Legacy of Orisha reading notes (Patreon)
Content
the day i bought Children of Anguish and Anarchy, the person ahead of me in line looked back and said "oh that book is terrible."
foolishly, i did not heed that warning.
i mentioned in previous posts about the Children of Blood and Bone movie that i was planning on re-reading the first two books to prep for finally reading the end to the trilogy so this was gonna happen anyway, but this process has deeply derailed my editing for BFA so the reading journey must double as research for the inevitable long form video about All Of This.
i don't know what that video will look like since i'm waiting til i watch the film, but in the meantime i've got thoughts on this series.
The Colorism Stuff
this will end up in the video in more detail but for now i'll say, anyone earnestly claiming that "being negatively impacted by colorism" is important, let alone relevant, for Amari's story did not read past chapter 3 of the first book.
The World Building + Character Development Crumbles
somewhat connected to the colorism, the longer the story goes, the less the narrative cares about building on the rules or stakes initially established.
for example, book 2 ends with Zelie connecting her soul to 4 other people's. in book 3, that never comes up. not even a passing thought of "i can't feel this anymore and i miss it" or, more importantly, how that power interacts with her new power gained in book 3.
given that the major question/conflict of book 2 is "creating a united Orisha," it's bonkers to me that Inan and Amari are not pushed on what that looks like to them. there's this desperate push for power that's super shallow -- and i think that could be an interesting conflict, but only if that desire is understood as shallow by the narrative. it's not.
connected to this, particularly in book 2, the goals and personalities of characters flop a lot to fit whatever is needed for the chapter at hand. and no one is talking to each other!!! it's so much internal rumination and making drastic, important decisions based on perceptions without having a single fucking conversation and it's infuriating. it's difficult to buy that these emotional dysfunctional children are the best in place to be leading a small party of warriors, let alone a nation. i know this is a YA and part of the genre is dealing with teenager decision making processes -- but YA books also usually push their protagonists to grow...
Zelie has more plot armor than 50 Cent (derogatory)
always defacto leader despite clearly lacking skill: i think it makes sense for her to be exalted after she brings back magic, but Zelie is not a good leader and does not want to be. this barely changes and yet, she is continuously given positions of honor/importance without question.
i think her hesitance toward leadership could be an interesting character trait, especially in contrast with something like being altruistic or being a strategic fighter, if it was genuinely examined and not just surface level angst/humility for like two scenes before we continue on. book 2 could've been more of her with the other clan elders trying to construct a sense of being a leader (especially in contrast with her desire to run/as a foil to Inan, and less so Amari, who were raised to believe themselves to be capable of leading) instead of one conversation with Mama Agba and then Zelie suddenly being very motherly to pre-teens.
impervious to blood magic: we're told quite early that "blood magic is the Worst Thing you could do." Zelie even witnesses multiple people literally get blown to smithereens once they use it! but the worst consequence that happens to her is that she's unconscious for a few days.
at least one person is actively sacrificed every book in order for Zelie to reach her end goal. like there aint nothing else? there's no other stakes?
i would be okay with the repetitiveness with this and the blood magic if:
1. Zelie ever took anything different from these experiences
often, when we do spend some time considering how she's fairing in the aftermath, it's a grief that somehow inevitably solipsistic. and i'm not sure Adeyemi recognizes how it comes across. for example in book 2, Zelie becomes a clan elder and leads an attack with 19 other people. she loses her second in command - but he's one of a few people who dies. in the aftermath, Zelie's grief pushes her to isolate even though the clans must continue to plan -- and someone calls out that behavior! they point out that they lost more people than her but have to keep going. and their comment is just seen as cruel, which yes, but it is a fair point to make that "right now, in this moment, none of us can afford to grieve because the work is not done" least of all the most powerful of them! however, the reaction to that person is "you don't get it, she's really hurting."
2. Zelie, or anyone, ever questioned why she's the special special.
after re-reading the first book, i noticed Sabaa Tahir in the Acknowledgements. Tahir is the author of the An Ember in the Ashes series - that i'm also in the midst of reading - and i could sense Mother Tahir's influence throughout this trilogy in so many places but, unfortunately, in a way that helped. anyway, in that series, the main character Laia has an unnatural gift (one which challenges even the Big Bad of the series) but she also experiences multiple different beings recognizing her strangeness and questioning it - straight up asking "what are you?" i'm assuming we'll find out in the last book (that i can now finally read, hallelujahpraisehim) but she's not given an OP ability without the narrative acknowledging that it's disruptive/uniquely given and there must be a reason for it.
from Mama Agba's vision that Zelie must bring back magic to Zelie's connection with Inan to Zelie breaking the power scale in book 2 - only to be reset and broken again in book 3, she is presented as The Chosen One for no reason and there's very little leg work into asking why or connecting it to a larger reason outside of Zelie.
The balance between Romantic Importance/internal desires and navigating violence/grief/power is skewed so heavily toward the internal desires at times that feels offensive or at least jarring.
in book 3, we get a half-baked allegory to the Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade when vikings or some shits start kidnapping Orishans because they are looking for a "girl with sun in her blood" to fulfill prophecy. when Zelie finds out about the prophecy - and that she, of course, has the desired power - whilst she's in the captains brig on the slave ship, she thinks "all these people are being enslaved because of me." girl, get real!!!!!!!!! how is that your first thought to be "i'm at the center of this"? like yes, because you fulfill the prophecy, sure but what kind of unhealed Leo bullshit is this hunny.
Amari's whole arc for book 3 is a great example of caring more about romantic storylines/potential/interest than literally anything materially impacting their world.
Zelie in book 2 desperately wanting to leave Orisha and only deciding to stay once she hears Inan is alive is another example.
she folds the first time she sees him and i was reading like i would be outraged if the future of my nation was in the hands of someone so easily swayed - well, tuh. perhaps this was realer than it knew.
somewhat connected: the reveals of the plot relevant stuff were really lackluster
Queen Nehenda was behind the event that lead to the raid that started the genocide of majis. This truth is revealed in like...two sentences. little reveal, even less impact.
Amari becomes a clan elder but we learn nothing about the prophecy she received - or if she received one at all.
i really don't like first person perspective and this trilogy is a great reminder of why.
and for more fun, here's the raw notes of each book. thank you for letting me get this out of my brain so that it doesn't have to keep clogging up my mind.