Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 475613185.mp4

Downloads

Content

Wish me luck guys! I'm knee deep in the trenches over the next 5 days to edit as much as I can before I'm away on Thursday. Also got to film 4 episodes of AOT tomorrow so that's going to be an intense and long day haha!

Files

Comments

Jay Mistry

*begins chanting “manifest luck. manifest luck. manifest luck. manifest luck. manifest l…”*

AK

A clarification about Yelena and the volunteers: They're not Eldians, they're from other nations Marley subjugated. They told us in episode 9 when they were introduced that they were conscripted into the Marleyan military, and then recruited by Zeke to help enact his plans

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

Some of the volunteers are Subjects of Ymir. We know this because Onyankopon discusses this when Sasha asks about why his skin was darker than their own. He calls himself a Subject of Ymir. So if he is then others are too. Yelena's backstory hasn't been revealed. That's not been confirmed whether she's a Subject of Ymir or not. All Eldians are Subjects of Ymir so some of the volunteers are in fact Eldians because it's a race. Some Volunteers won't be but there's direct confirmation that others are. Yelena - we don't know yet or at least I don't know yet because the show hasn't confirmed anything yet other than she's from a Nation subjugated by Marley but Eldians still live in those areas which we know from the beginning of S4 in relation to Udo. Some volunteers aren't Eldians. Some are.

Sevenpsych

I know you'll catch it in the edit, but you missed Porco standing looking sheepish in the group of soldiers that Pieck waves at while ascending the stairs with Eren.

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

I did indeed haha! I don't catch everything because there's a lot going on and I imagine most people on a first watch won't catch Porco hence the surprise of him showing up beneath the floor :)

AK

Respectfully, Onyankopon says "We exist because we're wanted" referring to all humans, not just Eldians/SoY. I just think it's an important distinction to make which impacts the way the audience views the Volunteers. It is a common misunderstanding though so not knocking you at all for believing it. The show could do a better job of clarifying it. I'd recommend rewatching the first part of episode 9 if you still doubt me 😄 Not trying to be an asshole here, just hoping to clarify ❤️

AK

I also just realized the biggest tell that they're not Eldians/SoY: They aren't wearing armbands in any of the flashback scenes even when they are still working for Marley 😄 The only loophole with that evidence is that they maybe ALL got past the blood tests, but it was a big deal that the Owl succeeded in doing so, therefore it stands to reason that all those volunteers would have a hard time with that. EDIT: In my version's subtitles, Onyankopon also said "The same goes for YOU Subjects of Ymir" (emphasis added).

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

There's still no absolute definitive proof that other Volunteers aren't also Eldians. We don't know every single Volunteers background. Again my point stands that some likely are and some likely aren't. I interpreted Onyankopon's language as inferring that he is a Subject of Ymir because that's how it's implied since he refers to her as the founder. No one outside of Subjects of Ymir refer to her as the founder. I appreciate the clarification but I also am allowed to believe that not everyone in the Volunteers is Eldian as Eldians exist in those nations and are conscripted too. Yes - they may have no armbands but we also know that many live in disguise and we've also seen that people can remove them too to slip under the radar. Literally revealed in Ep 16 that Zeke's mentor had a whole arse life beyond the radar. We can't automatically make that presumption. Yelena's backstory hasn't been revealed so again please tread carefully because we still know so little about her that anything you may could be a spoiler ❤️

AK

I'm keenly aware not to say anything specific about Yelena haha, don't worry ❤️

Drift3r

"I think the euthanasia process is just ethnic cleansing by another name" So many people miss this point.

Sevenpsych

I certainly did not catch it the first time, but when you specifically miss things it has come to surprise me. lol

Drift3r

I really liked that subtle touch of placing Porco in the crowd. It would of been so easy for the animators to not do that and no one would of raised a fuss.

Anna Kyruin

This episode ended "part 1" of the "final season" of AOT (which, let's be honest, is basically three seasons) which meant for people watching this on release they had to wait like 9 months until the next episode. Imagine just sitting with not knowing what's going on with Zeke and Levi, or the battle breaking out in Shiganshina for nine months? (granted, it's nothing like the gap between S1 and S2 lol)

Anna Kyruin

I was also so frustrated with how they treated Ymir and Historia at this point in the series. In S2/S3 Historia had so much potential as a force for positive change and yet here she is in S4 part 1 being the literal monarch and basically making none of the decisions. The whiplash of the subject/object inversion for her character between S3p1 and S4p1 was so jarring for me. Also relatedly I lowkey never forgave Isayama for killing off Ymir off screen between S2 and S3.

Ricardo

For your whole Thought experiment at the beginning.. I suspect that you should have all the information to go deeper into there, i just feel like.. you are not yet quite asking yourself the right question for this. Might have to try an different angle. Disregard, i should just keep watching before writing.. As usual.

Lack Broke

I find your take on the Volunteers really interesting. As for this episode, their allegiance has been not really clear for bow except from Yelena, and we don't know the specifics of her backstory. I see someone talked about the confusion on whether they're subjects of Ymir or not. It's an interesting question because most reactors don't question that part. Since Yelena has clearly been hiding her intentions, you're right to doubt what she says. Since they've been a huge part in progressing the plot of season 4, I sure hope it'll get addressed. (or not for the sake of Historia lack of screentime in this first part of season 4)

daragh faro

Pixis said it perfectly- "To tell a good lie, you should mix in some truth". Pieck did exactly that.

DepressedSoggyWaffle

Another reactor pointed out that that scene with Zeke almost looked like a reverse birth which if intentional would be pretty cool. The irony of someone who wishes he'd never been born being stuffed back into where he 'came from' in order to survive another day, after almost being killed by a guy who’s constantly surrounded by death but can never seem to die himself is just 💀 it's almost comical

DepressedSoggyWaffle

Yeah Ymir being offed off screen after they made her one of the most interesting characters, has always been one of my major gripes.

Dag

This is kind of what I was talking about last episode - if Yelena and others want a "quiet exit", well they're about to be bombed from the skies, and this just seems like a small Marleyan advance force - it's not the entire world bearing down on them just yet. The plan is full of contradictions.... even assigning armbands to determine when someone converted to Jaegerism - that's really rough, how can people not compare this and Marley? Fear, I suppose.

André Carvalho

In that scene, when Pieck raises her arms, she does it to show Porco that she’s restrained alongside Gabi. She’s simply brilliant!

André Carvalho

Jean’s observation when Yelena laid out the “euthanasia” plan is undoubtedly valid: who can guarantee that, once the Eldians have grown old at the end of the process, the world won’t still decide it can’t trust them and wipe them out anyway? If that is one of our arguments against euthanasia, we must also accept that the Eldians—regardless of any peace treaty or agreement—will always be targets of the world’s distrust. What’s more, we have to recognize that one reason civilization would attack them is precisely because it knows they have grown old and therefore weaker. In other words, weakness is not a winning path for the Eldians. They should avoid any action that diminishes their strength. We see the same pattern in our own world: nations locked in an intense race for power, for more technology, for groundbreaking inventions, all to stay ahead of the competition. The fear is singular: become obsolete, and your neighbors will start thinking, “Wouldn’t it be better to eliminate them now, while they’re weak?” The series suggests that military innovations are on the verge of making Titans less relevant in combat. Considering that, considering that trust may never materialize, that we must stay strong before the world or be attacked, and that we are about to lose our edge in warfare, shouldn’t there be an urgency to address this situation at any cost? The ultimate outcome of failure for the Eldians is the death of their loved ones—their parents, their children, everyone they hold dear. That is the Jaegerists’ line of thinking. And no, I’m not defending them; I’m simply pointing out what they believe. I’m one of those who, looking at what we see in our world and the cycles of our history, believes that peace with the Eldians is not something the world will allow. It’s simply unrealistic—and Jean seems to think the same. I don’t support the Jaegerists because, without question, fascism will never be the answer. But even after thinking seriously for years, I haven’t found a realistic alternative course of action for Eldia. We can all disagree, of course. I’m only contributing my perspective on the matter.

XV

The fear and hatred of Eldians isn’t just about ancient history or "past sins". It’s rooted in the ongoing threat Titans represent. The atrocities didn’t stop with the fall of the Eldian Empire, it's been shown that they continue today under Marley, which weaponizes both Pure and Intelligent Titans to oppress others. So for the world, it’s not just about what Eldians did, but what they’re still being used to do—and what they could do again. Whether it's under an Eldian empire, Marley, or a global alliance, this world's inability to reconcile with Eldians stem from precedent, potential, and the inability to guarantee safety. That's an almost insurmountable mountain to climb. The easier path would be euthanize all eldians, or kill all the enemies so there's no "other" anymore. But IMO the right path can often be the hardest, and even if there's little chance to succeed they must try scale that mountain as Armin and Hange are, or as Shasha's father says they must all "get out of the forest"

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

I have already spoken about that previously. I'm aware that it's more than just what they've done in the past but the past is also routinely used as a JUSTIFICATION for the mistreatment and oppression of Eldians more so than their current weaponization by Marley. Hence why I mention it. I've spoken at length in relation to the ongoing threat so I didn't feel it necessary to repeat myself haha! But yes - the hardest path is hard for a reason but far worth it compared to the other options presented!

David Caine

Nine months and a half after this episode for the next half of season 4. Nine. And a half. Babies were conceived and born. And we waited. I salute the fortitude of the anime-onlies, by then I had already jumped into the manga during the battle of Shingashina the previous season. And it still hurt to wait for the anime's full glory.

hman70

The way you stand up for Historia and her role in season four is almost 1:1 with how Jean and Conny stood up for her in the scene where Levi asked her to become queen, it's very sweet. Like "Hey she just stood up to her family and their expectations of her and now we're going to forcer her right back into that role just because it benefits us?" Her answer then was something like "I appreciate it guys, but I'm the one who gets to decide if it's forced on me and I'm willing to do it" would that be her same answer now? To what extent does she embrace her role as a mother like she did as queen? Would that even matter if her kid was forced to eat her by the time they hit puberty? If only there were some way characters could communicate their feelings to the audience with their words thoughts or actions. But alas for now I guess we must make do with few and far between shots of her looking miserable and draw our own conclusions lol

HAL

23:05 the guy who wishes he had never been born being unborn

HAL

I kinda see a point to her being sidelined cause installing the correct monarch is not that great a solution But they could've at least let her be with ymir then

HAL

34:10 well by sterilization ratehr than direct murder but then again tht has often been used as an excuse early on and doesn't make it much better

HAL

51:35 galliard was in the crowd when pieck said hello reiners probably too well known to blend in among them

Brandon Yao

Hi Sophie, just want to make a quick note about something you said about Yelena’s and Zeke’s intentions. Yes, war would still happen and conflict would still happen, but I believe Yelena and Zeke don’t see themselves as trying to bring about world peace. They just want to end the “terror of the titans”. This is a concept that is touched on a few times in this series, that the terror of being eaten by titans is so horrible that people would rather kill themselves than face them. Zeke sees it as cruel that they bring more Eldians into this world who will be spit on for existing, who will be turned into weapons against their will, and then have others experience the same terror of titans eating them and their loved ones. Hence, he takes it upon himself to end the Eldian bloodline in a “peaceful way” where the only people who have to be eaten anymore are Historia’s children (he probably sees them as necessary sacrifices, just like all the other people he has killed for his goal). Hence, euthanization. But yeah, that’s mainly what I wanted to say. I don’t think world peace is the ultimate goal, as even a person with godlike person couldn’t bring that about, haha. Zeke just wants to end the terror of titans, and basically put the Eldians out of their misery. At least, that’s my interpretation. Let me know what you think!

Tobe

Not aot related but is that priory of the orange tree on your shelf? I adore that book

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

I completely get you. I think my point is more about how Yelena tries to sell it as a peaceful alternative to war. Zeke is at least more realistic in his perspective! 😊

Tobe

I really enjoyed it and based on your aot reactions I think you will too. It does really interesting things with the concept of truth and history and the worldbuilding is so rich

KilZero

such a nice detail at 31:38, gabi tries to pick up a rock again like she did for kaya, but there are no rocks here.