Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 455876439.mp4

Downloads

Content

Schedule is changing this week to match YT TuesdayThursdaySaturdaySunday

Files

Comments

Adam

I don’t think Willy thinks eldians are spawn of the devil, even if he says it

Adam

Then again he’s so ambiguous all the time, I don’t know. It would be a tragic kind of self hatred

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

I think he does and also doesn't. An internalised self-conflict between loving his family who are Eldians and pitying the situation that they've all been thrust into but at the same time hating his people for the past due to guilt. Internalised self-hatred happens across both race and sexuality where you've grown up being taught to hate these people so much, but you are also those people so you struggle between hating yourself but also not.

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

Agreed but think that's for the purpose of emphasising his conflict. It's not clear for him so it's also not clear for us either :(

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

Yeah - he's been doing that though since mid S2 & S3 so not really new to see him do that haha!

Sanna Nyström

This is getting more and more intense. Loving the react! Can't wait for more. My fav ice cream flavor is chocolate 🍫

Dag

It's very refreshing to see a viewer with empathy for Gabi - it's frustrating that a lot of people really dislike her, but as you point out it's another victim of the cycle

vxctorrr

She’s a victim but also a very frustrating and dense character most times.

Ideos

Top tier reaction and analysis! Hard to choose the best flavor, but if I had to, I'd say lemon.

Wouter

"I might cry in the next episodes too." But Gabi has a gun, so everything will be fine. Whatever could make you cry in such a situation? All of this is mirroring the original attack on Shiganshina. Only then we as the audience knew nothing, were confused and had to find out over a loooong time. Now we know not everything, but still a lot about the reasoning and emotions of most people involved in the situation. We hate to see the war, but it almost seems logical, which is kind of worse? Stracciatella.

SoL

The slow build up from the start of this season to the explosion and these episodes is some of the best tension building ever in any series

Gina Queen

My fave flavour is vanilla honeycomb! I have a local ice cream shop near my house that makes fresh homemade ice cream everyday, its absolutely amazing😆

Russell Gambardella

In the past, Willy definitely exhibited all you've described, as evidenced by him saying "I cursed the blood I was born with" two episodes ago. While it's impossible to know his exact feelings now, I think his line to Magath about Eldians being spawn of the devil is his way of making the point 'After all the atrocities you've committed, THIS is where you draw the line?!' Add in the stress of knowing he's going to die soon plus feeling it's his duty to protect the world/so many people from Eren, I think his crass way of making the point I mentioned is just a way to vent his frustration. Especially since all the things Maggath has done has been for Marley's greed/colonization while Willy's plan, despite it being brutal and involving massive sacrifices, is actually to protect a potentially larger number of victims from the conflict. Also, I love how you picked up on the subtle details surrounding Maggath which hints he has some empathy and common sense; he's a well written and interesting character! Good luck getting through the next few episodes haha

Jakob Eslinger

My favorite moment is definitely Erin punching the war hammer in the face before it's even done transformering. I love that anti trope of not letting the enemy do their fancy power up or whatever it instead just goes straight for the kill lol

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

Ohhh interesting! The only thing I would have had close to Lemon Ice Cream would be Sorbet when I was in Sorrento. It's so good!!

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

It's not because we also have Frieren being posted alongside and requires Early Access ahead of YT :) Tuesday & Saturday are AOT.

Potate -O

my favourite ice cream is just ice. Only ice. Pure frozen water on a cone. No flavour, no cream, just the raw crispiness of frozen aqua. I throw the cone away when I'm done

Weeros

I think I speak for most here when I say we’re here _because_ of the long yaps 😌. Favorite ice cream flavor = liqourice. One other thing - as always, really appreciate the nuanced and sympathetic / more adult take. Too many reactors are kinda locked in ”good guys bad guys” mindset so the highlight of the episode for them is when Mikasa & co come to kill everyone, no matter how much the show tries to nudge viewers to sympathize both sides.

Jakob Eslinger

To give Eren some credit, he technically didn't attack until after Marley and the world declared war on paradise. To me that makes a little bit of a difference. He waited until he was sure peace couldn't be an option. Or at least that's how I see it. Doesn't make it any less awful especially for the innocent civilians. But Marley decided to have this war declaration in the interment camps. Retaliation was inevitable after what Marley did. Regardless it's extremely well done with how they showed both sides.

Brandon

I'm pumped for this week and so happy that you put this out a day early! Personally I love peanut butter cup ice cream, probably my favorite. Eren's favorite is Monster Mash though. ...Zofia got Crushed Oreo....

Wuschel

True, I always interpreted the lines in question as just reciting a shared cultural mantra just so that Willy can skip pointlessly debating the ethical question of sacrificing the Eldians for a plan that was already set in motion anyway.

Lack Broke

My favourite is Pistachio, literally best flavour. You seem to be reacting to this episode the same way most people are. We're shocked by the atrocities our characters commit by attacking Liberio, we see them become like Reiner, Annie and Bertholdt. We want to believe that there is some plan behind it, because what could justify this massacre. They fell right into Willy's plan. And as Jean said, their future has never been more uncertain than now.

Jaron Clark

Like others have mentioned, I appreciate the fact that you are able to empathize with Gabi. It's definitely harrowing to see how callous Eren seems to have become, but yet we hold on to hope that he has some greater noble goal in mind that will justify his actions. Can't wait to see more! Also my favorite ice cream flavor is coffee and chocolate chip, and after that is mint chocolate :)

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

You know I said exactly that in my outro right? Peace may not have been an option but nonetheless there has to be an alternative to just replicating the SAME CYCLES that you know are going to do nothing more than create further blood shed and violence. At some point retaliation has to stop being the answer and justification.

Hezer

So many things I'd like to discuss, but I'll still have to wait while things are unravelling. I can only say that the writing to make you like and to humanize the "other" side is so good here. From the first episode, you're kind of cheering for the warrior candidates, and also for the Marleyan titans to win. And then you're faced with the "who's actually the enemy here?", when you're cheering for individuals on both sides, all the while knowing that not all of them are going to win. And I'm gonna go with a very finnish choice on the ice cream flavour. Salmiakki (salty liquorice) is absolutely the only best flavour (and maybe I'll accept mixing it 50/50 with vanilla). It's somewhat acquired taste (salmiakki in general), and takes some time to get used to. But once you do, you're hooked on it like a large portion of finns are. 🤣

Hezer

Not a huge fan of pure liquorice either, but with the added "salt" (ammonium chloride) it makes all the difference. Gives it that interesting edge to the taste.

Jakob Eslinger

Yes I typed this out as I was watching lol (cookies and cream ice cream btw). Breaking the cycle is the key, it's just how do you convince a population who feels wronged that they should move on. However, assume for a moment that Eren didn't attack and Marley did declare war like they were planning to and invaded paradise. Would the "correct" move still be to sit by and let your enemies unite and destroy you? I don't know the answer to that.

Eleonora Frizorger

Well, she’s a child and children tend to be like that 😂

Eleonora Frizorger

I love salted caramel flavour. Thank you for your reaction. I’m really glad that you can empathise with Gabi. I love her very much. I was sad to see her friends die like that. When I first saw this episode I was depressed even though I was spoiled and knew what comes next for some time already. But it was devastating to see Eren act like that 😁

Dot

Yeah I view it the same way you do Russell. We know that Willy believes Eldians deserve to live, he says that much, and he as he says in this episode, he’s been working on building the reputation of Eldian’s all over the world. Based on this, it’s clear that him telling Magath that they’re spawns of the devils was to combat any moral hang ups he might have with this plan

00_Calcifer_00

Eren: "Gotten Eat 'Em All" 😂 These reactions are genuinely the highlight of my day! So excited for the next ep!

Zarayut Ziri

Anyway, the soundtrack is awesome.

HAL

the tyburs are also kindof using children strategically tehy keep the warhammer in their family anyone can only keep it up to 13 years before dying and they want to keep secret who has it at any time so they have to have several children every 13 years

HAL

11:30 it always felt a lot more like willy is just going for that when talking with magath cause he needs magath to pull through for this plan to me - he probably has his own doubts but he still wants to pull the plan through and to make that happen he needs to make sure that magath is willing to sacrifice them

HAL

no more good or bad guys, just people I don't want to die killing each other

HAL

no ice cream too cold

Jesús López Coronado

Damn, girl, it's a breath of fresh air to find reactors who truly know how to express themselves when they empathize with characters. You have a beautiful soul. Greetings from Mexico.

Mesbah Mohamady

About Sasha, she was already able to kill Gabi with the gate guards but she did not ! she saw Gabi very well and she is a perfect sniper but she decided not to kill her because she was a child

Andreuzz29 🖕

Hello I’am Italian, i Enjoy so much wathching your reaction!!

David Caine

I loved the weight of thought you gave to Magath's comments to Willy, most would never even comment on the substance of it an realize even side characters are heavily thought out in the plot. So I love the way you analyze the details of plot and character traits in a precise and logical manner, because in fact crumbs are there and people can follow them by paying attention to the thoughts and words and actions of characters. Especially in this anime, where they have to condense the information given in the manga, pick and choose, so they have to be more precise and terse and poignant and meaningful with every sentence, without changing too much, this adaptation was superbly done. It's just awesome that you give it all the time and thought it needs, just a very small handful of reactors do the same.

• merry

Mint chocolate chip is my favourite ice cream flavour! C: I personally like Connie and Floch's new hairstyles but i think Jean looks too old in this season for a guy who isn't even 20 yet. You've probably seen him by now but Armin is literally so cute in S4 AAAaa

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

ARMIN IS AN ABSOLUTE CERTIFIED CUTIE!! Yeah I feel like Reiner also looks older than he actually is supposed to be haha! Mint Choc Chip is my favourite too!!

Lemon

Magath's ambiguity/grayness is often overlooked by this part of the story so it is so nice to see you hang on his every word and understand him as much as it is possible by this point. You had the same exact reaction with Gabi that I had when I first watched the show. I just immediately jumped to the "Gabi is Eren" argument. Always wondered what it would be like if Eren was born in Marley. Although Reiner is his parallel in a lot of things, he obviously is very different from Eren, yet, by this point in the story, can't possibly imagine Eren being different than Gabi in anyway, if he was born in Marley. There is, I believe, even a scene in the first season where Eren does the exact same gritting teeth expression as Gabi did in this episode but looking at the left instead(Gabi is looking at the right). That has to have been done on purpose, right? Favorite ice cream flavor for me, it is actually two, especially if together. Coconut and Coffee ^^

tonkatsu

Love how empathetic you are, Sophie!

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

That's what I thought. The way they both grit their teeth in the aftermath of violence they don't fully understand (Eren 1 x 2 and Gabi 4 x 6) is identical. They both express an inability to understand what is going on. They both struggle to comprehend why this has happened. They both SWEAR REVENGE for the deaths they've witnessed against those they view as the enemy. Eren and Gabi are the same. Two children forced into violent acts of revenge because of a conflict that was thrust upon them. They are two sides of the same coin. Paradise and Marley.

Jonathan Charles

Gabi isn't in the exact situation as Eren was though, I don't know if this will sway your opinion or not, but... Gabi knows the history of Eldia and Marley, as well as the details of Marley's attack on Paradis. As a Warrior candidate, she relished the thought of exterminating her fellow Eldians. Expecting Paradis to simply lie down and die without fighting is naive - and saying she does not know why Zofia and Udo had to die is immature - but deep down, in my opinion, she knows the reason and chooses to ignore it. Eren by comparison didn't even know he lived on an island until a few years ago. I'm not sure what my point is, but being angry and informed doesn't quite seem the same as angry and confused, to me.

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

Whole heartedly disagree. Doesn't matter that Gabi is aware and even then she's not FULLY aware either. She's only aware of what she's been told by everyone around her much like Eren was too. She's a child that's been brainwashed her entire life into believing a narrative that isn't true. You're expecting a child to have a critical thinking skills. She's a kid. She can believe a narrative and STILL NOT fully grasp what exactly the consequences are to her actions and decisions. Much in the same way Eren acted brash and threw himself into dangerous situations without critically thinking. The issue is when we attempt to enforce adult behaviours onto literal children and then condemn said children for not acting in accordance. Child soldiers will actively advocate for the death of their enemies but when faced with the reality of war often find themselves confused and torn. We don't condemn them the same way we shouldn't condemn Gabi. They are two sides of the same coin Gabi and Eren. Both are thrust into a war they don't fully understand and both have suffered immensely as a consequence. They are the reality of what it means to be children within conflict. The issue with your perspective is that you are expecting Gabi to behave and act older than she is. Much in the same way people were frustrated at Reiner, Bertholdt, and Annie. They are KIDS. They're not supposed to act rationally. If anything this show realistically depicts just how traumatising it is to expect children to behave like battle hardened soldiers when they are not mentally equipped to do so due to age but also because they lack a thorough and complete understanding of the world.

Jonathan Charles

I’m glad you took the time to write that, thank you. I can’t see perspectives outside my own, and it’s a problem of mine. I often need others to make me aware of why they think and feel a certain way, and you’re good at that. I don’t mean to be cold and heartless, but I do come across as that sometimes.

ace_pops

I don't comment much, so hi! Absolutely loving these s4 reactions, can't wait for the next one!! The main reason I love the whole beginnning of this season is just how much they humanized the Marley "side" (not Marley itself, but the people living there - even the gate guards trying to save Gabi or the Panzer unit saving Pieck in this ep). I really love the canditates (Gabi and Falco especially) and feel for them so much bc they're literally just kids in this horrible situation they can't do anything to fix. So I've always been quite annoyed when (the few times I've watched different reactors get to this point) people instinctively start "cheering" (or just getting hype) when Eren destroys that big building full of innocent people or when our Survey Corps is going around killing those people (which I don't even blame them for, but come on, we're not really supposed to be happy about it), just because it looks cool and they've been our main characters for 3 seasons. Even Zofia dying & Udo getting trampled was more or less forgotten after it happened. So even if they "get" that this attack wasn't a good thing - or that the show itself is anti-war, they still tend to feel like "the Marleyans had it coming" and kinda disregard the episodes that were supposed to make us understand the other side isn't some big, cartoonishly evil entity, but is made up of all sorts of people - some more or less evil, some misguided, some good natured despite the propaganda they've been fed, some innocent kids etc. We're supposed to understand that continuing the cycle of violence & war is wrong, no matter the side doing it. I was 100% sure that you would see the parallels here, and I'm glad you did! I especially love the fact that we have Gabi as such a direct parallel to Eren - really drives home the whole point in a great way. Excited for the upcoming reactions! <3 Also, favorite ice cream flavour is either tiramisu or oreo :)

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

I don't think you're cold and heartless. Everyone is entitled to their opinion but I find it hard to see it any other way due to my work with transgenerational trauma and the impact of ethnonationalist narratives on young children and the replication of violence. I think without that background perhaps I might have seen things more your way, you know? But that background fundamentally shaped how I see children in conflict especially when they become absorbed into fighting because of the narrative they've been taught. You can't help but see the tragedy of their situation of never truly having a childhood because all they've known and been taught is violence :(

HAL

most snacks I kinda just regret later

EDC

Your empathy towards Gabi and the Marley gang is much appreciated especially this early on. What a kind soul you are Sophie.

hman70

So often I want to leave a comment but it feels like you said everything that needed to be said over the course of the video. Gabi is absolutely becoming another Eren, a child who grew up in the shadow of oppressive walls, ignorant of the wider world, suffering unimaginable trauma and embracing a path of violence. We’re in the same situation at 1x2 watching a kid dedicate themselves to righteous vengeance but as an audience and the journey we’ve been on, our reactions to the two identical set of events couldn’t be more different. I love season 4 so so much. #GabiGang And my favorite ice cream flavor is gonna be chocolate, I’m a basic boy 😅

Hippopi

Pretty sure you've seen the episode where Gabi says "Did you see it happen?" by now and that line pissed me off so much. Gabi is basically a Holocaust denier there which is especially screwed when HER COUSIN LITERALLY DID IT. And she KNOWS that.

Hippopi

Eren never bought into what the rest of the Walls told him though. He was ALWAYS going against what everyone else said, he always had his own beliefs that weren't pushed on him at all. Also Eren has killed civilians before - within the walls when he fought with Annie.

vikkkky!

i love mint choco and sambayon/zabaione!

Keller

Mint Chocolate Chip or Coffee favored

Midnight_Kitty

my favourite ice cream is snickers ice cream.

Ilurandir

I like cherry and plombir flavour) At this point i haven't seen it much further (currently on 4x10) . My thoughts still are - Eren have seen all of the past(so he is carrying all of the trauma of all those people who has been before, that's why he is so dead inside), and sees possible futures and he knows what road he must chose to end all of this suffering and wars. I think it's partially destiny but not Ymir's doing directly. Don't know why am i writing this, because you already have the whole picture, but thought that i might still leave my thoughts) Also rewatched some other people reactions to Marleyan side of story... It sickening some people rooting for their death and want Gabi to be killed, especially after episode 8(I understand the anger on her but come on, throw her out of the ship really?!) . You are full of empathy and that's great! Don't know why it's so rare.

Ilurandir

P.S. Ehh... So sad i am late to this party( would have been cool to watch your reactions when they were coming out with other in this community. Anyway, to add - at this point i wasn't rooting for anyone, was just sad to see beloved characters try to kill each other (