Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Link: https://u.pcloud.link/publink/show?code=XZK42F0ZfwM09ebdPDue3RGtxbTFzzlFQWak

Files

Previews only

Comments

Steveo

A lot of people would agree with you about Anya's speech being the best/saddest moment of the episode! As well in universally agreeing that the episode, while devastating, is incredible. Very cathartic for a lot of viewers. Easily a top 5 episode of the series. As for the first scene of the episode, Whedon didn't want to have the production credits showing while Buffy was trying to revive her mother. So it was most likely a flashback to their last Christmas of happier times.

Darrell Palmer

Anya is amazing, one of my favorite characters and she really gets to shine here. Sarah Michelle Geller really gets to show her skills. I don’t know what other actress could have pulled this off. Many actresses would have grabbed those dramatic scenes and milked them for all they were worth, but would have stumbled badly when it came time to kill the vampire. Sarah’s range is incredible. Also, I’ve always loved how well Dawn holds up her end of the acting. I don’t know of any other show that comes close to BTVS for depth of acting talent and quality of writing. I’ve been watching Television for well over sixty years and this is the show I always want to come back to.

Vicky N

Having gone through the lost of a love one. I can assure you that those reactions are very realistic including the one when you fantasize about a miraculous recovery. This is one of the best episode of any tv show I’ve ever seen.

Tara.

It's definitely a phenomenal episode, don't feel guilty for thinking that cause I think everybody would agree on that. Just wanted to let you know that from what I have read, I think that Joss wanted Tara and Willow to kiss earlier but he never got permission to do so, but because of the "non-sexual" nature of the kiss in this episode (Tara comforting Willow) he got away with it. Idk how true that is but it does sound about right.

zerofk

This might be the most powerful episode of any TV show I've ever seen. The depiction of grief is so real, raw, and honest. The execution is also on point. The lack of music, the odd camera angles, even having that dinner party scene to avoid having credits over the painful scenes. It's all very purposely done to put the audience in the right mood. And it fucking works. From an in-universe point: I love Tara so much. She is a steadying influence on them all. She just comforts everyone simply by being there. One thing I don't like about the episode is the vampire attack - even though Joss Whedon insists it is necessary. It shows that life goes on. Mourning does not end life's struggles. But I still don't like it. I do like the bit after the fight though.

x_Rhi_x

Definitely a phenomenal epsiode. A masterpiece of TV. When buffy looks at the phone and the buttons are blurry, or when you can't see the eyes of the paramedic when buffy is "listening" to him, the awkward silences between the gang in willows room, lack of musical score, xander still getting a parking ticket, the sound of kids playing outside when buffy opens the back door and looks like crap to indicate life goes on and doesn't care for individual situations.....all amazing. Anyas speech is always what's gets me in this episode, too

x_Rhi_x

Also buffys dad is called Hank lol

Kate

Yep! This was Willow and Tara's first *onscreen* kiss, but definitely not their first kiss as a couple; they've been heavily implied to be intimately involved for quite a long time. But back then, this was one of the very first queer relationships on mainstream television, so the writers had to fight to show them onscreen. This kiss had to be "earned" in the eyes of WB, and I love that once they got the green light from the producers, they gave it the biggest close up they could, in a context that highlighted the emotional intimate aspect of their relatioship.

Thom Purdy

Actually, the network tried to get the kiss cut, but Joss threatened to quit if they did, so the network relented.

Thom Purdy

I've recently realized how significant it was for Anya to say "I wish...", being an ex-vengeance demon.

TheBlowpop

Yeah, and I agree that scene didn't need anything to distract from it. Even so, I've always felt that it kind of fits with the idea of the denial stage of grief, like Buffy's having this thought about how everything was just fine; this can't be real. And then we snap back to reality with a jolt. It might have been more effective as that if it weren't so long, but there was the issue with the production credits, so it makes sense.

TheBlowpop

This is (as weird as it sounds to say) probably my favorite Buffy episode of all of them, because it takes something we all experience in life and portrays it in this real, raw, honest way, and it shows several different people dealing with grief and loss in their own individual ways, because no one really handles grief the same. It doesn't really matter who you are or how you deal, you're likely to identify with someone here in one way or another. When Buffy is on the phone with the 911 dispatcher, and she says, "She's cold," the dispatcher says, "The body is cold?" And Buffy says, "No. My mom!" And as the EMTs arrive, Buffy pulls Joyce's skirt down. Then, when Giles arrives, and she comes charging down the hallway, "No, it's too late. We're not supposed to move the body!" and then she realizes she's said the words that mean her mom is really gone, that reaction is the one that gets me the hardest, I think. The lack of a score is a great choice. I've seen the interview where he says he wanted to challenge himself to do better, and the score is a comfort and there's no score to grief. All that's fair and true, but I think more so than just a comfort, a score is a guide to how you should be feeling right now in a particular moment, and having a score telling you how to feel would be inappropriate for this episode, this topic of grief, because we can't be told how to grieve, we just have to do it our own way. The little things like Buffy looking out the back door and hearing children playing, the whole bit with Dawn at school before Buffy arrives, Xander's double-parked car getting a ticket, and even the vampire attack in the morgue... the world doesn't stop just because you do. And the way that it's more difficult for Buffy to kill the vampire because she's just... drained. Emotionally, mentally, physically drained. And it's the only thing in the whole episode she can actually fight, which is also kind of symbolic in a way. Sarah Michelle Gellar is a phenomenal actor. The whole cast are, really, but she truly shines in this.

Briony Addey

I do think that the reaction (which is very common, not unique to Dodo at all, I used to feel this way too, for sure) of hating the vampire scene and wanting this EP to be free of supernatural elements, is probably that little part of our brains that doesn't believe genre tv /fiction can be 'art' in the way drama can. But like others point out here, the vampire represents both the mundanity of the 'everyday' work Buffy has to do, as well as the importance of her calling, neither of which she gets to opt out of, even in the face of overwhelming personal tragedy. I also like Willow and Tara's first onscreen kiss being here. It lays bare the deep, deep inhumanity at the very heart of homophobia. Love is our purpose, our consolation, our comfort- to want to deny it to people when they need it the most is truly monstrous.

Melissa Amato

Joss, is Cruel... He only wanted to hurt us all. No Reactor should be alone at this time, in the Fangdom. We all love & feel for everyone. Joice was important to the Series, & the way Joss just kills her, is like ripping our own hearts & stomping on them. He wanted Reality to Hit us all big time in the Feelz... It was handled with his usual cold hearted indifference, & un like the Gentleman from Grimm Fairytail Lore, this experiment, after the lighter hearted April Robot ep. & Spike, so obsessed over his loss of Buffy, comic verge of insanity, & so very weird creep factor. Let's ruin Spikes Character another notch. & have everyone hate him, including Buffy. Because Angelus was the paragon of virtue? (Air hugs) mein friend, DoDo... Joss, is cruel... He was one of the Gentleman. Suited higher up, ripping our lungs out. Breathe, ok... Air hugs. Danke, blessings sent. 🐶🤦🏻‍♀️💖🌍🌎🌏💖

Eve Black

OMG the light is one of the most beautiful songs