Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hey everyone, here it is in full! Thank you so much for the support throughout the production of this video. I'm very sorry this one took so long. Although the research and script phase was quite long, it wasn't too bad. The real problem was the volume of animations I queued up for myself. It's just impossible to communicate points about how notation works without complex animations that require storyboarding and After Effects work. There were around 80 animations in this video.

I'm going to be coming back over the next few days to propose a few new directions / videos for the channel and I'd be very grateful for your feedback.

In the meantime, please enjoy!

Files

Previews only

Notation Must Die: The Battle For How We Read Music

Many people feel that western notation makes it unnecessarily hard to read music. If we want to sight read, learn music theory or just practice an instrument, surely there's a better way? Right? This has been a hot topic for almost 1000 years... AND I PUT IT TO BED RIGHT HERE! Support me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/Tantacrul View my content on Nebula: https://go.nebula.tv/tantacrul Tweet my Twitteriness: https://twitter.com/Tantacrul Come visit our Discord: https://discord.gg/ttc-chat Subtitles by Pentameron ---------- CHAPTERS ---------- 00:00 - Setting the stage 09:26 - Notation must die INTRO! 15:12 - Ancient Greek notation 19:40 - The history of western notation 31:57 - Chromatic staves 36:15 - The piano roll 42:54 - Clefs (and resistance to change) 44:42 - Muto method 46:45 - Notation & the aristocracy 48:25 - Tablature 51:40 - Guitar Hero 52:51 - Klavarskribo 54:08 - Other types of keyboard notation 55:47 - Musitude! 1:01:18 - Dodeca 1:03:01 - Accessibility 1:04:31 - Farbige Noten 1:06:49 - Jullian Carrillo's system 1:08:26 - The best of the rest 1:11:52 - Where can we go from here? ---------- BIBIOGRAPHY ---------- BOOKS Julian Carrillo: Sistema General de Escritura Musical (Mexico City: Ediciones Sonidos 13, 1895) Charles Francis Abdy Williams: The Story of Notation (New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1903) https://archive.org/details/storynotation00willgoog/page/n28/mode/2up Willi Apel: The Notation of Polyphonic Music, 900-1600 (The Mediaeval Academy of America, Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1953) https://archive.org/details/notationofpolyph1953apel/page/32/mode/2up Gardner Read: Source Book of Proposed Music Notation Reforms (Bloomsbury Publishing Plc, 1987) ARTICLES AND BLOGS Adémar de Chabannes, Carolingian Musical Practices, and Nota Romana - James Grier - Journal of the American Musicological Society, Vol. 56, No. 1, pp. 43-98. - University of California Press Musical Clefs and their Abolition, T. L. Southgate - The Musical Times and Singing Class Circular, Vol. 30, No. 559 (Sep. 1, 1889) https://www.jstor.org/stable/3360190?typeAccessWorkflow=login Cross eyed pianist on the topic of notation being ‘elitist’. https://crosseyedpianist.com/tag/elitism-in-music-education/ The Muto Method https://muto-method.com/en/score.html Proposed redesign of piano sheet music https://medium.com/alex-couch-s-portfolio/how-i-d-redesign-piano-sheet-music-355c4f9012f1 Musitude https://musitude.com/ The Modes of Ancient Greek Music https://www.gutenberg.org/files/40288/40288-h/40288-h.htm VIDEOS Reconstruction of Greek music, led by Professor Armand D'Angour https://youtu.be/4hOK7bU0S1Y Offertorium: Jubilate Deo universa terra https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tw0Ny4Z4wD4&ab_channel=GradualeProject An introduction to mensural notation https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G1F2FSLakVA&ab_channel=EarlyMusicSources OTHER LINKS Daseian notation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daseian_notation Style similar to Nonantolian notation https://unipub.uni-graz.at/obvugrscript/content/pageview/5564611 Mensural notation wikipedia page (which is very good) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mensural_notation Database of high-res scans of early Christian music https://www.e-codices.unifr.ch/en/list/subproject/stgall_music Mensural notation scan: Missae partes decantari solitae: Kyrie, Gloria, Credo, Sanctus et Agnus Dei cum notis musicalibus https://search.onb.ac.at/primo-explore/fulldisplay?docid=ONB_alma21295855650003338&context=L&vid=ONB&lang=de_DE Mouth pictogram imagery by pch.vector https://www.freepik.com/free-vector/mouth-animation-set_9176068.htm#query=mouth%20speaking&position=0&from_view=keyword&track=ais

Comments

gardenofadam

I didn’t have any negative response to them, while understanding that doing them was a decent compromise Martin came up with to acknowledge the inevitable criticisms that come from actually defining ones’ scope.

Anschel Schaffer-Cohen

Love this video as always. I'm a bit disappointed that you didn't discuss shape notes, which are probably the most common form of alternate notation used in the US, especially by people who don't think of themselves as "musicians". But I very much understand that you can't cover everything

no

as a painter i sort of wished that somebody would come up with a shapes&colors based tool for depicting or explaining music and now that you ve made me look at the huth's scheme - i take it back, seems disorienting, explains nothing helps no one! yes to shapes but probably a no to colours. (although i think it's also due to how differently a designer's and a painter's use and approach to shape and color would be). and i am very interested to hear your thoughts on color and sound

Kevin Austin

Wonderful intro / survey of the topic. Missing is a strong relationship between notation and performance in the 21st century. In general use, except in extreme conditions of very new music, an audio representation of a piece is available.

Kevin Austin

I like your work and find the finished version far superior to the first drafts from a while ago.

Martin Heuschober

the insight that many disruptors focus on the easy part of music making - reading the sheet - which can even be taught without playing an instrument. with the aid of flashcards and other memory systems. and not the difficult part of how to keep motivated, posture and hand/finger/... positioning so you're not hurting yourself in the long run, musicality, rhythm... but rather they fail to simplify a notation because of the inherent complexity music has

Dominik Wagner

To be honest: Sheet Music was a mental barrier for me for the longest Time. I do agree with the tone and conclusions of your video, and at the same time I'd love to contribute to a custom notation system display in MuseScore for "Colornotes" - as I did write my own to simplyfy/speedup my learning progress. I think we desperately would need a lingua franka in terms of exchange format, midi isn't enough, musicml to close to just traditional notation. How we view that piece of music should be in the consumers choice. MuseScore helped me a lot to gain access. That combined with Sheet Music OCR gave me a workflow to export good enough midi data to generate good Color Music sheet music. So Thanks for all your great work here!

Dominik Wagner

I personally would love more videos about alternate notation systems (all of them ^^) as well as some of the different file formats and their limitations. E.g. abc notation, various midi variants, lilypond, etc.

Joanna

I went to a music school as a child, I was taught well and I definitely *can* read the standard notation, but tbh I still hate having to do that to this day. To me it's like a foreign language that's very logical and easy when you're immersed in it for a decade, but still difficult and clunky to read and write after learning it for just a year. And, you know, a year is already 10 times longer than the average time people are willing to dedicate to their new "I wanna play a guitar" hobby. Maybe if we emphasised it's more of a "language", instead of just a "notation", it would be more understandable/acceptable to people that it by its very nature requires some dedication to grasp. (But this is ofc just my subjective view on the matter, and I struggle with specific processing issues that make this harder for me than it should be for a regular person, so take this with a grain of salt)

Mark Johnson

I love this video. As a middle-aged individual learning piano, I struggled both with reading sheet music and dealing with fingering. My overly obsessive brain sent me down a rabbit hole exploring alternate notation systems and eventually designing my own "Compact Semi-Tonal" (CST) notation system. However, I didn't stop there. I also redesigned the piano keyboard layout (somewhat Dodeka style) and 3D-printed a replacement set of keys for an 88-key MIDI controller. After a few months of getting that out of my system, I gave away the keyboard and chucked the notation system to get down to the business of learning standard notation on a standard piano keyboard. That said, I came away with a tremendous appreciation for the design of both and a much deeper understanding of how notation and instrumentation evolve together and affect one another. It was an exciting adventure, to say the least! (PS - I love all the shots of Musescore's notation rendering you incorporated into the video -- it's just so beautiful to look at!)

Thomas Keppler

Videos like this are why I love your work so much. Despite me needing free up an evening to watch it (which is worth it!) it's always put together in such a thoughtful way. Thank you!

Robert Weiss

Watched this from start-to-finish and was fascinated with the variety of serious and cuckoo ideas for representing music. I'm an amateur - a church choir guy - and I use Musescore to transcribe and to generate part tracks for rehearsal prep. As a retired programmer, I had a momentary rush when you showed how MuSc can present in any of several styles which are equivalent representations of the same musical intention. Just like Microsoft (for better or worse) created Foundation to support different application languages. Thanks for the time and depth you brought to this still-evolving art.