Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Link: https://u.pcloud.link/publink/show?code=XZTF2F0ZMdVS8DXGAoSA16wUYoA4MSq9sqmV

Files

Previews only

Comments

Heidi Elizabeth Marcum

Street Rats- Thank you so much for another fun reaction for Once Upon a Time, Dodo!! I enjoy this episode a lot, despite the few fairly minor nitpicks I have with it. And I love that Aladdin, Jasmine, and Jafar have come into one of this season's major storylines. I've always loved the Disney movie, Aladdin too. It's one of my all time favorite Disney movies. So, I was very happy to see them brought into Once Upon a Time! :) First... I would like to say that I am once again disappointed that there are so few moments between Emma and Killian. We see him periodically throughout this episode, but we have to wait until the very end for Killian to even talk, let alone for him to really be a part of the story. But I love and understand his reasons for being upset and worried about Emma, which I will come back to shortly... Now... as an episode that introduces Aladdin as the Savior and brings him together with Jasmine finally, I really enjoy this episode a lot. However, I didn't love it and here's why... Aladdin and Jasmine's story is quite a bit different than their love story in the Disney movie, Aladdin. Which is a really good thing, and I appreciate the differences in the stories, because this show is known for its twists on the original stories, which I love for the most part. In Once Upon a Time, Aladdin is actually a Savior like Emma is now, and a reluctant hero. And Princess Jasmine comes to Aladdin seeking his help to rid Agrabah of Jafar, already with the knowledge that he is the Savior. Whereas in the Disney movie, Jafar tricks Aladdin into becoming the hero. I really love this twist and I love how Jasmine inspires Aladdin to be the Savior he needed to be, even when tempted by Jafar with the sheers that would free him of his burden and allow him to live a long life, with Jasmine if she could accept his decision to do so. And this is where I am disappointed with Aladdin's story arc. In the end, it is revealed that Aladdin actually gives in to Jafar's temptation, and has given up his duty as a Savior in order to take the easy way out, before disappearing for many, many years in fear of Jasmine's disdain for him. I love Aladdin as the hero, and I love the twist with him being another Savior, so it actually hurts me a little to know that he actually gave in out of fear of death. However, I also understand why he does as he does too. Being the Savior is a difficult burden for anyone to bear, which we've seen numerous times with Emma. Especially throughout all of season three. I was hoping that Aladdin would come back still as a Savior in order to give Emma more hope. But with this being said... even though Aladdin may no longer be a Savior, hopefully he and Jasmine will still be able to help Emma and the others to save her, and that they'll be able to save her people and all of Agrabah. Next... I'm really happy that Emma's secret she's been keeping from Killian and her family is finally out at last. Although, I kind of hate how it is revealed, when the Evil Queen disguises herself as Archie and forces Emma to tell everyone. It's funny and a brilliant idea on the Evil Queen's part. And again, it makes sense that this is what it would take for Emma to have to reveal the truth to them. Yet it's a bit of a let down, I think. I would have preferred for Emma to tell everyone the truth on her own. Emma's family's reactions are all spot on. And I absolutely understand Killian's disappointment and silence. I don't really think he's so much mad. I believe he's hurt, and more so he's terribly afraid of losing her. This much is very evident. And I love that these are his reactions, just as they would be for anyone who is in love with someone who's been lying to them about a burden such as she's going through. However, I am also sad that Killian chooses to keep the sheers rather than throwing them away, "thousands of leagues below the seas," as he tells Emma he did at her behest. Not disappointed by his actions, because I completely understand why he would be afraid to get rid of an artifact that could very well save Emma's life. I am just disappointed that we once again have another secret that will undoubtedly come back to bite Killian. Secrets are heavy throughout this show, as you've already seen so much as it is. And there are more secrets to come aside from Killian holding onto these sheers. If you remember... David is also currently keeping a secret of his own, as he is still searching for answers about his father's death in spite of Snow believing he's given up his search after she believed him to have burned the card with information about his father's coin. Anyways... We'll see if Killian comes around in time to have more hope in Emma's decision to remain the Savior no matter her fate, for which I am incredibly happy about by the way. And in spite of my frustrations with the rise of this new secret, the final scene sets up for an exciting episode to come! :) Oh... and I absolutely love, love, love the reveal that these Sheers of Destiny once belonged to the Three Fates, known from Hercules, as they are seen severing people's souls from their bodies upon their deaths with sheers almost just like these within the Disney movie. However, instead of these sheers having the power to sever people's souls from their bodies upon their deaths, I absolutely love that these sheers now in Killian's hand have the power to sever a person from their fate, or destiny. Absolutely marvelous!!! Next... I kind of hate that the Evil Queen kidnaps Archie and then turns him back into Jiminy Cricket to keep him captive, and that Zelena is continuing to act as her wicked self. Don't get me wrong... these scenes between Zelena, the Evil Queen, and Archie with the baby are hilarious, and I still love the Wicked Witch. But I still don't really care too much for her character throughout this season until much, much later. As for Jafar and the whole Cave of Wonders storyline... Jafar is a good villain, although I have to admit I am a bit disappointed that he doesn't really get the chance to shine in this episode, as all he does is pretty much talk a bit to Aladdin and Jasmine, and performs a tiny bit of magic when he turns the men into rats and imprisons Jasmine in the hour glass. Which is a brilliant nod to the Disney movie. As is seeing the Sultan being enchanted by the magic in Jafar's staff, and him playing with the toys. I really love the actor chosen to play Jafar... Oded Fehr, best known for playing in The Mummy movies with Brendan Frasier. As for the Cave of Wonders... Since you love the Disney movie as I do, you might also share my same feelings that the cave within this episode is a bit of a let down. First, the Cave is already risen from the sands. The golden scarab, like you mentioned having remembered from the Disney movie, is not used to raise it from the sands. And then, only a few words are needed in order for Aladdin to open the Cave, as he takes a few words from the original Ali Babba stories... which I actually really do love the nod to. "Open Sesame!" And when they find the fake diamond, there is really no big destruction or chaos that erupts other than a pillar that Aladdin easily blasts apart to save himself and Jasmine with his magic. I admit that I was kind of hoping for a good magic carpet adventure. However, I really do love that the Cave of Wonders is brought into this episode, and that this storyline helps to prove to Aladdin that he is indeed the Savior, not to find a magic lamp like the movie. This is actually a good twist, especially since the show's creators never had any intention of bringing Genie into this this Aladdin story arc at all, which is really a good thing because I don't know how they would be able to pull him off well without destroying a character we all love... all thanks to the phenomenal Robin Williams. :) Oh... I miss him so much. Next... I love the moments between Emma and Henry, especially in the crypt when he apologizes for bringing her into the life and forcing her to become the Savior. I love that she reassures him that she wouldn't have changed her fate for anything because it gave her the family and the love she's always wanted. And I really love the final scene between Killian and Emma, because they are so loving and because Killian is his usual self with her until she leaves, then he is seen pulling the sheers from his jacket's inner pocket. Overall... I do really enjoy this episode very much. I would have made some changes if I were writing it myself, but I appreciate each of the storylines nonetheless. And I really love the actors chosen to play Jasmine, Aladdin, and Jafar. Especially Jasmine, who is played by Karen David, an actress I have seen in many shows. So, thank you once again, my friend! Until your next reaction... Sincerely, Heidi

Miguelito

I would say that Emma has been the Savior throughout the entire show. It’s a part of her identity now. Using the shears gets rid of her magic and her identity as a savior. She doesn’t even know who the figure under the hood is (in her vision). Shouldn’t she at least find out first before she makes a life-altering decision? I think she should at least give it some time to think about it! All in all, super excited for more :) Can’t wait!