retrospective on past Bridgerton thoughts (Patreon)
Content
I've just recorded the upcoming video about historical/historically set fiction and, of course after finishing the damn thing, I re-listened to a video I posted 5 years ago about Bridgerton and the allure of "diverse casting."
I wanted to see if I still had the same perspective and while I do for some major things, it was interesting to hear where I now differ and some of my early predictions for the show.
If you're interested in full context, you can skip to 11:06 of this video
Shout Out: Lady Granville
apparently back in season 1, she was the only named South Asian character? she left an indelible mark on my mind as I referenced her frequently.
in commenting on Lady Granville's presence and the consistent colorism through the show, I lowkey predicted that Kate could be a darker skinned South Asian woman. well - when talking about the popular prediction at the time that the next love interest would be a Black woman, I suggested that a more deeply melanated South Asian woman would be baller too. i'll await my cookie in the mail, thank you.
Predicting the Next Mrs. Bridgerton (Kate/Sophie)
I also guessed Sophie would be a Black woman and I'm really glad I was wrong because the optics? of a Black Cinderella? maybe not great when Prince Charming is a white man.
this is...maybe a contradictory thought but misogynoir takes a lot of fun out of having dynamic depictions of Black women in that I think it can limit some people to only wanting expansive portrayals if they're flawless and not realizing that said desire is also limiting/reductive/not useful (like in hindsight I think Kate as this snarky, sharp witted being portrayed by a Black woman would've had a lot of pushback via "why can't she be soft?").
So... no gays?
I predicted that the show wouldn't allow any gay happily ever afters and I'm really glad to be wrong about that! even if it's not happening for the "Obviously Queer Siblings" (Benedict and Eloise - which, we don't have to get into her business; I really have no skin in that game.)
"Shondaland interracial relationship haven...known to have strong Black female leads"
I have an idea for a video that's going to take a while but I do really want to peel apart the expectations held of Shondaland shows, where it's rooted and how said expectation can choke our interaction with their shows. for now i'll say, the quote above my come back to bite me in the ass and you know, that's the risk of putting your thoughts on the internet.
The perspective of representation as a personal experience/"you decide which characters and narratives to resonate with"
I want to revisit the idea of "Representation" more expansively at a later date (is this just turning into a list of video ideas? you be the judge). I touch on it very briefly at the end of this upcoming video but the term is thrown around so much that it has become extremely expansive and loose. not to the point of losing meaning but just that flinging the term down does not spark focused conversations as often anymore.
A fine line between inclusive adaptation and performative diversity
Somewhat connected to the previous thought, it's maybe worth having a deeper conversation about what "inclusivity" looks like and the limits/potential of that as the foundation of a narrative's ethos. Bridgerton is surely well intentioned but it leaves a lot to be desired in large part, I think, because of a desire to "keep things light hearted." But also, the show's idea of inclusivity is flawed at the root. I talk at length about the switch up in season one that soured me on the show but the foundation of discussing race in this show is tinted with liberal post-racial America/Britain idealism that is not only not true in reality but also is clearly not holistically understood within the production given that the show drops the ball for cast members of color at nearly every possible chance. how you gonna sell me a product you wouldn't even buy yourself?
I know people put a lot on Shonda Rhimes, the person, and this might not help with that but the heads of the creative branches of Shondaland are all white. The creator and showrunner for seasons 1-2 of Bridgerton is a white man. The current showrunner is a white woman. The current costume designer is a white man (who I believe also joined in season 3). When I think about how and where this show is falling short in terms of race, there's several weak points that stretch above and beyond the writers' room. I don't have a full thought here, just some very early research that's Interesting.