some more EA thoughts (Patreon)
Content
i promise i'm not reverting back to ranting about the sims all the time but this reddit post about the recent The Sims x Coach collaboration through a free base game update made me want to follow up on a post i made a few months ago.
in this post, OP is complaining that the sims is becoming "unrelatable" by including high cost items attached to branded, real life products and that the inclusion of said products is both isolating to the player base and could encourage poor financial decisions.
i think this is a short sighted view that doesn't take into account aspirational marketing. idk if this is a real thing, mind you; i'm just digging into shawna ripari's bag a little to speak to a pattern i've noticed.
"aspirational marketing" occurs through either
1. a stable of influencers all repeating the same song and dance about how this is a got to have item you've got to have
2. organic mass interest (eg. stanley cups, hobonichi techno) where further purchases are driven by FOMO
the sims may be a straw on a camel's back but it makes sense to me to consider both the camel (the consumer) and the straws (advertising through multiple media streams or accounts), so to speak, if we wanna be critical about marketing oversaturation in general.
however, with this specific collaboration i think a more interesting aspect is the potential that The Sims is using aspirational marketing to pull new players into the game as opposed to using the game to pull consumers to Coach. (considering that this is a free base game update being promoted through Coach's current social media campaign)
can't afford the highly coveted item? install the now free simulation game where a digital version of yourself can have the bag. oh you want substance to the game? you'll have to purchase DLCs for that
it's really smart, i hate to say, but also points to how EAxis is always trying to court newer, and i'd argue younger, players to the game.
connecting back to that November post/all the rara about the EA buyout, i think this collaboration is a great moment to break the rose colored glasses about EAxis. not because there's items in the game that the player wouldn't be able to afford (something which has always been true) but because the collaboration is such a flagrant grasp for more consumers.
ultimately EA is a corporation moving greasy to keep their pockets full and i think players (even "critical" ones voicing their unease in the "complaint subreddit") are struggling with understanding how that impacts EA's behavior because they are more invested in the game being "relatable" (which like...what does that mean in a game where you can fuck the Grim Reaper and build a space rocket in your backyard) in spite of EA. the sims is a benevolent entity separate from the money hungry overlords instead of being understood as a product of these capitalistic cannibals.
in November i mentioned the interest from players to put "the most weight behind the least disruptive choice," and i think that's continuing through critiquing a display of wealth (? i guess) without a deeper consideration or questioning of what EAxis is doing and what players (individually or collectively) want from EAxis -- and to be honest about those wants and how they might contradict their complaints!
cause, for a lot of folks, it's a whole lotta fire & spice until there's new content that they're interested in.
i think it's natural to hold two conflicting thoughts ("i don't like that the brand does X" "the brand just released something i want") but the problem so often is that the desire for the shiny new content supersedes the burgeoning complaint. when you buy the shit anyway, it's reasonable to question how important/legitimate your criticism was. i think people fall back on justifying their purchases/capitulating to their desires because it's more uncomfortable to admit the fragility - or performativeness - of their moral high ground (for lack of a better term).
speaking of, i'm bracing for the impact of the next ( and last?) expansion pack, especially with the addition of an "African" (it's giving Nigerian, which is fine but be specific) inspired world, something players have been asking for for literal years. i smell a catch-22 on the horizon.
anyway lemme go back to editing the actual planned content for this month.