Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

“The Sky Treading Art, at its core, places the human in the heavens, and gives them agency. That is a crucial word- agency. The power to make choices. This is the ‘treading’ part of the title, you can walk where you will, not driven hither and thither by the winds of fate or circumstance.”

Tian imagined that Cruel Treachery sitting in front of him, her bald head shining in the diffuse light of the cavern, the solid blue of her eyes mirroring the sky peaking through the hole in the roof. She had sounded indifferent when she said it, but she almost always sounded indifferent. It pricked him, a little, to think that the only inflection he could remember from his teacher’s voice were indifference, anger and bitterness, the latter two directly inspired by him, and the fact that, even in the privacy of his mind, he still thought of her as “teacher” not “master.” 

He needed a master now. A teacher had no obligation to help with something so plainly outside the negotiated bounds of their work. A master would be involved with the overall development of their disciple, though Tian assumed “involved” was a bit of a moving target. What a master might consider an appropriate degree of assistance would vary from person to person. 

Practically the first thing she had said about the Sky Treading Art was that it situated the human in the heavens and gave them agency. That meant something. It was her core cultivation art, and was important to her emotionally. He could assume that she felt this was the most important thing to understand, that this image was core to the art and, by extension, her. 

“Do you think she would go for it? Actually, what would I even need her to do?”

“She would be delighted to. I’m not joking, she would be genuinely delighted to. As for what you would need her to do, she would be applying her… I don’t know what they call it here, spiritual pressure? Divine sense? Mind Power?”

“Shen?”

It’s shen, yes, but it’s an application of shen. She’d be jamming the melting paste into your body while you run your body cultivation art. Pushing while it pulls, as it were. Your art is considerably high end, but Earth Milk is strong stuff. The art could get overwhelmed, especially when you mix in all those random yin treasures you have. She will guide the overflowing qi into your dantians and meridians without overwhelming them, then use the overflow from that to nurture your nascent shen. Extremely delicate work, and potentially permanently crippling if she screws it up. Fatal, in the case of severe error.

Tian unwillingly nodded. He got it, all of it. Grandpa let the moment return to silence. 

“Should I use some of this for Liren?”

Not right now. Maybe if you find more in the future, but for now, she needs to grow her yang qi before condensing and purifying it again. Her physical body needs no reinforcement anyway. 

“And… just any yin treasures?”

So long as they don’t absolutely clash and seem useful for body refining. Earth Milk is a powerful earth elemental treasure, yin phase. It is all about acceptance and forming a basis for other things to build on. You might use that mystery mushroom of yours, there should be a good degree of overlap. Thanks to all the heretics you looted, you have a decent little selection of Heavenly yin herbs, roots and so on. Whack ‘em all into a mortar, mash ‘em, boil ‘em, put them in a stew. The stew is you, if that wasn’t clear.

“It was clear.” 

There is another angle you might not be considering. You haven’t made any progress in discovering what changes have happened in your body, and Merciless was unsubtle in his hint. He’s right, too- you figuring it out is going to be a lot more useful than me just telling you. 

“Which you said before.”

Which I said before, yes, and you also have a massively, massively cursed pair of shears which are just screaming out yin energy heavily related to both qi and shen generally, to say nothing of curse qi and demonic qi. Might be a very revelatory thing to work into your upcoming soak, if you can figure out a good way to do it. Perhaps in conversation with a more experienced elder.

“If I can bring myself to trust them enough to reveal a secret I’ve only ever told Liren.”

Mmm. Well, Voidcatcher certainly spotted the statue, and I’d put money on Merciless and the White Peacock spotting it too. It’s hardly invisible to the right sort of eyes. It’s just that, for them, it’s simply not worth their attention. Their foundations are already set, you see. I suspect there is some sort of problem with that bald woman’s foundations too, because the more I look at the Sky Treading Art, the more inexplicable her failure to advance becomes. It’s pretty direct about how the advancement to the Perfected Human realm works, without coming out and saying it in exactly those words.

Tian watched the butterflies dance over the pond, leaving shimmering illusions with every flap of their fragile wings. They were happy in the garden, drifting from blooming flower to blooming flower, not disdaining wild garlic scapes or mustard greens allowed to bolt, but always returning to the dustless lotuses in the pond. He wondered if the lotuses would break through to the Heavenly Realm. They were certainly accumulating qi, and he knew plants didn’t cultivate the way humans did. Presumably a revelation wasn’t required.

“The freedom to make choices, huh? And it’s… whatever the word is. Thing that must be true because of the first thing.” He was speaking to the air, but Liren overheard and answered anyway.

“Corollary. Which is?”

“The necessity of accepting the consequences of those choices. It seems I will need to pay our master a visit.” Liren just shrugged. Tian shifted awkwardly, still not at peace with the thought of getting so vulnerable with a sect elder.

“How is the reformation process going at the disciplinary squad? You just keep telling me it’s ‘good’ without giving me details.”

“Because nothing is final until everything is final, and nothing is final until the sect elders and Sect Master Rui adopt the new rules. The rules are actually mostly done. People have been discreetly working on this for years, even before me. It just took someone willing to flip the whole table and tear off the faces of a lot of very senior people to bring the project forward.”

“They found just the right person, then.”

“Mmm.”

“But specifically, what are you changing?”

Liren gave him an unreadable look. “We are abolishing the current land use system for the mortal descendants of members of the sect.”

Tian’s breath caught in his throat.

“Residency in Mountain Gate City will be conditioned on service to the sect, not lineage. Heavenly Realm cultivators will still be eligible for free cave residences there, subject to minimum merit earnings in a given year. Hit a certain threshold, and you qualify to reside in the Monastery proper. Note that it doesn’t just cost merits, you need a minimum level of honorable service to come here at all. But it’s not conditioned on your status in the sect beyond being in the Heavenly Realm.”

Tian nodded, blinking rapidly.

“Having kids who join the sect doesn’t qualify as “serving” the sect anymore. We are getting out of the merchant game entirely, as an organization. Rent for mortals will be paid in goods and services, not a million miles different than any other feudal lord. Both mortals and immortals will be subject to the corvee, should it be necessary. And any dead land, land where kids are born sickly and food doesn’t grow, will be deemed uninhabitable, the residents expelled from the land and provided compensation.”

“Your family…”

“Are being poisoned by the land they stole. Until we understand how, it’s insane to let people live there. And it gives me credibility. I’m sending my own family off the mountain. Who dares play games now?”

She sounded very tired, but no less resolved.

“We are still figuring out how we can ban immortals from backing mortal trading houses. There are some practical problems there, but the idea has a lot of support. I am trying to figure out how to ban private mortal power bases entirely, but it seems to be impossible to cut off clan ties. My goal is to make such power institutional. Our hand in the mortal world should be the Kingdom itself. If an immortal needs something done by mortals, he can pass word through the Mission Hall, who will delegate downward. But like I said, practical problems, and figuring out the clan issue is going to be a massive pain.”

She rubbed her hand through her short cropped hair, now almost entirely a vivid red with flecks of orange and gold. It gave her a magical, dangerous feeling. Tian had the hallucinatory thought- what would it look like if she grew it long? She would hate it, she thought she was too masculine already, but the idea of long flowing red tresses tumbling across their pillows gripped him like little else could. Liren diverted him before he could finish opening his mouth.

“We are considering building new cities on the Mountain, but that’s not my department. Ah… what else… some procedural changes on how complaints are handled between people of two different realms, we are trying to figure out a way to make investigations truly impartial, but with so few people that doesn’t seem to be completely possible. It’s going to have to be a cultural shift.”

“I imagine it would. Any word about the inner-core-direct disciple system?”

“Not confirmed, but… massive changes. The rating system for prospects in the Outer Court is being abolished, though they are keeping the Dragon Calling Bell. Access to arts and training are being stepped way up, and I’m hearing things about changes to how missions are designed.  Inner Court Disciples are going to have their benefits completely reworked, but first and foremost, they are going to be educated as though they had a real chance to break through to the Human realm.”

“Good. And, don’t they already?”

“No, actually. This is what I’m hearing second and third hand, but what I’m hearing is that the quality of the initial breakthrough is a huge indicator of the potential for breaking through to the human realm, and ultimately, though nobody has come right out and said this, the perfected human realm. It explains the structure of the monastery, and why they reserve the Sky Treading Art for the Direct Disciples. But since nobody knows a way to guarantee an initial breakthrough…”

“I get it.” Tian nodded.

“But after thousands and thousands of years, they have a few shen cultivation manuals in the Scripture Pavilion, and the Elders are certain to have even more in their private collections. Which they will volunteer for the good of the sect, apparently. Just about everyone will be able to find something suitable for them to cultivate. So even if they can’t manage a high quality initial breakthrough, they will have a path to make the attempt to break through to the Human Realm and beyond. Access to shen arts and more advanced qi training will be based on lifetime merits and, crucially, mandatory attendance of classes on the ethics and philosophy of the Ancient Crane, along with completing ongoing sect missions. Core disciples are the same as Inner Court disciples with even better benefits and even higher requirements for ongoing training and ongoing sect missions. I saw some elders picking out a group of mansions and cave dwellings as a special district reserved for core disciples. Make ‘em feel fancy and motivated. Direct disciples… are what they are.” Liren smiled, but her voice didn’t hide her frustration.

“Education. Their big plan to reform the Inner Court is education.” Tian closed his eyes and pinched the bridge of his nose.

“We are a sect. What else can we do? The list of things that violate the sect’s morality and public conduct rules now runs to six pages and ends with ‘and any other behavior which shocks the conscience.’” Liren pinched the bridge of her own nose. It was worse for her. She had been the one trying to write the rules.

“I wish I knew. And for regulating the Disciplinary Squad itself?”

“For anything other than summary execution, the punishment has to be confirmed by the head of the Squad, and a right of appeal to a panel of three randomly selected elders is being created. Best I could come up with. Summary execution is now being restricted, as is the use of torture in investigations.” She sighed. “Which does raise the question of when the line is crossed between investigation and punishment, but again, I just don’t know of a better system. We are working on it.”

“A changing sect. One we are already planning to take a gamble on.”

“Pretty much. And it’s not like we don’t have any affection for the old place.” She smiled at him, and patted the rock she was sitting on. “I have a lot of happy memories here. That’s worth fighting for.”

Tian held back a sigh. He was being excessively paranoid, it seemed. He would have to do what Elder Rui had said, and extend a little faith. At least he was confident Cruel Treachery would say yes. So without further ado, he went, and he asked his new master for her help.

“I cannot. And you really shouldn’t have asked.”

Comments

LordMars

Damn that was impressive turnaround of a last sentence. What a cliff. As we have seen Gramps be wrong before but that was typically due to a lack of information he was able to provide or for the sake of guidance. Typically not such a direct contradiction to something he has insisted on a half dozen of times in the past 2 chapters. Interesting interesting.

Teach

Oh. Oh no, that’s unexpected.

Chrysos au

Thanks for the chapter

Teach

Not really much to say about the sect reformation. In general it doesn’t matter how the system theoretically works. It’s how it works in practice, and the morals of the people working it

Chrysos au

Refusing to help her student's! A betrayal of sorts. How cruel.

Robert Mullins

Is it refusing if you are not doing something because you literally can't? Are you currently refusing to fly through the sky and shoot lasers from your eyes?

Robert Mullins

She must be much more injured than Gramps was expecting.

BIGLARGEFISH

Damn cruel treachery is really making sure that she is never seen as the master she so desperately wants to be.

Zephyr

I don't understand why Tian is being so paranoid about his loot. Even at their worst the Ancient Crane Monestary enforced a zero tolerance for higher realms stealing lower realms' stuff. Plus the worst people in the monastery all got kicked out. On a related note, I hope Warby is careful about the main characters following their sect's rules. Too often in stories like these the rules go by the wayside once it becomes inconvenient for the protagonists.

Brian P.

And the bloody fight to implement it once the barrier around the mountain goes down. I got the impression the majority of the inner court was still out there, not to mention other sects and kingdoms, and they’ll all need to be brought to heel or driven out.

KarmaXY42

He isn’t necessarily wrong yet. If this is just a thing too far outside the terms of the agreement then yes grandpa was wrong, but it’s also possible tian needs to use his double pupils and the purified scissors to perform soul surgery on Treachery so she can help him. He did make sure to point out both the shears and body change right after saying treachery would love to help.

Mobb

Considering how basically all of the direct disciples and almost all of the core disciples are behind the ward, a direct confrontation would be extremely foolish from the Inner Court members. Not to mention that starsieve cut down their numbers considerably and the human realm Daoist masters backing them. Enforcing the rules shouldn’t be too hard, but making the inner court follow along and start trusting the monastery again, for the betterment of everyone involved, might be borderline impossible.

David

She said "cannot" not "will not"

BIGLARGEFISH

Saying you really shouldn’t have asked is pretty not cool regardless of cannot or will not.

Veridescent

Yeah a master who feels a need to support with what they do know and to go above to give aid to another member of their in-group whose circumstances may differ a bit to them is important for working with how wide the Dao is. Because the Daos both all pervading and intertwined unexpected synergisms, stacking, and intermingling may happen for cultivation methodologies, tools, etc. But I do still feel the filial framework is extremely flawed and brittle for such issues, its mainly a strategy defined by scarcity in cultivators and ignorance(with that scarcity frankly stemming from that ignorance of methods of cultivation). I honestly think the same "extended family" type identity mediating interactions and attachment idea can very still be worked. It can just be applied much more holistically socialized cultural identity and thus allowing a spectrum of "anyone being your teacher". Frankly whats likely needed is a better ethical framework for agreements between a master and student for the given acceptable boundaries of behavior the master would like as well as more equitable ways to help everyone involved when aspects are beyond the ken of the given Masters experiences even if they have some insight. In a somewhat similar vein, centralization is always focused around speed of decision making. I do kind of think, decentralized practices like gourmet, the calisthenics, etc having institutions similar to the Pure Lands Monastery and Beggars Guild have secure if maybe a bit unofficial ties to the Monastery and tying that to other related Sects also provided better information would be a better pattern than trying to simply focus on the Kingdom. The Kingdom frankly isn't good enough to be the centralized filter through which they can receive more cultivator prospects. What they need is a robust method of sharing information and refining methodologies and shuttling that growing knowledge base to all relevant actors to better make specifically the opportunity cost of Orthodox cultivation lower. The aspects of socialization and education would then make them the area for people to eventually to go to, from inculturated affiliation and some aspect of Hegemony in further education due to the Mountain still being the prime area of cultivation resources. Basically if you can tie that pattern of filial piety as its nominally supposed to be, systematically to the Monastery, so they are considered integrated patrons, you can garner loyalty, affiliation and a flow of talents despite the inefficiencies in figuring out what the best methods may be for each cultivator. And as a plus it may more tightly bind other sects to them through cooperation while also providing capacity to refine the Monasteries own methodologies. This quite relatedly also aligns rather well to what has to be done on some level to stamp out clan politics. Two things must be achieved with a third thing as a interwoven corollary. There must be a universalized level of service provision to the people who make up the powerbases and enforcers of the Clans, and thus more generally the people. Thus the Legitimacy of the clans would be stymied, while the affiliation tied to those services would grow. A greater socialized culture must be a part of that service provision such that loyalty to the clan is less advantageous and less of a concept than loyalty to the affiliated organizations. Or state if we really want the Kingdom and it can manage it; it hasn't so I am doubtful of its capability. The third thing ties into administration, the given admnistrators and bureaucrats must be systematically both protected, held to standards in that protection that both bind and define their boundaries of behavior, and supplied well such that they can do their job and ignore attempted blowback from the clans when they feel their powerbases are threatened. The Kingdom started a bit of this, but has as noted with Hanshen failed to do it fully as it is too weak to not appease the clans with a scapegoat. Education and Socialization are some of the most powerful levers one has for behaviors. Only big issue is maintaining a uniform consequence for behavior. There is a question of what better frameworks of shame and non-invasive uses of Qi could be used for managing consequences(rather than simply punishments or death). Such may be a element of better developing early shen integration, but cultural resistance is a big factor here still. As a positive at least, it seems as one goes further into the imperfect human realm one must at least somewhat introspect on identity and this givens levers of care for enforcing ethics. Of course if the Sect cannot truly change its internal values, reform will fail, and simply be devoured and coopted. And in such case the Sect is simply doomed for not being good enough to change, wasnt inevitable in such a case though.

FoolRegnant

I guess I hadn't really thought about it, but are those outside the barrier still considered to be part of the Monastery?

Veridescent

Morals are socially defined and weighted, so its a mixed question of socialized labels and logistics.

Teach

Interesting question, it doesn’t appear Liren has thought about it either

Teach

Plenty of non-sect existences on the mountain. Tian isn’t in the kiddy pond any more, he’s in with the big frogs. And also, starving streetrat is gonna horde. He’s got trama

Lochar

Because he was born in the dump where anything and everything was liable to be snatched away at any moment and he's barely gotten to the point where he can start healing those scars. Liren is his dao companion and he's learned what that means to him. This was him testing what should have been the next level of trust that absolutely should have reinforced him being willing to share out.

Chad L.

Tian is going to wind up providing the inspiration for her to advance. Ally acquired. Sneaky grandpa.

João Vene

Having to enforce the rule means there is a need for it, and this arc is all about Tian and Liren applying to the 'real' Monastery the lessons they learned in the Monastery that actually exists in the outside world. Is there a real chance Cruel Treachery and the people inside the mountain barrier will steal the loot? No, not really. But it's also certain that if Tian was careless with his loot for even a second around people like the Longs, they'd steal everything they could. If they had even a whiff of the statue refining his body, they'd try to crack his soul to get it out of his dantian. The whole tension is that Tian and Liren can't separate the two monasteries, while for the super isolated elders like CT, the inner court and the Longs aren't really part of the Monastery at all. They're servants at best. (I don't know if she would call inner disciples as servant disciples, but that's essentially how the monastery treated them. They're not part of the family)

Jacob

“And you shouldn’t have asked” makes me think she’s saying it’s inappropriate? Like if she’s unable to help that’s something he could not have known. Is it about her feeling “rejected”?

Jeryd Greer

Interesting. Warby, this little sentence being here is serving well in this format of I most wait until tomorrow, but is reminding me of how often i personally do it to end chapters of my writing and makes me sure that its best in whole book releases because it’s a gut punch to wait through.

Jeryd Greer

Yes! Chrysos au is in fact a right bastard for not sharing their secrets with us.

Jeryd Greer

I wish to fly and shoot eye lazers

Jeryd Greer

Except for all the seniors he knows in the hospital betrayed sect siblings for their perceived treasures.

Tadas

It would be interesting if Earth's Milk or the Statue is exactly the type of treasure she needs to fix her foundations. The drama! The decisions! Statue probably more likely than Earth's Milk - it seems rare but not impossible to acquire in thousands of years while statue is all about balance and might be unique.

Michael

> mash ‘em, boil ‘em, put them in a stew PO-TAY-TOES

Baconwargod

Damn first time gramps has been wrong it seems that’s cool in its own way and sets up the old man isn’t functionally omniscient in his understanding of the people around Tian. Just a very very very old hand at reading people that’s right most of the time.

vorpal

I know this isn't the first time we've talked about how awful the general inner court is, but this chapter really puts it into context. You break through to 2000 glorious years of life and then, unless you're one of the lucky ones, your fate is to spend all that immortal time watching the sect invest in your betters instead of you, while you have to fight over table scraps. No wonder so many of them went, very charitably, off the rails. I do hope we get Lin's perspective on these changes at some point.

Zephyr

@Jeryd Greer But that is always peers betraying each other (heavenly vs heavenly). Not seniors suppressing juniors. It's a big difference. Earlier in the series they made a whole thing about how filial piety is a two-way street in this regard.

CastorInvictus

I imagine the reason Teacher Treachery cannot help is related to whatever is wrong with her cultivation. And whatever that is may be a hint towards the origins of her honor name.

erfan ashkan

My theory is that cruel trechery let some one down once and thus doesnt trust herself to do what Tian asks

Venerable Ro

You know, I'm having a funny thought here. Starsieve committed suicide over a perceived failure to live up to his moral/ethical obligations. "Dognose" was extremely restive and dissatisfied over being burdened with his obligations to an unappreciated position. Treachery is bottlenecked and cultivating an Art that emphasizes personal freedom at the bottom of a narrow enclosed canyon. Every cultivator we've seen practicing the Skytreading Art has been afflicted with issues apparently stemming from a perceived lack of personal agency, and they've all held deeply traditional views of institutional fealty. What if that's the issue right there? What if the Skytreading Art, handed down by a wandering Immortal Crane, is fundamentally incompatible with a rooted sedentary life? The scripture that accompanies the Art emphasizes the divestment of burdens, yet the masters we've seen attempting to cultivate said art have all assumed significant personal obligations. Obligations that have severely impaired their lives. Wouldn't that be funny? Wouldn't that be just the sublime height of irony? The dynastic core Art practiced by the sect's leadership might be conceptually opposed to the traditional obligations of an orthodox sect, they might be deviating and stalling expressly because they're not "free" to wander off and go do whatever they like. And now perhaps Tien accidently cripple his "Master's" cultivation because he's forced her into a situation where what she wants to do is at total odds with what she needs or can do. A bird with a broken wing trying to fly?

Veridescent

Its pretty classical to a lot of the reasons for corruption in chinese dynasties honestly. A lot of clan influence stemmed from simplifying things a bit, a lack of wages to actually cultivate the ability for beaucrats to police them. It seems fairly relevant for the sect given how the Longs developed themselves

NoAriGuy

Thats an increadibly insightful theory honestly, and one thats makes perfect sence in world too.

Kain

I know I’m biased but for real I think I trust Gramps’s opinion on her condition more than her. He totally could have missed something but it would be very funny if the reason she can’t help out here, and also can’t advance, is just some fundamental misunderstanding on her part that Gramps hasn’t even considered because he thinks it too trivial or unrealistic.

Merlin King

Oh that’s a solid theory. A cruel treachery on *her* part, and a constant reminder. She’s defined herself against it

frenchfryguy2012 .

Yeah, I am excited for them to hopefully “cultivate” their master disciple relationship. He put himself up first and told his secret. Now will she tell him hers( what she can anyway, his low cultivation does mean she can’t tell him everything for multiple reasons, mind reading, harm his dao, etc …

LordMars

This is a really great theory.

CastorInvictus

Agreed. It seems to me the behavior of the elders hasn't demonstrated confidence. If they believe in their own wisdom and the value of their teaching then surely the best, most Daoist answer to doubting disciples is to show them the way bit by bit and let them come around in their own time. But it's very believable and very human that people used to being venerated for hundreds or thousands of years would feel entitled to it. But the best way to learn something is to teach it, and if they're going to teach Tian the dao they're going to learn in return. I look forward to seeing how he helps resolve their heart demons

G&S Gaming

@Robert Mullins Yes, yes I am. I could totally shoot lasers from my eyes and fly, but I'm not made of steel or faster than a speeding bullet, so I'm kinda worried they would catch me, see?

Beelzy

Did this chapter get misnamed? I'm not seeing a chapter 11.