Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Apologies for the scary headline, but this is something I've been mulling over for a while now, and I wanted to run it by you folks and get your feedback.

I'm thinking about switching to a monthly fee for my patrons rather than this confusing "Pay Per Piece" thing that I've always done. It would be a one-way change, as I don't think I can switch back once I've done it, so I've been a little too cowardly to make the move yet.

It would require me to revamp the tier system a bit, but I think it would free me up to try new things and maybe do something besides just the usual mini comics each month. 

Lately, I've been feeling kinda frustrated, like I'm just doing the same thing over and over again, and I'd rather keep it fun for everybody.

The upside for you folks would be knowing exactly what you're paying each month. I also think it might attract new Patrons who (like I would, to be honest) might balk at this whole "how much am I going to be charged?" thing.

Please let me know your thoughts on the matter and any concerns you might have.

Thank you all!

Comments

Avery Hillpeak

Whatever you decide to do man. Love and support the content

Justin Pfeil

No worries. I’m not going anywhere.

bel0919

ok; do you have an idea about the probable fee plan ?

Kuratenshi

As someone who has balked at several other pay-per-piece authors, this will draw in new patrons. Couldn't give you numbers for how many though.

SeanSupreme

Yeah that will be fine, if you find yourself frustrated with things as they are then it’s time for change.

SomeYoungGuy

I feel like since you can already set a monthly limit for how much you (as a Patron) want to contribute, it's not much different than setting a flat monthly subscription fee anyway. I'd be supportive and would imagine no one would jump ship so long as there are price tiers close to what they already pay.

Vander

You should absolutely do this! Pay per month pledges should be the standard in my opinion. People support for the pledge rewards, and are only entitled to the pledge rewards. That way, you can have the monthly patreon content be more free form, and get out of the cycle of mini-comics. As an aside, you've been doing them for a long time, so it's completely understandable you're getting that feeling you are doing similar things to what you've done before! I had the same problem with sketch suggestions, hahah. I would encourage shaking up the monthly reward and doing things differently! Because mini comics with Polls end up choosing the more popular themes over and over again, when a Round-Robin style would be fairer to people who only like certain niches. (like myself) (You should increase the price of the sketch-suggestion tier too, as it's way too low for the Current Year(TM))

cousarmy0001

I probably would have added you sooner if I'd known how much it was going to run me each month. I understand why some people choose to go the pay-per-piece route, but from my side of things the set rate is preferable. I'm more comfortable with choosing a higher tier with that as well.

Mikhail Veselov

I already capped the Pay Per Piece with No More Than limit, which you can do on Patreon, so I'm already on a fixed price :))

ThomasB.

Not fussed either way, its your show and we are the captive audience.

Vspartan501

Do it! Just do it! Don't let your dreams just be dreams!

Donald Randolph

As others have done, I capped the per-piece to a monthly limit, so I am effectively already there. Counterpoints: Changing the tiers to monthly would avoid that extra step/confusion for newcomers. Monthly would let you take a "paid vacation" of not posting once in a while (I am okay with that, though some folk may feel a bit more entitled :{ ) There may also be issues with Patreon behaving differently depending on age of the account (artist and patron) and how the artist setup the original rewards. Sometimes I have noticed when reviewing my subscriptions that they do not all allow the same options, even within the broad classes of Monthly or Piece.

Icon_Charlie

Go for it. I'm willing to pay for you to continue to work. Charging tiers would be good as it is simple.

Andrew Hunter

Thank you all for the support! I'm still thinking over just what the new tier system would be, but it would probably be built around the $5/month for sketchbook art and $10/month for all the color art that I do on Subscribestar, just to keep things consistent, though Patreon's tools would make it much easier to offer extra stuff here for higher and lower tiers.

Classical Salamander

I have to say that 'per month' is easier to understand than 'per piece', but at the same time Patreon already allows patrons to place a monthly cap on the 'per piece' charges. :p On the other hand, anything that makes it easier and more fun for you, that's cool! :D In any event, voting on colorizations and shamelessly begging for sketches is something I love, and will keep doing right up until you raise your prices to "camgirl" levels. ;p