Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

AOT SEASON 4- Crunchyroll vs. Blu-ray

  • Crunchyroll: Attack on Titan Season 4 140
  • Blu-ray: Attack on Titan Season 4 342
  • 2022-10-14
  • 482 votes
{'title': 'AOT SEASON 4- Crunchyroll vs. Blu-ray', 'choices': [{'text': 'Crunchyroll: Attack on Titan Season 4', 'votes': 140}, {'text': 'Blu-ray: Attack on Titan Season 4', 'votes': 342}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2022, 10, 14, 18, 24, 41, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 482}

Content

hey everyone! ^-^

we are getting very close to the end of AoT season 3… So how should we watch Season 4?

Comments

Cubjitsu

I’ve only ever seen it on crunchyroll, but If the blu ray subtitles are the same then go for it! Also there’s a few end credit scenes throughout the season, all of which you have to watch.

Benjamin Yee

Barring a 5 second sequence in one episode where 2 shots were accidentally displayed in the wrong order, the Blu-ray is on the whole the superior version.

Shulman

Blu-Ray, no contest. It's just a straight upgrade.

Jonathan

I've seen a few videos comparing the two, and I definitely think the blu-rays look better. Lots of little details that come off looking better. Plus they fixed a few inconsistencies, like a character's hairstyle that should have been different given the time that the scene occurred, etc.

Phthalo

If you’re going to watch the blu-ray, make sure to find a version with the Crunchyroll subtitles. As the others you might find, such as the Damedesuyo subs several blu-ray releases use can have very abridged translations that won’t match what you’ve seen on Crunchyroll. I would say having proper subs is vastly superior to the visual upgrades the blu-ray offers, but of course, both would be ideal.

Xavii MAncero MosquerA

Blu Ray 100%! If you really wanna enjoy the new animation studio, them Blu ray. But it's true what one said, make sure the subs are the correct ones!

Josh Ashford

I say whichever version has the best subs lol, I watched on crunchyroll but as long as the blu ray subs are good then go for it I say

LordFifth

Blu-Ray, but make sure to get the Crunchyroll subtitles, a lot of fan subs are very abridged and of poor quality, and it will affect the enjoyment a lot

Sean Carroll

Blu ray looks better but the subtitles are very inaccurate

Ace of Spadez

It's a must to go with the blu-ray no debate, and not only for season 4 but for the whole series.

Corey Hughes

How would one even use Blu-ray with different subtitles? Is that possible?

Ace of Spadez

Not sure if you guys are aware, there was a studio change for AOT season 4, it's animated by Mappa. Same studio as Jujutsu Kaisen and Chainsaw Man!

Ace of Spadez

One thing I want to point out, Season 4 has been released on Bluray with every episode so far in Japan, here in America we only have the bluray version up until season 4 part 1. Although for part 2 I'm sure you can find online the Japanese bluray verson with official English subs.

PST3

the English subtitles on the blue ray weren't that good

trouty42

I don't get it, I've watched everything on Crunchyroll and was perfectly happy. Now I'm seeing people warning about bad subtitles on the blue ray and you have to stress about making sure to get the right subtitles? This just feels like a huge hassle for a tiny upgrade in visual experience. I don't think people take into account what reaction creators have to do to make their videos. I don't know what B & A's setup is but I'm betting they're either watching it on a computer monitor or a smaller gaming monitor. It's easy for the average person to just slip in a blue ray dvd and start watching on a huge 4K TV without worrying about lighting, if everything is recording and the sound is good. End of the day if it's easy for them to accommodate blue ray and they're willing to buy it and all that then that's great. I just feel like us as watchers make them feel like they have to jump through hoops for us when I'm just happy they're reacting. I don't need special requests.

Jason Parker

Just watch on crunchy roll. It's still great and it will be easier for us that watch full length reactions

Musab imran

Honestly I voted blue Ray but I should’ve voted crunchy roll. The subtitles are very strange on the blue Ray

Black Inferno

blu ray translations are worse by far

pink

worse animation is much better than worse subtitles in my opinion

Narwhalw7

To me the bluray visual changes are not much of an improvement, and in some cases i think it looks worse, especially some character faces.

Adam Adamowicz

I'm so glad about the poll results - yes, the visual upgrate is massive and SO WORTH IT! Subtitles are perfectly fine on blu-ray as well. I'd love to hear some specific complaints, they're basically the exact same translation that was used for the original.

Painfoot

Blu ray is better for part 1 worse for part 2

Epsilox

I would probably recommend sticking with Crunchyroll since those are the subs you've been using so far and it will keep it more consistent for you, especially since that's probably what we'll all be using when part 3 comes out. The blue-ray visual upgrades are really nice though. I'll enjoy watching with you no matter which one you choose.

Darby

Blu Ray would be more difficult to line up full length reactions vs. Crunchyroll.

Ego Jinpachi

I haven't seen the bluray version, but if it has different scenes, subtitles, or sync discrepancies, then I rather watch the original version as we all did as viewers our first time, that would be the genuine journey after all.

Ego Jinpachi

And guys... if their first time is bluray then they won't notice what are the improvements in quality since they have nothing to compare it to, it comes obvious to you having watched the og version, but they are going in blind, remember that.

Asteroidea

Okay so on the subject of the subtitles, I was a little confused because I didn't remember there being a big thing about them being 'bad' when the Blu-rays got released and I couldn't really find any discussion of it online. I've seen both and I couldn't remember noticing a difference. In the interests of SCIENCE, I actually went back and watched both first episodes side-by-side to check. It's a different translation for sure, but there's really not a whole lot in it, quality-wise. From my beginner Japanese language perspective I think the Crunchyroll subs are slightly more literal and the Blu-ray subs are a bit more interpretive? I noticed the latter swapped out a couple of Japanese idioms for more recognisable English equivalents, which I think is a good thing, but also had a couple of instances of colloquialisms/slang being used by characters where it seemed a little bit odd. The difference is super marginal and entirely stylistic though; there's effectively no difference in the content of the dialogue, and I didn't notice anything that seemed like a mistranslation. I'm pretty confident that holds true throughout the entire thing too, otherwise there would be legions of folk online kicking up a fuss about it. I also didn't have any sync issues with running the first episode side-by-side - they DID slightly change the timing of certain cuts, but I don't think they did anything at all to the audio track for the remaster, so episodes maintain the same start and finish time and people watching full-length on Crunchyroll won't end up lost on full-length Blu-ray reactions or vice versa. TLDR: Blu-ray subtitles are different but perfectly fine (IMO) and people watching full-length Blu-ray reactions can still follow along on Crunchyroll. I'd absolutely go for the Blu-ray. They really did make a lot of big improvements to lighting and fixing off-model stuff, particularly early on in 4Pt1.

KOOAH

I like how the latest comment is still getting lots of likes because people keep checking to see if the new episode is up

Yo

BLU RAY BROS

trouty42

GG blue ray stans