Mansa Muhammad's journey across the Atlantic in the 14th century, and an exploration of West Africa's maritime culture from the 12th-19th century. (Patreon)
Content
“We belong to a family in which power is inherited. He who was king before me did not believe that the ocean was impossible to cross". This is how Mansa Musa begun his story about his predecessor's audacious but ill-fated journey across the Atlantic.
Interpreted literally, the expedition of Mansa Muhammad across the Atlantic ocean was the most ambitious exploratory journey undertaken by a west African in the medieval era. Most scholars have often approached this story by exclusively focusing on Mali's internal politics, with only brief mentions of West Africa's maritime traditions. They attimes contrast the grandiosity of Mansa Muhammad's ambitious endeavor with the rather modest nature of West African coastal societies' maritime activities. The Atlantic ocean appears to have been peripheral to the interests of the large inland empires which controlled vast overland trade networks, and their coastal activities were relatively limited such that offshore islands like Cape Verde (which is 500km from Senegal) and Sao Tome (which is 250km from Gabon) remained uninhabited prior to the 15th century.
However compelling the abovementioned arguments are, the possibility of cross-Atlantic sailing during the 14th century cannot be understood using only cursory observations about the occupation of offshore islands in the 15th century, but by considering Muhammad's adventure within the wider west African maritime culture.
This article looks at the History of West Africa's Maritime culture, focusing on long-distance trade and the use of naval technologies, in order to ascertain the likelihood of Mansa Muhammad's Atlantic crossing.
Beachfront of Rufisque town, Cayor kingdom, Senegal in the 18th century, showing the different types of local vessels.
Early accounts of West Africa's maritime culture; From al-Idrisi to Mansa Musa.
The maritime culture of west Africa is best understood by exploring the history of the coastal societies and the nature of their interaction with the Atlantic ocean.
One of the earliest, most detailed and most intriguing accounts of west Africa's maritime culture and pre-Colombian Atlantic travel in general, was the account narrated by the Mali emperor Mansa Musa to the Mamluk governor of cairo Abū Amīr Ḥājib in 1324 that was recorded by the chronicler al-Umari .
"We belong to a family in which power is inherited. He who was [king] before me did not believe that the ocean was impossible to cross. He wanted to achieve his extremity and was passionate about this project. He equipped 200 boats which were full of men and as many who were filled with gold, water and provisions, enough to face several years. He then said to those who were in charge of these boats: "Do not come back only after you have reached the end of the ocean or if you have exhausted your provisions or your water". They left. Their absence was prolonged. None returned while long periods were flowing. Finally, a boat returned, only one. We asked the chief about what they had seen and learned. “Gladly, O Sultan,” he replied. "We have traveled a long time until the moment when a river with a violent current appeared in the open sea. I was in the last of the boats. The others came forward and when they were in this place, they did not were able to return and disappeared. We don't know what happened to them. Me, I came back from this place there without committing myself to this river". The sultan rejected his explanation. He had subsequently 2000 boats, 1000 for himself and his men and 1000 for water and provisions. Then he installed me as his replacement, embarked with his companions on the ocean and left. That was the last we saw of him and all those who were with him, and so I became king in my own right" (François-Xavier Fauvelle pg 4)
This excellent account is unfortunately tantalizingly vague with regards to the most useful details about west Africa's maritime culture; Did Musa's predecessor (identified as Muḥammad b. Qū by Michael Gomez pg 101) and Malian society in general believe that there was land on the other side of the Ocean?, Is the story's implicit framing within a wider narrative of succession more about legitimating a dynastic shift than about seafaring? (Musa and Muhammad belonged to different branches of the royal dynasty), and What type of watercraft did Muhammad construct and how sea-worthy were they for long-distance sailing?
The first two questions are explored at length by François-Xavier Fauvelle and Michael Gomez in two books and one article ill link below, (Le Mâli et la mer by François-Xavier Fauvelle, The Golden Rhinoceros by François-Xavier Fauvelle pg 161-168, African Dominion by Michael A. Gomez pg 100-103)
But it’s the last the question concerning West African Maritime traditions that the above authors are less corned with- that is the topic of this article; could seafarers from Mali (or any other part of West Africa) successful cross the Atlantic ocean? And, was the incentive for long distance Maritime activities strong enough for them to undertake such an adventure?
Muḥammad al-Idrīsī's (d.1165) account of Atlantic seafaring west Africans and north Africans.
Prior to Musa's firsthand account of west African seafaring, there are is atleast one secondary account of seafaring in the Senegambia region recorded by al-Idrisi which deals with the salt trade between the Saharan salt center of Ijil and the banks of the Senegal river (then controlled by Ghana empire and the kingdom of Takrur) , wherein vessels from the mouth of the Senegal river could journey up the Mauritanian coast (presumably to Arguin ?) from where they loaded salt brought overland from Ijil. (Thornton, A cultural History, pg 12)
This trade between the Sahara and the Sahel/savannah was quite lucrative and has been explored by other scholars as the foundation of the economies of the empires of the western Sudan, (Ann McDougall, SK McIntosh)
And there's no reason to doubt that the riverine societies of the Senegal region who were already familiar with hauling these goods using the river, couldn't extend their journey into and along the Atlantic coast to the Saharan salt centers. This form of integrated maritime-overland trade wasn't uncommon in the region, as I shall cover below.
Al-idrisi also mentions Muslim traders from Lisbon who attempted to trade in west African gold by sailing down the Atlantic coast but couldn't make a return trip (likely due to the canary current) and had to make the return journey overland. (Thornton, A cultural History, pg 12)
Trade route from iJil saltworks to the Senegal riverine system controlled by Takrur and Ghana, based on al-Idrisi's description
History of West Africa's maritime culture:
For many west African coastal societies, the Atlantic ocean was the part of a vast hydrographic system that connected distant points; its estuaries, creeks, and lagoons form an interconnected, protected system of waterways facilitating fishing, warring, and a large-scale movement of goods that nourished a trade that predated and later complemented that of the Europeans operating on the high seas (Thornton, Africa and Africans, pg 20)
Fishing in particular is likely to have been the earliest Maritime activity that African coastal societies engaged in. Early European accounts include mentions of fishing gear and canoes fishing some distances off the coast of the senegambia, the gold coast, and in the bight of benin ( Jean-pierre 191-193) and archeologists have also uncovered mounds of fish bones along the west African coast (Thornton, A cultural History pg 13)
"divisions" of west Africa's coast in the 18th century
Most west African watercraft were constructed in different sizes and for different purposes (primarily for fishing and trade), but their basic features were similar. The lower part of the hull comprised a single hollowed-out log, to which is added planking reinforced by crosspieces to build up the sides of the craft. (George E. Brooks pg 7)
Boatbuilding in the West african coast may be as ancient as it is on the mainland where the world's 2nd oldest watercraft was found; the Dufuna canoe dated to 8500BP, although it was made for riverine and lacustrine navigation.
How far these fishing boats could go at sea was likely considerable but doubtlessly limited to the size of the vessel (for carrying provisions and the catch) as well as its maneuverability. On the Gold coast in 1529, it was noted that "the blacks of the village (Elmina) have many canoes in which they go fishing and spend much time at sea", the distance that such vessels could navigate is unlikely to have exceeded a day, going out in the morning with the land breeze and returning in the afternoon with the sea breeze, covering a distance of about 14-30km offshore (Robin Law pg 3-5)
But the biggest challenge to any attempts at long-distance seafaring were the ocean currents. Unlike the Indian ocean (whose counter-currents flow in opposite directions depending on the season), The Atlantic Ocean has strong, consistent currents that run through it all year. The most significant of these currents was the canary current which runs south along the coast of Portugal, down the coast of Morocco and past the Canary Islands until it’s at a distance off the northern coast of Senegal, afterwhich it then takes a sharp turn into the ocean and enters the Caribbean. The Canary allowed ships to sail south from Morocco to Mauritania but couldn't make a return journey, and neither could African vessels journey beyond Mauritania. Similarly, Atlantic voyages to the Americas and back are unlikely to have been undertaken, barring the accidental drift by vessels caught in the Canary current. (Thornton, A cultural History, pg 11- 13)
Ocean currents of the Atlantic
Ocean currents and prevailing winds on the west African coast versus on the east African coast
Commercial Incentives, adoption of naval technologies and long distance Maritime trade
Unlike Fishing; long distance Maritime Trade, Warfare and Migration, often required a level of political organization associated with centralized social structures, but the recurring feature of pre-15th century west African coastal societies was their political fragmentation, in stark contrast to the vast, ancient states of the mainland (jean devisse pg 404, Thornton, Africa and Africans pg 104)
In absence of state-driven Maritime activities, its therefore likely that the commercial incentive to further develop naval technologies was lacking in west African coastal societies prior to the 15th century, and the general contrast between the political formations of the coast and interior are simply a reflection of the contrast between the political and economic interests of former which rarely overlapped with those of the latter.
Its important to note how significant the incentive for trade played in west Africa's maritime history. While the vast mainland states were rarely engaged in maritime activities prior to the 15th century (with the exception of Mali and Benin), They possessed a very sophisticated overland trade system operated by various "commercial diasporas" that had accomplished cross-continental trade especially to north Africa, even before the Portuguese had arrived. The wangara/Juula gold trade diaspora for example, could switch gold exports easily between Senegal and Elmina in the 16th century (Wilks pg 467),
The extent of this sophistication can be compared to their east African peers who had a rather vibrant maritime culture since the 8th century, and able to sail across the Indian ocean by the 11th century, but wouldn't accomplish cross continental overland trade until the 19th century.
For this reason, evidence for Pre-European trade contacts or migration between African coastal societies are very scare, but after the 15th century, The growth in coastal trade on the arrival of Europeans, initially in gold, ivory, and cloth and later in slaves, provided a major impetus for African seafarers to adopt naval technologies that greatly expanded the extent of their maritime activities, and arguably enabled to the emergence of coastal states in the gold coast and loango coast; which were previously relatively fragmented compared to the fairly large pre-15th century coastal states concentrated in the Sene-Gambia, Bight of Benin and Kongo.
The inclusion of the sail on west African watercraft appears to have been a later adoption after the 16th century as European accounts leave little doubt about its novelty to the coastal societies including those in the Muslim-controlled coastal societies of the Senegambia that would have had some level of familiarity with north African watercraft (robin law pg 4)
The use of Sails was quickly adopted over the 16th century and became fairly common in the Senegambia, Gold coast and the Bight of Benin from the 17th century onwards, with boats of multiple and single sails reported along the shores of Rufisque and Goree in the Senegambia, as well as Axim on the gold coast and Badagry & Lagos in the Bight of Benin (Robert Smith pg 519)
After its adoption, the sail was often complementary to the paddle rather than a substitute of it. In this way, west African watercraft retained the advantage of being maneuverable and being easy to beach. (jean-pierre pg 201)
View of Rufisque, the capital of Cayor kingdom, Senegambia region, in 1746, showing various types of local watercraft.
19th century engraved illustration of a local boat off the coast of Goree island, Senegal with some of the sailing equipment described above
Rigging (the system of cables and ropes that support the mast of the ship and manipulate sails) was also adopted by west African sailors especially in the gold coast and Senegambia region, such as in the cities of Rufisque and Goree where a cultural syncretism within the afro-Portuguese population and their maritime interests encouraged its adoption. African boats and small ships with several masts and sails were thus a common sight off the shore of Goree (jean pierre pg 202)
While the afro-Portuguese owned the larger watercraft and greatly increased the adoption of various navigation technologies, their vessels were operated by other groups such as the Niominka, a serer ethnic group active along the coast of Senegal (George Brooks pg 265, He explorers the history of the Afro-Portuguese at length in the book I linked below)
view of Goree Island, Senegal. Created by Durand-Brager, published in Magasin Pittoresque, volume 11, page 292, Paris, 1843 (the vessel in the foreground was used by local mariners in both Maritime trade and riverine trade, as well as provisioning European ships such as those in the background)
Large watercraft which were capable of carrying tons of cargo, were steered by rudders and their hulls are fitted to accommodate masts rigged with one or more sails. The addition of weather boards to increase the height of the vessel above the water, as well as a rudder for steering larger watercraft, (George Brooks pg 7)
Unlike the Sails, Rigs, and rudders, its difficult to determine the history of the use of other constructions which made up the superstructure, such as the quarter-decks, "castles", and benches. All of which were fitted on canoes for both fishing and warfare (Robert smith pg 518)
The extent to which inter-African maritime trade was influenced by European traders is still a subject of debate. Throughout the pre-colonial era until the mid-19th century, the position of the European on the west African coast was very precarious and depended upon the benevolence of the Africans who not uncommonly attacked European trading forts (such as in 18th century Dahomey and 19th century Asante), and had in the earlier centuries of contact defeated several European naval incursions. (Thornton, Africa and Africans, pg 37-38)
This fairly balanced level of interaction extended to maritime trade whereby larger European ships often stopped at a considerable distance away from the coast -due to the risk of grounding the ship- from where they were supplied by African boats. In the Niger Delta during the early 16th century, large canoes carrying upto 80 people were able to venture 300 miles upriver to bring down goods and provisions for trade (Robin Law pg 3)
The African sailors of the Gold coast region became particularly skilled in supplying and provisioning European ships, as well as transshipment of goods between African ports, such that when European activity increased along the bight of Benin, whose inhabitants were less engaged with ocean navigation unlike their peers, boatmen from the Gold coast were employed by Europeans to provision and supply ships, and small communities of these Gold coast seafarers were established in the region (robin law pg 6)
Gold coast sailors are reported to have gone even further than the bight of benin, extending to upper west central Africa coast where there are mentions of vessels sailing from Elmina (Ghana) to Loango (Congo) in a journey of about 2 months to exchange cargo (Phyllis Martin pg 65)
There also appears to be evidence of maritime trade and cultural exchanges in networks that extended from the Cameroon coast to northern Angola ( Carina E. Ray pg 9)
Such a journey eastwards from the Gold coast to Angola may have been possible in a single direction even before the Europeans as the Guinea ocean current flows eastwards. But its only likely to have been undertaken after the adoption of the sail allowed return journeys as the Harmatan winds in December to February, allowed Gold coast mariners to sail against the current (robin law pg 8-9)
Its however unclear if the gold coast traders engaged in a direct navigation across the entire length of the coast (such as the well documented cloth trade between ivory coast and the gold coast) or segmented (ships carrying canoes) (Robert smith pg 517)
In the Upper west African coast, Trade between the Sene-gambia and the guinea coast in kola nuts and pepper predated the Portuguese arrival and involved an overlap of maritime and overland travel. Watercraft manned by Niominka seafarers travelled from the Sine-Saloum estuary just north of the Gambia river to Cape Verde Senegal, about 100 km to their north, but couldn't go further as the canary current made travel further north difficult (George Brooks pg 5, 49)
The development of coastal trade enabled the emergence of state systems among coastal societies, and expanding commerce was naturally accompanied by expanding armies of states seeking to control it. Naval warfare along the west African coast included the use of watercraft in the transportation of fighters, battles at sea between different states' navies and engagements with European vessels. But since the largest and most prosperous African states remained largely on the mainland, Naval warfare was often secondary to their interests and thus never attained the form of long-distance nature that for example, the east African coastal societies attained (between the Swahili, Comorians, vs Malagasy -covered here, and the Aksumites vs the Arabians -covered here)
I'll therefore leave this section of Naval warfare to John Thornton's warfare in Atlantic Africa, which covers it excellently.
Conclusion:
In summary, Mali and other pre-15th century Atlantic coastal societies were unlikely to have made a successful crossing of the Atlantic prior to the 15th century (barring the possibility of an accidental, unidirectional landing), not just because of "The tyranny of wind and current is the easiest explanation for the length of time it took to make the Atlantic a highway" as Thornton explains (Thornton, A cultural history, pg 11), but also because prior to the 15th century, there was little incentive to develop navigation technology beyond what was necessary for the mostly fishing activities of the West African coastal societies, as Devisse explains (Jean Devisse pg 411-412)
Long distance Maritime activities in West Africa were only possible after the growth in coastal trade beginning in the 15th century and the adoption of naval technologies in the 16th century that enabled west African seafarers to transcend the constraints of Atlantic seafaring and create a vast Maritime network that linked the coasts of West Africa to West-central Africa.
Link to download folder for the books referenced in this article;
Books
François-Xavier Fauvelle: The Golden Rhinoceros: Histories of the African Middle Ages
George E. Brooks, Eurafricans in western Africa
John Thornton: A Cultural History of the Atlantic World, 1250-1820
John Thornton: Warfare in Atlantic Africa, 1500-1800
John Thornton: Africa and Africans in the Making of the Atlantic World, 1400-1800
Michael A. Gomez: African Dominion: A New History of Empire in Early and Medieval West Africa
Articles:
Ann McDougall: Salts of the Western Sahara: Myths, Mysteries, and Historical Significance
Ivor Wilks: Wangara, Akan and Portuguese in the Fifteenth and Sixteenth Centuries. II. The Struggle for Trade
Robert Smith: The Canoe in West African History
Susan Keech McIntosh: Reconceptualizing Early Ghana
François-Xavier Fauvelle: Le Mâli et la mer (XIVe siècle) Autour du récit du sultan Mûsâ sur l’expédition maritime de son prédécesseur Muhammad
(the original pdf is in french but ive added a translated pdf)
Jean Devisse: Les Africains, la mer et les historiens (Africans, the Sea and Historians)
Jean-Pierre: Une histoire maritime africaine est-elle possible? (Is a Maritime History of Africa Possible?)
<I couldn't make translated pdfs of the last two, I used google translate here>
Books and articles that are referenced but not included in download folder
Phyllis Martin: The External Trade of the Loango Coast, 1576-1870
Carina E. Ray: Navigating African Maritime History
Robin Law: West Africa's Discovery of the Atlantic (available for online reading https://www.jstor.org/stable/23046841?read-now=1&googleloggedin=true )
Files
Previews only