Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 784702656.mp4

Downloads

Content

no spoilers in comments pls :)

** previous season access will be available on the archive (some videos may be hosted here as opposed to the offsite archive) if your tier allows.

Files

Comments

Mrs O

I love episodes that have real history to it and I also think it was and still is my favourite

Siobhan Linehan

Ok, this episode is VERY controversial. Some people adore it and others think it's problematic. Unfortunately I'm more to the problematic side of things simply because it doesn't portray the history of the situation correctly. The episode portrays Rosa Parks as the person who's there to single handedly save the black community. When in reality she was one woman in a large movement that planned the bus boycott, her one act of saying no did not change history so it makes no sense that the episode tried to portray her not moving to the back of the bus as THE moment that changed everything when it wasn't at all. It's definitely the iconic moment that people talk about so I get what they were trying to do, but there was SO much more to it than that one moment. It was actually a woman called Claudette Colvin who was the first black woman in the movement to refuse to give up her seat but she was a teen mum so they thought that Rosa would be a more acceptable face for the movement. There were also several other black women who refused to give up their seats before Rosa did. So yeah the logic of The Doctor putting that one moment of Rosa refusing to give up her seat making everything right again doesn't actually work. The next problem is that they literally had The Doctor, who's currently in the form of a white woman, being behind getting Rosa where she needed to be and that's something A LOT of people had a problem with. The writers basically made it so this significant moment in black American history actually only happened because of a white British person, so I can see why that pissed people off. And then there's Ryan. He said "I don't think the FBI know any black guys." But the FBI frequently used black spies to infiltrate Civil rights movements and literally killed civil rights leaders with the help of Black spies. And also how did Ryan know SO little about Rosa? Not only is Rosa Park's story taught in every British high school, but Graham talks about how Grace loved Rosa Parks. Graham said she brought up Rosa Parks as soon as she knew Graham was a bus driver but yet she didn’t teach her own grandson anything? That seemed weird to me. I hope you don't think I'm being a moaner or anything. I just feel these are important points that a show like this should be getting right. And I love this Doctor and this team, I'm a huge defender of this era of the show, but yeah this episode just has too many issues for me to be able to enjoy it. 💔