I'd like to get your opinion on justifying a gameplay mechanic (Patreon)
Content
Hi all! Normally, I'd probably make a poll out of a question like this, but in this case, I don't think seeing Yes vs No would help me very much. I need to understand why people feel the way they do for this topic.
Here's what's going on. In my game, every few seconds, a woman will have a "need" that she wants to have satisfied. You satisfy it by pressing the buttons in the correct order. After that happens, you currently get paid. With this money, you can buy new upgrades and things to do with the women in the next level. In my mind, it's important to be able to earn money from the start of the game, because buying upgrades is fun.
Keep in mind, none of the women start as hucows and harpies, they transform into them as the game progresses. The reason I bring this up is, it's not as simple as, "Happy cows produce more milk which earns more money." That doesn't work because the hucows aren't hucows at the beginning of the game.
The question is, why would you get money for satisfying each need? I'm trying to justify that. There are two main ideas I'm considering, but there's probably more than two good ones.
1. At the end of every day, you and the other farms have a little pageant. If your women are happy, they have a better showing and earn you more money. So you don't directly get paid per action. You get paid at the end of the day.
2. A government auditor is on the farm with you. She watches everything you do throughout the day. Just like the government checks quality of fruits/vegetables/meat in this universe, in the game universe, the government cares about the quality and well being of the farm girls. Each time you satisfy a need correctly, you get paid by the government.
I think these both have their pros and cons.
Pageant Pros
You get to have a pageant! Nice visuals, etc.
There could be some randomness to the pageant results.
Fun things like bonus points for the "Best in show" winner.
Pageant Cons
I don't like how indirect feedback is. You do x actions and only get feedback about how well you did when the level ends. Of course, you could get "happiness points" after every action, but the conversion from that to $ just seems like unnecessary complexity.
I don't feel like there's a strong link between farm girl happiness and how much you'd earn at a pageant. Usually pageants are more about contestant looks than contestant morale.
Gov Auditor Pros
It's the perfect character to give you the tutorial. BTW, I don't plan for her to be a stuffy, uptight person. She'll be bubbly and outgoing, like Ms. Monet.
There's a strong link between your actions and getting $. The feedback happens instantly.
Gov Auditor Cons
Anything involving the government is kind of boring, especially when compared to a pageant.
--------------------
I'll admit, my personal preference is for a Gov Auditor, but most of the people seem to prefer the pageant. But I don't think I've asked enough people, that's why I'd like to get your opinion.
One very important detail: If I were to pick the Gov Auditor justification, there could still be pageants. Pageants are a fun idea regardless of how I justify why you get money per action.
Anyway, I'd love your thoughts. Thanks!