Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Decide who wins!

  • Grand Elder 22
  • Elder Mo 209
  • Amber 140
  • 2023-06-12
  • 371 votes
{'title': 'Decide who wins!', 'choices': [{'text': 'Grand Elder', 'votes': 22}, {'text': 'Elder Mo', 'votes': 209}, {'text': 'Amber', 'votes': 140}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 6, 12, 15, 37, 14, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 371}

Content

Who should claim the spirit forge masters inheritance?

Note whoever is picked won't join Ashlock's gang on Red Vine Peak. They will go back with the Redclaws and stay at the White Stone Palace. However, they may eventually end up moving into a specially-made forge in the mountain or something.

Let me give a run down of the candidates:

The Grand Elder: Already in the Star Core Realm. Realistically most likely to conquer the inheritance as he is the one who has contemplated the mysteries of the universe the longest.

Elder Mo: A man who has experienced a second wind in life due to Ashlock and is a big fan of the Ashfallen Sect. Currently in the 9th stage of the Soul Fire Realm and has the chance of ascending to the Star Core Realm within the pocket realm.

Amber: Young Genius of the Redclaws. Somewhere in the mid stages of the Soul Fire Realm with a lot of future potential. Feels inferior to Stella and Diana due to her slower growth.

Currently, my personal choice would be Elder Mo... but I shall let my Patreons decide! Also, feel free to discuss in the comments. The result of this poll will not determine the winner, as I will also take your comments into consideration.

Comments

Thomas Underwood

Amber feels like she would grow to be the redclaws representative in the ashlock sect and the grand elder needs to be a powerhouse not a crafter

Jaxon

Elder mo cuz he would be the most loyal one

TheFallingWhale

The grand elder and elder mo both feel like combat junkies where as amber would probably do well ad a crafter

Wanderer of Worlds

The Grand Elder has been introduced as a very experienced fighter, with centuries of combat experience. Having him become a crafter all of a sudden would be weird. Elder Mo is similar. He is already very set with is experience, and in the last chapter, has been confirmed to be very skilled in combat, so much so, that he can keep up with the Grand Elder. But due to him not yet attaining a Star Core, he should still be more flexible than the Grand Elder. And as mentioned, he is currently very in favor of the Ashfallen Sect, which would be very helpful. Amber, with her being described as a Genius and her lower stage in the Soul Fire Realm would probably be the best choice, since she should be able to adapt to the technique the best. Her feelings of inferiority could also change into competitiveness, which could help her Cultivation and her understanding of the technique. She would be the best choice in my opinion.

Kenneth Welever

I originally chose elder mo because he is the most logical choice but the most advantageous for the redclaws would be Amber since she is the youngest and has the most room and time to grow into this inheritance without taking a hard left to the far greater powers of the elders. Also the elders are more experienced fighters and having the least experienced combatant become a powerful crafter would benefit all sides.

ReadingObsessed

I can see a twist where the inheritor has to be a woman cause the creator was a misogynist.

phantom

Did not realize Elder Mo was only at the soulfire realm. I would put it between Elder Mo and Amber. I personally voted Elder Mo because he seems like he would like to settle down. The grand elder has too many other responsibilities to be a crafter. honestly I would say this would hurt him grabbing the inheritance of something he was not meant to be. Though that also makes a good case for Amber. Amber does not seem interested in crafting (though she does not seem uninterested either.) and she is young so she can still choose her path. At the same time it would be forcing a path that may not be suited so still voted for Mo.

phantom

Elder Mo being experienced at combat I don't think makes him unsuited to be a crafter. Who knows it could be why he never got to the star realm as I doubt he ever had much a chance to learn crafting with how demonic sects are. Oh yeah ones like the metal one have crafters but they also have tons and tons of money to throw around.

Human2849

Do you mean a misandrist? If the creator of the inheritance was a misogynist then why would they allow the inheritor be a woman?

Putrescent Ego

Man I don't wanna decide sheet like this you choose

Human2849

I was also thinking that Amber, being younger and less set in her ways, would be more receptive to a new viewpoint and accept the inheritance sooner. As a fan I like Elder Mo so I wouldn't mind him getting the inheritance, but I still think that practically Amber would probably be more ideal for it. Although, if Elder Mo gets it I'd assume he'd take a personal disciple to teach some of the inheritance, maybe he chooses Amber? So they both become crafters?

Demon Fire

It's funny how everyone put what they really think in the comments, but not on the vote... Most of y'all say amber as she is the most best person to choose in my opinion, & y'all's, but it doesn't reflect on the vote it seems 🤷🤷

Gonvas

For me is Amber. Is not a matter of talent or affinity but sheer determination and concentration to learn the ways of spirit forge. The impression I got is that the 2 elders are more battle oriented and are only after this from greed because it's from a powerhouse. I feel like that is not enough to learn this new art. They may feel subconsciously that this isn't something right for them, they know they have good positions and power even without this art and it will make them unable to go all-in to learn this art. Amber is young, gave me the impression to be the character more open to become a crafter instead of a fighter, more easy to become something else, ... Same greed as the other two but I think she has the greater determination to become something more, to be useful, that hunger to go after a big goal, ...

Basically God

Personally I don't mind if the winner becomes a part of ashfallen or something akin to a middle man.

Sancturillore -- Élie Simard-Wallot

To quote my comment from the latest chapter: "I hope Elder Mo will win. Like the Grand Elder, Mo is more experienced and knowledgeable than Amber. And Mo definitely feels determined to finally improve and progress than anyone else here. Also, he feels a debt of gratitude to the Tree, and the only way he can give back to the Tree to fulfill that debt is to become much stronger and more importantly more useful to the Tree. This inheritance is one such opportunity."

Valderan

Yep, Elder Mo is a solid choice but I went with Amber because her sense of identity isn't set yet. If Mo gets it it will be a new chapter in his life but he would need to abandon much of his current duties which benefit the Redclaws greatly. If the Elder gets it he would have to stop being the Grand Elder to take advantage of it, or just squander its gift. Amber is the only one in my mind who could grow into the role and fully utilize the inheritance on its own terms.

Sancturillore -- Élie Simard-Wallot

Elder Mo's expertise shown so far isn't combat. While he is indeed very good at combat, his greatest strength shown in the story so far is his capabilities as a nurturer of the young generations. As a teacher. It could very well be that he has a talent as a crafter, but simply never got to know about it due to not trying it in the past (and not having had resources to try in first place). Also, fire spirit root cultivators are stated to be more emotional and impatient. What is the one thing most needed to be a good teacher or a good crafter? Patience and being calm. While Elder Mo can get very emotional for things about himself and his cultivation, him being such a good teacher and nurturer implies that he has that patience and other traits that are good for both teachers and crafters. (But yes, all the while being grumpy, but that didn't stop him from being genuinely liked and respected by the young generation, so I assume that his grumpiness was more of a general thing and more apparent when interacting with the older generation.) He also has a lot of drive to be useful to others even when he finds himself lacking. When he noticed and acknowledged that he wasn't able to progress in his cultivation anymore, Elder Mo didn't do what most others in his circumstances do in cultivation stories. Elder Mo didn't become more desperate and manipulative. He didn't become more reclusive and selfish. Instead, Elder Mo tried to genuinely help others.

Sancturillore -- Élie Simard-Wallot

Also, while Elder Mo is indeed very good at combat, his greatest strength shown in the story so far is his capabilities as a nurturer of the young generations. As a teacher. It could very well be that he has a talent as a crafter, but simply never got to know about it due to not trying it in the past (and not having had resources to try in first place). Also, fire spirit root cultivators are stated to be more emotional and impatient. What is the one thing most needed to be a good teacher or a good crafter? Patience and being calm. While Elder Mo can get very emotional for things about himself and his cultivation, him being such a good teacher and nurturer implies that he has that patience and other traits that are good for both teachers and crafters. (But yes, all the while being grumpy, but that didn't stop him from being genuinely liked and respected by the young generation, so I assume that his grumpiness was more of a general thing and more apparent when interacting with the older generation.) He also has a lot of drive to be useful to others even when he finds himself lacking. When he noticed and acknowledged that he wasn't able to progress in his cultivation anymore, Elder Mo didn't do what most others in his circumstances do in cultivation stories. Elder Mo didn't become more desperate and manipulative. He didn't become more reclusive and selfish. Instead, Elder Mo tried to genuinely help others.

Sancturillore -- Élie Simard-Wallot

Elder Mo literally is described as a really good teacher and nurturer of the young generations. Liking combat when you finally get to do some alongside an old friend after at least a century isn't being a "combat junkie." Especially since it was also a time for him to experience his new found power after having finally gotten rid of his heart demons and having finally risen again in his cultivation stage after centuries.

Wanderer of Worlds

I agree that he is a great teacher, but for all we know, only one person may be able to inherent the technique, in which case, it would be better for Amber to get it and have Elder Mo guide her with his knowledge.

julian hu

I feel like Mo's occupation as a nurturer for the sect would translate well into someone who nurtures and creates treasures. I can also imagine him as an awsome teacher/artisan elderly Person who gives wholesome advise and Equipment for the younger Generation of the sect. I also like that he is very cool headed and seems to know how to think first and act later. With amber I just can't imagine an immature child as a master artisan and crafter. The motivation being fueled by inferiority is also very boring for me since I feel like we get enough teenager bullshit with Stella. I just feel like Mo's motivation would be towards the betterment of his sect and his people and also gratitude towards ashfallen sect and therefore their betterment instead of 'I wanna proof myself because that's what young people always want to do' kinda mindset. I also can't imagine her winning a willpower contest if she can't even talk confidently with people from her own sect, where she's hailed as a genius. Compare that to someone who at some point resigned himself to death and still found the energy within himself to support others. That's not even in the same league Imo

julian hu

Idk maybe your bias, I see a lot of pro mo posts aswell. Also not everyone who voted will comment and since the comments last time were very pro moand the scale tips in mos favor, everyone who's pro amber will have a higher motivation to post compared to someone who is pro mo and saw comments and results of poll

Human2849

You have to remember that there are over 100 votes in the poll right now, but far less commenting. Just because there is a vocal minority for one thing doesn't mean the majority think, or in this case vote, that way.

Demon Fire

No sure how that's bias ? I was reading the comments, if you read the comments you'll see most people say Elder Mo, but they believe amber should have it, just based on prospects. Elder Mo is old , & more inclined to fighting than sitting, he & the grand Elder are fighting machines, as amber has the most potential in anything, why would elder mo be satisfied with staying in making weapons? He just broke through to the star core realm. It's not bias it's a formulated opinion based on cultivation novels in general.

Demon Fire

Do you remember why he was a nurturer? (Stuck cultivation lvl) so he focused on the younger generation

Niels Valkenborgh

Elder Mo because his name is an anagram for Modeler

Me

I think Amber is the best choice. She is still young and has huge potential. Her thinking is probably also more flexible due to her youth. The Grandelder is more suitbale for direct combat power and thus should not be sequestered away into a spirit forge. And Elder Mo should be tasked with instruction as he has great experience with that. Of course he too has great combat potential especially since he is used to teamfighting with the grand elder but his primary purpose should still be to serve as an instructor and teacher.

Nigel Franklin

I select elder Mo because I want to hold open the possibility that Amber joins the inner circle or has more interesting interactions with them.

Me

I totally agree that the grandelder should be used as combat potential. And while i agree that Elder Mo too could be used for fighting, i still think he should primarily focus on teaching the younger generation (while of course also improving his cultivation). His experience with being stuck at a bottleneck for hundeds of years and nearly going mad while trying to seek a solution is also gonna be very beneficial for his qualities as a teacher.

julian hu

Yes exactly he couldn't further his cultivation, therefore death hung over him and he was selfless enough to wholeheartedly support the younger Generation which for me shows a lot of mental fortitude and a mindset worth nurturing. The fact that he didn't become selfish, afraid of death and trash is proof of character. If I compare this to amber whose depth doesn't go beyond immature feelings of inferiority, I can't see him losing a contest of willpower

Hymntastic

I think whoever works the best narratively should get it. But most likely Amber would be the best choice as the elders both have a path forward as it is.

Glenn Merlin Hinkley

Order of opinion: Amber, Elder Mo, Grand Elder Amber first, but only from a plot standpoint, because she doesn't have a tie-in to the Ashborne sect yet. Elder Mo received the breakthrough due to Ash's truffle, the Grand Elder made the vow and is working to learn the language already, so his fate is already tied directly. Amber's fate is only indirectly tied to the sect, so if she is to be a main character in the future, she needs a plot hook to directly tie her to the sect. I'd vote Elder Mo over Grand elder because of their attitude towards the sect. Elder Mo has been given a second chance at life due to the sect, and thus will want to return the favor more. The Grand Elder will come around when his sect flourishes, but it feels like his current attitude towards the Ashborne sect is still one of selfishness, while Ash's goal is to lift up everyone

carebear90

I'd honestly expect that all of them eventually grasp the Technique. As to who does it first and claims the whole inheritance? I'd hope it'd be someone who'll actually try to disseminate that knowledge through their clan instead of hoarding it for themselves. They could do with 'something special' to stand out from the other stronger clans. Like the Metal guys have their own exclusive cultivation paradigm. Amber doesn't seem like someone who'd focus on the others in her clan for quite some time if she's so insistent to 'catch up' to Stella and Diana. Elder Mo has a history of teaching but only because he was stuck with his own cultivation. How likely is it that he'll focus on making up for lost time instead of continuing to teach? The Grand Elder is the most stereotypical 'Demonic Cultivator' of those three. He seemed wholly prepared to do away with his family members to secure this treasure for himself. Shortsighted and full of avarice... How likely is it that the words of Elder Mo will have a lasting impact? So, in the end, it's a toss-up between Elder Mo and Grand Elder for me. Both are not ideal, but Amber is probably the least likely to 'waste her time' with teaching others in the foreseeable future.

charles

give it to the eccentric old man yeahhh

Ethan B.

Honestly a very tough choice between Elder Mo and Amber for me. Elder Mo feels very mature and capable of taking on the inheritance, while Amber is more fresh and has fewer preconceptions towards the fire dou that I would argue allows her to be more open toward making spirt forging her main dou.

Grappleshot

Grand elder makes sense due to the cultivation, though I don't know about determination or what that is, but I feel like he's safe, but has a great opportunity. Mo has the fanaticism of someone who was miraculously saved from a terminal disease that was slowly killing him calle mortality and that should give a lot of determination. Amber would just have an inferiority complex and the will to make herself better. Personally I like Amber because, that would mean another person that Stella might get jealous of and another youngster that would be living under the tree, that would just be, in time another family member to the tree, minus being orphaned, so she might see tree as that cool uncle that is also a tree.

Lazy Lemon

I'm more in favour of the grand elder, I liked elder mo position as a teacher (which will be difficult if he is secluded into his forge) and don't necessarily want the young genius take it from the elder for amber thus why I want grand elder. Plus it might make him feel better about not only being a weapon for war but also a crafter

Xzel

Grand elder or amber should inheirt the legacy because they will create tension with the AF sect . Unlike Mo who will be a fanatic of Tree . Which make the merger or Mo's clan settlement nside AF Sect to easy without conflict boring .

The_Mmo_OG

Elder mo can stay a teacher and teach about spirit forging if there clan is staying with ashlock for the long run the grand elder would be the protector elder mo could direct the youth and the younger generation can learn forging from their elder. With this the ashfallen sect becomes a alchemy and forging sect + theres that kid from the alternate cultivation type imagine them actually using spirit forged items too help them cultivate since it would be qi infused metals could be interesting too pull a 3rd clan into the sect through finding them a superior cultivation method perhaps.

Vladimir Merritt

Oh thank God that result of the poll won't decide the winner... and while I appreciate the engagement you are encouraging from us... I really do not like the fan driven plot choices... I come for the original content from you.

Sleepking10

Amber amber amber future powerhouse and leader

T̶̢͜ ̛́͜o̸̷͟ ̵̕͡a҉̸̨ ̴́͞s̵̷͜ ́t̷

I was leaning towards Amber, because having a potential rival for Diana and Stella would be pretty neat, and I'm liking her character and potential for character development so far. But, I'm loving the dynamic Elder Mo and the Grand Elder have. They're two old, life long friends who've fought together and have a good friendship, rivalry and chemistry. Sadly, the rivalry can't be explored much due to the stark difference in cultivation levels, but if Elder Mo gets the inheritance, then it could become a genuine challenge for the Grand Elder to keep up and force them both to keep growing to compete with each other. Really cool dynamic I'd love to see, (edit: also poor grand elder, bro got shafted, nobody wants him to get it 💀)

phantom

Have you seen dwarves? being grumpy is practically a trait for crafters.

phantom

I was not for the grand elder because I think it would actually harm him. He is a leader and the main combat force of his group. Him suddenly spending his time sitting around crafting would be a big blow. Sure a crafter would be more valuable. but when other people can take that up the choice is clearly not going to be the one in an important position. There is also the fact the beastwave is not far away and the crafting advantage is more long term. that is not a lot of time for crafting where as leadership and combat force is very important. Besides if he is not suited to be a crafter than it will hurt him. sure it is great for him now but like. that is only because it is from a higher cultivation expert.

Sancturillore -- Élie Simard-Wallot

Wandere, why go for him having to guide Amber and her getting the inheritance if he cam do it himself while she focuses on catching up to rise as an equal in power and potential to the other girls? She won't have time to focus on getting stronger as much if she has to do crafting stuff. On the other hand, Mo will likely be a star core once he's out, which will likely be beneficial to crafting, and will those no longer need to focus on getting stronger for a while. He will have the time to do crafting.

Sancturillore -- Élie Simard-Wallot

Being younger doesn't equate being more flexible. In many cases, such as Amber's too, there's a lot of uncertainties and doubt in their thoughts and feelings. She also doesn't have great willpower. Mo on the other hand is one if the most flexible and calm headed thinker in the series. And his will is strong.

Melting Sky

The Grand Elder is an old warrior tempered by centuries of war who still has that fire of battle burning brightly within him even after all these years of relative peace. He needs to be out there kicking ass and taking once he has his breakthrough into the star realm, not puttering around a smithy. He should be out there leading his people and swinging rather than making swords. I voted for Mo since he seemed the fittest for the role, but Amber could have worked as a young firey "genius" finally finding her true passion in this new craft.