Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

BICYCLE!

Comments

Julie Wine&Reason

I was happy that Biden called out the lies and dropped a "Hell" and a "damn" in the debate.

Julie Wine&Reason

How in the fuck did Trump's lies about murdering a born infant and his othering and horrendously racist talk about immigrants not clearly reasonate?

April Poff

Love y'all's suggestions for the new debate format!

Chris Littrell

I agree with Heath’s suggestion of the tag out but not with Taker’s church bell. Needs to be Austin’s glass shattering! Think about it, Kamala breaking another glass ceiling? PERFECT!!!

Clockworkk

Biden had a really bad debate performance, yeah. But even Gavin Newsom pointed out that you shouldn’t turn your back on your guy after one bad performance. We HAVE to prevent Donald Ducked-The-Draft from getting into office again. For all our sakes.

Heath Enwright’s Husband

Is there some unwritten rule of journalism that says whenever someone claims something was taken out of context, you’re not allowed to ask them about the content? It’s uncouth?

Laura Lusby

the part where he said Drumph has the morals of an alley cat was my favorite

Matt in L.A.

I love you guys, but I couldn't disagree more about Biden's debate performance. Biden was already far behind, with no obvious path to victory. Those of us who doubted his ability to win were placated over and over with assurances that once the general had started in earnest, then Biden would reveal his true power, dispel the stories about being too old, and show us all that we were wrong. But we weren't wrong. He is too old. Not too old to be president, but too old to beat Donald Trump. He beat Trump in 2020, but only because he used to have a great reputation (as Obama's Veep). But he doesn't have a great reputation anymore. It's not his fault; he was a great president. Inflation wasn't his fault; Afghanistan wasn't his fault. His age and his stutter aren't his fault. But that doesn't matter, if people won't vote for him. And the debate was literally his last chance to change the narrative. Of course there will not be a second debate, because Trump doesn't want to give Biden another chance (and Trump won't seem 'chicken' because no one will believe that Biden can win). Supporting Biden now is forgoing our last best chance of reversing this inexorable slide toward autocracy. We should instead politely dump him, and get an exciting ticket, like Whitmer/Warnock (give Harris a plum cabinet job, like secretary of state, so she doesn't feel betrayed).

CarrieBoo

I was not ready for so much butt stuff talk.

Matt in L.A.

Not if you count the popular vote, but that's not what decides elections. In the swing states (which he only won with a few thousand votes in 2020), he is getting trounced in the polls. Trump has already had the only trial he will have before the election, and it's made no impact. What possible trick could Biden use to turn around the race now? We know the American people CAN elect Donald Trump, because they've done it before. I have no faith that Biden can do anything to stop Trump. But I think a different ticket could.

Matt in L.A.

Imagine a Whitmer/Harris ticket (or vice versa). If Dems could dream bold, in one move we could utterly transform the narrative of this election. Everyone would stop talking about Biden, because they'd be talking only about the first all-female ticket. In a post-Dobbs world, this is the perfect time for a ticket led by women who aren't afraid to talk about abortion. Yes, it would be scary, to try something so unknown, but one thing that we do know, is that no one who was not already convinced to vote for Biden, is going to choose him now. He can't win without the middle, so he cannot win. He is no longer an option.

The Skepticrat

Matt- Sounds like we have similar politics and similar goals but we differ on strategy. That's fine, and there's some subjectivity there based on estimating how a different ticket might do in November. But you said something that's objectively incorrect. You said: "Biden was already far behind, with no obvious path to victory." And then when Annette pointed out that Biden was NOT all that far behind, you suggested you meant that in terms of electoral votes, and said Biden's getting "trounced" in swing states. I looked at an electoral simulation from 538 that came out POST-debate (July 1st), and it has Biden winning the electoral vote 49 times out of 100 and Trump winning 50 times out of 100 (or 494/1000 for Biden vs. 502/1000 for Trump). That does NOT represent "far behind" and it represents a path to victory in the electoral college in 49% of scenarios. And again, that's given the POST-debate situation. So to whatever extent your opinion on strategy was based on "far behind" and "no obvious path to victory", I'm hoping you'll somewhat modify the strength of that opinion in light of this new information. --Heath

Matt in L.A.

Hi Heath. Let me share some of the numbers that I find concerning. I will use June 25th as my reference date, because it is pre-debate. On June 25, 2020, in Nevada, 538 had Biden leading Trump by 8.8 points. Biden won the state by ~33,000 votes. On June 25, 2024, Trump is leading Biden by 3 points. In Arizona, Biden was leading Trump by 4.8 points in 2020. Biden won AZ by ~10,000 votes. Trump is now leading by 3.1 points. In Georgia, Biden was leading by 1.4 points in 2020. Biden won GA by ~12,000 votes. Trump is now leading by 4.8 points. In Wisconsin, Biden was leading Trump by 9.6 points in 2020. Biden won Wisconsin by ~21,000 votes. Now Biden is leading by .2 points. In Pennsylvania, Biden was leading Trump by 8.1 points in 2020. Biden won PA by ~81,000 votes. Trump is now leading by .5 points. In Michigan, Biden was ahead by 10.7 points in 2020. Biden won MI by ~154,000 votes. Biden is now leading by .2 points. Do you see what I’m seeing? In 2020, Biden barely squeaked through to victory, despite decent polling in these states. Now, he has decent polling in none of these states. Yes, surely, there will be some reversion to the norm, and some prodigal lefties will come home to vote for Biden, but there’s no reason to believe that they are more numerous than the prodigal right-wingers. What possible dynamic exists between now and the election, to improve Biden’s odds?

Matt in L.A.

Some other details that I think are worth considering. On paper, Trump is actually quite beatable. He is one of the most disliked poltiicans ever and is now a 34X convicted felon. The Dems are actually relatively popular, as shown in the '18, '20, and '22 elections. The Republican party is in disarray; they've allowed stop-the-steal crazies to take over all the local parties, and they don't know what they're doing. Also, Trump has effectively vacuumed up all the money that down-ballot Republicans would normally rely upon. Plus, everyone's bummed about Dobbs and concerned about the runaway Supreme Court. So, in theory, our candidate should be kicking Trump's ass. The problem is not the situation; the problem is Biden. (Again, I like Biden, and I think he did a great job, but...) If Biden stays in the race, he will not only lose, but he will depress the numbers that other Dems need to show up.

Matt in L.A.

And one last thing. The usual answer we all give is: if you're concerned, then volunteer. Phone bank and knock doors. Fine. I'm willing to do that, to help save American democracy. But if I do so, how do I respond to the person who says they're worried about Biden's age? What do I tell them? Do I bullshit them, say "he's not really like that" or "that was a fluke"? I don't have a good answer for them, because even my liberal parents in their mid-80s think that Biden is too old.

The Skepticrat

Some topics worth discussing. You seem to be an intelligent person and I'm hoping also intellectually honest. So before we move on...are you admitting that "already far behind" in terms of electoral chances was incorrect (given that professional statisticians put Biden's chances at about 49% even given the numbers you presented)? And also admitting that "no obvious path to victory" was also incorrect for the same reason? Internet discussions break down easily if these moments don't happen.

Matt in L.A.

Hi Heath. Let me be clear that I'm a huge fan, and I'm usually just part of the choir you're preaching to. Did my original post lack nuance? Sure. I was writing to advocate a position, and didn't foresee a conversation with you, so I chose strong definitive language. Obviously, I can’t see the future, either. In truth, I think Biden is very likely to lose, rather than is absolutely going to lose. It’s still not great. That said, let’s look at the 49% victory that 538 is offering, and put it into historical context. If we go back to my arbitrary date of June 25, but in 2016, we see something very disturbing. At this point in 2016, 538 gave Hillary Clinton a 77% chance of winning, with Trump at 22%. In this context, a 49% chance of winning is terrible. It’s worse than a coin flip. I don’t want to stake democracy on a coin flip. I may have lacked subtlety in my original post, but my concerns are founded on data. And the polls just keep getting worse for Biden.

Matt in L.A.

Other things worth considering: Inflation wasn’t Biden’s fault; quite the opposite. I know he did better than most world leaders at combatting inflation, but the American voter doesn’t know / doesn’t care. They blame him (but not the Democrats writ large) for inflation. Choosing a new ticket effectively resets this problem back to zero. The Israel/Palestine conflict has soured a good deal of the youth base against Biden. That resistance could also be reset, particularly if a replacement nominee was clearly pro-cease-fire. The Supreme Court has given us all kinds of great issues to run on. But those issues are complex, and need an excellent communicator to exploit. I live in the progressive mecca of Los Angeles, but I have seen absolutely zero signage for Biden/Harris, which wasn’t true for Hillary in 2016. To me, that speaks loudly about the lack of enthusiasm for our current ticket. Whereas, Trump has millions of devoted, even rabid followers. In a simple contest of enthusiasm, Trump is killing us. I think we can do better than “at least he’s not Trump”. Especially when it comes to convincing the undecided, we need to be able to offer a better argument. There is a gift in the fact that the debate was historically early. It means there’s still time to react, to adjust and revise. There isn’t of course, any time for Biden to improve; miracles don’t exist. But there is still time to choose an alternative. We were not given a choice this election. Biden chose to run again, and the Dems chose not to put up any reasonable alternative. But when Biden chose to run again, the writing was already on the wall. He was incredibly unpopular, even then. His great reputation as Obama’s VP had already been replaced by becoming the inflation bogeyman. There were already huge concerns about his age, and even his own party wanted him to “be the bridge to a new generation”. He knew, and we knew, that he was already a compromised candidate, but the reassurance we all got was: no, he’s not really that old. That’s just Fox News, selectively editing his appearances. As soon as the general starts for real, Biden will demonstrate how spry and resilient and coherent he is. Except he didn’t, and he isn’t. And there’s no reason to believe that he will suddenly become that.

Matt in L.A.

And one more argument, in three words: Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

The Skepticrat

I appreciate your willingness to engage here. I think this is a valuable topic to discuss and I'm convinced that you're a thoughtful person with all the best intentions. Most importantly, we both have the same goal of winning in November however possible. That said, I was hoping for a bit less hedgey language in your response. I don't think "lacking nuance" and "strong definitive language to advocate a point" are the most accurate descriptions of the original post. To say that heading into the debate, Biden was "way behind" and had "no obvious path to victory" was objectively incorrect. I think a full admission in those approximate words would've been the fairest response. Going into the debate, he had approximately a coin flip chance. (Slightly less now, which I'll admit IS worth discussing, but I'm getting ahead of myself.) So I'm looking above, and I see that you've laid out a decent sized list of further arguments, but I haven't done the same yet, because I think it's important to proceed one thought at a time, with stops along the way to make concessions where it's fair to do so. And I think this is symptomatic of the problem with online discussion. To be fair, I think we're all guilty of this, myself included sometimes. We all want to present all the best thoughts we have as quickly as possible so everyone can see the splendor of our ideas. But that's not the best route to delving down on a topic. I much prefer a system where both sides are potentially making reasonable adjustments to opinions where applicable, and then finally arriving at the most justified answer to the question. We might both end up with the same opinion as when we started, but the method I'm describing has a much better chance of finding common ground where it's useful. And it's more accurate and informative to anyone else reading along. So imagine we can rewind, and hold off on all the extra facets that you presented, and instead proceed in a more measured, step-by-step fashion. I'll start with a framing of the discussion. The ultimate question is: Who has the best chance to beat Trump in November? The two options are (1) Biden/Harris or (2) a different ticket of Democrats chosen at a brokered convention with about 10 weeks until the election. Obviously, I'm using language that indicates my position, but I believe that language is accurate nonetheless. That IS the situation. So given that situation, I'm saying I'd prefer to gamble on choice (1) and you're saying you'd prefer to gamble on choice (2). From there, I'll address one argument you made and we can tackle that argument only, and then move on to the next. I'll start with a short one. You said "3 words: Ruth Bader Ginsburg." I'm assuming the general gist is: the future of the Supreme Court is crucial. I agree. So the argument of "Ruth Bader Ginsburg" applies equally to both sides of this topic. We both think our strategy is the best one to ensure 4 years of a Democrat making SCOTUS nominations. So that's a wash. We can erase that argument from the chalk board, and we can move to the next. Would you agree? If yes, you can pick the next individual topic. If no, you can explain why. Or if this whole thing is exhausting and you don't have time for a long discussion, I totally understand. Either way...one love...BEAT TRUMP.

Matt in L.A.

Hi Heath.  Yes, agreed, beat Trump.  That is the crucial and critical outcome that we all can agree on.  We're just divided on how best to accomplish that goal. I made the RBG comment without explanation, but that was a mistake on my part.  Yes, of course, SCOTUS is super important, and yet another reason why Trump can't be elected.  But what I meant was the legacy of RBG.   Ruth Bader Ginsburg is a legend; I loved her when she was alive.  But she is not the only person who could've worn that robe.  And unfortunately, she stayed in her office too long.  Because of her determination that she retired only on her own terms, she accidently led to the appointment of Amy Coney Barrett, which led to the undoing of so many decisions that RBG held dear.  That's my argument from Ruth Bader Ginsburg: Biden similarly is an excellent person with a great legacy.  But that doesn't mean he should stay in office.  If Biden's pride leads him to stay in, and he loses, then we all friggin' lose.  And since I think he is very likely to lose, I think RGB's legacy is very instructive.  RBG shouldn't have taken that chance with America's freedoms, because we lost them.  And Biden shouldn't take that chance with America's freedoms, because we are so very close to losing them.

The Skepticrat

Hey Matt- I've had a full change of heart on this topic. Unqualified mea culpa. I'm extremely excited about Kamala Harris taking over and I was definitely wrong about the extent to which there would be disarray in the party leading up to the convention. And your instincts about a new candidate being a net positive in the polls look to be spot on. I'm loving that a discussion on the internet helped lead to a meaningful change of opinion (even when that included me being shown to be wrong). Our conversation was part of my thought process as I changed my view. Cheers!