Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

In a few minutes, I'll post the feature poll for December.  We're a little behind due to exhibiting at PAX Unplugged and fulfilling our DungeonMorphs Kickstarter, but most of that is done now. 

Our winning theme this month was the "Monasteries & Keeps".  This helps us round out the temples & magic towers we did earlier in the year.  We'll also include a druid grove, bard college, etc. so there is some building type for most major classes.

We're looking at changing up the Patreon because we've decided on a way to hopefully make things much more useful.  Basically, I've felt that 15-20 icons per set just isn't enough to get into very much depth for many of the maps.  For example, we did a month of dwarves, and only scratched the surface of the needed icons to truly give you enough variety for several maps.  In the dwarf battlemat set we had a couple floor types, a bed, chair, altar, forge, smelter, rails, cart, table and two doors.  We expanded that a bit with the bonus icons month, but we really should have given more of many of those (rails that curve or switch, double bed, regular chairs, etc.) as well as a number of other things: forge tools, gem-crafting table, items for a furnished bar/tavern, etc. All of the sets would benefit from a larger selection of icons.

So Keith & I want to do just one set of 100+ icons per month.  Based on my prior survey, 4-5 months a year would be classic world map icons, and the other months would be roughly evenly split among the other icon types.

Pledge levels would be something like:

$1.50 - Support further software development, vote in the new feature poll.

$3 - As $1.50, plus access to a discord...?

$5 - As $3, plus get the icons each month

$7 - As $5, plus get to vote on each month's icons.

Our prior change to the Patreon was widely appreciated.  Voting on new features was one of the top choices when I polled about which parts of the Patreon you value most.  (Three options were within a couple votes of each other.)

What do you all think of that?  Send me a message or post a comment.

Thank you!

Joe

Comments

John

I am all for larger sets for the reason given, but agree with John Buczek to some degree as I like the the World / Kingdom and the HD Isometric. Would we know in advance what was coming ?

Inkwell Ideas

@John & John: You'll definitely know well before the end of the month. I almost always post the theme by the 20th of each month, so that gives you 10 days to decide. And with only one icon set for Keith and I to decide on, we'd likely be able to post by the 10th. I'd sort of hope folks simply lower their pledge if it is a style you don't want so we don't lose you completely (and in case you're supporting for the software updates as well), but of course the beauty of Patreon is you know you can end support at any time.

Peter Deadman

Joe, further to the above, I think it'd make sense if you laid out on the calendar in advance which month was which so supporters could plan accordingly.

Anonymous

I use the Classic World Map Icons, so I really like the increase in number of icons per set. However the list of theme's for us to choose from each month is not a very short list, so I wonder (as it relates to the classic world map stuff) how that is going to work. Will it be 2-3 races/themes in those months, just one, or depend on what kind of theme we are talking about? No matter the answer, I'm in. The fact that this program is being supported and expanded the way it is has earned MY interest and support.

Inkwell Ideas

@Peter: its possible we'll be able to say next month is world classic icons, then city icons, then battlemat, then world classic again, then world isometric. I'm not sure if I should mix it up by changing styles each month or do a couple of one style in a row.

Inkwell Ideas

@Chris: There would be one theme (orcs, elves, post-apoc, etc.) in one style (classic world, city, battlemat, isometric world) each month. So January could be 100+ world/classic feywild icons, then February would be 100+ battlemat science fiction icons, etc. (Based on what themes people vote for.) Maybe I'd let people vote for the styles as well, but that won't let me tell people more than a month ahead of time.

Richard Keeney

Just my two cents, I think the mindset of the supporters that want to “pull” support on months they don’t want a given set is wrong. The purpose of Patreon is to support the overall direction AND benefits of this program. If the monthly icon set continues to be ones you don’t want then there is something to bring up to this patreon team so that all the users ans supporters see the icon sets desired along with program improvements.

Jeff Verzak

I only use the Battlemat icons and, often, don't use many of them because they're just not something I'd use. That's fine -- I assume someone out there will find use for them -- but part of what makes it fine is the minimal $1.50 price. For $5, I'd likely cancel since I don't know that I'd find the value in it or be as unconcerned about months where the icons don't appeal to me (especially if they're not battlemat icons at all). I'd like to say that I'd lower on the off-months, etc but, realistically, I have enough to do without tracking my Patreon tiers month by month.

Bruce Meyer

So you're saying that we won't get any icons at the $1.50 level anymore? I'd likely cancel if that was the case. I agree with @Jeff Verzak above. I currently have not used Worldographer in a long while due to not having a regular gaming group at the moment so it wouldn't be prudent for me to pay $5 a month for icons on a program I haven't used in awhile.

Bruce Meyer

Besides, why would I pay $1.50 a month just to vote in a poll for icons I would not get? Why would anyone seriously pay money of any amount just to vote for something they will never get (unless they pay for it again through DriveThru)?

Inkwell Ideas

The $1.50 level I'm proposing is for people who aren't interested in the icons--it is to vote in the new features for Worldographer instead.

Inkwell Ideas

Honestly, I'd agree. If you're not using Worldographer or the icons and don't see that changing in the near future, there's not much reason to support the Patreon here.

Inkwell Ideas

Thank you! There are many different reasons to support the Patreon based on what we're offering. For everyone who enjoys using the software and wants to guide it with feature ideas/voting, we have that. Some folks want a specific thing in exchange, and the icons (although intangible) serve that purpose, whether it is 15-20 or 100. But it is Keith's & my hope that doing one robust icon pack will appeal to more folks than four mini-packs and rotating the style each month is how we can do that. But we're not decided either, and some other alternative/compromise may occur to someone here.

Jeff Verzak

Understood. I'm just saying that, for $18 a year (currently, Tier 1: Pick a set of icons to keep), I'm fine with getting Battlemat icons I might not use, etc. For $60 a year (minimum tier to get icons), I'd want to be much more selective and would likely just cancel rather than worry about adjusting my pledge each month that doesn't have Battlemat icons or icons for themes I don't need, etc. Nothing personal, I get that you need to find a way to make your time and effort worth it, just giving honest feedback.

Bruce Meyer

I plan on using those icons once I get everything straight and a good (reliable) group going. I'd love to keep this Patreon going but I wouldn't be able to stick with it if it goes up to $5.

Julius Wollfarth

The battle map icons for a few months could have definitely benefited from having some other ones included. Instead of just focusing on one theme for a month or two for one type and indicating that in the poll. The $7 vote tier doesn't sound that great as your just getting a vote and nothing else. maybe adding something else. Also, you might want to make a version of map objects/symbols without the drop shadows to include with the ones which have drop shadows. Some people may be using other software and not want them.

Anonymous

Agreed, I am not sure I would stay on 7 just for the poll. Also agree with drop shadow.