Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

  1. its ok to say 'Top' and 'Bottom' in Thai Bl Ships but dont address them as that?

  2. I can ship tf out of them because it is encouraged

  3. is it bad to compare different ships and make it sound like a competition?

Let me know what i shouldn't say or do.

Im learning about the BL world and i gotto say, there a lot to take in LOOL

Comments

sky

1. Yes, but it’s very complex 2. Yes 3. It’s okay to have favorites and some actors aren’t as skilled as others but I also think it’s okay to have opinions

PrincessNur V

Just be yourself Ben, no pressure, just keep entertain us like you always do

Key

1. Yes. 2.very much so 3. I don’t mind it. Especially if that’s all you can compare it too. But people have their own relationships and not everything is the same. Kinda like when you’re dating a diff person. It’s not the greatest to compare them to others.

belulu

I'm learning like you so I don't know. But it's nice to see that you care

kim

Idk about the first one but the but I don't think there is any competition between any ships but don't be like oh they r better they r more handsome cuz that's kinda rude but if it's like oh it's similar to that ship then it's okay

Misha Goldfinch

What about switches?It can't be always top or bottom 🤔 gen question.

Nevaehhh

Yes yes, just be yourself !!

sia 𝜗ৎ

it is okay to say top and bottom as long as you don’t just see them only as that yk what i mean

ilays

1. Yes, because it’s a bit demeaning to call them their positions bcs we don’t do that with het ppl as it has nothing to do with who they are. Being feminine ≠ bottom, they’re separate aspects. It’s fine to refer to it in the context of s*x obviously. 2. Yes, you can even say they’re dating if that’s the energy they give. Like that’s what these ships are for and if they’re not confirmed they’re people who literally kiss and act in love for a living, it’s normal to be suspicious. 3. If your heart desires? people are too sensitive about this imo. But it’s normal to compare and contrast when they’re in the same industry they’re bound to have similarities/differences. I feel like not comparing is not speaking your mind, it’s not always a negative thing. You can also have a favorite ship and ones you’re not feeling, you’re human it’s fine. Not feeling a ship ≠ hating them.

Savage🩷🩷💋

It's okay to say top or bottom, it's okay to ship them, I mean we all delulu even though we know that alot of them are just doing their job🤣🤣 ... But yh, I mean i don't have an issue with comparing ships tho causeobviously there's always sonething in one ship that's different from another, but i cannot speak for other people, you know people might have their favourites and if it doesn't favour them, they get mad so probaly don't make it seem like a competition, but honestly still speak ur mind, I love that you're always urself, that's what made me love you at first anyways, u speak ur mind and u never try to offend anyone, compare and state the things u see too.... I mean it's BL world, love ya😘😜🥰

hari

Just do what you want, it’s okay

Muyaho

All is fine as long as you're respectful. If you ever say anything out of pocket the comments will tell you. (I know that sounds scary) but you'll just have to go by ear lol

Tiffany Bennett

Yes it's ok to call them top and bottom but never to their faces and yes ship them as much as you want because most of them are actually dating in real life and comparing them is fine but a competition nooooo.

Zoe

1. You can say it, but don’t make it their whole personality. Also remember top and bottom “energy” can sometimes come across as misogynistic or putting them in a box. You can be a golden retriever and still be a top. You can be muscular and dominant and still be a bottom. 2. Yes. 3. Don’t compare, people will come for you. You can of course be vocal about which ships are your favorite or which shows you enjoy the most. But putting the actual actors and ships up against each other can cause wars in your comment section (or towards you).

mei the belulusaurus🦖

For me ben (my opinion) 2 is okay but comparing in no 3 is for me a no no cuz every ship has its unique thing or lets say signature vibe, same goes to no 1 saying who is SUPPOSED TO BE top and bott i have a very baad experience with this since i was a PorTeeteePor, the fandom was a mess back then cuz they said Por is too cute to be a top and tee was too big to be a bott to be honest i dont really care is cutie por would be a top and masc tee was a bott but hey toxic fans wont just let it slide.

malo

I am learning with you

Jessica Danowski

2. Yes for sure 3: as a fan I’m fine with number 3, but beware there are fans that won’t like it. I’m pretty laid back about it as everyone has their own opinion. If you like PondPhuwin and want to compare them with TeeTeePor go for it. (Big fan of both BTW) each pairing brings something different to the table. Hope that helps! 1: I can’t really say as I’m not a member of that community so I don’t feel comfortable saying yes or no.

HH

I’m someone who believe it’s never a good thing to compare one to another and just enjoy the content but you do you

Ruby_S

1. Exactly that! It’s better if you don’t address them by “top” and “bottom” but instead use their names, but you’re still ok to talk about it! 2. Absolutely 3. I wouldnt compare them in terms of like talent or anything like that because they are all great at what they do and deserve respect for it. But you’re free to have your own opinion and favourites!

Jasmine

dont worry about it to much, just be yourself

Desiree Francies

It's okay to say Top and Bottom, just maybe don't focus so hard on that, they're whole people lol, it literally only matters when it comes to sex

Eren Johansson

1. Characters are okay but I wouldn't address actors as top or bottom. And I don't like when people define someone solely based on their position or say that feminine men can't be tops or vice versa. 2. Yes 3. You can compare pairs based on your opinions. I like other actors more than others and that's okay

Sun Woo

Hey Ben! Here is a quick breakdown to help you navigate this, and first off, we love your genuine, unfiltered reactions, so please don't change who you are! Since you're learning the codes as you go, here is how most fans see it: ​1. "Top" and "Bottom" labels: Using those terms to describe character dynamics is fine, as long as we don't project heteronormative stereotypes onto them. The issue in your previous video wasn't the words themselves, but the idea that a "bottom" has to fit a feminine mold or behave a certain way—or that if someone doesn't match society's rigid expectations of that role, the dynamic should automatically be flipped. Real people and characters are way more complex than a sexual position; you aren't defined solely by being a top or a bottom, and breaking away from those binary clichés is actually what makes many BL dynamics so refreshing. (Also, separating the characters' roles from the real-life actors is always a good rule of thumb!). ​2. Shipping: You can definitely ship them as much as you want! Fan service and shipping are a huge, encouraged part of Thai BL culture, as long as it stays respectful of the actors' personal boundaries. ​3. Comparing ships & series: Having opinions and comparing specific aspects : like on-screen chemistry, character personalities, or how a romance is written—is completely normal and great for discussion, as long as it doesn't turn into tearing actors down. What doesn't really work is comparing entire series on a global scale when they belong to completely different genres, universes, and budgets (for example, comparing KinnPorsche to ThamePo , even though you didn't do that!). You can't really rank them objectively against each other, but you are 100% entitled to prefer one story over the other!

Peepokoo

I love the fact that you really dive into world of BL, so happy for you (and us of course). I am a bit tired that bl is mostly about people talking about tops and bottoms, I feel that is a bit boring. Actors and characters have names, but fans do that A LOT so it is common. The bl shipping world is crazy, I´m not a fan of that, since it pairs actors to do roles together in dramas just because the ship is strong. I wish they would mix it up more to give actors a chance to have more variety.. But still I get that it must feel safer to have the one and same partner, tho it can be restricting.. Competition is childish I think, people like different genres and actors so.. Like I don´t compare K-pop groups, they all have their own charms.. But yeah, all this shiping culture have a very toxic side too.. People get too obsessed and the industry make the couples do fanservice that I think exceeds all the limits of actors work..

Sparta Java

I am of no help with your survey but I am thoroughly enjoying this new journey hahaha

Sam S

1. It’s okay to state Top and Bottom occasionally (but use their names as the preference), but not to only see them as that. The characters are more than just the sexual position they might occupy in a relationship. It’s also not ideal to base your perception of who is a top or a bottom on what you perceive as their physical attributes, or how they behave. Bottoms can be muscular (Pavel is a great example), or have what would be considered more masculine behaviours (Apo in KinnPorsche). Tops can also be cutesy and soft (Pooh or William are good examples, when you see them interacting in real life). In the PoohPavel video, you seemed fixated on the ship being “PavelPooh” because of how they present - it should not for anyone other than the people in the pairing to decide on what position they take. Pavel is proudly a “muscular bottom”. 2. We all ship our favourite actors/pairings, but keep it somewhat respectful because ultimately this is their job, and most BL pairings are not actually a couple IRL. 3. You can definitely compare different pairings, as they all bring different dynamics to the BL space. Some are much more comfortable with very spicy scenes (BoatOat, ToptapMinlee, AuauSave, BossNouel, MileApo, etc), where others are more cute, or have more chemistry. Compare away, but as ever, as long as it’s respectful.

Minniemin

1 Yes as long as there’s the understanding that the personality of every top and every bottom is very different and they don’t have to act a certain way just because they’re a top or a bottom 2 Yes!! 3 Comparing isn’t bad because different couples have similarities and differences!! Personally I don’t mind it whatsoever but other people may have different opinions

Bambiiieee

1. I think it’s okay to address a ship as top or bottom… at the same time acknowledging their preferences…you are still learning about the community so there’s no hard feelings but there are time when some of the ships have gotten hate for not “looking like your conventional top/bottom” eg poohpavel even though pavel has said he preferred the bottom… so all in all it’s not bad to address them as t/b 2. Shipping is actually encouraged in bl😂 3. I don’t mind comparing personally

Muti‘s bellypiercing

Everything is fine Ben 😂👍🏻 don’t pressure . Just be yourself

Caroline Fowler

1. Many people use Top and Bottom or you might see (Seme and Uke). I think as long as you are respectful with using terms it’s fine and use the terms more with the characters themselves versus the actors. Just don’t always play into the stereotypes, because there are muscular dominant bottoms and more playful “feminine” tops too. 2. Ship tf out of them. But keep in mind they are in a business partnership so they do end their partnerships sometimes. And for fans that are very invested, they might feel heartbroken over it😢 (we like to be delulu and think everyone is dating their partner but we never actually know if they are unless they truly confirm it) 3. I don’t like to compare ships because you might get some haters from it. I think it’s nice to have your favorites. But in a general comparison it’s fine, just always be respectful and not put another ship down.

Selin, Haechans gf (real)

Ben it’s okay to do all of this lol this fandom is literally built on stuff like that just don’t overdo it, other than that it’s chill

Bambiiieee

I would say it’s okay to refer to their preferences if they have specifically told us… if they label themselves as a switch couple it wouldn’t be right to tag them otherwise

Stephiekills

1. Yes as long as you keep in mind those roles don't define them as ppl or actors and are respectful about it 2. ABSOLUTELY 3. I mean having favs and pairs you don't like as much is normal but I wouldn't get too far into the weeds of comparison bc as others said that's just asking to start comment wars and also it's really easy to end up sounding like a hater. That being said you're doing great! It's a huge learning curve but you're picking up a lot

its me abeer

its never good to compare things but if u do it in a not malicious way than I guess go for it but if its as a competition like u said than I don't see the point of that

Carysa Locke

First of all, for #1—obviously, people are going to get upset if those terms are used in a demeaning or overly sexualized way toward real people, so it's best to avoid that. That said, I also think there’s a bit of a double standard in the fandom sometimes. The BL industry heavily leans into these dynamic tropes, and the actors themselves constantly joke about them and play into the whole "domineering vs. babygirl" thing during fan service. Yet when fans playfully mirror that exact same energy, people act like fans are the problem—as if fans avoiding those jokes is going to single-handedly change how the entire BL industry operates. I think the important distinction is knowing the difference between fiction/fan service and reality. Most of us aren't making assumptions about real-life gay relationships or strictly assigning roles to actual people—we're just engaging with the tropes the industry actively sells us. At the end of the day, engaging respectfully just comes down to keeping that boundary clear: keep the jokes focused on the characters or the playful fan service personas the actors willingly lean into, avoid projecting those labels onto their real personal lives, and don't use those terms to reduce an actor's talent or personality down to a stereotype. For #2—yes, ship away! Shipping is literally the lifeblood of this industry. Companies, directors, and the actors themselves actively encourage it because it builds community, drives engagement, and is honestly half the fun of being a fan. As long as you remember that it's entertainment and respect their real-life boundaries (like not harassing them or any real-life partners they might have), there's zero shame in enjoying the chemistry they're selling. For #3—yeah, turning ships into a competition is usually where things get toxic fast. Comparing chemistry or saying "I prefer X pairing's dynamic over Y's" is completely fine and normal, because everyone has different tastes. It only becomes an issue when fans use one ship to tear down another, start fan wars, or attack actors for working with new partners. Every pairing brings something different to the table, so it's way more fun to just hype up your faves without putting others down.

Jess

Personally, I watch the videos cuz they are fun and I like that you speak your mind. Every ship is different I don’t see anything wrong with pointing it out. That’s what makes them special. They are actors after all.

Sam S

That’s where “vers” (versatile) comes in - where partners have sexual flexibility, and both top and bottom during sexual encounters depending on how they feel in the moment. We don’t see much of this in BL (yet), but there are conversations happening about it, even by actors themselves who don’t want to always play one or the other on screen.

N•O•Y ninio

Yes, it's okay and sometimes it's more convenient because remembering names is hard and I personally do it. just remember that it doesn't define their personality. There are a lot of stereotypes in this industry, but the industry itself is very diverse and it's important to see that. 2. Absolutely yes 3. of course!!And also you can choose favorites, like in everything, there are favorites, you like more and less. There are more talented actors, there are less, there are couples with more chemistry, and there are couples with less, and that's completely fine. Just say everything respectfully. Your content is great and I really love it! Don't stop being yourself, it's entertaining and fun. You're doing great, Ben.

Zahra Faqeri

I would say yes, when I get to learned about a new ship and am not familiar with their names I use the terms top and bottom. But I highly encourage to learn thier names. You can ship them as much as you want lol. Comparing them in intensity is ok but when I comes to looks and or personality it's not ok!

StayKristy

1. Let's be honest, terminology "Top/Bottom" very odd in general. 'Cause in different positions different person 'on top'. Fe LITA ep6 Rain was pretty much on top 🤔 And as far as I know, in rl gay couples don't call their partner wife either. Usually it's husband and husband (or wife and wife, in case lesb). But this part BL world prefers to ignore 😅 3. I don't think your comments looks like competition. But we tend to compare different dramas anyway 🤷‍♀️

Nexxuss

1. It's okay to say top or bottom, as long as you realize it's not their whole personality and that tops/bottoms aren't always stereotypical. Try to keep clear of it coming out as misogynistic 2. Ship away, but beware of ghostships - people be crazy sometimes lol 3. I would steer clear of comparing ships, it's a minefield. You think Kpop fans are toxic sometimes, BL fans can sometimes be worse.

Desiree

I would say it's fine to call them top or bottom so long as you don't start trying to sorta force them into certain stereotypes or boxes yk?? Also yeah I would say don't make it a competition since every ship has their own personal dynamics going on like it's perfectly fine to have favorites but keep it chill definitely

Nusra🇺🇬

1. You can use it but not as much as it can be considered stereotypical or labelling them as such yet they are more than top or bottom 2. Yes..ship them as hard as you can. It is encouraged 3. You can be vocal about your favourite couple but don't compare as it will come across as competition in the different fan groups and they may come for you But continue entertaining us as usual...Be yourself

Tsuliwaensis

just remove the sexism from your ideas behind everything and the misogyny from your language and you're good to go. 🤷‍♀️ and when I say "just" I'm joking, of course. there's a lot of work that needs to be done to your mentality IF you don't want to sound like an asshole. right now you only respect people when they read as "masculine", with "top-energy" and even then only when they are also the biggest, most violent assholes in any given room. you basically have to arrive at a place where you can respect and value everyone equally. but that would mean listening to a lot of queer progressives and educating yourself on the harm patriarchy does to all of us, including you. if you don't mind sounding like an asshole, you have nothing to worry about. if you want to appeal to an audience who is ok with that, just keep doing what you're doing. everyone else is just going to leave eventually. and don't worry, people who are ok with that sort of thing are always going to be the majority. there will still be plenty of straight women and gay men, maybe even some gay women who will support you either way. this is really something you have to approach based on where you own peace of mind lies. and how comfortable you are with yourself.

🌞SoLuna🌛

We love everything, Ben. Do what you want to do😌

Empress Ton

I agree with what everyone said. We love your reviews, they are hilarious and unfiltered. If you watch PitBabe you will see why Babe (Pavel) is a bottom, he just likes it. He is pretty masculine man but he likes being a bottom. There are quite a few BLs were none of the couples where there is no fem or bottom presenting energy, its just two dude falling in love and doing the grown up things. I personally am not a fan of fixed ships even though I do like the chemistry of certain ships. (Chemistry be flowing). I don't compare ships I just compare the characters in each show. It's also so many different types of BLs and genres of BLs. Welcome to the fun

Hey Auntie!

I think many have already given good responses. Also remember that an individual can be a switch as well. As for comparing I think that is always done in some way or another. But it is not a competition but in that they are telling stories. you can dig on one story more than another.

LizzyLove

Ben just be you. I truly enjoy your reactions to the bl series, so top, bottom whatever as long as it’s being said with respect. Shipping and comparing it’s fine too. I love bls and I love the couples but didn’t see them for who they are actors now if they are dating or not that’s a plus but not until they confirm it so overall just be you continue to do this for us because we’re enjoying it. Your reactions are amazing. I have so much fun watching you watching this BL and I can’t wait to give you more series that you can watch. So welcome to the world of BL.

Raffaella Cid

Dont stress too much over these. None of them are disrespectful, its literally how its presented to us (the audience) in most bl dramas

Maike_Staytiny

Just enjoy the shows the way you want to. People can either enjoy it with you or not, their problem🙂‍↕️

Ashhhh

That’s a very ignorant thing to say actually, he’s asking for education, which is necessary.

lmnope._

I think everything is ok as long as ur not putting them in a box like for example bottoms all hv to be feminine things like that. And all ships are different, some are more private and don’t prefer fan service but that doesn’t mean they aren’t any more real. Yknow?

Ashhhh

I love this comment :)

kelly earnest

1.its perfect ok to say top and bottom but its not about that is wrong is what you are saying its the way it comes across like how tops and bottoms in the dymantic are a sexual position it has nothing to do with what why act like or personality or if thrye are cute or younger or older or looks and appearances like how you said poohpavel should be pavelpooh cuz of Pavel being older and acting more masurlien than Pooh that has nothing to do with Pavel or Pooh being a top or a bottom this is just a expale of what we mean by that and why that was kind of wrong to say it that way cuz being a top doesn't mean they need to act or looka certain way like they don't need to be more domaint or older or have more msucle or a bad boy vibe to be a top and tops can also be cute and yougner and act chocitc its has ntohgin to do with the way one looks or acts in real life or their perosalitys anyone can be a top or a bottom its what the ship chooses it's just a sexual poastion in the bedroom has nothing to do with how one acts or looks same for a bottom they can be mascline and have big muscles or be femine and cute as well and vice versa with tops that not why we said those things on the poohpavel video its the way you say it like a bottom needs to look a certain way or top when that's not the case anyone can actually be a top or a bottom and we should respect the ships as they choose to be like poohpavel I feel its really not ok to call them pavelpooh

Mich🦦

No you’re just being ignorant. Ben is trying to make everyone feel comfortable by educating himself, you invalidating it is not helping.

kelly earnest

2.yes you an ship them as well you want its a thing most fans do

Effie Bakou

1. I'd say it's ok to use it for the ships cause in bl world the actors themselves use it and sometimes even the companies, as well most of the fans use it all the time 2. Of course, if they're official ship that's the point 3. It's ok, we all have our own opinions, and we can tell that you say it respectfully And we belulus know you, you're always trying to be respectful and learn, if someone's taste doesn't mutch or like the way you react the can always watch something else. I'm saying all of this respectfully and it's my personal opinion. WE LOVE YOUR REACTIONS SO KEEP BEING YOURSELF.❤️

kelly earnest

3.i think tis ok to have favs but it might cause some fandom wars if you say anything bad about or compare ships to each other in another ships videos you can say your favs without dising another couple just to create a positive vibe and not create fandom wars in your viewers

April Mayfield-Lee

1. You can say top and bottom as long as you respect the titles the pairings have chosen for themselves. The couples themselves have decided on how they’d like to be presented in their pairings and we should either get on board or find another couple to enjoy. 2. Ship them because some of them work hard at creating that delulu for us. 3. Comparing can get a little tricky; having favorites is normal but comparing them will likely just frustrate you in the end.

Ashhhh

Rain was never top in LITA 👀

Summer Jones

To what I said before I deleted it now I realise what I said didn’t come out right I’m just really bad at words I don’t mean anything in a ignorant way I’m really sorry

Upeksha

You can clearly have a favorite like my fav ship is Williamest and you can clearly praise your fav ship without comparing. But you can say things like oh they have the best chemistry. I do say that all the time. But keep this in mind about top bottom. It's actually two words... Thinking top should be the most masculine aggressive one. Bottom should be a fem boy, he shouldn't have muscles is not a good way of thinking. We have seen aggressive bottoms and calm tops too. There are some bl fans who criticize ships when top is not muscly, aggressive and also when bottom is physically bigger than top or taller and when bottom is also masculine and aggressive. Those are actually toxic fans. It's ok to joke like estWilliam or Williamest.. like that but talking shit is toxic

kelly earnest

also can we stop with saying there's top energy and bottom energy that's not a thing cuz their sexual positions and prefrences has nothing to do with how they act and look and what every they give off this is just my opinion you can be loud and express your thought just fine and be yourself and be unhigened about it but I think its more so the way you talk about someone having top or bottom energy is coming off bad cuz there isn't a such thing as that and nayonje no matter how they act can be a top or a bottom you don't have to give off a certain energy to be either its just a sexual preferance and how you do it in the bedroom who puts it in is three top and who takes it is the bottom nothing to do with how one looks or acts there is no such thing as top or bottom energy is all I mean not trying to be rude though and also pls dotn put them In box they have to give off to be either and pls try to refain form using top and bottom sometimes and just say their ship name instead and sometimes seapratign the actors from the sexual positions of top and bottom is great as well

kelly earnest

sorry fo this comment came off way to sexaulized I just don't know how else to say to and explain it and sorry for my English is off I am not a main English speaker its not my first langage even though I do know it

Natalie A

Hi Ben, I appreciate you taking the time to get some feedback on this and I am very much enjoying your journey into BL. Regarding your questions (and apologies for the long text): 1. While it is not a total no go as long as you are respectful (and we understand you are learning) simply calling then by top/bottom can be demeaning and get old pretty quick. Your PoohPavel video in particular hit a sore spot as Pavel has actually faced a lot of backlash and cruel comments about how he "can't be a bottom" because he is muscular even though he embraces being the bottom of the pair. People are complex and the industry is not likely to take risks on less "normal" looking pairings if the top/bottom visuals keeps being the main focus. We understand you are getting a lot of names thrown at you with all these new shows and pairs but I would encourage trying to learn the character or actors names rather than just top/bottom. The Website MyDramaList can also be useful for seeing casts and tracking things in BL. 2. Ship away it is actively encouraged by the industry and the actors. It is actually very similar to Kpop in a way. BL actors are not allowed to date as they are "dating" their pair and honestly its a huge deal if a BL actor is ever caught in photos with a women looking even slightly cozy. Closest comparison is something like MinSung from Stray Kids. Companies encourage people to picture the pair as dating and hint at things but its a lot of acting cause...you know these are actors. But it is still in good fun for the most part. 3. Comparing different ships...for your safety I would tread carefully. If you are comparing something like "MileApo have a much more mature vibe vs WilliamEst." and it is done respectfully and in the context of their performances that is fine. But again like kpop you are well aware that comparing kpop groups on which is "best" can get the fandoms wild. So...keep a similar mindset for that. The BL industry is massive (it legit makes up a decent percent of Thailands GDP) and as you learn more you will see different studios (like in kpop) have different vibes for their shows, actors, pairings, quality, etc. to achieve their goals and pitting them against each other is not good. Overall I think you are doing well and have certainly jumped into the deep end with enthusiasm which is great to see. I wouldn't want to see that tampered down but just keep open about feedback because unlike kpop shipping the BL industry is more of a representation for the LGBTQ+ community so there can be more feelings involved there. If you decide to venture out into the larger BL sphere of productions from Korea, Taiwan, Japan, and China you will also see there is different trends and nuance there so maybe something to think about in the future.

kelly earnest

top means they put it in no matter if your on top or not that what that means Ina gay sexual position if you put it in your a top and if you take it your the bottom sorry for this comes across way to sexualized its just super hard to explain it without doing that

Aurora

It’s totally normal to wonder who’s top or bottom, as long as you don't base their whole personality on it. There’s no such thing as a "masculine top" and a "feminine bottom", a top can be less masculine and a bottom can be more masculine, so those stereotypes don’t really apply! Yes, you can definitely ship them because part of their job is actually based on fanservice, just keep in mind that it’s probably not real, and have fun with it! Everyone has their own favorite ships and actors, so don’t worry about it! Just enjoy what you like! No pressure at all Ben!

Deedee

it’s ok to say too and bottom. but you’re making that their whole personality when it’s not. you keep thinking top means aggressive and masculine. & bottom mean feminine and sassy. when that’s not the case in real life gay relationships. tops can be feminine & bubbly. & bottoms can be dominant.

Ashhhh

Since you've asked and I'm seeing conflicting info here, let me give my 2cents, because I think it's VERY important. Firstly, the problem is that a lot of your comments come off as misogynistic - meaning you only associate certain behaviours with being a "bottom" = submissive, feminine etc. That's not how things actually work.... A ship name dynamic is sole based on bedroom positions..and if you watch some companies they have a stereotypical pairing dynamic - which is fine BUT not always the case in reality. This is why what you say can start to become disrespectful because even though you're reacting to a ship, you are still commenting on 'Queer' culture.. I hope you understand. YES, the BL industry does feed into a lot of stereotypes because it was mostly an industry consumed by women. A lot of these women are straight women who know nothing about actual queer people and what's considered disrespectful ... you can even tell by the way some of the books/series are written. However, a lot has been changing over the years and there is an attempt to streamline the industry to represent actual LGBTQ+ people. A lot of women here will tell you that what you say is fine but that's because they are 1. Straight 2. Know nothing about actual queer dynamics and 3. Live under patriarchal conditioning... or all of the above. Bottom line, you CAN talk about who is Top & Bottom, but outside of the bedroom..does it really matter?? Btw, I love your reactions, always have.. I SAY ALL THIS WITH LOVE :)

Sam S

Your English is just fine. 👏🏻 And I absolutely agree about the “top energy” and “bottom energy” statements need to stop/be toned down, because that’s not actually a thing outside of the toxic masculinity crowd.

Ashhhh

but it's okay to educate especially when someone asks to be...

StayKristy

I understand what it means, thank you. But it still a very weird terminology to use 🤷‍♀️ i don't know who came up with this and how it started, but i always felt that it's wrong 😕

Annalyn Hart

1. It is okay, but be careful not to reduce every interaction to Top vs. bottom energy. Human relationships don't really work that way. 2. You can ship them but be respectful. Some actors are more comfortable than others and lean into it more. No matter how close and cuddly they seem I always assume it's fan service until they confirm it. 3. It's okay to have favorites and opinions. You can share your ideas etc. but I would be careful about making it a competition.

Ashhhh

Actual gay people?? What lol

Ashhhh

it's okay to ask and it's okay for us to educate :)

Deedee

exactly. Idk why people act like he can’t be politely educated on important topics

Sam S

Yes to all of this! I think that the point about the BL sphere being viewed as much more linked to the LGBTQIA+ community than K-POP “ships”, means that we need to be more mindful of how we discuss the stories, characters and actors. Some shows do much better at accurate representation of the queer community than others. Hopefully Ben dives into the comments section, as he’s still very new to this, and there is lots of opportunity for learning and growth in how he thinks/talks about BL. I look forward to the evolution.

Ashhhh

Perfectly put :)

Deedee

no. people are trying and wanting to politely educated him. because some of his comments are disrespectful to the queer community.

kelly earnest

yes true like its also really not a thing a bottom or a top doesn't thave to give off a certain enegy and has nothing to do with the way they are in the bedroom and the terms bottom and top are sexal pistions they use in the bedroom nothing to do with what every or vibe they give off so just be respectful of the ship dymanic they choose and if poohpavel chooses to be poohpavel then soport or williamest and teeteepor choose to be those ships and dymanics in their series we should sjtu go with it and soport that and don't call them the other way around its very disrepctful of their choices they chose to act as in series but also top and bottom roles have nothing to do with how a actor acts or what vibe or energy they give off and tops dotn always have to be agressive and domient ones and bottom dotn always have to give off baby girl vibes or have no muscle or be feminine either it can be vice versa or any perosnlity they give off doesn't have to be one way to be a top or a bottom in general

Ashhhh

❤️

kelly earnest

and that's why we are saying it nott hat its wrong just the way you are saying it

Ashhhh

This is what TeeTeePor wanted to be but because of toxic heteronormative fans, they had to go with a fixed top/bottom ship unfortunately

Annalyn Hart

1. You can say it, but I wouldn't reduce every interaction to top vs bottom energy. Human relationships don't really work that way. 2. Shipping is fine. It is a part of the culture. Fan service is often used to promote actors or serries. Some len into it more than others. I always assume fan service unless the actors directly confirm anything. 3. You can have opinions and favorites and talk about that, but I wouldn't turn it into a competition.

Susan Lilley

I think your brain is trying to figure things out and going for the easiest descriptions and categories which can be tough on those people who have a lingering experience with prejudice and discrimination. You’re searching for descriptors to help you communicate I appreciate you’re asking these hard questions. Now for the hardest part. Letting your brain see the complexities of these relationships. Appreciating when characters fall outside narrow categories. You’ve got this Ben. Let’s grow together.

rateddalexis

yess heavy on the tops can alsoo be golden retrievers and bottoms can also be more dominant !!!

Ashhhh

Yes there is actually :) you should read some of the comments

kelly earnest

its a gay term and what they use in gay terms and what actual gay realtionships use its sexual positions the top puts it in/is the giver and the bottom is the receiver it makes perfect since to me as a person part of the LGBTQ+ commuity so even if a person is on top he still is the bottom if someone else is giving it to him sorry for this is very sexual terms I am sorry idk how else to say it

Sam S

Say it louder for the people in the back!! 👏🏻🗣️

Verlencia Cantrell

Ben anything you say is ok just treat this as if its the kpop culture as long as you don't sh*t on their acting or say this ship is better than this other ship or this BL actor is better than this other BL actor you should be fine. I feel as tho this post is in response to that one comment i saw in the poohpavel tiktok compilation ben posted basically saying jokes aside what ben was saying was irritating them and that ben was being homophobic. Which I feel that person obviously couldn't differentiate/comprehend that the words ben said and used he meant no harm plus to say that what he did was homophobic......that person doesn't know the definition then cuz homophobic is an adjective that describes attitudes, behaviors, rules, or beliefs marked by a fear, dislike, prejudice, or hatred against gay, lesb, or queer people ( or people preceived as such). Nowhere in that video did ben say or demonstrate any homophobic words/actions. It was more like the societal thinking of muscular manly men would obviously be the top and skinny men the bottom or the man who gives off more masculine energy is top and the other would obviously be the bottom which there is nothing wrong with that thinking. We as a society has been conditioned to think that way for a long time. Ben is new to this BL world so he doesnt really know the terminologies or the BL actors names so hes going based off observation and the vibes/feelings he picks up when watching the dramas and Real life interactions. He doesnt know that the alpha dominate vibes he picks up from certain BL actors who happens to be the bottom is termed/coined "power bottom". He doesnt know about Tops who are soft. Soft Tops are people who takes a dominant or leading role during s*x or intimate moments, but is remarkably gentle, sweet, affectionate, & emotionally nurturing in everyday life. Power bottom is a receptive (bottoming) partner in sexual encounters frequently within the gay male culture who takes an active, assertive, & dominant or controlling role in directing the experience. Sometimes it even has to due because the bottom is older than the top or the bottom having more experience than the top. Perfect example is WilliamEst.....Est is older than William & has more experience not only in bl acting but life experience as well since william is an Tpop Idol his first kiss was Est & from videos Est is the more mature one so his energy is more so assertive/dominant but he has his moments of babygirl/vulnerable side so in the real life video interactions he comes off as a top when really hes the bottom (power bottom). William is a soft top plus since hes younger he gives off puppy energy that wants to take care of Est.

SingingRazors

This one. Duang With You is an excellent example of of golden retriever top vs black cat bottom. MaxTul are the OG couple of both being built af.

SingingRazors

For 3. There's a large part of BL fans who get toxic when comparing ships to eachother. Think toxic kpop fans and what happens when comparing kpop groups to eachother.

Sam S

Yes to all of this!! As someone in the queer community, I feel that it’s so important that we share our perspectives on how the queer community is portrayed online (and in this instance, in BL). And even more importantly, how it’s discussed. I always try to keep the feedback respectful, as I feel that educating people outside the queer community is so important. That’s not to say that only queer voices carry weight in the conversation - there are lots of queer allies who have immersed themselves in the community, and have nuanced and educated views to share.

Sam S

Ben is asking for feedback, and is showing that he’s open to learn. So it’s important to provide the feedback he’s requested to allow him to develop his understanding.

Tega

So my advice is similar to most of what's already been said in terms of question 1. I'll just add that if you're looking for words, you can simply describe their actual attributes. Like, if they're dominant or submissive, you can just refer to that. If they have baby-girl mannerisms, just observe that. The key is that these attributes don't necessarily affect whether or not they're a 'top' or 'bottom'. There are tops who are baby-girl coded and very dominant, assertive bottoms. People are multifaceted, so you can use terminology (I'd limit it to when it's actually relevant and use their actual names in the first instance), but you gotta respect that people encompass much more than stereotypical understandings of what it means to be a top/bottom. For example, I feel sometimes when you say someone has 'top energy', what you really mean is that they're super dominant and assertive. I think you should just say the latter.

Sam S

@Ashhhh Exactly!! The heteronormativity is robbing us of such important vers representation.

Sam S

I love this!

Ashhhh

I agree and because the fandoms seem to be majority straight folks, the noise can be loud and wrong A LOT which gets so frustrating 🥲

Sam S

There really are some rules to abide by, and allowing the queer community to guide you on those is so important. Ben asked for feedback, and fortunately there are a lot of people in these comments who care enough to help educate him.

Sam S

With regards to using top/bottom vs using the person or character’s name… You wouldn’t define people by their race descriptor (as an example) constantly, as that would come off as racist if that’s the only way you referred to them. If you constantly said “the black girl” or “the Korean guy” rather than learning their name, most people would realise that was problematic. The same applies to the top/bottom descriptor, because regardless of whether it’s race, age, gender, sexuality or sexual position in a relationship - everyone is more than just that one aspect of their identity. I hope that makes sense?!

Sam S

@Deedee Agreed. 👍🏻

Ashhhh

sighh, I say give the industry 1 more year? Lol so much has changed in the last few so i'll keep my fingers crossed 😂

Sam S

Exactly this. And seeing people reply that “everything is okay”, without appreciating that how the fictional queer characters are talked about, can directly impact how people view and speak about the queer community IRL. Hearing problematic commentary constantly, gives people the feeling that they can say these things about queer people as it becomes normalised. A bit like the racist and queer-phobic rhetoric that politicians spew out constantly, emboldening people to say similar things in person and online.

Sam S

Yes, exactly. It’s fine to observe out loud that a character is the top or bottom during an on-screen sexual encounter as that’s relevant to what we are being shown. But it has no bearing on any other interaction between the characters, as their personality is just their personality. In fact, I love shows that don’t conform to the feminine and masculine stereotypes, or don’t lean into them too heavily. BLs are definitely evolving, thankfully.

Rene Chandon

for me and for many BL fans, it is fine to use Top or bottom, or Seme Uke as an alternative. Just remember they are actors! and not their characters! Yes, ok, ship them while remembering the above. the actors are often shipped too aggressively when they are not playing their roles. and as for comparisons, it is fine, people have faves. But please don't rise to the level of war!

alma bernal

Ben i dnt think theres one definitive answer. Top and bottom is always used. Many series even have it in their dialogue. Youll learn that the dynamics arent always soo stereotypical but the top and bottom thing will always be aa thing. Not alll tops are hella masc. And not all bottoms are hella fem. Then you got the dom and sub aspect to it. Theres a lot. Dont feel bad for using top and bottom but just remember the personalities differ. Some people will try to dump their personal experiences on you and thats not fair. This is bl. Its fake. Sooo you using top and bottom is what comes with these series. Just remember that they dont all fall into one general representation of the terms. Of course you can ship em. They ship tf out of eachother sometimes so u can too. And comparing isnt bad its a reality. Some will be different than others. Just maybe focus on how the series in general is different rather than the couples but either way its a fact. Not all couples act the same and not all series are the same. So you have every right to point out those differences and similarities too. Just have fun ben. Enjoy the ride. You dnt need to focus too much on wether people are ok or not. This is your platform and if ppl dont like it they can bounce. You have plenty more people that wanna be here.

Cee

l would actully say that joking and switching a CPs officiall name depends on which CP it is. Please don´t use PavelPooh for instance because they both don´t like it and they´ve had so much critique over the years because they ´re breaking the stereotypes. For them it´s better to respect their offical name PoohPavel both for the actors sake and becoause a lot of the fandom are seriously tired of that "joke".

Toasted Toad

I would say that some pairings have strong "seme/uke" energy (which I think is what you're identifying as top/bottom). However, in (hopefully) well written BL, there's going to be far more to their relationship than that, so identifying them by their preferred sexual position is a bit - I dunno - demeaning? At first, I found it funny, but now that you've had more experience I think it might be a good idea to move on a bit. What it does is give little value to the plot and other characterisations, which we've seen by you sometimes just skipping forwards bits that do not involve the couple (which I think is only justified where we've already seen scenes). I think caution should be exercised when comparing different ships. Try mentioning BTS and SKZ in the same paragraph. So tread a little carefully but it's perfectly legitimate. Personally, I think quality of acting is very legitimate too. There is one series where I found that, although the young cast were all great, the acting of all the adult characters very sub-par. And sometimes there might be a ship which just doesn't ring true for you (there is one for me). There's one novel I've been reading where, although it's clear all the way who is going to 'top', the power dynamic goes the other way.

t morg

1. yes but don’t confuse top and bottom with dominant and submissive. The 2 aren’t interchangeable, a top isn’t always the dominant one and the bottom isn’t always baby girl/submissive. 2. absolutely ship them till the cows come home, but try to avoid ghost shipping if you can 3. yes and no, yes if you’re saying this person is different to what you’ve seen before, no if it’s constant/the only thing being focused on. Just have fun, don’t over think too much and please don’t apologise for going too hard with the shipping we’ve all seen and heard far worse

Toasted Toad

You know what might help is to watch Heated Rivalry. All the guys are much more muscular (they're hockey players), and their relationship dynamics are much more equal than what I'm seeing in BL (although my experience is still limited). It's extremely well acted and very steamy! I think a lot of your BL viewers would be happy to see it with you - it's only 6 episodes on Netflix.

Toasted Toad

And there we go. A legitimate question from someone new to the genre and finding their way, realising there might be more to learn, is met with an angry lecture and all sorts of accusations. Way to go. That's exactly the way to put people off completely and ensure they never learn any more about LGBT etc. Everyone else is giving friendly guidance. You just want to tell him to f off. In which case, the unsubscribe option is freely available to you.

Sam S

Yes to all this!

N•O•Y ninio

What you say makes sense, but many times, as someone who is not Thai, it is very difficult for me to remember their names and follow them, so for many people I go by descriptions.😅 Not with the intention of not respecting them and what they are, but because it's just easier and of course it's just for me at home, not for anyone outside, everything one way or another I learn the names and tend to maintain respect and a new son in everything so it's easier for him and that's okay

Cat R

1. Yes, it is okay to say the words "Top" and "Bottom" especially when speaking in the context of sex/NC scenes or if the topic of the clip you're watching is discussing it. It only becomes a problem when you make being Top or Bottom their entire personality. These are real people with thoughts, interests, feelings and personalities. If you wouldn't like someone making your entire personality based on what you do in the bedroom, neither would they 🤷🏽‍♀️ sexual preference is nuanced and it doesn't matter if someone is "masculine" or "feminine" presenting when it comes to sexual positions. There are traditional dynamics like "Masculine Top" and "Feminine Bottom" especially since the genre started out as content for straight women however in real life there are masculine × feminine, masculine × masculine, feminine × feminine, feminine × masculine and everything in between! Even in straight relationships between a man and a woman, the man could be the bottom if he enjoys penetration and the woman could be the top with toys or strap ons if they are okay with being the one doing the penetrating. Ultimately what people do in their bedroom is none of our business outside of the context of the shows you are commenting on. 2. Ship away! The whole point of fixed BL cp's (couples) is the "will they won't they" "they're definitely dating I just can't prove it!" Aspect and most of these actors do fan service to feed into it so feel free to ship them as much as you want! Just make sure to keep it respectful and understand that these are actors doing a job and this is all fun fandom delulu unless the actors have actively spoken out to say they are actually dating in real life! 3. Personally I don't think comparison is inherently bad, if you are comparing the series or just stating the difference in the couple dynamics between couples and keep it respectful without tearing actors or pairs down to lift up another, I don't see an issue!

Tsuliwaensis

why are you so obsessed with me?

Sam S

I’m obviously not Thai either, and I’ve found MDL (MyDramaList) a helpful way to learn actor and character names over the years. As you say, you use descriptors for actors in the privacy of your home, rather than in front of an audience. I would personally recommend that Ben considers making a little “cheat sheet” for each show, with actor and character names, for easy reference during filming. MDL is the perfect resource for that.

Sam S

Well said.

Ashhhh

Absolutely agree with everything you said!! 👏🏽

Ashlie Mcneff

I would say all the comments are helpful and accurate.. my suggestion would be not to mix and match confirmed working ships.. creating ghost ships can be fun sometimes to think about, but there are some very die hard shippers for specific working couples. Nothing wrong with a little "what if..." Now and then, and you can absolutely have a favorite pairing, to be safe just don't mix and match. :) other than that I love your reactions and I'm so glad you decided to join us heathens in this BL hole! There are sooooo many good shows in a lot of languages! I highly recommend the last twilight, the eclipse, see your love and the last oath!

bludreamgirl

Can you pin comments on patreon? because this is just perfect

Zee Wyatt

My two cents... just continue to do what you're doing. I'm having a great time watching. You are hilarious! I nearly died laughing watching your top/bottom radar crash and burn over PoohPavel.

Ashhhh

❤️❤️❤️

AwesomeSunshineness

I think it doesn't hurt to do a little homework before reacting to some of these series. Learn the character's names and yeah it's ok to identify them as top and bottom in the first episode but after maybe just call them by the character names. It's ok to describe them dominant and feminine and your most beloved word "babygir" 🤣, but you can ease up on the top/bottom after a while. It also depend on what you say about being top/bottom, the tone etc. I find the fandoms can get way too spicy on this topic so it's best to avoid 😅

ㅣuv_bossnoeul

This is just my personal opinion, but I hope you don’t think of it as just the roles shown in the series. Of course, within the series they play, the top and bottom are often fixed, and they usually provide fan service to the fans according to their roles. However, that doesn't mean that in real life, the bottom lane should always have a feminine and weak image, like the one in the role. I don't know much about other couples, so I'll give Bosnoeul, which I support, as an example. In a TikTok video you recently uploaded, you were surprised that Noeul doesn't have the image of a baby girl in real life, but Noeul has a very hip and masculine side in real life. Wouldn't other BL couples be similar? Please don't compare couples to each other. Each couple has a different personality. And I think BL is one genre, so it shouldn't be belittled. Please give them lots of support!! 🙏

Tiferet

Lots of good points from people who commented before me, but in the spirit of education let me add this - Thai BL actors would usually refer to themselves and one another as SEME and UKE, which in Thai is usually rendered as ME and KE, but in subs/translations will usually either be spelt out in full or translated to "top" and "bottom". It comes from Japanese, those are yaoi terms (which is also why in Thailand BL and GL series are called "series Y"). As much as I don't love assigned positions, I respect that those are the terms those people actually use for themselves, and it does make it a bit more linguistically removed from the bedroom positions. So, for example, you'll hear William gleefully bragging about Est being the ultimate uke of GMMTV. As for shipping, every pair gets shipped by the fans, the MCs at events, by fellow actors, by themselves (WILLIAM), the whole industry is one big shipping game, publicly and in open text. But once you watch some of their content, you'll see that different actors have different attitudes to it. They can range from wildly enthusiastic (WILLIAM) to being good sports about it, to just laughing it off, they're very rarely unhappy about it and generally only if someone harasses them, be it toxic fans or asshole journalists.

Annalyn Hart

To be honest if it directly affects someone or a whole community, they have every right to say something. Conversations and coming to an understanding is important.

PrincessNur V

We here to be intertain lol, let Ben be himself and just enjoyed his reaction, Don't get easily offended please

Toasted Toad

Not obsessed with you, but what you say. Because you're being rude and unpleasant. He's asking us what he should do, aware that he might be making mistakes, and you're just insulting him. You think he should know everything before even starting. Even asking a question is not enough for you. You can't settle for being helpful like everyone else. He is not bulldozing on, refusing to accept correction. This is his first encounter with BL, but he has happily supported ships in the Kpop realm (always aware that it is delulu). That's why people thought he might enjoy BL.

Elix

Just gonna address a part of #1 that I think might be helpful. BL is ultimately queer representation in media. There is an industry surrounding it, fan culture, and a lot of the actors in the shows aren't actually gay but do fan-service and may be shipped with their costars for a very long time. While in the culture of BL the name organization might indicate a top/bottom orientation it can be a bit reductionist to use only these descriptors. Top energy and bottom energy can feel real I suppose but ultimately its just a sex position. Some people are top only, some people only bottom, and some are vers (do both), but that doesn't define a personality. A top can be cutesy out of the bedroom, a bottom can be in charge and dominant, it really doesn't define anything outside of the context of who's giving and who's receiving when you get to the literal meaning. Saying that a top is only masculine, dominant, bossy, etc and a bottom is only feminine, submissive, cutesy, and demure etc can be entirely incorrect, and plays into heteronormative stereotyping. Additionally, when you connect something to heteronormative stereotypes it gets into the realm of misogyny because then you are using antiquated ideas of femininity to define sexual and romantic relationship dynamics that might play into misogynistic power dynamics and ideals for women. This is all just to say that this world of BL is still connected to some very real topics and as you have asked these questions I would like to just point out the layers that are involved in relationship dynamics and how these words are simple and not offensive, but a bit reductionist in the context of queer identity. I hope that more of the videos will show the couples personalities, talents, and fun relationship dynamics in a way that can entertain as well.

johanna

maybe instead of saying top and bottom just say dominant and submissive, which you already sometimes did haha idk but please dont change the way you react because that is literally why i like your reactions so much and what makes them so fun to watch, i mean you asking these questions already shows that you want to be respectful and dont want to offend anyone and i think intentions matter

Ashhhh

I'm pretty sure if he said something that was offensive to a community you're apart of, you wouldn't be making this comment....

Sam S

Yes to all of this! 👏🏻

Deedee

that commentator is so weird. acting as if we can’t educate someone just bc we’re here to be entertained.

PrincessNur V

It's not weird, I'm just telling Ben be himself no pressure, you love his reaction right? That's why you here?? Same with me, so just enjoyed without hard feeling

PrincessNur V

Nothing is offense if you know Ben personality, he just being himself and Ben is not child so he know his boundaries, so I just saying we shouldn't make Ben feel pressure