Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Would you

  • 1 28
  • 2 616
  • 2026-11-08
  • 644 votes
{'title': 'Would you', 'choices': [{'text': '1', 'votes': 28}, {'text': '2', 'votes': 616}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 11, 8, 17, 39, 27, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 644}

Content

Random question.

Would you take ‘relationship’ advice from someone who

  1. Been in a relationship with 6 ppl but only lasted 6months for all of them

  2. Been in a relationship with 2 people but lasted 2-4 years

Comments

Misha

Am I taking *dating* advice or *relationship* advice?

Misha

Dating: 1 Relationship: 2

Mia Wilson

I mean they got experience

Solei Baker

2. Just because somebody has been in more relationships doesn't mean they know more about love. Sometimes quality matters more than quantity.

IrmaSKZ🥠

Both sides would have valid points and a different view on things, so I think it depends on what kind of advice is needed.

Ashhhh

Depends, sometimes people who stay in long term relationships constantly are chasing stability more than compatibility. Someone who moves on quicker may be someone who doesn’t stay in a relationship ‘just because’…

Melanie Thuerauf

😂😂😂😂 at first I was sooo confused because I thought 2 sounded like 2 people at once and thought why would you be two-timing reather than more relationship's 😂😂😂

Anja Lazarević

From someone who never dated.. i'll take patricia's advice.. iykyk 😊

StayKristy

Fist one about dating, second - about how to maintain those relationships. Personally I don't consider 2-4years as still dating

Ben Kim

What’s the difference between

Susan Lilley

This is totally a red herring. Someone can make horrible choices and give you good advice. I think you know good advice when you hear it. Usually (not always) it’s something you don’t want to hear. And how you give and receive advice is so important. Kindness and curiousity is always important. The best advisor is one that helps you arrive at your own conclusions.

Misha

Dating is casual, like, you can go on dates with a bunch of people and you’re “dating”. A relationship usually has a (mutual) title involved? Boyfie, Girlfie, Baby, Wifey, Hubby, Lovey, etc. (At least for me I know some people also have dating and relationship as the same lol)

Melanie Thuerauf

Sadly though it doesn't matter how long because we never know what the future brings my first serious relationship lasted 8jears before I cought him with my Best friend the last was only 2jears and got 2 butiful girls before he passed so happiness comes in many ways 😊😊😊😊

Ben Kim

Ok I changed it to relationship lol

Misha

💜 fun question tho lol

Elizabeth Perry

I think it depends on the 'who'. I'd probably ask for both opinions.

Mich🦦

Both? The first option they might be able to tell you what went wrong for them. The second option can tell you what went right for them.( if their relationship is healthy, because some longer relationships only last because it’s toxic)

Sam sam (Lan zhan)

depends if u relate more to option 1 or 2 s situation i guess 😭

Stephiekills

Secret option C- go for the advice from the person who actually seems like they have healthy relationships

Ashhhh

This

Camie Rabon

Decide whose relationships are more what you admire. And sometimes the person with no long term relationship experience has something to offer if they are just good at avoiding relationships that won't work and aren't desperate to be coupled up.

Cally P

It might be that person 2 is flogging a dead horse whereas 1 moves on once they know it’s going nowhere. Or 2 might be more selective at the start. Could be all sorts of pros and cons

Michele Higgins

Each can offer different perspectives. I would also say, it would depend on why the relationship only lasted 6 months. Sometimes things don’t work out, that doesn’t mean their advice wouldn’t be good. And not all long-term relationships are happy or healthy.

JCALBA

Definitely #2.

Ilia Shustikov

It really depends, but with more people come many different experiences. But it really depends on the person giving advice, and not really on the personal stuff as much. It depends if the person is smart and can actually give useful advice based on your specific situation.

Stellify7

I usually find 6 months is the justly famed honeymoon period, by 18 months it has run through the initial phases and will either get super serious or it's time to call it a day, although most people don't. Interesting question but these two options far too simplistic

Straykidslover

Oh Ben, is hard because I don't have a relationship with someone I dated before, I'm only 13 years old (a minor), and I can't really date someone until 16, so I can't choose

Ashley

For my friends group I’m usually the one that gives dating advice but I have never been in a relationship before, so I’m trying to figure out why that happens 🤣🤣

AJ

100% just because you stay with a person for a long period of time doesn’t necessarily mean relationship has healthy habits

KrizRodrigz

Option 2 represents me xd

Kate

3. Take relationship advice from old couple who have been married 30+ years non stop

LeCrunchNoir

Honestly just depends on the person. I personally hadn't been in a long term relationship until my current one. I chose not to stay with people if I knew they weren't the one. Been with my current person for 15 years. You can still give good advice even if you've not been in a long relationship and give bad advice if you have.

Mairead

neither is more valid bc people have different goals in relationships. you can be trying to figure out yourself intentionally, having fun, or even unexpectedly discover something about yourself you had no idea about which led to multiple attempts at rships. I'd say as long as there wasn't a clear sign of abuse or abusive POV / ideologies from this person, both can have really helpful insight. Varied info is always better because then you can avoid falling into confirmation bias traps where you unintentionally only seek advice from those who are most likely to answer in the way you are hoping.

Laura_H_E_H

As I was someone like 1 my past "relationships" lastet only 3 month because I wasn't in the right place for my head or my heart.. my friends told me I gave great advice! Now I'm currently in my first long-term relationship, and it's healthy as can be! I think if you know what good advice sounds like to you, then it doesn't matter how long a relationship lastet because you decided which advice you want to follow.

Lynzi

Neither ngl but at the same time I just observe instead of asking others because everyone’s experience is different

Peepokoo

Sometimes good people have shorter relationships because of bad people or then some good people think staying in bad relationships are gonna chenge better.. There are so many sides for every short or long relationship.. I listen only to genuine people, whatever their relations are, since they might have insight and experience to understand my situation. But mostly, we all need to live our own situation to learn..

meohmaya

I believe there’s a lesson in all advice. Good or bad it’ll land with you in some way or teach you something about yourself.

PinkypromiseOT8

I mean I chose the second one because it’s not the amount of people you’ve been out with really (to me anyway). It’s obvious the second option/person has gone through aspects of longer/possibly more stable parts of relationships? Never hurts to ask more than 1 person though aslong as you can trust them, ya know?

Tantalaya

Same here but I think it’s because you are seeing things objectively in ways that the people in relationships can’t

Ashley

Maybe 🤔 because they do say I give the best advice when it comes to dating

Emily Sicking

Ben, are you getting into a serious relationship? Give us the tea! Jk, obviously you don’t have to. So long as you’re happy!