Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Just closed the first fan art poll and after some slight shenanigans, Nami is your winner. I will try to have a picture of her drawn within the next few weeks. Already got a decent idea to start from. Thank you to everyone who participated!

Now, because I was keeping a curious eye on it, I did notice her victory was decided by a couple people changing their votes a few days in. Marin was the frontrunner by two votes once the final number of votes had been cast (11), but then over the next couple days, one Marin vote changed to Nami, tying them up, and then a Jiro vote also changed to Nami to give her the lead by one vote. There's nothing I can do to prevent that and I'm not really upset by it, but I do worry slightly about attempts to game the system in the future, or people who had voted for the character in last place changing it once they saw they were gonna lose. Just a bit less pure.

So, change going forward, polls will be open for just 2 days, rather than a full week. Frankly, there are less than 20 of y'all that can vote and this time we reached the final vote count by the second day. So this will just leave less dead air and chances for people to reconsider their choice. And let me just ask, if a poll ends in a tie would you rather I just pick one as the winner, or put it to a quick ~12-24 hour runoff poll? I'm not gonna make it so that a tie means both get drawn, cuz that just incentivizes y'all to make it end in a tie.

Comments

Bryson Castle

My vote would be towards runoff poll. As someone whose first choice doesn't often win polls, I'm very guilty of vote swapping to my 2nd favorite. If we're doing scout's honor and discouraging vote swaps, I'd at least appreciate the opportunity to vote switch honorably in a tiebreaker.

Chris Kornfeld

I’ll second a vote for a runoff. Sometimes I’ll have a very hard time deciding how to vote on a poll. A second one where a tie resulted will be handy for everyone.