Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hail to the NeRBs!

It is CLOCKTOWER WEEK here at No Rolls Barred and we are kicking off the festivities with your monthly Zoom game for the $6.50 tier. Ben and I did something a bit wild in this one!

The script for this episode is Trouble Brewing on Expert Mode, see it here: https://www.botcscripts.com/script/284/1.0.0

Hope you enjoy the episode, and remember that the in-person Patreon episode is coming this Saturday (25th) for our $11.50 backers.

Enjoy!

Laurie x

Files

A Tale of Two Imps | Patreon Exclusive Blood on the Clocktower

Check out the script for this episode 👉 https://www.botcscripts.com/script/284/1.0.0 Set sail with us on the NRB Cruise with live shows, gaming sessions and more on board! | Feb 15th-21st 2026 | Secure your cabin with a deposit today | Email nrbcruise@vacationeer.com for more info or visit https://norollsbarred.com/event-sign-up/oasis-of-the-seas/ 🎲 For BONUS Board Game Club and Blood on the Clocktower episodes, check out our Patreon 👉 https://www.patreon.com/NoRollsBarred 🎲 Subscribe to our RPG channel: Chaotic Neutral https://www.youtube.com/@ChaoticNRB Our gorgeous board game table was custom built by GeekNSon. Check out their store using our affiliate link and get a FREE Dice Tower with each purchase of a table: https://bit.ly/NoRollsBarredXGeeknson_online_store_sm Follow No Rolls Barred: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/norollsbarred/ Twitter: https://twitter.com/NoRollsBarred_ #BoardGames #Tabletop #LetsPlay Youtube Channel Comments Policy We appreciate the comments and opinions our viewers provide. Do note that all comments are subject to YouTube auto-moderation and manual moderation review. We encourage opinions and discussion, but harassment, hate speech, bullying and other abusive posts will not be tolerated. Decisions on comment removal are made by the Community Manager. Please email us at support@wrestletalk.com with any questions or concerns.

Comments

ItzSmashley

So excited there's a lot of clocktower available at the moment and I love it! Can't wait for the in person games 2 :D

Nils Beckmann

Wow! I recently discovered Arif's BotC Youtube channel and really enjoy him as a storyteller 🥳

Mazzis

Yippee!!How are there 3 outsiders in an 11 player game... with no baron? Apologies if this is answered in the video, I have to wait till tomorrow to properly watch

Josh Mc

Holly is the virgin...... Poor tempest

Electric Ninja

Yeah I was just wondering this too lol

Ryan Winwood

Yep, they do address it in the video, about 34 minutes in.

Ryan Winwood

Genuinely one of the best BOTC games I can remember watching. Which is impressive when you consider every character is technically just a basic TB character. Just shows the importance of a good script for context, and a skilled Storyteller to keep it all moving.

John

Going door to door and asking people what/if they saw something is called "canvassing" in the United States.

Sam G.

12 minutes in, feels really unbalanced to have a Spy who knows the grim but also essentially is poisoning two townsfolk

Sam G.

Actually, nevermind

Sam G.

I wish the evil team had been Sullivan, Tilly and Dom for this game.

Brittany

(Don't read past this if you don't want spoilers) ------ I was so frustrated when Sullivan said after talking with Liv from the get go, that he would protect her the whole time because Fortune Teller was the best role to keep alive. Then next day, just protects Mara instead randomly, thus leaving Arif open to kill Liv. RIP.

Cyan Droplet

I love how Ken and Arif suggested true worlds to the good team! I'm wondering if it would be possible to register the spy as good at game setup and have a spy in an actual atheist game? Maybe with the recluse registering as demon to them or with a poppy grower on the script? Although I have no idea how the spy would win in that situation...

Harbinger5

In a game where an experienced and intelligent group of players could not identify the cause for 2 demons, and one with an outsider error, the outcome felt predictable. So much so that Arif could explain the weird 2 demon thing and it made one iota of difference. It was good seeing everyone have fun but the outcome was predicable.

David Hayter

Amazing game, probably a bit too hard for the good players, but the wildness of the scenario got everyone talking and playing hard. Well except Tilly, but I think Tilly was happy to chill.

Bobby J

Felt a bit IMPossible for the good team - especially since all the most seasoned players were on evils side. But ah well was still fun to see

mod prime

It wouldn't surprise me if Sully got confused between the DA rule of not being able to protect the same player on consecutive nights and the Monk who can't protect themselves; and for a moment thought he had to change who he was protecting.

Ryan Winwood

I'm not an expert so might be wrong, but the Atheist says to remove all evil player tokens, so in this case, they'd still have to remove the spy because the token is still evil. They might register as good to other players, but not to the Storytellers, who are the ones responsible for removing said tokens.

Brittany

Possible, yeah. Still fun to watch though and love the cast, but why Sully, whhhhhy, lol.

Anonymous Geoff

Oooohhhff... That's a tricky setup! Good game, really enjoyed it. It is a shame for BotC in general that sometimes Good players can get sidelined in relatively passive roles, though often I suppose they may enjoy sitting back and watching the chaos.

Kyle King

Absolutely loved this script I love complicated head scratching games more of this plz

Kyle King

Correct ….. they would have to remove it …. However if they wanted to the story tellers could wake up the player on night 2 or some thing and change their character, for instance, if Marinette was on the script. Ben could say the pithag has turned you into the spy ( you don’t get an alignment change but will probably be thinking they neighbor a demon or recluse) could throw a pop grower in there just for fun or give some one the lunitic ability and tell them they have a marionette but because of the pop grower, they don’t know who it is. Then make up the pithag thing …… atheist scripts make things really interesting.

Cyan Droplet

Thanks for the replies! I think you are right, these kinds of characters shouldn't be able to register as something else for setup purposes, otherwise you could build a bag without a demon if you have a recluse or have a spy instead of a townsfolk, that would probably break the game!

Ryan Winwood

There's actually two potentially equally entertaining options with a Good Spy in an Atheist game. You either show them the real Grim so they know it's an Atheist game, but gaslight them into thinking they're Poisoned/Drunk. Or make them actually Poisoned/Drunk and show them a fake Grim filled with all sorts of nonsense.

Marty

Ben you truly are the best great script. These players are so smart and cunning that it is important to throw crazy scripts their way to keep them on their toes. Great job to everyone 👏

Kaetê

Absolute cinema

Daniel Ault

Is this where I find Arif’s podcast?

Jellythorpe

This is one of the most fun games I've seen in a while! Love that even though it was helping the good team, Ken Mara & Arif still gave them the pieces to solve the puzzle - which I think kept it balanced

Nexus Tenebrare

Didn't like this. To me someone 'registering' as something means they appear as if they were that thing. Not that they actually become that thing. Tilly's death shouldn't have activated Mara Joy's ability.

Spikey123

Can you explain why not, I don't quite understand the argument there. If something appears as if that thing to another role, that role proceeds on the basis they are that thing, even if there not, no?

Edith

Yeah I agree!

Lee Dellbridge

Sorry but that was the worst game I've seen on the channel. No way Scarlet Woman should become "the" demon because there was a demon already. If it said becomes "a demon" fair enough. It gave Evil the automatic win basically and good games don't do that. A rare miss from Ben.

Lee Dellbridge

But the Scarlet Woman's ability is they become the demon, not a demon. We already had the demon. The recluse should register as a demon for a slayer for example but turning a SW is in my opinion wrong. Plus good has to kill both demons? Unfair too.

Lee Dellbridge

See you loved it and that's great! For me it's the worst game I've ever seen on here. Unbalanced and unfair to good.

HalfPriceHero01

I disagree with your take on the Scarlet Woman's ability. The game's glossary defines "registering as x" as the mechanical rules of abilities treating you as if you are the thing you are registering as in every way - since the Slayer's ability reads ""Once per game, during the day, publicly choose a player: if they are *the* Demon, they die" if you think that the Slayer's ability should trigger on a Recluse then to be mechanically consistent so should the Scarlet Woman's (since they both say *the* Demon in their rules text). I *do* however agree that for game balance that only one of the Imps needs to be killed since the game's rules dictate that Good wins if *the* Demon dies and both are registering as *the* Demon. Legion is a special case, since Legion is a single Demon being played by multiple players.

HalfPriceHero01

It's called that here in the UK, too. I think Tilly's confusion lies in that the term "canvassing" can also refer to politicians going door to door to survey public opinion or to campaign for voters during an election (I believe the same is true in US English), but that kind of canvassing is also informally referred to as 'door-knocking' here.

Kathleen Goetting

Ehh I disagree. In a game with your friends, maybe not. But in a game filmed for content with lots of experienced players, I think it was a fine choice, and also one that was totally within the rules. You can be sure all players in this game will remember this now and will have it in the back of their mind as a possibility for future games.

Kathleen Goetting

Actually it was totally within the rules. To “register” as a character or alignment means you may count as that character or alignment for other character’s abilities, as per the BOTC glossary.

Lee Dellbridge

Fair enough I just don't think it's fun content when one team can't win.

Harbinger5

Yes, a game of super experienced players who couldn’t work why there was 2 demons. The evil team even explained a potential scenario and it still seemed too remote and unrealistic. A fun game to watch but less than normal because it was hugely one-sided and predictable.

Harbinger5

You shouldn’t have the evil team giving clues to the good team to balance it out - isn’t that the storytellers job? Demonstrates it was pretty one sided with the weird two demon thing none of the super experience players could figure out.

Lee Dellbridge

That is odd. I can see it for the £9 tier.

Harbinger5

Through Patreon it’s more expensive, I never realised that.

ElloryQueen

It wasn't impossible for the good team to win. They were just too hung up on that it could be an atheist game, and the evil team were also pushing it, as they should.

Lee Dellbridge

Personally I feel with the incorrect setup (which should have just been a re rack as I have seen others do) and then adding a second demon was a bit much but what the real issue was is then saying both demons must die. The good win condition is kill "the demon" and both were "the demon". It was at that point I lost all interest. But hey something has to be the best game on the channel and something has to be the worst. And it's just my opinion this was that for me. Both in person games were great so we move on. When it comes to rewatching games (which I do very often) this simply won't be in that.

Lee Dellbridge

Being in the rules doesn't mean it should happen in the spirit of the game. The incorrect setup was bad enough without adding a second demon. What's done is done, it won't be a rewatch from me :)

Joe Humbert

I do appreciate reviewing all the current game roles at the beginning. Please keep doing it

Megan Moore

SPOILERS: This was so entertaining! For those critiquing how the game was run, at first I too was thinking it was unfair, but came to a personal conclusion that Ben made the right call. If a drunk atheist is on the script then they have to try their best within the rules to look like an atheist game, which they absolutely achieved. With a seasoned BOTC group such as this, playing trouble brewing, it’s good that they now have the experience of seeing the Scarlet Woman work like this. It will only create better BOTC players in the future when playing atheist scripts. And it’s not like the world wasn’t proposed and actually considered by the good team with a little seed planted by the evil team. Bravo everyone!

Neil

Absolutely cracking episode - loved it!

Dwayne

i've just started watching this video so, sorry if its explained/resolved but how is there three outsiders with no atheist and no baron?

Lara

Really fun shenanigans. I love this video just by the fact that I have watched a lot of clocktower videos and this was something new I have never seen before. And I think that no Rolls barred on patreon is exactly the right place for it. By being on patreon you can expect it to be something untraditional, also No Rolls Barred explains everything heavily so you can follow even such a complex game and it is heaps better when you get a fun and advanced game for Patreon rather than something which wasn't qualitity enough to make it onto Youtube (a quick rerec for example). Well done everyone. More like this please ❤️

socialautiste

There is a small misunderstanding being made about the way good wins BotC. The default win condition for good is when: "there is at least one good player alive, and there are no living demons". You don't have to kill a demon to win, and that is important, because if you had to kill to win then the evil team could simply pit-hag out the demon and the good team could never win. And the demon does not have to be evil to prevent good from winning. A fun tactic can be to use the pit hag to turn random good players into more demons; it is up to the storyteller whether or not they will kill your current demon, but it is reasonable to make extra good demons because they just have to tell town and get executed. Obviously an ST should never allow the evil team to make multiple evil demons, but this was the ST making a 2nd evil demon (not the evil team doing it). That is a good thing to do in a script with an atheist, but only once probably in a hundred games. It is important for players to think about the atheist as "does this break the rules" when weird things happen. The problem good had here, was being hung up on "the ST is ALLOWED to break the rules" versus whether or not the rules are technically being broken at all. For a first time atheist game, that would be a distinction that is probably too nuanced and would be harsh for a ST to expect, but this was an "expert game" and Ben repeatedly gave them the hint to focus on "must this break the rules, not can this break the rules".

socialautiste

My personal favorite games are the KenRB and Red Dwarf episodes. This wasn't a particularly good or bad episode for me, but I perfectly get re-watching the episodes and having preferences.

Lee Dellbridge

Yeah that is very true. I suppose I am spoiled by 99% of games being really enjoyable so when one isn't it really sticks out. But yes if the players are having fun that is the important thing.

MyBooty!

it was INDEED worth seeing Mara Joys face when you told her she was the imp. Thanks for that content!

Sunny

i will always support chaos so this episode delighted me

Payton West

I love this game. Not because it’s what i agree with, how i would run games, or what i think would have been most fun. I love this game because it truly showcases the characters. The recluse is seen as a character that only ever exists to hamper the good teams info or for the evil team to frame. Tilly even said in this video that her character is useless. However, the ST was able to use Tilly’s ability to register as THE demon to affect Mara’s ability, and therefore changed the whole course of the game. It truly goes to show that every character, even “useless” ones affect the game. Beautifully done. People are just too focused on if they agree with the game or not…which doesn’t change anything about how the game happened lol

Payton West

I think showing people that a “useless” character can cause such chaos is a great way for them to truly understand their characters better. How far can every ability actually work together if the ST didn’t have checks and balances ? I loved it. Very very entertaining

Beth

I was going to be so mad if Arif introduced that world at the end and lost the game! BUT the good team can’t really be mad cause the bad team did throw information out there that was accurate as possible worlds. I think I’d be convinced it was atheist game though. If Mara was good, I think this would have gone another way 😂

Beth

I think Ben came in multiple times to clarify things to really drive home what it might mean to have an atheist game. He spoke in town square more than normal this episode. I think the evil team didn’t HAVE to balance it because it seemed to me Holly brought up the two imp thing first. I think the experienced players when evil make sure to bring up potential worlds that point to them because it’s better coming from them than denying it when other people propose it.

Nika-Rae

This episode was so much fun to watch. I think the story tellers taking liberties with this script was a great idea to mix it up after running so many games. I’m sure the players had fun detangling a web that was unique to what they’re use to figuring out. I also can’t believe Arif introduced the real world on the final day, I was going to lose my mind if he spoiled it for evil in the 11th hour.

Nika-Rae

Totally valid to have your opinion on the game, but saying “one team can’t win” is factually incorrect. Good could have won when they slayer shot Arif and got Mara on the block, or if they were sus on evil players and executed them both throughout the game.

Taru Kortelainen

I generally do not like Atheist games (or Wizard games either) because I like the puzzle solving aspect of the game and Atheist games tend to be just chaos and Wizard abilities are often impossible to guess or make the game unsolvable, but this one actually sold me on the concept of an Atheist game. I think generally Scarlett Woman doesn’t become the demon when the Recluse dies because it is so unbalanced most Storytellers won’t ever even figure out it is technically possible. But it is a solvable puzzle, and in fact it being mechanically possible makes it more likely to be Storytellers trying to simulate an Atheist world than something that would happen in a real Atheist game. If I was a player in this I would not have figured it out in a million years, but it’s fun to think about anyways.

Random User

Absolutely loved this one! And I think it was solvable. At the end they knew that two players had died, so removing the world of one imp. Confirmed Emily as slayer also removed the possibility of legion, which was an extremely powerful bit of accidental info for the good game. So they knew it was either atheist or some very fringe world. They were then given a lot of time on the last day to see if they could get to that fringe world - I think unfortunately because Tilly sat this one out, she wasn't looking at worlds involving the recluse, which would've been the key to arriving at the right conclusion. Also for it to be athiest, there would have to be something (usually) that's actually impossible. They knew librarian/washerwoman was possible with spy, Ben reiterated that his mistake was within the rules of the game, so they had to focus on that night with two kills - and because a slayer shot was successful, they knew there was at least more than one demon. A very difficult puzzle, but not impossible! And fun for all

Dakota Hitchner

I know this is silly but it kind of drives me crazy when talented evil players go overboard trying to help good players solve the game

Matilde Tozzi

Yeah, the good team almost won, what are they talking about... it's not like the evil team stomped them

Ashley Caveda

That's what I was thinking. If it were a real atheist game, the STs would give much subtler hints that they were breaking the rules, and try much harder to make it appear like a normal game. When it's a fake atheist game, they bend the real rules as much as possible to make things feel insane. That was the biggest clue of all that there was actually an evil team.