Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The disintegration of Christian Nubia in the 14th and 15th centuries created a power vacuum in the region of north-eastern Africa. In an era where political power was closely associated with religion, this vacuum titled the regional balance of power heavily in favor of Mamluk Egypt, the pre-eminent Muslim power of the era, while disadvantaging Christian Ethiopia, then the last remaining Christian kingdom in Africa, setting the stage for what became the most dramatic diplomatic showdowns in African history that at its lowest point had prompted one Ethiopian sovereign to march his vast army upto the southern border of Egypt.

In the tense political atmosphere, both states acted as protectors of eithers religious minority communities while also leveraging the threat of expelling the same as a bargaining tool, both extended proxy support to rival states with threats of alliances to invade the other's lands, and in what would have amounted to the boldest feat of hydraulic engineering in history, the Ethiopian monarchs threatened to divert the flow of the Nile river.

18th century manuscript with a Representation of king Yekunno Amlak seated on his royal dais, surrounded by Muslim ambassadors and servants British library



Background: the gradual decline of Christian states in Africa: relationship between Makuria and Muslim Egypt (see my substack post for a more detailed read)

Until the Arab conquest of Egypt in 642, virtually all centralized states on the African continent had adopted Christianity as a state religion, from the Romano-Berber kingdoms in Morocco to Byzantine Egypt to Nubia in Sudan and Aksum in Ethiopia, especially the last two states whose bishops/metropolitans were appointed by the pope/patriarch of the Coptic church in Alexandria (Egypt). The centuries that succeeded the fall of North Africa to the Muslim armies of the Rashidun and Ummayad caliphates greatly altered the political and religious landscape of Africa, but their crushing defeats in Nubia halted their advance into the region of Sudan and Ethiopia for nearly a millennia forcing successive Muslim dynasties of Egypt to contend with a formidable southern rival; the kingdom of Makuria. From the 8th to the 13th century, Makurian armies repeatedly invaded Muslim Egypt, often fighting on Egyptian soil, occupying Egyptian territory for lengthy stretches of time and undermining centralized Egyptian authority when necessary, the Coptic Christian community of egypt, which remained the majority of Egypt's population until the 11th century, often leveraged the power of Makuria, a fellow Miaphysite Christian state, to protect their ever declining political and religious authority in successive Muslim dynasties. In its relationship with the various Muslim dynasties of Egypt , Makuria tended to have the upper hand, buoyed by the demographic weight of the Christians who were often sympathetic to its interests, the fractional nature of the caliphates' politics, and the strength of the Nubian armies such that by the time the Fatimid dynasty in the 10th century emerged (then the 5th Muslim dynasty to rule egypt in just 500 years), Egypt had learned to contend with its southern neighbor, extending an olive branch that initiated a nearly unbroken 200 yr period of peace During this time, the Ethiopian state of Aksum had been in precipitous decline and one of its last rulers pleaded with the Nubian king David to intercede on his behalf and request the Alexandrian patriarch to send a new metropolitan (abuna) for Aksum, and in the succeeding centuries, atleast two bishops and one Ethiopian ecclesiastical figure are recorded to have travelled through Makuria. But the political landscape of the Near east changed when the crusader armies carved out other Christian states on the Fatimid's north-eastern borders in the 11th century and begun invading Egypt in the 13th century, leading to the fall of the Mamluks to a more militant Ayyubid dynasty that was ready to confront not just the crusaders but severe any ties they might have had with Egypt's southern neighbor, when the Ayyubids were overthrown by an even more militant Mamluk caliphate, the pendulum swung decisively against Makuria and the crusaders, the Mamluk armies snuffed out the last crusader state and thrust their armies south; down to the city of Old Dongola; the capital of Makuria, and for the first time in nearly 600 years it was the Nubians on the defensive. While it would take nearly three centuries for the ancient kingdom to fall, the abandoned of Old Dongola in 1365 signaled that the Christian state of Makuria had effectively been indisposed as a regional military power. 


The emergence of Solomonic Ethiopia

Coincidentally, the 14th century witnessed the ascent of "Solomonic" Ethiopia as a regional power, "the glorious victories of Amada seyon" as the emperor's chronicler titled his work, documents the swift expansion of the Solomonic empire across vast swathes of the Ethiopian highlands from its heartland in shewa (north-central Ethiopia) the infantry and cavalry armies of Amda seyon, armed with swords, shields and thrusting spears, conquered dozens of Ethiopian kingdoms creating an imperial state with a diverse mosaic of ethnic and religious multiplicity that included Christians, Muslims, Jews (falasha) and traditionalists

But even by the time of its founding in the 13th century, the Solomonic monarchs resented the limitations imposed on him by the dependence on the goodwill of neighboring Muslim states not just to protect Ethiopian pilgrims in the holy lands and conduct trade , but also for something as essential as obtaining an abuna for his church had to be done through the auspices of the hostile Rasulid sultans of Yemen, in 1274, Yekuno Amlak used such a diplomatic channel to request a bishop from the reigning Mamluk sultan Baybars of Egypt (the same sultan who invaded Old Dongola in 1276) but by the time of his successor in 1290, the Ethiopians hadn't received their abuna, this may have shaped the policies of Yekuno Amlak to his neighboring Muslim states such as the kingdom of Ifat and by the time of his successor Yibya siyon (1285-1294), the Ethiopian monarchs had begun taking a more conciliatory approach towards the Muslim states most likely with the knowledge that the Mamluk sultans had learned of their actions, with Yiba Siyon stating that "My father was an enemy of the Muslims But as for me, I am not like my father at all in this respect; but I protect Muslims in all the realms of my kingdom" 

This is perhaps the first instance in which the Ethiopian monarchs leveraged the presence of Muslim communities in their lands as a bargaining tool in negotiating with the Mamluk sultans of Egypt. (Taddesse Tamrat pg 127-128) this friendly sentiment may have also been influenced by the political realities in Ethiopia as the growing Muslim empire of Ifat posed a formidable challenge to the Solomonic emperors own expansionist ambitions, eventually forcing them onto the negotiating table for a truce. But by the reign of Amda seyon (1314-1344), the Solomonic empire had consolidated its realm and resumed its expansion especially into what were now Muslim territories; to galvanize his support, he couched his expansionist wars in religious terms saying to his armies that: "You fought for my sake in the past, and now fight for Christ" on their part, the Muslim rulers of Ifat similarly rallied several disparate Muslim states to their side and couched their battles with Amda seyon in religious terms of jihad, both leaders inspiring a crusading spirit in their armies, but the Solomonic empire ultimately emerged the victor and within its borders included the lake Tana (where the bulk of the Nile waters come from), as well as a vast community of Muslims, a community which increasingly turned to their co-religionists, such as the Mamluk sultans, for protection from what they perceived as increasingly repressive Christian monarchs of Ethiopia (Taddesse Tamrat pg 130-141)


Early Egypt-Ethiopia relations during the Zagwe era (10th?-13th century)

It's difficult to establish when the Nile waters, the Muslim Ethiopian community and the threat of military action, first featured in egyptian-ethiopian foreign relations, or even to what Ethiopian state the earliest Egyptian letters were contacting but as early as the 11th century, Egypt's Fatimid caliph al-Mustansir bi’llah (1036–1094) sent Abuna Sawirus (a pretender) to Aksum with instructions for the latter to construct mosques, the metropolitan is said to have built seven mosques before he was imprisoned by the Ethiopian monarch who proceeded to destroy them, this prompted a reprisal from the Fatimid caliph against the copts in Egypt, coincidentally, the Nile level dropped and famine begun in Egypt which was attributed to Ethiopia's interference with the river in relation to these events and in 1089/1090, the caliph wrote to the Ethiopian monarch begging him to restore the flow of the Nile, and in response, the Ethiopian king is said to have “ordered a large enclosed valley to be opened by the cutting of a dam. As soon as this was done the Nile rose ten feet in a single night and the whole land of Egypt was irrigated.” (Hable Selassie  pg 244-248) 

since there is little evidence of a centralized Aksumite or Zagwe state in the lake Tana region at the time, and even less evidence of an hydraulic engineering feat of such nature, the latter account, which is related in Coptic accounts, is very much likely a fabrication by the Coptic chroniclers themselves but one that was tailored to the real anxieties of the Fatimid caliph and his then majority coptic population who circulated the myth, and in the succeeding centuries, Ethiopian sovereigns would have become aware of the leverage this tradition provided them vis-a-vis their Egyptian rivals.

Relations between Fatimid Egypt and Ethiopia (early Zagwe kingdom? See Marie-Laure Derat's paper) proceeded relatively peaceful for the next two centuries (just like the Fatimids were friendly to the Christian Nubians), there's little mention of either states using their Christian and Muslim communities as bargaining tools in negotiations and its said that both desisted from mass conversions, several embassies are sent by the Zagwe rulers to the Fatimid court to obtain a new patriarch as well as protection for Ethiopian pilgrims in Egypt and the holy lands this seemingly cordial relationship continued into the early 13th century with similar requests were just as successful (Hable Selassie, Ancient and Medieval Ethiopian History, p. 261-262, 268) but a breakdown in relations is also mentioned in King lalibela's reign and he is said to have threatened to divert the Nile's course after many Christians fled from Egypt to Ethiopia because of maltreatment from the increasingly repressive ascended Ayyubid dynasty (1172-1250), his successor Nakuto La'ab in the second half of the 13th century, is also said to have contemplated diverting one of the Nile's tributaries, and by the late 13th century, a Coptic chronicler Jirjis al-Makin (d.1273) narrated a story about an Ethiopian king diverting and restoring the Nile to its course (Ḥagai Erlikh pg 38) seemingly substantiating what was in Egypt, a working myth.


Solomonic Ethiopia and Mamluk Egypt relations (1270-1517)

The above story then brings us back to the aforementioned story of Yekuno Amlak in the late 13th century and a failed request to send an abuna which represented a decisive break In Egypt-Ethiopian relations, despite Yiba Seyon distancing himself from the actions of his father, the relationship between the Mamluk sultans and Ethiopia continued to sour and by 1325, the Ethiopian emperor Amda seyon sent a letter to the Mamluk sultan Nasir ad-Din Muhammad reprimanding him for the destruction of coptic churches in Egypt and mistreatment of Christians in his lands, Amda seyon then threatened to destroy mosques in his own territory and divert the course of the Nile, the Mamluk sultan is said to have laughed off the threat, but just 5 years later, king Haqq al-Din of the Ifat kingdom was defeated by Amda seyon and despite Haqq's pleas for military assistance from the Mamluk sultan, no such aid was arranged and his defeat seems to have only served to soften the Mamluk's attitude towards Amda seyon. a contemporary Egyptian historian Fadlallah ibn al-‘Umari. Wrote that “The Ethiopians claim they were the guardians of the Nile, They say they allow it to flow only out of respect to the sultan.”  (Ḥagai Erlikh pg 43) 

By 1335 stories of the existence of an African Christian kingdom south of Egypt and Nubia had begun circulating in Europe brought by pilgrims from the holy lands, one such story by the Italian pilgrim Jacopo da Verona related that "They are black Ethiopians from among the people of Prester John, who is one of the greatest princes in the world. Those Nubians sing for the whole day and the whole night. They consecrate fermented bread They always carry, as I have said, a cross in their hand, even in the presence of the Sultan and in the presence of the Saracens, and they pay no tribute through the entire land of the Sultan. Also, however often the sepulcher of Christ is opened, they enter without [paying] money or tribute; and the reason for this is that Prester John, the Lord of Nubia and Ethiopia, has the potential within his own realm to divert the Nile river If that land did not receive this river, it would be wholly uninhabitable, as evidently [is the case for] all of Egypt; and, similarly, Prester John is more powerful than the Sultan." (Matteo Salvadore pg 5). Since its unlikely that this story was referring to the then diminished kingdom of Makuria which at the time was considered a Mamluk vassal by most respects, this is possibly the first confirmation of an African identity of the legendary Prester john, a non-European king that was popular in European traditions who supposedly lived on the other side of the Muslim empires adjacent to the Europeans and with whom many European monarchs had hoped to form an alliance against the Muslims.


The Ethiopian monarchs and their Mamluk counterparts continued sending threatening letters to each other and maltreating the copts and Muslims in either lands, this impasse sunk to a dangerous low when the emperor Dawit (1380-1412) raided upper Egypt (ie: southern Egypt) with a large army that reached the city of Aswan in 1381, where it's said to have “inflicting heavy blows on the Muslims.” and committed "frightful ravages on the lands of islam" (Taddesse Tamrat pg 267) according to Ethiopian sources, Dawit 

held back the Nile when he heard that the patriarch in Egypt had been imprisoned, according to Ethiopian sources, when the Egyptians saw that their waters had receded, they sued for peace and promised never again to be the foes of Christianity, The raid resulted in the Mamluk sultan to send a letter  in 1386 warning Dawit to which Dawit responded with mixed threats and respect, denying that he had diverted the Nile (Ḥagai Erlikh pg 44), Dawit then turned to his archrival the Ifat kingdom which his armies extinguished, they are said to have "ravaged mosques and built churches out of them", the capital of ifat was "permanently occupied" by Dawit's armies and "heard of no more" (Richard Pankhurst pg 51) and his successors continued what had now become a pattern, but some took a step further at attempting to tilt the scales in their favor by establishing ties with Christian Europe.


Solomonic Ethiopia's discovery of Europe (1402-) and its consequences on Egypt-Ethiopia relations.

Following the fall of the crusader kingdom of Jerusalem at the siege of acre in 1291 by the Mamluk armies, European armies had been dealt a decisive blow to their ambitions of creating a Christian state in the holy lands, and the crusader zeal was now focused squarely on destroying Mamluk Egypt, while the latter's focus was on dealing with the threat of the neighboring Christian states and after successfully undermining the centralized power of the Makuria kingdom and stifling any attempts by the Nubians to forge formal alliances with Europe, the Mamluks took bolder steps to lessen the threat of Ethiopian power and in particular, any alliance with the Christian kingdoms of Europe.

Whilemedieval  Ethiopian-European relations are a topic for another time, their formal commencement in 1402 by emperor Dawit added a new and potent factor in the relations between Mamluk Egypt and Ethiopia, Dawit's envoys were later followed by another Ethiopian embassy in 1427 sent by Yeshaq (1414- 1429) to King Alfonso of Aragon which included a bold (and very likely) proposal of a royal intermarriage between the Aragonese and Ethiopian dynasties, the Mamluks now had plenty of cause for alarm (Matteo Salvadore pg 40-43) The Mamluk chronicler al-Maqrizi (d. 1442) leveled accusations against Yeshaq for sending embassies to Europe in order to form a grand alliance against Islam, indeed by 1400, King Henry of England had already sent a letter to Dawit and although it's unlikely to have reached its destination, the real threat of an anti-Muslim alliance between Christian Ethiopia and Europe, combined with Dawit's invasion of southern Egypt represented a much more potent threat than any retributions against Muslims in Ethiopia or threats to divert the Nile. (Adam Knobler pg 39) relationship between the two north-east African states had sunk to a seemingly irrecoverable low.


For a short time, there was an interlude in which relations between the two states seemed to have thawed, during the early reign of emperor Zara Yaqob (1434-1468), the Ethiopian monarch  seems to have been on good terms with the Mamluk sultan  Sultan Barsbay (1422- 1438), he dispatched an embassy to the latter that carried  "a gift, made of gold, civet and other precious objects, together with a letter in which he advanced to this prince the most friendly concerns and invited him to treat Christians favorably and to have their churches respected.", but following the ascension of a new Mamluk sultan Jaqmaq (1438–1453) , relations seem to have quickly deteriorated, as growing intolerance was recorded on both sides of the Christian-Muslim divide. (Matteo Salvadore pg 44) and Zara Yacob dispatched an embassy to Council of Florence (1439–1441) which was supported by the Alexandrian church, and it resulted in the construction of an Ethiopian monastery in Rome, but this bold action (which may not have been directed by the Emperor himself) was only met with more retributions on the Egyptian copts, so in 1443, Zara Yacob sent a missive to the Mamluk Sultan that read: "I adjure and warn you with the peace and charity that are signified by this gold, which has by no means been sent you as a gift, but as a symbol, that you should at once release all,  the Christians oppressed under your authority, and that you permit and order the razed churches to be rebuilt" or else  "I will baptize all the Saracens subject to me - and they are almost innumerable- intheir own blood, and their mosques I will utterly destroy. I will seize from you Mecca and the tomb you venerate of that prophet of yours, and I will take from Egypt the floodwaters of the Nile -so that you and your people will perish by the sword, hunger and thirst at the same time" (Verena Krebs pg 256-257) just 5 years later, the contents of this stern letter echoed across Europe as  Jean de Lastic (1371- 1454), Grand Master of the Knights of St John in Rhodes, sent a letter to King Charles VII on 3 July 1448 that read:  "Moreover, certain Indian (ethiopia) priests who had sailed here to Rhodes told us through reliable interpreters that Prester John, emperor of the Indies, reported great butchery and slaughter by his neighbors the Saracens (Muslims), and most of all by those who claimed to be descended from the line of Mohammed, such as could scarcely be believed: for on a journey of three days the corpses of the slain were seen scattered all around. This same King of the Indies intended, moreover, to send an ambassador with gifts to the Sultan of Babylon, as is the custom among those of the East, announcing that unless he desisted from persecuting Christians, he himself would bring destruction and war against the city of Mecca, where the tomb of Mohammed is said to be located, as well as against Egypt, Arabia, and Syria, which are subject to the rule of this Sultan, and threatening also that he would seize the entire river Nile, which irrigates Egypt and without which nothing would be able to survive in that place, and that a second journey similar in kind would be given him. This ambassador was at first well received and provided for, means being given to him that he might visit the holy sepulcher of our Lord: but when he had returned to Cairo he was imprisoned by the same Sultan, with the design that he would not release this man if his own ambassador, sent to India and held there, were not to return" (Matteo Salvadore pg 45) 


The Mamluk sultan wasn't to be outdone however and is said to have an embassy to Ethiopia with a mixed and respectful response to the Ethiopian monarch as well as gifts,  but refused Zara Yacob's request to reconstruct the destroyed Coptic churches in Egypt and with this unsatisfactory response, the emperor  subsequently imprisoned them, and in retaliation, the Mamluk's imprisoned the Ethiopian embassy as well. This latter action coincided with the defeat of the Muslim kingdom of Adal which had now assumed Ifat's position as the primary rival of Christian Ethiopia, the defeat of Adal and the continued imprisonment of Jamqaq's envoys prompted an even worse response from the latter, who severely flogged the Alexandrian patriarch and forced him to write a letter to Zara Yacob requesting that he released his prisoners, but Zara Yacob only relented after 4 years, by which time, the above mentioned letter to King Charles was received with its contents including the disastrous defeat of Adal and the power of the Ethiopian monarch (Taddesse Tamrat pg 262 -265) Zara Yacob later sent a more friendlier letter to the Mamluk sultan in 1447  that included debates on Muslim theology about the treatment of Christians, their churches and their property and included a claim that the Nile could be diverted not because the Ethiopians would Dam it but that since they continually removed debris and driftwood from the river's path, they could choose to not undertake the audacious but noble task and leave the Nile to find a new course, but that since Zara Yacob was pious, he chooses to uphold the bond of love that existed between their predecessors and continue de-silting the Nile, a generosity that he threatened would be removed if Jaqmaq refused to fulfil his demands, Zara Yacob then sent several gifts to the Mamluk sultan and bed the envoys goodbye. While no reply from Jamqaq was forthcoming, this final act of reconciliation seemed to have concluded the rivalry between the two states, so much so that in the late 1440s and 1452, the Mamluks were urging the besieged Adal kings to make peace with the Ethiopian monarchs and submit to their rule, a notion that was unthinkable only a few decades prior (Verena Krebs pg 268-269)


Beset by succession struggles and declining power, both Solomonic Ethiopia and Mamluk Egypt went into decline, the latter more precipitously than the former with the Mamluk egypt falling to the Ottomans in 1517, and in 1531, the Solomonic empire was nearly extinguished by the armies of a resurgent Adal this time not with Mamluk assistance but with Ottoman assistance, opening a new chapter in Egypt-Ethiopia relations that lasted until emperor Yohannis' defeat of an Ottoman invasion in 1876.





References


Church and State in Ethiopia, 1270-1527 by Taddesse Tamrat

The African Prester John and the Birth of Ethiopian-European Relations, 1402-1555 by Matteo Salvadore

The Ethiopian borderlands by Richard Pankhurst

The Cross and the River: Ethiopia, Egypt, and the Nile by Ḥagai Erlikh

Mythology and Diplomacy in the Age of Exploration By Adam Knobler

The Zāgwē dynasty (11-13th centuries) and King Yemreḥanna Krestos by Marie-Laure Derat

Ancient and Medieval Ethiopian History to 1270 by Sergew Hable Selassie


Download some of them here 






Comments

No comments found for this post.