Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 462444039.mp4

Downloads

Content

I usually edit out the pauses between sentences but it takes so long to do so if you noticed there's bigger gaps between words - I've kinda given up because it just doubles the amount of editing time I have to do and with this being such a long video I just did not have the patience haha!I forgot to put the watermark over too haha! Oh well - special treat of having it without! I was rushing to try and get this up before bed so I just completely forgot.

Files

Comments

Rory Borcherding

1:36:23?? Oh yes please! I love it. I’m going to put this on for apartment chores time :)

Dag

Paradis is in a damned if you do, damned if you don't situation

SoL

oh no hes hot! :D

Sally

I do’t mind episodes discussions being this long. There’s so much to talk/think about I can also listen to these at work :P

Eleonora Frizorger

Thank you for your reaction and discussion. I like listening to you. Good night I don’t know what I would like to know. I am not in need to know the truth about anything really.

Dag

Ah Sophie - if you think these episodes are gonna get longer discussions, I dread to think how long the later episodes are haha

Eleonora Frizorger

I thought about it and I think I would like to know about my first cat. I would like to know the story of her life. When she was born, how many children did she have and, mostly, what happened to her when my mom gave her away. I never knew who took her and how she handled that stress. And when she died. And what happened to her body. Where is her grave? What if she never found a new home and was just thrown out like a trash? I think it’s the only thing that I would like to know for sure.

Lack Broke

This episode is really important and one of my favourite of this part of the last season. Despite not having action, this episode is so good at addressing the different themes. On one hand, the scene whith Sasha asking that innocent question to Onyankopon and forming a bond with Nicolo over food shows us how, maybe, peace is possible. Not everyone hates them (like the Volunteers) and some can change and learn to appreciate them (like Nicolo). However, Sasha dying is a reminder, that maybe this is too hopeful. The population of Paradis is only of 1 million people against more than 2 billions of people outside the world. People that now, are uniting to fight them. If I could have one answer to one question, it'd be whether we're alone in the universe or not.

Pham Hung

An underrated episode, many people take issue with the switching between the past and current events. I found it to be a masterclass in visual storytelling because the color palette of the past is slightly warmer. At the same time, hope has exited the show with Sasha as we use Armin re-telling the events to Annie, another brilliant framing device that gives some direction to an otherwise expository episode. This show refuses to hold its viewers' hands, but if you're locked in, there are many things to appreciate about these more information-heavy episodes. There is an additional layer to Sasha's death that I have not heard any reactor discuss, but the Blouse are hunters at heart; they live and die by instinct. "An animal is most dangerous when it is cornered," was Sasha's intuition back in season 1, and this line perfectly describes Gabi and her desperation. I think Sasha, deep inside, knew that her fate was sealed when she spared Gabi, to look at Gabi's eyes, similar to that of a wounded predator, the suffocating primal rage, but she couldn't go against her nature to put Gabi down. If you go back and watch episode 8, you will see a prevailing sadness and uneasiness from Sasha (she's jittery and constantly asks and checks if everyone boarded so they can leave). I might have overcooked, but Sasha's instinct and almost sixth sense have always been faithful to her character.

hman70

Some people might see these eps as slow but they give us so much to chew on as they flesh out the time skip, they're worth the long discussions you're investing. I might push back a bit on how inevitable this war was but I also want to wait for more episodes to pass before making that argument, plus it may just be optomistic thinking on my part anyway. I don't think I have a good answer for the post question, I'd probably want the answer to something mundane. Like what would a Dragon Age 4 have looked like if David Gaider remained as lead writer, or a souls lore question like who exactly was the Gloam Eyed Queen

NissanZaxima

Its pretty normal for these type of reactions to go for 1-2 hours with season for. The writing is just so good and intense and meant for long discussion.

ML Snow

This episode was in charge of the same duo as chapter 3, Hayashi [The director of S4] and Nishiyama. Both episodes have the same storytelling method, and brutal transitions like Reiner giving emotional support to Eren while loading the shotgun, and the latter Eren shooting Sasha. The 2 best chapters of this first part in my opinion with the 5 and 15.

The Voidger

I don't think there's just one thing I want to know the truth of; there's so many. However, I'd start with the history of my people as there is little that we know of when it comes to life before our country was colonized.

Rory Borcherding

Yay. That’s perfect for me. If this is what less edited videos are like, by all means, better for all of us :)

Lemon

Always a pleasure seeing you "rumbling". I love that you used that word. That was a long and interesting one. These more calm episodes are so lore/theory rich, simply delicious (Nicolo sea-food dishes delicious)! Didn't read all the comments so maybe someone already said this, but Sasha's last words, "肉", meat, sound like "Niku" which is pronounced very similarly to the Nico in Nicolo. Was she really saying meat? Or was she thinking of someone? It's sad but beautiful to believe she might indeed be thinking of Nicolo. About the question. I do belive time is not linear, and therefore we have an intelectual and processual limitation to understand it, so we feel like we live each moment in a linear way despite actually living all of them at the same time. Therefore my question would be more of a request: "would like to perceive time how it really is, not in the linear way we live it nowadays, even if for a bit". But if it really is not linear, then, experiencing it for just a bit would be experiencing it forever.... so... I think i didn't thought the question all the way through xD well... i guess i was the one rumbling this time.

André Carvalho

One question, Sophie: In your opinion, from the world’s perspective, is it possible to deal with the Eldians diplomatically? The Eldians ruled the world for 1,900 years, as far as we know. They destroyed cultures and committed genocide against entire races. Only a hundred years ago—after the end of the Great Titan War—did the world finally experience a time when the Eldian Empire was not looming as a terrifying threat to their lives. Eldia’s ability to dominate stems from a genetic trait: Eldians can transform into Titans—gigantic, powerful beings. It’s not something they can renounce or simply rid themselves of. So, no matter how well‑intentioned the current Eldians may be (like Armin and Mikasa, who made it clear in the episode that they want to talk with the world and show their commitment to peace among peoples), nothing guarantees that the next generation of Eldians won’t return to their imperial ambitions, right? After all, they have the power of the Titans, and even though technology is advancing and coming close to stripping Titan power of its primacy in warfare, it is still a frightening force, fully capable of bringing nations to their knees. Would you feel at ease living in a world where a people with such power—and such an ominous past—supposedly seek peace with the other nations? Would you trust them?

Khanh An Nguyen

as an atheist (i dont mean any offense), but does god exist, and if it does, which religion would have depicted it most closely?

Hippopi

"Oh my god he's hot" HAHAHA That was everyone's reaction

Hippopi

Also remember Udo talking about how Eldians are treated abroad - it being so much worse than how Marleyans treat Eldians. Which is HORRIFIC.

Krul

"We killed any hope for peace, but we had no choice". I think Armin's words to Annie perfectly summarize this part of the show. Hange and co. were really looking for a way out of the upcoming war but with Marley unwilling to compromise (or even talk at all) it was impossible to reach a peaceful solution. It's incredibly sad to see the unyielding gears of war starting to turn and being completely powerless to stop them. We know that our main characters are just replicating these cycles of violence and we want them to stop, but what option did they really have? This question really haunts me because it makes me think of the real world, which is full of these endless ethno-nationalistic conflicts, and makes me wonder if it will ever be possible to put a stop to the cycles of violence that keep fueling them. I know that "world peace" is such a naive wish (every pageant contestant in every cheap movie would sillily wish for it), but if I have to choose a question that I would want to know the absolute truth about, I think at this point I woudl ask: will humanity learn at some point how to live at peace with each other? Or are we bound to follow Erwin's words and fight with each other until there is one human or less?

hman70

I want to push back a bit on Paradis having “no choice” but as I said in my comment it’s a bit tough to do before future episodes play out so I can explain fully, but suffice it to say I think that if there was going to be any sort of peaceful outcome Eren closed that door permanently and intentionally by attacking the festival in the way he did.

PaxTheKing

Reminds me of that squidward meme "oh no hes hot"

hman70

Crazy question to think about, a bit like the mutants in X-Men or mages in Dragon Age. What do you do when you have a race of people who are for all intents and purposes human yet have some genetic trait that makes them an objective potential danger to those around them? Complicated by the fact that in this case the Eldians once ruled the world. Like What would we do if the third reich escaped to a remote island in 1945 cut off all contact with the world then today in 2025 announced they had overthrown their government and wanted to re-enter world politics—and then how would that change if Germans as an ethnicity were genetically ticking time bombs 😭 I struggle to imagine the world of reality treating the inhabitants of that island much differently than the world of AoT treats Paradis. (And yes I know real world analogies are messy with AoT because eldians can be in the same breath an oppressed minority with armbands who live in internment camps yet also somehow due to the empire’s history have symbolic parallels to facism themselves, so I apologize for that lol 😅)

Krul

The possible choices that could have been made is definitely one of the most interesting parts of this section of the show, but I agree with you that it is too early to discuss it here. So let's just put a pin on these comments so that we can talk about it later!

Anastasia Lipgart

I personally prefer this version - without cutting the gaps - more. Feels more natural. Thank you so much for your reactions 🥰

HAL

meanwhile we're reaching a level of complexity and theorizing where avoiding indirect spoilers is a minefield

HAL

multitasking perfection - put on episode, see reaction part while eating, hear outro discussion while working

Dot

Great question

vpobuil

Personally I'd be ok with unedited reactions if it saves you work, didn't notice too much of a difference. I'd want to know some winning lotto numbers. Learning something important like if an afterlife or aliens exist would just freak me out, and it's not like I would be able to prove it to the rest of the world afterwards.

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

So I think it is possible but again - we are asking people to change their perspectives which is not a shift done overnight. It takes active participation and engagement in order to shift the narrative and harm that's been done. It's not impossible but extremely difficult. Both parties also have to be onboard for listening to it which is why we've found ourselves in a current situation where war is somewhat inevitable. Yes, the Eldians can shift into Titans. However, the last 100 years or so has proven that they are not the threat they are deemed to be. Marley may not have trusted them but the Eldians were not the one that fractured peace by attacking the other. Marley did it to test for resources more so than out of the lingering fear that the Eldians could one day wipe them out. It was a factor hence going after the Founding Titan but resources were also a strong motivator too. You cannot guarantee that they won't return that way but likewise you also cannot continue to condemn and punish people for a history they were not alive to remember or participate in either. Using real world context and I know that it differs because we cannot shift into Titans but the point still stands. Germany committed horrible atrocities during WW2. Japan also. If we run with the narrative that such countries can never move away from imperialistic desires then we would still be punishing them today for a history that many were not alive to see or even contribute too. Japan may be a poor example due to being notorious in denying their war crimes against China and Korea. However, it does apply to Germany where 2 World Wars were fought in relation to them. We sanctioned them so severely World War 1 and forced their country into a position of financial hardship that allowed for the festering of fascist ideologies to rise and if anything pushed the country to believe that acquiring power and dominance was the only way to be taken seriously. At some point you have to question is this doing more harm than good? By judging and condemning others for the past are we not then guilty of ignoring the only wrong that we have done? But returning back to Attack on Titan. There is no denying the threat that the Eldians possess but as we see time and time again - why should they be punished for a history they do not remember or were not born to participate in? Imperial ambitions are a raised ideology. You can't apply it to all Eldians but rather the Elite few that pushed for power and dominance based on believing themselves superior. How far does it go? Do we condemn Marley for their warmongering? For their atrocities committed against other nations out of imperialistic desires? Remove the Titan aspect from the general populace for a moment and Marley are mimicking the exact same behaviour even down to weaponizing a power that not many have. I think if a country with such power had made efforts to change and grow then I'd be open to at least the perspective that peace can be established because again - who is truly innocent? No one. They've all committed horrible acts against each other. So why should we punish one set of people for a power they never asked to be born with? There is no guarantee and I understand the scepticism and the feeling of war being inevitable. Hell - I even said in this episode that I found it hard to really see any other way out. But we also have to be the change we want to see in the world and if we ride this perspective of condemning everyone for their history or for what they cannot change then we'll all remain fighting until there's no one left to remember. Which is truly a sad perspective and one I hope that's not shared. Again - I can emphasise but I also would be of the understanding that based on nothing having happened in the past 100 years that there's been a shift somewhat in the perspective and would at least be intent to figure out what is ongoing and to make the decision for myself. Rather than condemning an entire population to suffer and die for a history they were not alive to witness or partake in. Sorry if this isn't as concise or make much sense. I wanted to get back to you but god I am so sleepy from work so I've tried to articulate my thoughts as best as possible haha!

Torje Amundsen

The on-reflex "Oh my god he's hot" at the end got me good LMAO

Jakob Eslinger

Both Eren and Armins plans both gamble with the lives of paradis . Reminds me of Erwin

Midnight_Kitty

Any military side that purposefully targets civilians is in the wrong in every conflict. I would ask what happened to Epstein.

AstralPrime

Loved the "Oh he's hot" at the end haha, no kidding.