Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 495301079.mp4

Downloads

Content

I left in my core moments for the DUB as I had watched it for the first time in Sub (which is uncut) at the end. I didn't leave the full thing because I didn't really say much as I'd already watched the episode haha!

Files

Comments

Dag

The excitement! I think you're really gonna love this one

tonkatsu

Yay, it finally dropped!! So excited for you, Sophie! 😂

KrakenKing

This description confuses me

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

The first react is sub. I then included moments where I watched the episode in DUB after my discussion of the first episode.

Jay

As much as I love sub, dub for fmab has better line delivery and the translations for sub sometimes aren’t as good as what’s acc said in the dub

Jimmy Nylund

Regarding Bradley's confusing title: his title is just "Fuhrer". King is his first name and Bradley is his last name.

Alma

OMGGGG LET'S GOOOOOOOOO

Alma

The first few episodes are very fast paced and densly packed with information, so i won't blame you if you miss anythig haha. It took me a couple watches to process it all. To my understanding, they kinda speedran the early episodes of Brotherhood since they had already been adapted in the original 2003 series before it went off course due to catching up with the, at the time, still ongoing manga. So be ready to get info dumped on!!

ML Snow

Speaking of voice acting, Ed's Japanese voice actress plays the role of Hange in AOT

Alma

I agree with your stance on the dub vs sub on this series. I like both, and i do think the dub has it's moments where it can outshine the sub, but as a whole, i do lean towards the sub for the exact same reason you do. The dub is a little better on the humor since it rewrites the jokes to work better in english, but the sub is better on the emotional, which i do prefer over the humor.

Lemon

Very interesting that you added the part after the discussion watching dub and then comparing. Like you said, and I think no one will ever disagree: "they are both phenomenal". But I do agree the japanese one draws out more emotion from the voice actors who are absolutely stellar. Also it is so funny hearing Edward exciting/enraged voice as it is the exact same as the actress' "normal tone" when playing Zoe Hange in AoT xD After a few episodes i thought something similar to you: "I would die for Edward but I would kill for Alphonse!" xD Alphonse is the sweetest! Hope you enjoy the series as much as I did! We will all laugh, tense up, cry, be scared and "rage" with you! This is the perfect show to share with someone. I have advised this series to so many friends, and I always feel so happy how much everyone loves it, feels like bringing a little box of joy to people.

Dermos IV.

Not sure if this is a hot take, but I honestly think this series has one of the best soundtracks ever. The music is insanely well composed!

Alexandre Mortier

Love that you let us glimpse into your decision making process this way, thanks for that, (and for echoing what I personally feel in terms of emotionality as well) whatever choice you end up going with, I’m excited for this journey. And oh fun fact in case this hasn’t been mentioned yet; FMA is one of the only prominent 21st century ‘Shonen’ written by a woman (which really shows in later female characters feeling like actual people and not just one-note plot devices for me so hope you enjoy this story!)

Hezer

Yeah, if you directly compare the voice acting, Japanese will almost always be better. It's much more competitive profession in Japan, so that brings a higher quality overall. And as someone who's not native in English or Japanese and has been watching tv shows / anime in both languages for almost the same amount of time, a lot of times English voice acting has that cringe to it. Where the voice has feeling in it, but it's still somehow emotionally disconnected from the scene. There is also at least one Japanese voice actor that is quite highly regarded, but who will almost always give me the cringe feeling because the delivery doesn't connect with the character. That's not to say that English voice acting with this show is bad, just that Japanese is slightly better overall. There are also some characters, that I think are actually better in English.

Rory Borcherding

I’ve never seen FMAB, so I’m gonna watch it along with you for the first time! Let’s go!

Flubbedsquid

To fully appreciate this anime one should read "The Secret Teachings of All Ages" (this comment is satire) But unironically, you can tell in every aspect of this show how much research the author did. From the alchemical philosophy and esoteric story elements to the more grounded political and military stuff, everything is very well represented.

Don Ratto

ive watched this show both in sub and dub. i do prefer the sub but there are still a few characters i prefer in DUB, namely the fuhrer

Shxll

The voice actors for DUB and SUB are both amazing however i feel like the subtitles are poorly translated at times and it takes away a lot (for example when some says something and it gets quoted or referred to along the show the DUB is way more consistent and coherent where as the subtitles sometimes feel like they are poorly translated with google translate which is a shame), especially for quite a few of the most iconic scenes. Unfortunately i cant give an example without spoiling you at least until ep. 2. But thats just my opinion anyways and ill love your journey either way :) + the bloopers for the DUB are great

Adam

There are four additional episodes, known as OVAs. You can watch them interspersed through the show, or all together after the end. It may be hard to find them. But I swear they’re important and almost no reactors take the time to react to FOUR WHOLE EPISODES

Krul

LFG! I'm so excited for you to react to this show! I think others have already mentioned it, but the first episode is not exactly considered "canon" as the "freezer alchemist" was never introduced in the manga. In general the first episode was used more like a quick reintroduction of the world for the people that was already familiar with the previous version of FMA. Really looking forward to watch your reactions to the next episodes were the world and characters start getting more fleshed out.

Hannah

I think your assessment of dub/sub makes so much sense! And I agree with your comments when you were comparing the scenes. For me, I connect with the story humor a lot so that must be why I really enjoy the dub to watch on my own. I think that the sub scenes where the emotional stakes are high sounded amazing when watching this reaction with you. Excited to watch the series with you and do a full sub watch!

Adam

The sub is fine, I’m mostly disappointed because I listen to reaction videos at work and can’t read the subtitles. I will just have to watch them when I can get the time

Slendercucumber

I always had trouble "getting through" FMAB for some reason I can’t quite put my finger on—even though I honestly have nothing bad to say about the show itself. But maybe your reactions will add that extra spark, and I’ll finally be able to enjoy it together with you! ;) Also love the effort for the languageversions! Interestingly I never watched the sub so maybe that is an even more extra different aspect in this watch for me.

Ura Meshi

I highly recommend the english dub for this show. This is coming from a sub-only watcher but this show is one of few exceptions.

Justin Doan

I don't think this counts as a spoiler, but wow, the amount of innocuous foreshadowing/hints in FMAB right from the get go is amazing. It's nice that they added all that compared to the manga, as little winks to those who've already read the story

Jakob Eslinger

Damn, was hoping for the dub. I listened to these at work so it's a lot easier to follow what's happening. Also I think Ed and Al both have excellent voice actors. One of my favorites regardless of sub/dub.

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

I prefer Ed's SUB voice over his DUB hands down. Al's voice actor is phenomenal in both SUB and DUB!

Charlie baker

Wild , vics voicing definitely was peak

JitterBones

For those of us that really love this anime, for me as well, we've watched this anime to completion in both sub and dub and enjoy both for different reasons. I can't honestly say one is better than the other! It's a big reason why the poll was nearly split 50/50 and always has been.