Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 451455611.mp4

Downloads

Content

Files

Comments

hman70

Hi Sophie Darling, I'm Darling. I love anime, heartfelt reactions, and deep dives into symbolism and themes. I hope I'm the right place!

Damian Wysoczański

You are one of few people who didn't immediately believe Annie was Kenny's daughter. It's so obviously wrong that I can't comprehend somone would actually think it's true. I respect that.

Blackfyre5490

You are literally the first reactor I've seen that put together Bertolt stole his back story in Season 1 from that old man. Impressive memory.

JVSkol

Insane how close the got to the Founding Titan, got up to the bodyguard of the real king of the walls

hman70

OK SO Mappa ended up adapting season 4 beautifully, it's panel for panel with the manga at many times. BUT 4x3 stands out as an exception where they had to fit this flashback which lasted like 3.5 chapters into one episode. They fit it all in rather well and I think anime only viewers get the entire big picture--but in this episode in particular there's lots of little things that got left on the cutting room floor. My favorite and one I think you would have really liked is as short scene of Bertholt's PoV right before he transforms the first time outsideof Shiganshina. Our little guy is so intimidated by the size of the walls and doubts if he can really break them. I'll link a screenshot in a reply to this comment And shoutout to you for immediately catching that the hanged man's story was used by Bert all the way back in 1x3. In that scene it seems even Reiner's surprised to hear Bert tell that story. There's another Bert fun fact that made it into this ep that I'll leave to another commenter to point out :D

Anna Kyruin

This episode is so great. Recontextualizing the first and secone episode of AOT completely. It is so satisfying to experience writing like this where the author knows where they are going from the beginning and just crafts everything around the road there so perfectly. This season changed the rewatch so much.

Jimbeezee

Bertholdt’s sleeping position is that of the Hanged Man tarot card.

Anna Kyruin

Kind of makes me want them to make an extended cut, not that AOT isn't good enough as is :)

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

It's so sad when we know too that there's nothing going to prevent it from happening :( HAHA you should see my 4 x 4 when the name Kruger is mentioned. I'm like "HE STOLE KRUGERS LAST NAME!" Vindicated though that it is indeed Eren! :P

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

Wait people genuinely fall for that rather than seeing it as a cover story to justify WHY she's creeping around?! That's so wild to me when we literally have seen her dad in flashbacks!!

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

And honing in on just how young these children are inside the bodies of these Titans too. Just further breaks your heart because you know they are young but VISUALLY seeing it is so striking!

Mesbah Mohamady

Magath is the current leader of the warrior unit, He first appeared in S4 episode 1 leading the battle against the mid east forces Also in the flashbacks he is younger leading the training of young warriors and he is the one who was questionening the decision to send children to Paradis

Russell Gambardella

Yeah it's wild that the big bad armored titan we see charging at the gate in s1 is literally a child having an inner monologue about self esteem and not understanding anything mid-sprint.

Russell Gambardella

Such a masterfully brutal episode, I'm so impressed on how you caught every little detail!

Ideos

You and Filmbuff are the only reactors who have recognized Eren from episode 2, as far as I remember. Some reactors had to hear his voice, or needed the close shot at the end of episode 3. Others didn't recognize him until the name drop in the post-credit scene in episode 4. And those who missed that scene, had to wait till episode 5.

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

I definitely can see why people would miss it but from the first moment I was like "that has to be Eren..." but I had a moment of doubt like "could it?" but then seeing the way he drops compared to the others made me suspicious. When you watch the scene in 4 x 2 he doesn't fall with panic like the rest, it's almost a delayed response as if he's watching the others before reacting but again there's no sense of panic or urgency in his movements. It's like he's going through the motion. That coupled with the "your armband is the wrong way round" instantly had me on alert that there was something more going on. If you were born and raised in the internment camps - there's absolutely no way it would be on wrong. Only someone who has never experienced that life would make a mistake like that!

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

Thank you! Gets a little confusing with all these new characters trying to remember who I have or haven't met haha!

Eleonora Frizorger

Thank you for your reaction! I’m dying to see your reaction to the next episode

Abdullah Al-bogami

It honestly baffles me how so many people genuinely hate the Warriors—Annie, Reiner, and Bertholdt—with such intensity I’ve seen other reactors literally celebrating Bertholdt’s death, laughing when he called for his friends, and just completely dismissing the entire emotional weight of this episode too. And I can’t help but think are we even watching the same show? The story clearly wants you to empathize with them, Annie crying as the Female Titan, the entire OVA dedicated to her, the sad music that played during Bertholdt’s death where the focus wasn’t even on Armin it was all on him. And then Reiner got an entire episode exploring his trauma and suicidal thoughts, The show laid their pain out for us, and yet some people still choose to ignore it. It’s like they’re watching this show as if it’s another generic black-and-white story with clear-cut heroes and villains—when it’s literally not The whole point of the show is that everyone is a victim of the cycle of hatred, and no one’s hands are clean. It's morally grey, layered, and deeply human What’s even weirder is how many of those same people feel sorry for Grisha’s backstory, but not for the Warriors when they literally grew up under the exact same kind of oppression Treated like rats and vermin by Marleyan citizens, and like tools and weapons by the Marleyan government. It honestly makes me mad. Reiner, especially, is one of my favorite characters of all time.

Kevin

Now that you’ve reached this episode, I can finally mention the fun fan theory about the weirdly drawn “Bertholdt” standing on the wall with Reiner that you thought was a new character. The theory is that he is not Bertholdt, but what Reiner imagines grown up Marcel would look like. He IS wearing the exact same clothes that Marcel is wearing when he dies. Reiner also says he’ll be Marcel, so he could always be imaging what Marcel would do in each situation, especially the day before a big battle. Do I think this is what the author was going for? Probably not. It is a really fun theory to cover for the animation inconsistency though that makes a lot of logical sense!

The Voidger

One of the hardest lines to ever come up here is Kruger's: "No one would go to war if they knew what it would do to them," and it's one of the messages I really hope that everyone remembered more about the show. War is hell, and it takes a toll on those within the battlefield; it changes them, breaks them, turns them into different beings altogether. And Isayama shows us front-and-centre one of the products of war—a broken former child soldier. I cannot emphasize this enough, but your continuous reinforcement of the idea that these people—our main characters—are mostly child soldiers thrust in a war that is not their own is one of the best aspects of your analysis. I really love this episode and your picking up on Beetlejuice's stealing that man's backstory is also really, really cool. A little factoid for the trio's time in Paradis is a minor factor on why they weren't sussed out immediately as not being citizens of the walls. Aside from spotty records following the attack on Wall Maria and Zhiganshina, Reiner shared his last name with at least one family in Paradis. The arm from 1×1, who also happened to belong to the Survey Corps member from that episode's intro, is Moses Braun. This was never brought up in the anime and is inconsequential to the plot but it does kinda shed some light on Karina's choice of words when describing the Eldians of Paradis to young Reiner in this episode. Anyways, I am stoked to hear your analysis on the episodes to come. Stay safe. Stay alive.

Krul

This is one of my favorite episodes of the show. You have known and understood what the "warriors" have had to go through for quite a bit of time but still, watching it all play out is so heart wrenching. To think that the fearsome Armored Titan, that took down Wall Maria and sealed the fate of hundreds of thousands of people, was just a scared and confused little kid trying to understand the situation he was put in really recontextualizes a lot of what we saw in season 1. It was very impressive that you remembered the story that Berthold told Armin and Eren, and that you were able to realize he had stolen it. There are a couple other scenes in early season 1 that you may remember, but that I needed several rewatches to catch them: 1. In episode 1x02 we can see Berthold, Reiner and Annie as kids asking for food in the same refugie camp where Eren, Armin and Mikasa were staying. 2. In episode 1x04, Reiner and Eren where doing some exercises with a knife when they spot Annie slacking off. To rile her up Reiner told her to "Remember what happened the first day we were here". Annie gets mad and proceeds to whoop Reiner's (and Eren's) ass. We now know he was referring to their first day in Paradis island when Marcel got eaten. In general, the whole of season 1 is littered with these little pieces of dialogue that only make sense now that we have the whole context. I think it is one of the reasons why AOT reactions are so popular. It is impossible for us to look back at season 1 with the same eyes now that we know everything that was actually happening in the background.

Mickael Landry

It still blows my mind that the horrifying monsters we saw that fateful day were a bunch of inexperienced kids. 🧒🏻🧒🏼👧🏼 The fall of Shiganshina always seemed like the grand plan of some evil mastermind, pulling the strings in the background. As it turns out, it was nothing more than an act of desperation, carried out by children who must’ve felt just as scared and lost as Eren did that day. The Armored Titan looked like a vengeful demon on a mission to annihilate mankind. Never in a million years would I have imagined that an anxious little kid like Reiner was responsible for all of this mayhem. AoT is brilliant at recontextualizing events and characters.

Mickael Landry

One detail I wanted to point out! Bertholdt's weird sleeping positions were confirmed by Isayama to be the result of him constantly having nightmares because of the resulting PTSD and guilt he felt from his actions. 🛏️💤 Him saying how he kept dreaming about the old man hanging himself shows the haunting effect that he had on Bertholdt. Because of the wall that HE broke, that resulted in the guy's kids dying... and as a result, he hung himself shortly after. Those deaths he caused materialized in his dreams through his sleeping positions. In the position resembling that of the tarot card "The Hanged Man" no less! It's honestly a bit crazy how those weird sleeping positions we heard Jean and Connie mention here and there before were unknowingly about Bertholdt having nightmares. And sadly, as seen by this episode and the past few episodes, Reiner's basically a broken shell of a man. He's got a few years left until he gets eaten, and he's literally just wasting away his days. The only thing he has left after every single person he cares about either died or got captured are those kids...and the memories of when he was a soldier. I know what Reiner's done is basically irredeemable and he can never atone for all the deaths he's caused, but I still can't help but feel immense sadness for the guy. If not for Marley's brainwashing and how the world is towards Eldians, Reiner would've otherwise been just a normal, honest, kind, and upstanding guy. His attempted suicide scene hit so hard for me. Just the glazed, dead look in his eyes was so heartbreaking. Ever since Reiner was born into this world, it was "damned if you do, damned if you don't". 🤷🏼‍♂️

Lemon

Something I find really interesting is the opposition/equality duality between Reiner and Eren. On the scene where Reiner almost suicides, the sun is hitting him on his back, you can barely see him,he is almost completely a shadow, a vult, in the light. That makes me think of the lunar and solar hero representation in this story(so far): Eren is like the solar hero, luminous, "strong", acknowledged and praised by his peers, the proud representative of the Paradis people. Reiner is like a lunar hero, emotional, "weak", not praised or proud, in the shadows. I believe this duality and the representation of Reiner in the shadows is intentional. Doesn't matter what side, people will have/want/believe in heroes. But they are but broken men/women, not heroes, just humans. PS: It's easy, and lovely, to see how much fun you are having at this point with this story, as the strings of the story start converging. Love the softer eye make up today, btw. I miss the dinossaur shirt though xD

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

I've never heard of the Solar and Lunar hero. I'm going to presume this is unique to Japanese culture in terms of literary motif and symbolism? It's definitely not one I've seen in my field but I do intend to read more Japanese mythology and literature now that I'm watching anime so I can better spot the cultural motif's that allude me due to this not being my area of study.

ML Snow

This is one of my favorites of this first part, it is one of the best directed. It never ceases to amaze me for all the details it has. It makes you have a more complete vision of what happened as well. 20:08 a mention to this cut, it's quite terrifying and great how they handled it. “Reiner is dead. If we need Marcel, then i'll be Marcel”. There really are several hints of the infiltrated warriors in the first chapters of the series, it's awesome. In the manga it is shown in more detail how they break through the wall. The strategy was to unleash chaos inside the walls and infiltrate. For that Annie would call the pure titans from a long distance, then exchange with Marcel to run to the walls, but as Annie had to run alone she was exhausted when they reached the wall, Bertolt breaks the wall and charges with Annie, that's why we only see Reiner enter. I imagine that the director wanted to put it in the chapter but surely they didn't have the time.

Rory Borcherding

One heartbreaking personal theory I have is that, we’ve seen that the final straw to Reiner’s mental breakdown was when he ended Marco’s life. But the OTHER final straw was finding out Eren was a titan. Before the battle for Trost the RBA trio still thought their target, the Founding Titan, was going to be inside one of the Royal Family members or something. They never imagined it would be held by one of their comrades in the 104th. So I think a huge part of Reiner’s mental break that a lot of people might not pick up on is that he had to confront the fact that their target, the person they had to bring home to be eaten, was at least potentially the person that Reiner empathized with the most on Paradis. That must have been an extremely difficult thing to reckon with. And remember, Marco’s ending happens in the same battle that they find out Eren is a titan so he was trying to process all that at once. It’s also why Eren is the person he reveals that he’s the Armored Titan in 2x6, because on a certain level, he felt so bonded to Eren that he literally forgot that he couldn’t realistically trust him with that information at that time. And maybe in some way, trying to get Eren to go with them of his own free will was his way of trying to reconcile the guilt he felt at knowing he had to eventually hand over his friend to be eaten. It’s so sad but it makes soo much sense after seeing this episode. Then when you think about everything else surrounding Reiner and his position in life, you realize that he has NEVER been able to be himself. He’s spent his entire life so far living a lie in one way or another. :’( The weight of that has to be so heavy. But it also hammers home the theme of people being trapped, the lack of freedom. Just like Eren felt the walls kept him from being free when he was growing up, Reiner has built up emotional walls that keep him from being free as well. And that fits the theme of his Titan so well too. He has a thick layer of defensive armor on, in more way than one. And at the same time, as you mentioned in your video, he has a desire to protect others, he always put the protection of others in priority when he can, that’s who he is at the core of his being. And so just like his Titan form represents a toxic aspect of his personality, it can also represent a healthy aspect of his personality too. A dual nature, just like his mental state. Daaammnn sorry this message is long but I just kept thinking of more things to add. This show has so many layers!

Sami

Wow, I have watched this show like 100 times and never thought about it that way. Great point!

Hippopi

Now you know why all 3 Warriors were just beneath Mikasa in rankings in the 104th. They'd already done all the training years earlier.