responding to comments from where have all the Black girls gone? (Patreon)
Content
is this the best idea? possibly not.
but i recently received a comment that really curried my goat so i'm here to try to articulate why i find two common reactions dismissive and obtuse.
first of all, i want to be clear that i'm really happy with the responses and interest i've been getting from this most recent video. thumbs up ratio makes the brain go brrr.
also i don't plan on doing this often moving forward but i've received a handful of comments that remind me of one of the reasons i moved towards making content that looks at generic tropes instead of character tropes.
every time i make a video about Black women & girls in media, i can count on one of two things eventually being said:
"the problem is all the biracial women in media"
or
"you should stop complaining and make your own stuff"
i typically ignore these because, honestly, i don't know the most productive way to respond. so i'm putting down the expectation of making a fruitful conversation and just spitting for a second.
blaming biracial women and girls
i know i made a joke about Netflix's Biracial Factory but, in my humble opinion, even if we mandated that every Black character ever only be played by actors with two Black characters, we would still face similar representation issues because the problem isn't miscegenation, it's colorism and by extension white supremacy.
take for example, the common trope in every other Black family sitcom produced since The Cosby Show to have male family members be significantly darker than the women and girls in the family. the fluorescent beige call can also come from inside the house.
i'd hope after watching even half of that video you'd understand that i'm not just "complaining about a lack of representation" but striving to question the deeper mindsets that impact everything (even Black produced shows).
to this end, i also don't fully understand the point of laying blame completely at the feet of biracial women. because, again, the root of the problem is a bit beyond that.
"make your own stuff"
admittedly sometimes this is said encouragingly but several things:
1. production (as in physically making the thing) is only one step of film/tvmaking. pieces must then be distributed and exhibited. aka how and where is this stuff being made available to people?
which is to say, independent producers still have to contended with finding a way, through this wonky industry, to get their media in front of audiences. a process which is affected by the same or similar issues smothering productions.
if you wanna have a conversation about alternative distribution models, we can absolutely do that but to suggest that the solution to my critique about the insidious racism baked into an industry is to just "make what you wanna see" puts flames on the side of my face.
2. i don't think it's futile to be critical of the most popular media options available to viewers. we shouldn't be pocket watching productions but we absolutely can engage in critical thought about narratives and images.
also yes people can, and should, seek alternatives but it's both reasonable and faultless for someone to open up [insert big streaming service here] and want to watch something that doesn't leave them questioning their existence because characters that look the same are so difficult to find. *especially* if we're talking about coming of age stories targeted towards viewers age 16-24.
3. i don't believe we can make a new better industry (nation/world) if we don't understand where the old one went wrong.
see again: colorism perpetuated in Black produced shows.
4. for what it's worth, i've written and produced three short films that all intentionally positioned dark skin Black women as the main character. the second of said films is available on an indie streaming service. the third is currently in post production with the intention of turning it into a full series or a web comic, if not both. i'm making the things and i'm still talking shit because these are not mutually exclusive acts.
anyway, be sure you vote in the poll for the next video topic before it closes at the end of the week.