Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 449374619.mp4

Downloads

Content

Files

Comments

Noah Winkler

I know you have been going through personal issues recently, but I do thank you for sharing this reaction this soon. I don't mind the wait, as I know youll always come back :)

André Carvalho

"What is the point of being a Marleyan Warrior if you still identified as an Eldian (an treated almost like a regular one)?" I’m only at the 7:50 mark of the video, but I’m sure by the end of this reaction you’ll understand. They’re not doing it for themselves; they’re doing it for their families—so they can become Honorary Marleyans. That way, their parents gain small but meaningful benefits. I won’t give away any spoilers, but you’ll see more references to this in the upcoming episodes.

Adam

Yes, the yellow bands. I imagine yellow bands can travel easier, get better jobs, won’t get randomly killed as much … If there’s no carrot to the stick, no rewards to match the punishments, the eldians would more easily revolt.

The Voidger

I was going to say something regarding a minor, non-spoiler detail that may have been overlooked here but then you cooked up a theory that sounded really interesting. We'll let that cook. Stay safe, Sophie.

Adam

Gal-y-ard sounds more mouthy than Gal-yard. That’s how I say it but I’m American so who knows

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

It's a rhetorical question. Not a literal one. I'm aware of why - I've discussed that in length in 3 x 20. The rhetorical question is designed to make you think how the promises don't match the expectation e.g. you're still oppressed working for your oppressor. The carrot was becoming citizens. Whereas we see that's not the case. They may have slightly better treatment but they're still not an equal and still forced to live in the internment camp. I'm aware why people do it. I'm making the point that they are never going to have a seat at the table - they are still oppressed regardless of the promises made. The reward isn't quite justifying the lengths to which they expect the warriors to go. My question is more so HIGHLIGHTING the lack of equality that was promised :)

Pham Hung

I randomly teared up at your reaction to Ymir's faith. Most reactors couldn't quite understand her story because it was told in an unorthodox way in season 2, which doesn't make much sense until the end of season 3. A nameless, blameless orphan plucked from the streets to bear a name too great for her to completely understand, scapegoated and given a second chance. Ymir lies to herself - that she is selfish, cheats, and steals to survive just to meet another girl who is also lying to herself, living only for others, a fake kindness that is ultimately selfish because she wants a hero's death. Ymir gave Historia the push to explore options other than just being swept along with the flow and duty of her ancestry. This episode is probably my favorite "humanizing the enemy" beat I have consumed in media. It's not overly done (looking at you The Last of Us Part 2), it's quiet, somber - they don't go out of their way to make us like these past enemies, Zeke was chucking rocks at the Scout not 10 episodes ago, but seeing what is still a teenager (lol) getting warm hugs from his grandparents was still heartwrenching.

AK

Loved this reaction and breakdown! I may have missed you talking about your plans/philosophy around watching openings/endings, but here's my thoughts about the ones in S4: The first OP and ED (S4E1-E16) do not have any spoilers. As with almost every OP/ED, it may be possible to theory-craft and analyze them deeply to get hints about the story, but I think if you just watch casually without going frame by frame they are worth watching. For the next OP and ED though (starting in S4E17), I would say please avoid watching the OP. There is an episode past which you can watch without being spoiled, but I won't say which one it is unless you would like me to. The EDs for both parts are spoiler-free, and there are a couple episodes in S4P1 and P2 with post-credit scenes so you would have to skip/watch anyway to get to those (remember the old trick: it isn't over until you see "To Be Continued" ;) ) The first special (1hr long) has no OP but does have an ED, which is spoiler-free. The second finale special (1.5hr long) has no "ED" per se but does have a little montage playing through the credits that is important to watch, and a short post-credits scene. Overall if you want to be extra safe you could hold off on watching any of the OP/EDs until after you finish their respective part, but I just wanted to let you know what to avoid to be spoiler-free. Again, thank you so much for posting! I know you've been having a rough go at it lately so I really appreciate you continuing to post :)

Jakob Eslinger

Rainer explaining in such a serious tone Sasha eating a potato was so funny to me when I first watched this lol

Anna Kyruin

You probably caught it in editing, but the person toward the beginning you thought was Connie was a soldier committing suicide. I feel like this whole episode is just showing how saturated with violence and trauma the lives of these children are. Gabbi and Reiner just walk right by the corpse paying it no mind. Other examples: Reiner's flashbacks. The traumatized foreign soldiers being shipped away that Udo reacts to. The traumatized trench digging troops reacting in terror to the soldier yelling "BOOM!" P.S. Cart Titan is my favorite Titan. I've been avoiding saying this every time you express your distaste for it because you hadn't actually met Piek yet, but Piek is such a lovely bean. ( I do understand the uncanny valley effect of her titan's face though)

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

Piek is lovely but hate the Cart Titan design hahaha Also didn't catch that in editing. Based on the slight glimpses we've been getting that I believe are Jean and Mikasa. I just straight up presumed it was Connie doing Assassin Creed moves.

HAL

38:35 there are plenty gradients to evil, they can treat honorary marleyans quite shitty and still treat them a lot better than the other eldians

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

I know? 😂 My point is that they're contributing to their own oppression by helping them because they'll never be seen as equal.

Benedict

Nothing better than an empty afternoon and a Darling Reaction.

david

Even watching the show in english it was something I was confused on first watch, but yea another detail I read in a comment some time ago is you can see he puts his hand over the door purposefully to make sure none of the marleyans soldiers walk through while falco is talking like that, and is making a point to falco to be more careful with the way he speaks in public.

Weeros

Ahh. Can I say once again I really appreciate you appreciating all the details and making all the astute observations here - makes the reaction to these what some would describe "slow" episodes so enjoyable to watch.

Jonathan Charles

I've read that last sentence a few times now, and I don't think I'm seeing things. Zeke. A teenager?

Pham Hung

lmfao I might've exaggerated it a little bit. He's 29 here and 25 in return to Shiganshina. But look at that bearded bastard still running to his grandparents like a little boy. I was very much aware, that's why I put the little "lol" there, It's more of a dig at this anime's inability to portray age because old man Levi is pushing 35 by this point while Reiner is supposed to be 21...

Pancake

I love the way you think Sophie. Enjoy this season, it's really good

Dag

Dozens of Marley's survey ships haven't returned from Paradis huh

Jonathan Charles

Ahh I see. I read the "lol" as incredulity, as if it was hard to believe, but still true anyway.

Lack Broke

I love how you perceive the strong contrast of brainwashing and propaganda in Reiner's family and how while he was absent for fives years, they all spouted and nourished this way of thinking into Gabi. She truly admires him for something he may doesn't believe anymore.

My Toasty Toast

Okay I had to subscribe and join the conversations now that you’re at season 4. This is one of the darkest yet best written episodes in the series. The slow pan-in of Reiner at the dinner table as he describes just normal quirks that people have while this ominous music plays in the background is so well done because for the Eldians in the camps what’s scarier than there being devils in paradise island is that the devils were people just like them all along. It was a similar situation in German-occupied Poland during WW2, where the Polish viewed the Romani, Jews, Homosexuals, etc as sub-human partly because of there fear that their German overlords would lump them in with them as well. Also, the soldiers coming back to their internment zone loosely reminded me of the scouts returning from an expedition to a community that rejected their pursuits and complained about the taxes and expenses. Both on Paradis and in Marley there’s an attitude of disdain towards the people comprising the military from the people who are directly benefiting from their sacrifices. Im so sorry if my opinions and observations are a little incoherent, I wish writing was a better strong suit of mine

• merry

Aaaa the Reiner table scene is so gooodddd!! I love love love how he basically just tells them completely normal things that any child might do like he’s reminiscing because… what else can he even say?

hman70

Your commentary is so consistently on point, it’s been obvious since s1 your content would thrive in season 4 :D though like I’ve said in past videos as awesome as it is to see you make astute predictions I’m most looking forward to the reactions to things you don’t see coming! Like the gut punch of Ymir being gone 😢 looking back on season 2 she knew that would almost certainly be her fate but she chose to save B&R by going with them anyway. What a selfless girl, how tragic that she didn’t get to continue as a character after how awesome she was in s2.

Russell Gambardella

For me, this episode is when the characters and world became elevated to an entirely new level of feeling real. It was rewarding to see you instantly recognize Reiner's words to Falco on the train as a warning to not think like that publicly and also to comprehend the significance of the many layers of the dinner scene. It breaks my heart how Reiner wants to talk about his experiences on Paradis but knows he can't be honest for the sake of his family. A small , chef's kiss esque detail I appreciate is how they lead into the dinner scene with Gabi's "BOOM!" she exclaims during her war story; it's a clever juxtaposition of the Marleyan soldier who yelled the exact same thing to make the Eldian soldiers with PTSD fall down. It really emphasizes the point that the cycle of instilling hatred via indoctrination is being passed down to the next generation.

Terauso

Any moment the Cart titan is on screen is Pieck content. :)