Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 502081758.mp4

Downloads

Content

No confirming or denying any of my theories or discussions until after we finish!

Files

Comments

Cisco

So Eren and the others attending that conference thing with the Eldians conference was Eren’s last attempt at making contact with the other side of the sea for peace. But the rhetoric by the spokesperson, to Eren, made it clear that they thought of the island Eldians the same way as the other non Eldians do, that they were island devils. Perhaps they could’ve directly engaged with that Eldian group, but Eren decided to move forward with his own plans.

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

I'm aware. That's the point I'm making. They had other plans beyond listening to the Spokesperson. They were planning to reach out and speak with people but they never got that chance. Eren never gave them that chance.

david

17:00 I know youre just trying to be empathetic but lets not start justifying stealing because "hes a kid in poverty" lol doesnt mean he gets a free pass after taking their money. Obviously not saying I agree with severe punishment, but theres a middle ground

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

He's a refugee displaced by war. I'm sorry but he's doing what he can to survive like anyone would in that situation.

david

Agreed, still dont care lol. This is the same thing people do with eren and floch btw just on a lesser scale you realize that? "oh eren was so oppressed they gave him no choice but to kill all of humanity" .... Like bruh lmfao It really doesnt matter what situation hes in, it doesnt justify wrong-doings. Im telling you you're on a very slippery slope there... If you ever experience a home invasion/get robbed I expect you to do nothing about it if it involved a kid who "needed it" right? Again I understand why people do these things and we should help them, not teach them that stealing is okay.

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

You do realise that there is more than just black and white when it comes to these issues? You can't just say because I'm empathetic towards someone stealing to feed themselves and their family, who are STARVING because of war and displacement, that it's akin to supporting a genocide and advocating for a genocide. So no - it's not a slippery slope. They're two different scenarios. Again, you're throwing in a home invasion which has nothing to do with this situation. I never said what he did was right or okay or even justified. I'm merely saying that he doesn't deserve the punishment inflicted upon him and that we would do the SAME THING if stealing was what stood between feeding your family or starving to death.

david

Well I said I agree with you there lol he doesnt deserve the punishments they suggested but it also doesnt justify him stealing again no matter the situation, and no you never said it justified it but I did get that feeling from watching so my bad I guess. Also yes, stealing and genocide arent the same, but the concept of people justifying doing wrong due to a situation someones in is where it starts is my point.

Jason McCaslin

Again I just wanted to say I'm sorry about yesterday. I know you said you forgive me, but I'm the type to overly apologize when I'm wrong.

tonkatsu

Lol your reaction to the swimming colossals! 😂 I would say we manga readers were surprised as well. 😂 Just got to say one of the things I deeply appreciate about AoT is how realistically complex it is. It doesn’t prescribe a clear solution to war/conflict/hate, but it does a great job exploring the themes, the roots of these issues, and possible responses. In doing so, it makes us sit with the discomfort, the questions, and the complexities, rather than offering easy answers and a convenient resolution to its dilemma despite it being “just” fiction and any author can just offer a convenient resolution and convince the audience with it. (“It’s just a story anyway! Anything is possible!” others might say.) But AoT respects reality’s truths and its audience enough to let them reflect and wrestle with story’s weighty themes that echo so strongly in the real world.

Anna Kyruin

I see a couple comments and am guessing a lot of people will not get your point about Eren not allowing diplomacy despite him seeing how tilted the view of Eldians was in Marley. I would just ask those people to imagine if they would what would have happened if Willy Tybur and Armin Arlert were allowed to sit down and talk.

Ouna

I really see it otherwise, as hange said before, they were only trying to observe their thoughts and ambitions and weren't open to the idea of exposing themselves to the enemy. Only, if they see a possible postive outcome would they then try communicating with them. And I agree, wouldn't choose either to stand there with no means of protection and declare that I'm one of those devils he just swear to kill. Also, these people didn't even know then that the island's devil are now out and about. Though they still ignorant devils caged behind walls, and still advocate for violence againt them. Now, what would they do if they are actually standing with all that knowledge next to them?

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

So much could have happened if the opportunity had been allowed. Yes - Eren did not like what he heard and he saw that as a sign to continue BUT that does not mean that there wasn't still a chance for peace to be brokered elsewhere. You can't ever say that you tried everything if you didn't even allow them that opportunity which was the whole point of the expedition to begin with! We knew the chance was slim. We knew that there was going to be a bias. However, what the Pro-Eldian leader stated in public may not be what he believes in private. They have to say this because they're in Marley and are oppressed. Forced conformity to appease is very much a post-colonial tactic. Whose to know if that's really his beliefs because they never SAT DOWN with him as they indented. Eren took it at face value and ran with it. We also know from Gabi and Theo that perspectives can change and shift if given the chance. There will always be what ifs now. What if they had spoken with the leader and the movement? What if they had spoken with Willy? What if they had talked more and fought less? What if they had the chance to shift the narrative? What if Eren hadn't made the decision for all of Paradise without speaking with the others? Marco's words of 'we didn't even get the chance to talk' is all the more haunting.

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

And yet they don't know unless they try and they knew that the chance was slim. However, they never got that opportunity to observe further or even make contact with more sympathetic ears because Eren took it upon himself to make the decision for Paradise without consulting anyone and dragging them into a conflict with no prior warning. They weren't given a chance for their idea to end this peacefully because Eren chose not to go along with it. So you can't say that there's not 'what ifs' especially as it's supposed to be symbolic in replicating Marco's final words of "we didn't even get a chance to talk" because they didn't get that opportunity either. There's no knowing what could have happened because we never got to see that nor did they get the opportunity to explore that avenue further. It was cut off before it ever truly had a chance to develop which is all the more the pity especially when we see how people of this world can be embracing of others if given the chance. Narratives can shift when people are exposed to the 'enemy other' and it is solely because they've been 'othered' and never been met before that people see them as monsters. They could have broken down that narrative but they were never granted the chance or the opportunity.

Eric Newton

I remember a few episodes back you said you hated the whole ‘pregnant female’ character cliche, and that “there better be a good reason Historia got pregnant” and I commented that there was, because she’s the worst girl ever. But no spoilers at the time! Historia didn’t get pregnant to stop Eren’s plan, she did it to help Eren’s plan. Because she was pregnant, the military couldn’t feed Zeke to Historia immediately like they originally intended so they had to hold Zeke in isolation in the forest to come up with a new plan. Because of this she bought Eren and Zeke more time to break out of their respective captivities, gather allies, take over the government, and meet in Shiganshina, so Eren could fool Zeke and start the rumbling. “Exterminate the titans?! Who the hell wants to do that bullshit?! I’m starting to hate humanity! Let ‘em get wiped out by the Titans!” She had the idea first, and went through with it in the end. Because she’s the worst girl. But still best girl :)

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

Hm I don't fully buy that's her philosophy nor would I say that's a good reason for her to get pregnant. I much prefer the idea that she does it to defy Eren because in the context of the conversation she's pleading with Eren to NOT go ahead with his mission. She may have unintentionally bought them more time but I don't think her intention was to allow Eren to continue his mission or to even side with him on this. To become pregnant is to accept that she will have to sacrifice herself one day to keep the continuation of the cycle and that her child will be a target for its royal blood. The pregnancy feels in defiance to Eren rather than aligning with his plan. I think it can be argued either perspective but I much prefer this being a sacrificial attempt to protect others by restricting her freedom.

XV

I see a lot of people off-line and online mistake that the past history happened 2000 years ago. Everything in this story started 2000 years ago and ended 100 years ago.

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

I'm aware of the difference. I'm talking about the enslavement of the Marlayen people who were oppressed for 2,000 years which is used as a justification for their bias and systematic oppression of the Eldians in turn. We know they were enslaved for 2,000 years because it's been reiterated time and time again :)

Eric Newton

Yeah I get that, i didn’t want to be literal, I just thought that quote is just a funny/ quirky little detail Isayama threw into the story just for it to come back. Kinda like how Eren said he’d destroy the world in S1, just for him to actually do it in S4 lol. But yeah it’s definitely not her philosophy. She was definitely pleading because she learned the truth. But I think if she really wanted to put a hole in Eren’s plan, she’d do it behind his back instead of asking him directly beforehand. Personally, I think if she really wanted to be a sacrifice a destroy Eren’s plan, she would’ve eaten Zeke like the military originally planned then gotten pregnant, and force Eren to use her as the key to access the Founding Titan power rather than Zeke. I think her being pregnant only helped him rather than hurt him

Drift3r

But if he can see into the future, and/or let's say possible futures, so don't you think he probably already knew how it would turn out?

Robin Crow

Got some great next 2 parts coming, can't believe its going to be over, AGAIN!

Jordan Olivier

I haven’t pressed play yet but just want to say THANK YOU for deciding to start reacting and making AOT your jumping off point. I have really enjoyed following along and will be staying for whatever you’ve got coming next!

Damien Lebourdais

What a journey Sophie, enjoy those last épisodes

Don Ratto

AHHH I CANT HANDLE THIS WAIT. is there a double patreon i can pay for to get these another week before ahhhhhhhh

Brandon

So i wanted to wait until this episode to explain why I am on the side of Eren and Floch. First, we have seen a lot of references to WWII era Germany in the way that Marley treats the Eldians (armbands, forced into ghettos, etc). But the conflict between the world and Paradis is more similar to Cold War US vs Russia, with a significant twist. The introduction of The Prisoner Dilemma scenario. The Prisoner Dilemma is a scenario in which two suspects are arrested and interrogated separately for a crime. If they both stay silent and cooperate, they can both go free. But if one betrays the other, they will be granted immunity from the crime. The dilemma is if you should stay silent in the hopes that the other prisoner does't rat you out and you both win, or do you cooperate before the other prisoner potentially has the opportunity to do so, thereby condemning you. Now consider that scenario in reference to the Cold War. The reason that neither side launched nukes, was because it would mean the destruction of their side as well. Hence, mutually assured destruction. But what if each side did not have the ability to know that nukes were launched until the complete destruction of their nation? If the destruction would not be mutual, but instead dependent on whoever struck first. Would it be responsible to risk the complete destruction of your people on the hopes that the other side doesn't launch first? Both Paradise and the world coalition both have "nukes" in this world. Paradis obviously has the rumbling, but the coalition has military power that is orders of magnitude above Paradis. The surprise attack on Shiganshina only used a small force of five airships (which Paradis doesn't have defenses for) and they caused widespread destruction. Imagine a whole world's air force attacking Paradis in surprise, potentially with Eldian/Titan bombardment. I'd also argue that the world coalition had already committed to being the side that would strike first when Willy Tybur declared war against Paradis. If not for the attack that Eren and Paradis made on Marley in that moment, the following day would have been the start of the assembly of the world's military to make this first strike. Sure, Eren & Co. had laid plans and Eren was ready to kill, but nothing that had cost lives up or couldn't be reversed up until that point. If Willy had called for peace on that stage, would Eren have still transformed and attacked Liberio? What I like most about this show is that it really pushes the bounds of your morality. I obviously agree that genocide is wrong, but I would also argue that our world has never been in a scenario where either side can commit a complete genocide against the other with one fell swoop to prevent the complete genocide of their own people. I actually believe that it would be the morally necessary thing to do, although I would not take any pleasure in it.

André Carvalho

Mikasa: "What happened?" Eren: "Nothing yet." Yes, Eren drops a lot of these little "memories of the future" moments during that episode. When his friends finally appear after the infamous "you're family" moment, Eren says, "Perfect timing," so he clearly knew they would show up after the answer. Now, a little reflection: if he knew his friends would arrive after Mikasa’s answer, did he also know her answer beforehand? If so, why ask? What’s your take on that, Sophie?

Cisco

He doesn’t know alternate futures though, can’t say anything else or else it’s a spoiler

Jay Mistry

More like 28 pounds, as 1 stone is 14. Correction: 32 pounds (see: Darlings Squad Unite chat)

Ouna

We have been with this show for years and by now we can clearly predict what's the end result of such plans, the show is all about people's greed and violence that depict real world cruelty, to expect some rosy/happy ending from that would be a lie. That's not reality. But I understand the idea behind your statement of exploring all options. After that war statement, they would still need to go back to the island and look for an other way to introduce themselves to the world. The azmabito already declined their offer before, the only group advocating for Eldian's human rights is preaching for their deaths, they arleady wasted three years exploring the not so much choices they had and now they need to go back again and waste a few more years while Eren has less than 4 years and Zeke 1 year left ... I hardly see any choice left for them other than them willingly accepting their deaths.

hman70

This episode & your commentary were so good I had to pre-write a comment that I can post later in the final chapters 😅 so close to not having to worry abt spoilers. besides that I love your judgment of Eren leaving the scouts high and dry before they truly gave peace a chance, he abandoned the mission way prematurely. It seems so clear but it’s an argument that has to be made a lot in other comment sections lol.

Daniela Fangueiro

Morality can't be more important than life and death.

Ash Kaulitz

I love how a lot of us had the idea in our head that the titans would walk across the ocean. Even though they are only like around 50 meters tall and the ocean is 3000+ on average. the scale of the titan is so big and constantly reminded that you forget how insanely deep the ocean is.

Ideos

This is lost in the translation, but when Eren says he'll "wipe out every last one of them", he's using the counter for animals (ippiki = one animal) instead of the counter for humans (hitori = one person). This is a grammatical feature that doesn't exist in English, since it only uses a universal counter for all objects (one, two, three...) vs Japanese where each noun class has its counter. The statement therefore reduces the rest of the world to less than human, to justify killing them. It also echoes Eren's statement in episode 2 of the series where he vows "to wipe out all Titans".

Dr Sophie Darling Reacts

He also slips and says "I will wipe them all out" which doesn't include Titans and which I've said since S1 was a huge indicator that Eren would become an anti-hero

icyfire

I think for Eren, there really is no other choice. It seems like he has two non-negotiables: Historia and her kids cannot be turned into titans, and Paradise to have a guaranteed peace after his four years are up. Taking that into account, there is no other choice but to rumble.