ve had some good days over the past month or so. Actual good days, not just days that you survived. So what makes you so hell-bent on getting back to your old life?
StealthieGurl101
Seconded. Most of us would kill to be in your place.
Z3ke (Original Poster)
Hmm. I won’t bite your head off and I won’t complain to StealthieGurl that most everyone would really freak out about what I’d gone through in Frontiers. I’ll say that there are two things that are pushing me to head back home.
First, yea, I’ve enjoyed myself here. Cliffhaven was great, especially those singing rock thingies just outside of town. Lashings was a whole bunch of drunken nonsense and it was fun. You’re right when you say that I’ve had some fun, which is an insane sentence for me to type out when I think about all that’s happened to me in this world.
But New York is safe. Earth is safe. Home is safe. Well…maybe not safe safe. Outside my apartment, which has probably been rented out by now because I’ve missed so many payments, there was always someone doing the druggie lean somewhere nearby. I remember someone getting shot on the corner because of an argument. The cops always had patrols going nearby because the area was kinda dangerous.
Most people would probably hear that and think wow, Zeke, such a great place to live. Man…sarcasm doesn’t really translate well over text. Anyways, I know how to deal with all that. I know the neighborhood and the people and I know when something is actually dangerous and when it is just part of the background noise.
Z3ke (Original Poster)
I remember meeting this chick who came to New York for school. She was an international student, and I remember her telling me that whenever she would go do her laundry - taking bags of clothes a few blocks away to the laundromat because most buildings don’t have machines in the basement - she’d call up her mother and stay on the phone with her while she did it. That wasn’t all that strange to me because I know people call their parents for all kinds of reasons.
What got me was that she’d stay on the call when she got on the subway and tell her mother each stop that they hit. She was so nervous about traveling throughout New York City that she needed her mom on the phone with her, even though her mother was literally half a world away. And she was living on the Upper West Side, where half the people on the block are families pushing strollers or taking their little Shiba Inu’s out for a walk.
That wasn’t my take on New York. I’ve always been more comfortable with the seedier aspects of the city and the stuff that makes everyone else nervous. I thought I was really comfortable with that kind of danger until I got here and had animals trying to eat my face and gangsters trying to mug me and cults trying to sacrifice me. I guess I had an inflated view of my own street smarts.
Still, I know cities. I know the rougher parts of them and I know how to make my way through them. If I went back to New York, I know I wouldn’t have to deal with almost killing myself by activating glyphs I don’t understand, or dealing with attacks by THREE kaiju-sized monsters, or some psycho who can hop between bodies, or cults, or Mad Max Villains, or pirates. I could just go back to my normal life.
Z3ke (Original Poster)
There’s another reason for why I wanna go back and it doesn’t have anything to do with safety. I’ve been wondering whether I should say this out loud or not but…fuck it. You’ve all heard worse from me by now.
I want to go back home so I can rub it in the faces of my “friends.” Those air quotes are very much intentional.
Alan and Jessica. I think about them more than I’d like to admit. It’s not in a sad and pining way. It’s more that I’ll be doing something and they suddenly show up in my thoughts. I’ll be walking along the road and my brain will be like huh, I wonder what Alan would say about this. Or I’ll see something and think about what Jessica would be saying if she were standing there next to me.
I can still picture their faces and I can still remember the stupid inside jokes that we all shared. Sometimes I’ll be doing something and think that it would make a great story to tell them before I remember that, oh yea, that’s not a thing anymore.
They promised that they’d be there for me and that I could count on them, and the first time it actually mattered they broke that promise instantly. Not eventually. Not after some long time where our friendship faded and things fell apart. Instantly. Immediately. Like that promise was nothing but words.
If I make it back to New York…when I make it back to New York, I’m not gonna reach out to either one of them. This isn’t some sort of fantasy where we hug it out and everything is magically okay. I don’t want an apology and, honestly, it wouldn’t mean much to me anyways. But I do have this stupid, petty little fantasy where one of them eventually looks me up. Maybe they check out my Instagram or they run into someone we both know and they find out I’m alive. They find out I’m doing fine and they realize that I built an entirely new life without them.
And just for a second, I want them to understand what they did. I want them to realize that they’re terrible people. I want them to realize that the person they thought they were and the person they actually turned out to be aren’t the same thing, and there is a huge fucking gap between those two people.
That’s it. That’s the entire fantasy. I don’t need them to apologize and I don’t need them back in my life. I just want them to feel it for a moment. And staying in this waystation means that that moment can still happen. If I walk away from it now, it’ll feel like abandoning the first piece of evidence that my old life might still be reachable.
MushroomCleric
Well…dayum. Okay. You do you Zeke.
SomePeopleCallMe_Maurice
Yeaaaa…I’m not going to touch that. Instead, I’ll focus on what Warden said and remind you that having some snacks and a bedroll only solves ONE of the problems with staying in the waystation.
We still don’t know whether that room is safe to sleep in. We don’t know if someone can make their way from outside while you’re passed out on the floor. And we still don’t know if the Kindling can keep that place up and running for days.
Shooshy-Usher
Everyone here is treating Zeke like he’s stupid and/or reckless, or like he’s ignoring the risks because he doesn’t understand them.
That’s not what’s happening. He’s scared to leave because that glowing green door is the first real lead he’s got about getting back home. If he leaves through any of the other eight doors and the waystation up and disappears on him, then from his perspective he’s lost his one shot at getting home. That’s not an irrational fear, it is something completely and entirely human.
StoryLeech
Fair. If I were in his position and someone showed me a door that might lead home, I don’t think I’d be in a hurry to walk away from it either. Can we figure out whether he should be scared of that happening? Let’s see if leaving means losing the door?
DeadReckoning
Fantastic timing!
DeadReckoning
Good news Zeke! I’ve got something that will help. I tested another of the doors and this one led out near Lakspur. I checked the map and everything, meaning that the waystation DOES act like a fast-travel network.
But that’s not all I did. Getting to Lakspur wasn’t the hard part. It’s the getting back to the waystation that you’re worried about, right? So I went ahead and tested it.
I walked into Lakspur and wandered for a bit before heading back out to where the kindling dumped me. My minimap was still turned off and I got properly lost once again, and it happened. The Kindling showed up, surrounded me, and opened a door.
The best part about all this is that I didn’t have to go back to that one patch of forest where I found the Kindling the first time. They trigger across a broad section of the map. I don’t have the boundaries mapped out yet - and that is something the rest of the forum can work on - but the takeaway is that as long as you’re in the right general area and you get lost, the Kindling will be there. This isn’t a one-time fluke.
DeadReckoning
One thing I didn’t do was unlock that ninth door you’re talking about. Whatever got you that door is still unique to your version of the game. There are a couple ideas I want to try, but until one of them pans out I think you should do what everyone else is saying and get your ass to Lakspur, get a hotel, get some real food, and wait for us all to solve this for you.
Hambones
| wait for us all to solve this for you. |
Yeaaa…I wouldn’t bet money on anyone cracking that tonight.
Z3ke (Original Poster)
Good to know. But I still don’t like the idea of leaving this door alone.
L7GobstonesSupreme
Nobody’s asking you to like it. We’re just asking you to recognize that you don’t have to suffer at the waystation to prove you’re serious about getting home.
AnywayHeresWonderwall
Be honest about the scale of work that we’re all going to do, Zeke. We need to figure out why you’re seeing nine doors and not the eight the rest of us are seeing. That’s not a five-minute puzzle to be worked out.
ReCoil44
To put it more precisely, we’ll need to isolate the variables that differ between DeadReckoning’s playthrough and Zeke’s actual circumstances, determine which of those variables are causally relevant rather than incidental, and only then assess whether the ninth doorway is even reproducible under controlled conditions.
StoryLeech
Jeezus…Zeke, if you want a translation, this is what ReCoil said: blah blah blah, what Wonderwall said but with more words.
Dead has a shit ton of stuff to test out and none of it is going to be done in the next twenty minutes.
Z3ke (Original Poster)
I get that. That’s why I want to be here for it. If the door works, I won’t want to find out while I’m sitting in a hotel room in Lakspur.
Gormommie
But you shouldn’t be staying there. Imagine that Dead and the rest of us spend the next three days trying to unlock the door. That means you’re going to eat through three days of emergency rations. Then imagine that we finally unlock the door and find out it leads to somewhere useless. OR dangerous. Congrats, you didn’t achieve anything except wasting three days of your emergency supplies.
We’ve got no idea how long you need that food to last. All this time in the Fracture-verse and you’ve learned preparation, but you seem to forget that preparation sometimes isn’t enough. Whenever you think you’ve got a handle on things, that’s when this verse finds new and creative ways to mess with you.
The better idea is to spend your time resting and relaxing and prepping for what comes next, not just sitting there and checking your Tech Slate every few minutes.
ReCoil44
This is a straightforward resource-management problem. You possess a finite quantity of emergency provisions. DeadReckoning possess an effectively unlimited supply of attempts, since his failures cost him nothing more than a reload. There is very little strategic justification for you burning through a finite resource while he spends a renewable one on your behalf. Preserve your supplies. Get a bed and a meal in Lakspur. Let those capable of experimenting safely do the experimenting.
SpicyShoyu
Ew. Agreeing with ReCoil feels like I’m encouraging him.
Z3ke (Original Poster)
Fine. I’ll get to a hotel. What door was Lakspur behind, Dead?
DeadReckoning
It’s the third one on the left. Put your back to the Kindling door and count from there.
***
THREAD: Kindling Door -- THEORYCRAFTING THREAD
USER: Plethora
Plethora (Original Poster)
I started this theorycrafting thread for the Kindling door and what is behind it so we can argue without it getting buried under forty pages of people asking whether Zeke is okay in the main thread. This is specifically for working out what the ninth door is, what might have triggered it, and anything else remotely useful that people can bring to the table.
C0daCreator
What would Zeke do without Plethora?
CrushDaddyXx
Have more fun. Get more loot. Set off more explosions. I don’t see the problem with the arrangement we’ve already got.
NullSigil
Crush, what are you doing here? This is supposed to be a theory thread, not the anarchist cookbook.
CrushDaddyXx
I’m trying to contribute. The way I see it, the ninth door showed up because Simon Pucco killed a Living Story, which means the obvious next step for all of us is to figure out HOW he did it and then kill another one. If we’re going to start testing Living Story death mechanics, is there anyone better?
HollowHeartsClub
Before we get into that, we need a name for this thing. I don’t want to keep calling it the ninth door. That seems too…weak.
SoluneX
| we need a name for this thing. |
Super Wolf Gorilla Bear.
SignalLoss
BOOOO!!! That was only in the Funimation version and you know it.
DeadMienWalking
How about the Weigh Station? It works because it’s a waystation AND because Zeke has spent so much of his story talking about weight. Waystation. Weigh Station. It works on two levels and I refuse to apologize about how pleased I am with myself for coming up with that.
Footballish
Or we can just call it the Kindling door and stop trying to come up with punny names. We’ve already got enough terminology in this game to keep track of.
HexaDeweyDecimal
Hey Plethora, I know you said that this thread was meant to keep the theorizing away from asking about whether or not Zeke is okay. I’m cool with that. But with that in mind…does anyone else think that Zeke isn’t okay? He seemed a little off when he found the door and it was suggested that it could lead him home.
GamerGamer
I uhhh, may be off the mark on this one, but I think that Persona is starting to affect Zeke. My theory is that this forum wants him to be this “storybook hero” so badly and is forcing him into that role to gain information that Persona is transforming him into one. That’s why he’s bouncing back so fast from nearly dying. Heroes encounter near death experiences all the time and don’t get traumatized, so Zeke’s Persona won’t let him either.
Plethora
^Gamer. That’s been my thinking too, all the way back in the Under-MIZ. Persona is actively changing Zeke. But for the purposes of this thread, we’re going to assume that we can still help him and Persona isn’t going to suddenly turn him into a crazy person. That means our immediate goal is to understand what we’re dealing with with the ninth door and, ideally, figure out how to get him back home.
Village_idiot
| get him back home. |
Won’t he be too scarred for normal life? Also, how would all his magic and skills work, do they just disappear or does he just manifest a Fracture even in our reality?
Hidden_Boss
Maybe Zeke getting home is the Fracture event.
Thestralbiege
OH. SWEET. MOTHER. MARY. AND JOSEPH. I FIGURED OUT WHAT WE SHOULD CALL THE NINTH DOOR.
It shall, henceforth, be known as…the Ember veil.
LET ME FINISH!!!
NullSigil
?? Uh, I guess we’re supposed to let Thestral finish?
Thestralbiege
I’m too excited. This is huge. This is mega big. Okay. Okay. Follow alone. We’re all thinking that Zeke started this fanfic to guide us to small bits of lore that this community missed out on, right? It’s how we got the House of Seasons and the Rank 11 in Pathfinding. Well, I think that this particular discovery is even bigger than that. Think about it, why is the game called Emberveil in the first place?
I don’t know a lot of people on this forum who have posited that particular question. Seriously, we’ve all picked apart this entire series down to the individual pixel. We’ve datamined cut dialogue, cross-referenced item flavor text between games, reconstructed unused questlines, and built entire wiki pages about throwaway environmental details that nobody at Severance ever expected anyone to notice. But somehow, through all that glorious nerd fandom, none of us ever stopped to ask the most basic question: what does the name Emberveil actually mean?
Opening my Steam library, I can see tons of other games that I know where their name comes from. Control is because of the Federal Bureau of Control. Skyrim is because the game takes place in the Skyrim province of Tamriel. Mass Effect is because of the fictional mechanism that makes faster-than-light travel possible, and it’s fundamental to the setting and the entire story. Those titles aren’t just random words that sound cool; they point towards something important about the world.
So what is Emberveil pointing at? Break the word down. Ember. Veil. An ember is what is left of a fire, or something that hasn’t completely gone out yet, while a veil is something that covers, separates, or hides what lies behind it. Put those concepts together and you’ve got something interesting.
Look at what Zeke just found. We’ve got a hidden door tucked behind another hidden door, and it was found by searching for a Living Story that is called THE KINDLING.
Kindling. What is kindling? It isn’t the fire itself; it’s the material you prepare so that a fire can actually start. You’ve got the tinder which gets the spark. You’ve got the Kindling which grows the fire. And then you’ve got the fuel which burns. And how did Zeke describe the Kindling? He called them lightning bugs. You know what is another name for lightning bugs? That’s right. FIRE flies. BOOM!
This is insane. THIS IS AMAZING! ZEKE HAS DONE IT AGAIN!!!
StoryLeech
Ugh, hang on. I need to process this because I was NOT expecting this thread to turn into a title analysis at two in the morning. Can you walk me through your argument one more time, but this time be less freaking out when you do it?
Thestralbiege
I think the game’s title is describing this hidden door. It’s been sitting there in plain sight for all these years, and nobody thought to question the name of the game because it just sounded like a cool fantasy world.
Zeke “accidentally” found the literal thing the entire game was named after, which means that this waystation isn’t just A secret location. It’s THE secret location.
Blazer66
This Kindling hole grows ever deeper and more dramatic.
SignalLoss
Eew. Don’t call it a Kindling hole.
MangoChutney
Hmm. Thestral has done one of two things. He’s either come up with the most interesting theory that this forum has seen in a while. OR, he’s at the end of a three-day study session and has become completely detached from reality. I can’t tell which one it is.
ReCoil44
I want to introduce the appropriate amount of skepticism into this thread before this theory becomes unquestioned canon within the next hour, because as it stands this forum possesses a frankly astonishing talent for converting an intriguing coincidence into doctrine.
Titles are not always load-bearing. Sometimes a word simply sounds evocative and it is selected for that reason alone. That said, I will concede that Emberveil is unusually precise when considered alongside the recent discovery of that ninth door. The recurrence of fire-related terminology, the Kindling’s apparent role in revealing the waystation, and something concealed behind an existing layer makes the coincidence considerably more interesting. I am not prepared to fully endorse Thestral’s theory as fact, but I am equally unwilling to dismiss it.
Plethora (Original Poster)
I’m okay with calling it the ember veil. Now that that is decided, here is my read of the situation: the working theory is that the door exists because of whatever Simon Pucco did to the Krill Kraken. I’m not concerned with that the Krill Kraken died so much as how it died. We already know that Living Stories can be killed. It’s happened in-game before, mostly after brutal fights. I’m interested more in what happened afterwards. I think whatever Simon Pucco did not only killed the Living Story, but it unlocked that ninth door.
To test that out we need to have Dead and everyone else who has unlocked the Kindling encounter kill a Living Story. It doesn’t need to be anything exotic. Just go after whatever is accessible and reasonably survivable. Once that is done, go straight back t the waystation and check whether a normal kill produces the ember veil. If it does, great. That mystery is solved. If it doesn’t, and my guess is that it won’t, that tells us the door isn’t about killing a Living Story so much as figuring out what else we need to do to them.
OreganoTrail
Already ahead of you on that. A few of us have ran DeadReckoning’s method before this thread went up. As for myself, I’m getting exactly what he did which is the eight doors. Nobody I’ve talked to has seen a ninth.
I’m making my way towards the TKTK, because that is the easiest Living Story to kill. I’ll update you all when I get the chance.
Plethora
Now for something that I am more concerned about, other than just killing Living Stories. Zeke described the glow on the ember veil as sitting only on the bottom left-hand side of the frame. NOT the whole thing and not spread across it in the way you’d expect if the ember veil was a fully-formed doorway. He mentioned a small patch of glowing just off to one side.
That description bothers me because it might mean that the ember veil isn’t fully unblocked. Going by game design, if the door was completely unlocked and acted like a fully functional passage, then I would expect the glow to take over the entire doorway. What Zeke described sounds less like a finished door and more like something only partially formed.
Which raises the uncomfortable possibility that this isn’t a one-and-done thing. If Simon Pucco killing the Krill Kraken only accounted for a small glowing patch, unlocking the whole of the doorway might mean doing it again and again. Possibly several times, and possibly each one needing to happen in whatever way actually feeds the ember veil.
TableFlip_DM
:: his eyes go wide in recognition about what this means. ::
Oh. This is brilliant. This is amazing. I fully buy into your theory about killing Living Stories not being the only thing that Zeke would need to do to fully unlock the ember veil, Plethora. The problem we’re facing is that we don’t know exactly what Zeke would need to do to kill those Living Stories.
But do you know who would? There is a group in Emberveil that has boatloads of information about Living Stories. There is a group that has more equipment and more actual magical knowledge than this entire forum could put together with a year of dedicated digging. And it just so happens that they are currently holding an auction in Lakspur, the very city that Zeke is headed towards.
That’s right, I’m talking about the Collectors.
I know everyone was against the original heist idea that Warden and I thought up, back when you all thought we were doing it just for shits and giggles. But now think about what it means.
Zeke goes to the auction. He looks around, same as he did in Lashings, and he uses his ridiculous protagonist powers to pull him towards the right object in the right room that will allow him to do whatever Simon Pucco did to the Krill Kraken. Not only is he a protagonist, but he has that Luck 11 going for him. Remember when he was attacked by the Hemocyte Swarm and he grabbed one of their lenses and then used it to unlock the puzzle for the Witness Chambers?
That’s right, Zeke will drop some tidbits about whatever object or ritual or whatever we need to unlock the ember veil. We just need to get him to the auction.
He doesn’t even have to have his character know that it would kill a Living Story. All he needs to do is get to the auction, give us a list of objects that look interesting to him, and then we start running tests on them. We attack Living Stories with whatever object or ritual or whatever he has on hand, we get an answer on how to unlock the ember veil, and we win.
CrushDaddyXx
Oooo. I like it. Zeke goes to the auction to find the WMD and then uses it to kill more Living Stories. It’s got everything we all want. Puzzles. Action sequences. A heist - for TableFlip to salivate over. I’m in.
But we can’t go in half-cocked. We need a plan and we need a strategy. You can’t just send Zeke in with half a formed idea and hope for the best.
StoryLeech
… Crush and Table, working together. This is going to go bad.