Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

A 2000 year old architectural complex that contained equations and illustrations of instruments for observing the stars.


In 1914, archaeologists discovered a large building in the ruins of Meroe (the ancient capital of the Kingdom of Kush from the 4th century BC to the 4th century AD) the  structure had several architectural fragments and representations that immediately pointed its function as an astronomical observatory as observed by John Garstang, the head archeologist at the scene who was a scientist and mathematician by training (Depuydt, L. 1998, pg 172) But the discovery of this ancient African Observatory soon fell into obscurity, it wasn't included in any major studies of ancient astronomy and avoidance of it soon turned into denying its existence until the topic was resurrected in 1998 by Egyptologists and Nubiologists


The Observatory

The buildings numbered M 954, 954a and 964 are located in the ruins of Meroe city, the first two rooms were then covered under the palatial building numbered, M 950 that was constructed above them at a later date, the rooms 954 and 954a which, were now subterranean, were accessed through a staircase that had originally led to a flat roof or another room; ie 964, the rooms 954 and 954a and the staircase were thus originally connected  (László Török 2011, pg 129). Of the aforementioned three rooms, it was Room 964 that was the observatory, measuring roughly 5m by 6m

Below is a photograph showing the staircase at the center that descends into the lower rooms 954 and 954a , the west wall on which astronomical graffito and illustrations were inscribed and the square plinth seated on a square pillar (shown on the left of the descending staircase) on which an isosceles triangle was inscribed





The illustrations of astronomical instruments

On the west wall of room 964 were two graffito, one of which were representational, and one of showing a quadratic equation

Of the first two, the best preserved was an illustration of people handling an instrument; "it shows a figure in the center seated on a tripod stool and he holds a circular object, behind him, a second figure leaning forward, with his arms extended beneath the first

A line projecting upward from the circular object then intersects a long tapered shape. At the base are two long lines that end in small circles while near the point of the shape, ten lines are drawn which may depict five lines passing behind it, A second, fainter line projects from the rim of the larger circle to the lowest of the small ones ( Logan, T.J. and B. Williams, 2000 pg 67)


The second illustration, while not found on the wall of room 964, was certainly connected to the first, it shows a circle that’s divided into quadrants but held from one direction, two lines project from the circle to a vertical shape, perpendicular lines are shown intersecting it, beyond the vertical object are two vertical lines with short diagonals that resemble branches or fronds, these are more likely instruments of the same type as discussed immediately below but with the diagonals reversed (Logan, T.J. and B. Williams, 2000 pg 67)



The graffito of the astronomical equations

Found on the west wall, above the fist step on the staircase (see in extreme left photo of the observatory) and inscribed in the cursive Meroitic script;  was an equation consisting of a vertical line separating rows of vertical marks, the top three rows on each side have 15 marks totaling 45 with the lowest rows on the left containing five marks, a group of three above a group of two, and on the right there is a row of ten, most of the rows are subdivided into rough groups of three marks, at the bottom right of each side of the equation is the Meroitic letter "A"

At the top of this equation above the horizontal line are two groups of nine and nine (or ten) lines (the one on the right is incomplete)

At the bottom of the equation is a forth graffito that depicts an instrument, a vertical pole with a triangular plane covered with graduated angles, which (excavators identified as an azimuth instrument, (Logan, T.J. and B. Williams, 2000, pg 70)



An inscription was also found on the square pillar that was on the left of the descending staircase., it consisted of three lines incised on the western face of a square stone/plinth that was on top of the pillar , these lines would meet to make a bisected isosceles triangle with each side forming an angle to the center of 14 degrees, these three lines extend to the base and the center line was angled at roughly 76 degrees from the horizontal in such a way that its nearly equaled the angle of another Meroitic engraving that depicted a pyramid angled at 72 degrees(Logan, T.J. and B. Williams, 2000, pg 70)


Grastang summarized his findings as such "on what was the the western wall we found a number of graffiti representing both calculations or record of observations and actual sketches of two instruments which would seem, so far as they can be understood, to correspond to a transit instrument with circle and an azimuth instrument" (Leo Depuydt, 2000), almost a century after his findings, several recent studies have since come to support his findings; an early unpublished paper by Nubiologist Bruce Williams in 1997, another by Egyptologist Leo Depuydt in 1998, another by Nubiologist Bruce Williams and Thomas J. Logan in 2000 and lastly by Nubiologist Laszlo Torok in 2011


The background; On the evidence for Astronomers and mathematics in the kingdom of Kush

As shown by the third graffito of the equation that used cursive Meroitic letters; ie the character that looks like 'S R' which Is represented at the end of each equation is the Meroitic letter for "A" therefore the authors of the graffito were local inhabitants and not the neighboring Ptolemaic Greeks or Egyptians (Leo Depuydt, 2000 pg 177)

Further evidence is presented from the titles of a Meroitic priest from the late period named Wayekiye (A), his titles were listed as "hont-priest of Sothis in the going and coming of the Moon”, “waab-priest of the five living stars”, and “chief ritualist of the King of Kush”

Torok writes that " though the star Sothis was also worshipped in the personified form of the goddess Sothis, the second title referring to the five planets, i.e., to an astronomical notion and not a temple cult, makes it sufficiently clear that also the first title defines its owner as an astronomer and The third title points in the same direction" ( Laszlo Torok, 1997, pg 473)

Wayekiye thus belonged to a special class of priests called the learned "writers of sacred books" , educated in astronomy and astrology and were also responsible for measuring the 12hrs of the day and the 12 hours of the night and defining their lengths during the course of the years as well as seasons

The primarily reason for this astronomical work was connected to the timing of feasts, especially the determination of the date of the inundation

The last statement brings us back to rooms 954 and 954a, and why they were connected to the observatory, the rooms were constructed around the 1st century BC (which also provides a date for the observatory), built into rooms 954a were two sandstone basins in the shape of modern bathtubs with a plastered and coated water inlet, these stone basins are also present in a few other buildings in Meroe and at Gebel Barkal

Torok interprets their function as such; "the function of the stone basins may have been the preservation of the “pure” Nile water drawn from the river at the time of inundation, the date of which was determined by learned priests who carried out their measurements in the Early Meroitic predecessor of building M 950" combined with the proximity of the Amun temple and the monumentality of the section's architecture, he therefore interprets that this section of the city of Meroe where this observatory was found as "the habitation quarter of priests" some of whom doubtlessly practiced astronomy (Laszlo Torok, 2011, pg 131 to 132) this was supported by Bruce Williams who writes that "the records on the wall associate celestial events with some meteorological phenomena related to the rising Nile, this would connect astronomical complex to the basins" 


Mathematics in Kush

An engraving representing a pyramid dated to the 1st century BC was discovered in Meroe, it was engraved on the wall of chapel of the pyramid "BEG N8" but was actually made in preparation for the construction of another pyramid, The drawing was at the scale of 1:10 and shows a truncated pyramid with a side length of 11.58 meters and a height of 16.80 meters, with two lines running diagonally at an angle of 72 degrees which was a steep sloping slope characteristic of Meroitic pyramids

The drawing includes 48 symmetrical lines representing 48 stone courses that led up to a clearly drawn platform and the the base is divided into vertical lines engraved at a distance of 5.25cm apart, The proportional ratio between height to base equals 8 to 5, vey approximate to the golden ratio - a ratio that frequently appears in classical architecture ( Friedrich W. Hinkel, 2013)

By comparing the details in the illustration, the pyramid engraved to be constructed was the BEG N 2 pyramid of King Amanikhabale, thus dating it to around 40BC

It thus clear that the astronomers of Kush were familiar with mathematics and applied it not just I construction but in astronomy, and that the engraving on the square pillar is therefore not without precedent, it being dated to the first century BC as well


Interpretations of the instruments

On this is where differing opinions are offered, in Garstang's opinion, the drawings show an astronomer at his transit instrument, and the instrument itself is described as a transit device ( an instrument for measuring time) instrument with a circle, this interpretation is backed by Bruce Williams who writes that "the Meroe graffito clears shows a transit device, here the observer is holding a mirror while an assistant, standing behind him makes sure the observer holds the mirror exactly horizontal so it doesn't move sideways

Since the north pole wasn't visible after 2500BC, an astronomer needed to mark the movement of circumpolar stars over a year as they revolve around the celestial north pole. Once the above is determined, the astronomer would then need a permanent marking device which is where the square plinth comes in, the accurate nature that the angles engraved on the plinth match up support the theory that the square plinth served as a base for a tall tapered pole. The mirror was etched with a cross (see second graffito) the observer would then track the "Decan star" such that its image hits the tip of the triangle on the square plinth , when the star aligned with the tip, it crossed the meridian; its transit point, this would start another hour of the night".

Decan stars were 36 stars that rose and set at different times of the year which ancient Egyptians and Kushites used to tell time, but unlike ancient Egyptian illustrations of these stars that were religious in nature, this Meroitic illustration is a technical one, showing how to make an observation and what to expect (Logan, T.J. and B. Williams, 2000, pg 77)

The equation too was related to the square plinth, the right side of the equation has top three rows consisting of 15 marks each, possibly related to the 15 day star clocks used in the Nile valley civilizations, but the fourth row after the top three consists of ten marks which are difficult to interpret, after this row and the Meroitic letter for 'A', is another cursive Meroitic character that indicates a notation of the total and it is given as 10

The left side equation has; three rows of 15 marks and then one row of 3marks and one row of two, and the letter A but has no notation for total (Logan, T.J. and B. Williams, 2000 pg 78)

An alternative interpretation has been offered in which the instrument depicted is a Gnomon (a fixed instrument for measuring shadows) although the author himself expressed doubt over it being what was illustrated in the observatory graffito since gnomons (and similar sundials) were fixed, yet the graffito shown represents an astronomical instrument with full curvature, also, the content of the equations is astronomical in nature, lastly the astronomer drawn in the first graffito seems to be manipulating the instrument yet gnomons are fixed (Leo Depuydt, 2000, pg 174)


Conclusion

Its clear that a disciplined astronomical observations took place in this room, the astronomers here were likely high officials and based their calculations largely on the sun's movements and on the movements of the 'Decan stars', the people of Kush were meticulous record keepers (Bruce Williams, 2020, pg 403) and that their mathematics system of recording and predictions was sophisticated and practical

Given the dating of the observatory complex to the 1st century BC, it was certainly the oldest known building in antiquity set up for the explicit purpose of making astronomical observations (Logan, T.J. and B. Williams, 2000, pg 80), predating the 'Cheomseongdae' observatory of south korea by over seven centuries



references;

Logan, T.J. and B. Williams, 2000, On the Meroe Observatory

Bruce Williams and Geoff Emberling, 2020 The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Nubia

Leo Depuydt, 1998, Gnomons at Meroë and Early Trigonometry

László Török, 2011, Hellenizing Art in Ancient Nubia

László Török, 1997,The Kingdom of Kush

Friedrich W. Hinkel , 2013, The Royal Pyramids of Meroe



Comments

No comments found for this post.