Harman Phoenix 200 Film Review (or the first new color film in quite a while) (2023) (Patreon)
Content
Hey everyone! I hope your holidays were lovely and your new years were joyous. I'm here with a fresh roll of film and a few comments on it: Harman Phoenix 200, the all-new (?) C41 color film from Harman/Ilford. This is a rare occasion; Harman itself has said it's still experimental (it has no halation layer, similar to Cinestill's repackaged cinema films 800T and 400D) but new C41 color films haven't really come out in a while, so I had to shoot it.
Before I go further: Here's the full roll on Flickr!
Now, for comments on the film itself: It's not bad and I prefer it to Cinestill 400D or some of the weirder Lomography stuff I've seen, but it's also not really good per se. But, at the same time, I still liked it. Allow me to explain.
Here's a shot that pretty accurately depicts the tonal range of this stuff. The sky is blown out (and halated; you can see the reddish glow in the leaves and posts), and there's still lost shadow detail in the darkest sections; if I had to estimate, it's probably closer to a slide-film-like 5-6 stops of dynamic range rather than the 8-9 ish stops of Kodak's cheap stuff (Colorplus, Gold) or the 10-11 ish stops of Kodak's pro stuff (Ektar, Portra).
This isn't all bad - it works well perpendicular to the sun in relatively even light, with dramatic contrast. Blues are a little weird - they have that instagram-photographer-who-shoots-the-desert-on-Portra teal toning naturally, this is me attempting to correct for that (and failing) - but it's not ugly, overall.
Color reproduction elsewhere isn't too bad. This film (I found out halfway through the roll) is actually technically rated as ISO 125 or so, which means that it does better if you over-expose by one or two third-stops. If you shoot darker than that, you end up with pretty green-cast shadows, as you can see here, although the shot is far from ruined. It does have some very chunky grain, mind you; I don't tend to care about this, but it's rougher than you'd expect for a 200-that's-actually-a-125 film.
But, you know, overexpose a bit too much (or meter for midtones) and you're probably gonna lose some sky in broad daylight. This shot still works like this, so honestly, I'm not too upset about it, and I think it's actually a good look if I shoot with it in mind. Nonetheless, it's still a weakness of the film.
So where's this stuff the strongest, then?
Luckily for my Pacific-Northwest-Dwelling ass, the rainforest is by far where it is the best. Greens are phenomenal on this stock, and overcast skies dampen dynamic range to a point that Phoenix can actually perform properly.
And this is why I like it. On a day-to-day basis, if I were shooting cheap color film, I'd probably want to go with a (comparably-priced) roll of Colorplus 200 because it handles the range of direct sunlight a bit better, but for overcast color film - especially in a city with so many rich greens - this actually works really, really well, and it has a character I like.
I hope if any of you were considering buying a few rolls, this encouraged you to give it a shot; it's more than worth the $10 a roll it's goin' for, just to try out something new, imho! Anyway, I started my new gig at Motor1 yesterday and one of my final pieces for Slashgear went live, a review of the Acura MDX Type S I had a few weeks ago! I'm excited to start sharing some Motor1 work soon!