Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This is the 2024 Acura MDX Type S I had this past week, and I just finished my article about it (one of my final pieces as a freelancer); it'll go live soon and I'll link it here. But I've been thinking about trying to change how I write my press-car reviews. 

I've had precious few press cars in my life (Ridgeline, Arteon R-Line, NSX, Colorado Trail Boss, Crosstrek Sport [article coming soon], and this - that's everything since my career began three years ago), and I always try to make them have a hook in some way. With this piece, I tried to make the things I did with the SUV drive the narrative structure of the story (rather than presenting specs, and then telling the story), to create a natural segue from factual information to emotion. I'm not sure it worked, is the thing, because trying to write a 1,600 word piece that's informative, opinionated, interesting to read, and actually helpful to an imagined buyer is virtually impossible to do in that short of a word count. 

How do I avoid this in my most interesting pieces? Well, generally they're about classic cars where I don't need to inform a buyer, or I go over word count (or both), and they're more like lit-lite than a car review. They're assuredly less helpful to someone shopping for a car, but more interesting to read. 

With this revelation, I think I'm going to see at my new job if I can sometimes just do a story like that, even with a new car. There are so many bog-standard new car reviews now I cannot imagine that people would be upset if sometimes, when I got an interesting car, I just talked about the interesting things I did with it for a while... or if I simply rambled for a bit. As it is, on the cybertruck piece - where I very aggressively aimed for appropriate short-form wordcount - the biggest piece of feedback I got from readers was "I wish it were longer". I just wonder if audiences have the attention span for that en masse with automotive writing. 

Files

Comments

John Neff

I think they have the attention span for it if you cultivate the reputation for doing it well. People like your Dan Neils, Ezra Dyers, and Zach Bowmans have that reputation for me and I tend to read everything they write no matter how long.

Interurban Era

I just read the article and I think it strongly WORKED. I felt more natural than skimming past the info-dump of a car I'd never buy (or afford) to get back to the story. Saying how the single turbo's power band actually helped you accomplish a driving task and enjoy what could otherwise be a mundane 7 seater kept me far more engaged. I think more writers should lean into the "WHY does this particular engineering decision MATTER to you, the potential driver/owner?" and it worked really well here. More of this, please! It also helped me build respect for why Acura chose to build this thing in the first place, and that you got to enjoy it on a ferry ride out into the wilds of Washington state with your partner made it all the better.

Tran Girlismo (& Victoria Scott)

Thank you so much Miles!!! I am glad this worked, I'm gonna try to see if I can keep writing reviews like this in '24. I had fun with it, it made the pictures a lot more meaningful, and apparently it was worth the effort!