The Stone is Waiting for God. The Stone is Waiting for You. (Patreon)
Content
Look at the picture. No context. Just look at it. Does it make you feel something? Does it make you think of something? Even if it doesn’t, note it down. Whatever your reaction to this picture is, take a moment and note it down. I’ve done that, earlier today, and I have been trying to figure out what this picture means ever since.
Put the note to one side. We will come back to it in a little while.
This is a post about how we, or I, at least, experience art, and the pleasant dangers of meaning. It’s also about how I spend my writing breaks and a glimpse into the grab bag of associations that is my brain, so. You know. Lasciate ogne speranza, voi ch’intrate.
Yukio Mishima likened words to black insects, a sort of vermin infestation that interfered with truly experiencing the world. He included the interior of our minds in this - he was devoted to physical exercise in part because if you exert yourself enough, there is a moment of ecstatic selflessness where the distinction between you and the world vanishes and you simply are, with no words or thoughts to complicate this enormous sense of being and belonging.
That is one way to approach visual arts. The piece speaks for itself, without words, and should be felt, rather than understood with words. Words are external, a foreign creation. Worse are the words of other people telling you what it means. What others bring to the art piece is no more than empty opinion, and is not the thing itself.
The creator could tell you what it means… or not. They might be silent on the subject. What its creator intended, they hopefully achieved in the piece. If not, the interpretation is now out of their hands. This, incidentally, is the so-called “death of the author,” and a prime example of specialist, technical language reaching the general public and being misunderstood. Which is ironic.
So what can we make of this picture, isolated from any context? Not much, I think, but you may find something I missed. I'm a devil for context. I won’t walk you through an analysis of the component pieces (yet), but it does raise an interesting sub-question of whether the subject matter of the paintings on the walls should be considered, or even established, if we are adopting a strict “the picture speaks for itself” analytical frame. But let’s ignore the question. It’s a trap, you see.
I have, like a stage magician, only presented the illusion of choice. I have forced you to pick a card marked “picture,” distracting you with all this talk of context free analysis. What you see above is a picture I took, and what it is a picture of is an art installation.
Now. Can an installation piece exist free of context? Can it speak entirely for itself? Perhaps, but I believe it cannot when the location of the installation is a vital part of the artwork as a whole. Pictured is a subset of the art installation called Relatum by Korean artist Lee Ufan. This particular piece is called, simply, Relatum - Stone. The installation is in the Chapel of St. Martial, in the Palace of the Popes in Avignon, France.
We now have several points that could use examination and yet more context, if available. For example, the artist, Lee Ufan. Who is he? Why was he selected? Is it relevant that he names all his art installations Relatum? I don’t know. I hadn’t heard of him before today, and still know practically nothing about him. I do know, thanks to a documentary video that is part of the installation, that he turned ninety while making it, (the installation itself consists of several parts covering a number of rooms in the palace, and all together could easily fill half a football pitch), and he wanted to force people to reconnect to nature. To connect the ephemeral to the eternal.
Then we have the chapel. All those murals depict (with captions in Latin, though you can’t really see it in the picture) a visual hagiography of St. Martial. St. Martial, per the pictures, was divinely inspired to convert Gaul to Christendom. One of the pictures shows the saint-to-be receiving the pastoral staff from St. Peter, and if that isn’t an on-the-nose bit of artwork for a captive French-ish Papacy in exile, I don’t know what is.
Taking a step back, we have to consider the significance of the chapel itself. It is a place of private prayer and reflection for the seven Avignon popes (and later, others), attached to their private quarters. It is a place of direct communion between man and god. Which is a bit interesting in a Catholic context, but it is, again, the Pope’s personal chapel.
The chapel is in rough shape. The murals are damaged. Does the history of the palace have significance here? It was converted into an army barracks and a prison at various points. There was an infamous massacre in the cells beneath the palace. There was a lead smelting operation in the chapel below this one (this is the second floor of a tower), which damaged the whole section of the palace. Is that significant to the art piece? Knowing that now, has the picture changed for you?
Then we have the stone. I couldn’t find any information about the stone, its origins, or its composition. It simply is. It has appeared in its present, apparently unworked, form in the middle of the Chapel St. Martial in the Palace of the Popes in Avignon, France. Placed there by a geriatric Korean gentleman and his many youthful assistants.
The absence of context for the stone forces us to use our imagination, and thanks to all the information we now have about the setting, the chapel, the palace, we have many germs of inspiration. Does the shape of the stone have significance? It looks a little like an egg. That’s an easy metaphor wherever it is located in the world. Or what about the fact that it is a stone? There is a visual pun, here, and it has layers.
“And I say also unto thee, That thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build my church; and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it." Matthew 16:18 in the KJV, for those playing at home. The Catholic interpretation of that passage, historically, was the confirmation of Peter as the inheritor of Christ’s mission on earth, and the moment when he received the Keys to the Kingdom. It is a cornerstone, literally, of the doctrine of Apostolic Succession. We then have a Protestant interpretation; that what Jesus is responding to is Peter’s preceding confession that Jesus is the messiah, the son of the living God. Korean Christians are predominantly Protestant, and Evangelical. So we have to choose- is the correct interpretation to view the stone in the context of the room, which is the ne plus ultra of Catholicism, or the context of the artist?
There is a third layer to the pun- What if Jesus referred to himself as the Messiah and Son of God, contrasting that divine immensity with the pebble before him? Because Peter, in Greek, is Petros. Stone. It is Jesus’ divine nature that is the bedrock, not the dross of the earthly realm. The dross formed from his mortal mother, or the dross that is Peter- both are flawed, and transitory. Only the heavenly is eternal and perfect, in this context.
“Heavenly” is another term to carefully consider. The hellenized Jews of the era, which Paul in particular very much was, as were other apostles, would have some familiarity with Plato’s philosophy even if they hadn’t read it. It’s a picture in two parts, isn’t it? The dualism, the perfect world of thought and souls above and the imperfect material world below. We look back at the picture and more and more contextual lines get drawn, more suppositions are made, more thoughts, inspirations, emotions emerge. Meanings pile up, though not certainty.
Plato is really inescapable here. We could take the stone as a metaphor for the Monad, emanating the chapel. The stone structure endures, damaged and flawed, and our thin veneer of understanding, the suffering of mortal life, is peeling paintwork on the walls. Wearing away and showing a glimpse of what is real beneath. That human emanation, imperfect and transitory as it is, only exists because of that original thought, that primordial holy impulse that is “Stone.” Which leads us to the Logos.
“In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.” John 1:1, KJV, but we must move past Erasmus’s legendary work and look at the original Greek yet again. Logos. God is Logos, a divine thought, a divine word. Before “Fiat Lux,” the Word existed. Meaning existed. Before the creation of heaven and earth (a bit of dualism that, by most scholarly assessments, entered Genesis centuries before Plato) was the word and meaning. They weren’t an impediment to the experience of existence, they were vital to it. Divine thought, exemplified by the saint’s life in the murals, brought forth the stone, which in and of itself is representative of the animating emanation from the Monad which gave rise to the chapel the murals are painted on.
Following this thread of analysis, ignoring the implicit rebuke to Mishima, we come across a new challenge to our analytical frame. We talked so much about what the ceiling, murals, chapel, and stone mean, or mean in relation to each other, but really, they are a single, unified installation. We have to look at the piece as a whole for meaning, not its component parts. Which suddenly feels a bit Daoist.
The scene could come straight from Zhuangzi- Confucius and Mencius look around the room and lament the collapse of ritual, the collapse of the filial bonds between shepherd and flock, and wisely tell each other the collapse of the Papacy’s secular power (which was already on the decline from its 12th century peak when the palace was built) can be plainly seen in the crumbling murals and stray rocks on the floor. Meanwhile, Lao Tzu is sprawled on a mat on the floor, shaking his head and pointing at the stone. He doesn’t bother to say anything, since they can’t hear his meaning, but if they could, surely they would hear him yelling “How much clearer do you need it to be? All the mortal wealth and suffering, glory and shame, is washed away by time. Nature, the Great Dao, remains.”
If I recall correctly, it was Zhuangzi who gave us the metaphor of the uncarved block and taught the vital utility of an empty bowl. What could be a purer demonstration of that principle? All that was forced into an unnatural condition has become damaged or decayed, and even when new, it only gestured at a reality. The stone is itself, unaffected and unadorned, and it has weathered the centuries without the slightest harm.
Nature, of course, leads us back to the ancient Korean artist who made the installation. A man old enough to be picking out doormats for his residence in the hereafter, he would have opinions on this matter. He wanted to reconnect humans to nature, to demonstrate and juxtapose the ephemeral and the eternal. The uncarved stone is an obvious proxy for an eternal Nature (note the capital), taken in the same sense as Spinoza meant it - God.
Jefferson, Locke, and half of the Enlightenment were tromping right behind Spinoza, glossing it with terms like “Nature’s God” or “Natural Law” and other fudges worthy of their hypocrisy. They meant God as an emanator of a divine order, one which was hidden and confused by power hungry clerics. For example, picking an example entirely at random, the Avignon popes who would stand at the window overlooking a corner of their courtyard and offer indulgences to the crowd below.
But the power of the stone to shock is in its unnatural, artificial, placement. Nature has intruded on a place it was explicitly banished from. (Cue Protestant coughing.) Like us, it is a modern visitor in the Pope’s once private quarters.
Lest you think I am putting too much on the stone, anthropomorphising it too much, even deifying it, recall the name of the piece: Relatum - Stone. It is the stone we are meant to relate to, not the chapel. We are meant to relate to the stone in its context, taking it where and how we find it… If we are to give the artist’s intention any consideration, which is still in doubt. After all, the piece speaks for itself, doesn’t it? It’s not like there is a sign explaining what it means anywhere. I checked.
So after all that, what does it mean?
Hell if I know.
But I can tell you what it made me feel.
I saw the stone in the chapel, and I had the sense that it was looking up. You can’t see the ceiling in this picture, but it’s more than ten meters up, north of thirty feet, easily. I had the feeling the stone was looking up with a sense of expectation. Then I had a feeling that, actually, the stone was facing outwards, looking out at the people peering through the glass at it. Then the words caught up with the emotions.
The Stone is waiting for God. The Stone is waiting for you.
I’ve spent the last nine hours going around and around on this, walking through modern art museums, enjoying the rain in a medieval city center, talking tea and teaware in a shop I stumbled on as I wandered without a map. Learning that the owners there knew a man I buy tea from, back when he still lived in France and not up a mountain in the jungles on the border of Laos and Yunnan. I have a half-dozen scribbled pages in my notebook picking through my thoughts about the installation, teasing it apart over mushroom risotto and crispy batons of panisse dipped in tomato marmalade. Trying to figure out what those two sentences mean.
All that “meaning” I’ve piled up isn’t what will stick with me. It was the lived experience, the shock of seeing it, and the rushing in of words to capture the feeling, and the sensation of worrying at the feeling with my tools of words, trying to find the core of it and never quite capturing it better than that instant, thoughtless reaction.
The installation closes in ten days or so. Later visitors won’t have the same encounter there I did. If I saw it yesterday, or a year ago, I might not have had the same encounter. I would have been a different person, one who wasn’t ready for it. I won’t go back and see it tomorrow. It’s said it’s piece to me.
Look at the note you wrote before. Does the picture still provoke that feeling in you? Do you find the same meaning in it? Does it still leave you cold? Did I waste my time, or did I spend my brief life wisely? Dear reader, does the search for meaning get in the way of living, or is it the only way to live?