Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The picturesque escarpment of Bandiagara in central Mali are home to one of Africa's most famous communities, and were the scene of modern astronomy's most intriguing mysteries. Perched along the lofty cliff-face, Dogon society, with its distinctive traditions from art to mythology to architecture, has for long captured the interest of modern art collectors and intellectuals across the world for over a century.

The most intriguing of all Dogon traditions was their advanced astronomical knowledge about 'Sirius B', a dwarf star that is part of a binary star in the Canis Majoris constellation, that was only discovered using a telescope in 1862 and remains invisible to the naked eye. Dogon priests had told anthropologists in the 1930s and 1940s, that they preserved ancient knowledge of the universe relating to their religious calendar; in which the focal point was the Sirius star system, the 50-year orbit of Sirius B, and the latter's high density, all of which were proved strikingly similar to modern Astronomical observations.

The Dogon's astronomical traditions about Sirius are some of Africa's best known across the world, having been translated across dozens of languages including Japanese and Russian, with commentary from famous astrophysicists like Carl Sagan, as well as becoming the subject of pseudo-scientific lore about ancient extraterrestrial contacts.

This article explores the Dogon cosmology about the Sirius star system, analyzing the history of Astronomy in west Africa and the origins of the Dogon knowledge about Sirius's binary nature.

The view from Bandiagara escarpment

Manuscript folio from an 18th century astronomical manuscript from Timbuktu showing the orbits of planets in our solar system


An astonishing anthropological study: The creation myth of the Dogons as recorded by Griaule.

The academic world was first introduced to Dogon cosmology by the pioneering anthropologists on Dogon culture, Marcel Griaule (1898–1956) and his colleague Germaine Dieterlen (1903–1999), both of whom are the only academic sources for the Dogon's Sirius-related material. Virtually all evidence for the Sirius lore is contained in their two books; Dieu d'eau: Entretiensavec Ogotemmelpublished in 1948 and Le Renard pale, published posthumously in 1965. At the time of first publication in 1948, the Dieu d'eau: Entretiensavec Ogotemmel(english title: conversations with Ogotemmêli) was a monumental work of anthropology; never before had such a coherent, mysterious, and deep set of ideas been found, seemingly governing all social life in a community, previously unknown outside west Africa. From that point on, the Griaule “school” became a scholarly cult, investigating the world of words, signs, and mythopoetic correspondences throughout the Dogon and Bambara regions of the French Sudan.

(Haunting Griaule pg 49, Griaule's Legacy, pg 97)

Below is a summary of Griaule's Dogon traditions from which context the traditions about Sirius are taken.

According to the Dogon story of creation, Amma (God) created the universe inside a cosmic egg, and then created 8 principle seeds on which 8 primordial ancestors would nourish themselves based on agriculture. Amma's egg transformed into a double placenta, then Amma created two pairs of twins; the two twin-pairs in the upper half of the placenta were; Nommo Die and Nommo Titiyayne, while the two twin pairs in the bottom half of the placenta were Nommo Semu and Ogo (some translations use the name Yurugu). Ogo then tries to create a world of his own and commits several vile offences in the process including taking a piece of his detached placenta that became the earth, this prompted Namma to sacrifice Ogo's twin; Nommo Semu using Nommo Titiyayne as the executioner. It's from Nommo Semu's sacrifice that creates the star system of Sirius, while the remaining placenta not taken by Ogo is used to create the Sun, Ogo also receives a punishment of circumcision and the blood from this act pollutes Nommo Semu's placenta, causing the appearance of Mars. The story then proceeds with Ogo's punishment by turning him into a fox, Nommo Semu's crucifixion on a cross, and Amma's arrival onto earth by an ark, inorder to purify the earth.

( Sacrifice in Africa pg 126-128, Dogon restudied pg 140-141, African Worlds pg 86)

This very detailed story continues at great length covering the creation story's influence on all facets of Dogon society (which is beyond the scope of this article), but the highlight of the story is that the first elements of space and time; the Sun, Sirius, Earth, Moon and Mars; were born out of violence and inoder to redeem them, a sacrifice of the innocent Nommo Semu had to be made. To combine and summarize the astronomical astrological elements in all publications;

1)The Dogon ritual calendar was dominated by a star system called sigi tolo, (which modern scholars call Sirius A or just Sirius).

2)Sirius had a smaller companion, which is called põ tolo(which modern scholars equate to Digitaria/Sirius B) that is said to orbit Sirius A every 50 years, and is denser than it, being made of a "heavy" metal

3)The path of Sirius B is an elongated oval shape, with Sirius occupying not the

center, but a position near one of the (elliptical) foci

4)There is another companion called emme ya tolo (which we shall call Sirius C), that is four times lighter than Sirius B and orbits around Sirius A

4) There's also another companion star called the “Star of Women” (which we shall call Sirius D).

Since most discourses about these traditions tend to emphasize Sirius A and B, but ignore C and D, for reasons that will become apparent below, we shall mostly ignore the latter two companions and focus on Sirius A and B.

(Modern Mysteries pg 174, Sirius Matters pg 63)


Dogon Fame and worldwide reception: from Carl Sagan to conspiracy theorists

The notion of Sirius having a dwarf star companion (Sirius B) is an astronomical fact; having been postulated by Friedrich Bessel in 1844, and observed by Alvan Clark in 1862. But the mystery is how could the Dogon know this without contact with the Clark's works and lacking modern astronomical equipment, (since it's impossible for the naked eye to see the white dwarf in the years before the mid-19th century; given the number of astronomical constraints at the time). Adding more to the mystery, the measure of Sirius B's density provided by Griaule's Dogon traditions is equivalent to ρ = 9 × 103 gr cm−3, which is three orders of magnitude near the average density of a white dwarf.

( Why Was the Companion of Sirius pg 174-175, Sirius Matters pg 62)

The revelation that the Dogon had a deeply scientific and very modern knowledge of the Sirius system was monumental, and Griaule's works were widely read across the world and translated into several languages including Russian and Japanese. The Dogon knowledge about Sirius's binary nature gained even further publicity after pseudo-scientist ("UFO-ologist") Robert Temple wrote a book in 1976 entitled “The Sirius Mystery” that attracted the attention of respected astrophysicists including Carl Sagan and space journalist James Oberg. I'll leave the pseudo-scientific aspect of Temple's work, their influences, and their subsequent criticism, at this point, as they are beyond the scope of this article and have been treated better in an excellent forum post that I have uploaded in pdf below, as well as in Holberg's chapter referenced below.

( Dogon Alien “Mystery” Demystified by Isaac koi, Sirius, Modern mysteries by Holberg)


Critical re-examination of Griaule's Dogon traditions

Griaule's Dogon traditions about Sirius were so unusual in their seeming astronomical and astrophysical detail and specificity, that they generated an enormous amount of subsequent interest and dispute, especially in the field of anthropology, where Griaule's form of ethnography (termed the "Griaule school") was coming under strong criticism as early as the 1960s and 70s, most notably by Dirk Lettens in 1971. But it was the anthropologist Walter van Beek, whose 1991 article "Dogon restudied", heralded a new wave of critical works which discredited many (but not all) of Griaule's findings and methods of study.

(The feedback effect pg 160-161)

In Van Beek's study of the Dogon, he found that;

1) the Dogon don't have the form of proper/harmonized creation myth that is widely shared across the community as Griaule presents it. The figure of Ogo is mostly unknown, so are many of the themes used in Griaule's creation story. Dogon society is not dominated by religion or religious matters and neither the aspect of Twins, nor of Astronomy given significant importance in Dogon religion.

2)the Dogon know about Sirius (and the other visible celestial bodies) and they call it dana tolo (rather than sigi tolo), they know it as "the hunter's star" (rather than the "Dog star" as Mediterranean cultures called it), with the game and the hunting dogs being represented by Orion's belt. But in Dogon cosmology, the position of the Sun and the phases of the moon are more important, while Sirius' position in the Dogon's ritual calendar is virtually non-existent. For this reason, the Dogon (whom Van Beek studied) don't know of S irius' binary nature and its relative density (just like every society on earth prior to 1862 and the majority of people today who are otherwise uninterested in astronomy), nor did they claim that it has other companions (Sirius C and D) as claimed by Griaule.

(Dogon restudied pg 148-150)

Pointing to Sirius, using Orion’s belt (Sirius Matters, pg 6)


The Sirius star in modern astronomy, and the one pre-Dogon speculation about Canis Majoris' binary nature.

Sirius A, the "Dog star" (called α CMa / α Canis Majoris / Alpha Canis Majoris) is the brightest star in the night sky, is undoubtedly an outstanding celestial body and has been known across various societies around the world with or without traditions of mathematical astronomy. Considering the immediate Solar neighborhood, Sirius A is the brightest star visible on earth besides our sun, and has been so for around the last 90,000 years (ie; most of the history of modern humans); because it is relatively close to us (the 5th closest star system) thus it appears bright, and also because it is intrinsically brighter than most stars. Its therefore unsurprising that it appears in Dogon cosmology.

( Sirius Matters pg 52-54)

But the presumed companions of Sirius are what set Griaule's Dogon traditions apart. Before the Dogons, the only other speculation about Sirius' binary nature prior to its scientific postulation by Bessel was in a short work by Voltaire (1752), in which the latter mentioned that "on one of the planets that circle around the star Sirius". But the speculation that Voltaire knew of Sirius's binary nature proved to be unlikely given his minimal interest in the matter; the more likely explanation being Voltaire's belief in the plurality of worlds that was upheld by most encyclopediasts of his time.

(Sirius Matters pg 57-58)

Sirius A and B (tiny dot on the left), image obtained from a 60-inch telescope (Sirius Matters, pg 78)


A history of the Dogon, and their position in precolonial West-africa's political landscape.

The Dogon were never an "isolated tribe" nor did their traditions and religious practices (in which Sirius was claimed to be central) preserving the vestiges of a uniquely "Sudanic culture/religion" as implied by Griaule . Rather, the Dogon had for long interacted with the various societies, kingdoms and empires of the western Sudan (the region west of Timbuktu). Prior to the Dogon's migration into the Bandiagara region, the latter was home to the enigmatic "Tellem" people, who were offshoots of soninke speakers from the Ghana empire and are associated with a rich artistic tradition (that was inherited by the Dogons), as well as the construction of the 800-year old Nando mosque, presumably the prototype of the Djenne and Sankore (Timbuktu) mosques -- although other historians argue that the mosque was likely of more recent Dogon construction, and stands as a "bold proclamation of Dogon cultural identity."

( Sahel Art and Empires pg 144, 169-170 Dogon images and Traditions pg 182-191,)

Soninke (Tellem) and Mande (Dogon) migrations to the Bandiagara escarpment

The nando mosque


After the Dogon's arrival to the Bandiagara in the 15th century from their original homeland of Mande at the heart of the Mali empire, they were marginally affected by Mali and Songhai's expansion in the 14th-16th century, but direct contact with and adoption of Islam begun in earnest with the emergence of the theocratic empires of Massina and Tukulor of the 19th century where the Dogon played a very central role primary foes of the former (who had deployed Hamitic themes in the tarikh al-fattash to justify their enslavement) and as allies of the latter so much that Bandiagara became the Tukulor's third capital (after Segu and Nioro). While the Dogon were largely animist (non-islamic) upto the mid-19th century, during which they had been practicing various forms of highly complex but localized religions centered around temples/shrines, they eventually gradually adopted Islam in the late 19th century, and were most likely exposed to the intellectual productions of 19th century Tukulor empire (that also included Timbuktu), which were inturn borne out of a millennia-old scholarly tradition in west Africa, whose subjects of interest included Astronomy.

(The Bandiagara emirate by Joseph Bradshaw)

Dogon homes

The Binou shrine

the Kargue-Dogon mosque

Palace of the last Tukulor ruler, Aguibou Tall in Bandiagara

a chief's palace in bandiagara


A history of mathematical astronomy, West African astronomy in 18th century Timbuktu, and modern Astronomy in the 19th century.

The city of Timbuktu was a major scholarly center in medieval west Africa, it inherited and engaged in the tradition of Islamic learning since the 12th century, part of which was dedicated to mathematical Astronomy. Unlike some sciences which have multiple independent origins, the fundamentals of mathematical astronomy in the Old world (which ultimately led to the observation of Sirius B in 1862) were invented in ancient Babylon and subsequently transmitted and innovated across multiple cultures in an almost linear fashion. As the astronomy historian Otto Neugebauer famously put it; "Nowhere within ancient civilizations known to us did the sciences (of Astronomy) originate independently, neither in pre-Hellenic nor in early Greek civilization, in the ancient Near East, on the iranian plateau, nor in pre-Arian or Arian India -with the sole exception of Mesopotamia, probably in the early second millenium (barring China and Meso-america). It is at this single center that abstract mathematical thought first appeared, affecting, centuries later, neighbouring civilizations, and finally spreading like a contagious disease"

(A history of Ancient mathematical astronomy pg 557)

The mediaeval Islamic astronomers established their success in that field, based on the foundations of Babylonian, Greek, Roman, Indian and Persian astronomy, and it's from these that the Islamized west African astronomers inherited and innovated their own mathematical astronomical sciences within their local and regional intellectual context in centers such as Timbuktu which was home to several astronomers and its old libraries preserve dozens of Astronomical works, but few have been studied and translated.

The sole study on Timbuktu's astronomical works (and just the second study on African astronomy after Neugebauer's study of Ethiopian astronomy) was an educational treatise on astronomy that was copied in Timbuktu in 1723. It was a commentary written by Abul Abbas; a Timbuktu scholar, about the work of Mohammed bin Ya-aza, a Moroccan scholar. The treatise explains the purposes of studying astronomy; guiding people on and off the sea, determining calendars, decorating the sky and determining prayer times. It also includes precise definitions and calculations of Islamic calendars, month, leap years, and provides a geocentric model of the solar system with the then 7 "classical planets"; from mercury to Saturn, plus the moon. (note that modern planets since Unarus were invisible until discovered by telescopes in 1781, and that geocentric models were generally not replaced by the modern heliocentric models until Copernicus and Galileo in the 16th/17th century.

(African cultural astronomy pg 183-187)

The millennia-old astronomical traditions across the Old world were subsequently innovated in the Islamic world and transmitted into medieval Europe; directly through Spain and indirectly through translations of Arabic works, where they were further innovated as part of a broader intellectual renascence, which ultimately led to the innovation of astronomical equipment through which the previously invisible companion of Sirius was observed in 1862.

(see Mathematical Astronomy in Copernicus's De Revolutionibus by Neugebauer and Islamic Science and the Making of the European Renaissance by George Saliba)

Abul Abbas's 18th century astronomical manuscript from Timbuktu, another manuscript showing the rotation of the planets


Contextualizing the Dogon knowledge about Sirius B.

With regards to explaining Griaule's Dogon traditions about Sirius B that he collected in the late 1940s, it's instructive to note that all of it was fairy widely known in academic circles of late 19th century Europe and was in public domain by 1926, the subluminous nature of its white dwarf companion was becoming apparent in the period 1910 to 1915. The high mass and the elliptical orbit were known for fifty years before that, and the reported sightings of a third body in the Sirius star system(ie; Sirius C) date from the early 1920s. This isn't to include the Dogon's knowledge about Mars and Saturn, the latter of which, as I explained above, is the last visible planet and was known in classical astronomy (although, knowledge of Saturn is fairly common across many societies so it need not to have been transmitted to the Dogon)

(Sirius Modern Mysteries pg 177-178)

In the meantime, the Dogon, then under colonial rule by the last decade of the late 19th century, had been in extensive contact with several figures who were at the very least, familiar with the available public knowledge about the modern astronomical discoveries regarding Sirius B, prior to Griaule's first visit to the Bandiagara in 1931. From the time of French colonial conquest of the Bandiagara capital of the Tukulor empire in April 1893 (they had already captured Segu in April 1890 and Nioro on January 1, 1891), there was likely indirect contact with the Dogons by way of a scientific mission led by Henri Deslandres to observe the solar eclipse April 1893 which travelled through parts of the former Tukulor empire, there was also direct contact with a quasi-anthropological mission led by Louis Desplagnes into the Bandiagara escarpments in 1905, and from 1907, there were a number of missionaries and mission schools active across the Dogon country and Mali from which cursory information about Sirius B could be obtained.

(Sirius Matters pg 65-66, Sahel Art and Empires pg 168)

The most likely origin of the Dogon claims of Sirius' companions however, were very likely to have been Griaule himself and his (now discredited) methods of study. He often confronted his informants with items, be they artifacts, plants, animals, or stars, and expected them to provide adequate information immediately, presenting them with an array of etic data (such as star maps and astronomical data) to elicit a presumably endlessly detailed cultural response. While Griaule had no background in astronomy, the information he obtained didn't require anything beyond a cursory encounter with the kind of information about Sirius in western press. Its therefore unsurprising that, besides the stories of Sirius's companions, Griaule's version of the Dogon creation myth is littered with Abrahamic themes; possibly obtained from himself (ie; biblical) or supplementing the Dogon's knowledge of Islam. These included motifs of crucifixion and the ark (which are Biblical) , and in other stories; the inclusion of the names Adama and Hawa (which are Islamic). Van Beek recorded even more Islamic themes among the Dogons about Noah's curse in the creation of White (European colonists) and Black (Dogons), that are strikingly similar to the Hamitic themes popularized in the 19th century tarikh al-fattash, which positioned the Dogons and other non-Islamic antagonists of the Massina as "black" against the Fulbe elite who called themselves "bidan".

(Dogon restudied pg 156-157, 152, Sultan, Caliph pg 231-232)

It's likely that in his questionable process of study, Griaule's own knowledge had been refracted back to him through his (very small circle of) informants, which, added to his position of authority backed by a colonial presence on his part, and on the Dogon side; a small circle of crucial and creative informants, had created this feedback fueled by a courtesy bias (to not disappoint him) and monetary realism (they were paid informants). It is therefore unsurprising that there have been no new elaborations about Griaule's version of the Dogon traditions about Sirius since his passing in 1956, only critiques and entirely new anthropological research. And that other anthropologists have encountered multiple examples of this sort of feedback especially among the Dogon, but also across the field in general. What initially appears as a "Dogon anomaly" operating under totally different cultural premises; where an elaborate set of myths were intricately association with institutions, turned out to be

"a work of ethnofiction, a fitting tribute to the joint creativity of anthropologist and informants"

(Dogon restudied pg 152-155, Haunting Griaule, pg 49-50, 57, The Feedback effect in modern Dogon culture )

With regards to Sirius in particular, Griaule's Dogon informant Ambara, didn't speak about Sirius in terms of a double-star system, but about stars of different generations, meaning two adjacent stars in the sky, which were to be considered as father and son to Sirius as a "grandfather." These stars, which were also identified by Van Beek's informant, were simply the two other stars of the so-called "Dog constellation" that are quite visible and were fairly well known across multiple societies, so Griaule must have interpreted the information given by Ambara and Yebene in a different fashion, as a system of double and triple stars. Making it equally likely that Griaule simply misunderstood an otherwise interesting aspect of Dogon cosmology.

(Dogon restudied pg 157, Sirius Matters pg 6-7)

Sky photograph of the Canis Majoris constellation, with Sirius as the brightest star in the neighborhood.

the other constellations close to Sirius's constellation


Conclusion: A 'Sirius Distraction' from Dogon history.

What has made the Dogon society so intensely intriguing to modern scholars -perhaps more than any other group in West Africa is their knowledge of cosmology which parallels conventional science. If we restrict our analysis of this Dogon knowledge to Sirius B, we can safely conclude that, like virtually all mathematical astronomical traditions in every society across the world, the Dogon's knowledge of Sirius' invisible companion was yet another example of transmitted knowledge (albeit, a modern one) that was innovated into their local intellectual/religious context.

If we extend our analysis of Dogon knowledge to include its rich cosmological and mythological corpus as presented by Griaule, we can see that Dogon mythology is doubtlessly intriguing and warrants it's modern interest. With regards to Griaule's study, it's important to note that Van Beek's critique of Griaule's anthropology is far from conclusive, the critical response from Van Beek's peers in his own article (see its bottom section pg 158-163), and other scholars such as Andrew Apter's cautious defense of Griaule's findings; shows that much of Griaule's work wasn't simply "a product of his creative and fertile imagination".

(Griaule's Legacy by Andrew Apter)

The extensive corpus of Dogon mythology, art, cosmology, religion, architecture, and their role in the 19th century Sudanic empires, constitutes an important contribution to the history of west Africa that shouldn't be overlooked in favor of sensationalist discoveries about a single star.

The Dogon may not have seen an invisible star with their naked eyes, but like ancient astronomers, they did look up into the night sky from their lofty homes on the Bandiagara cliffs, and pondered the mysteries of the universe.



List of references (underlined books are available in the download folder below)

Sirius Matters by Noah B rosch

African cultural astronomy by Jarita C. Holbrook et al

A history of Ancient mathematical astronomy by Otto Neugebauer

Dogon images and Traditions by Huib Blom

The Bandiagara emirate by Joseph Bradshaw

Sultan, Caliph, Renewer of the faith by M. Nobili 

Sahel Art and Empires by Alisa LaGamma

African Worlds By Daryll Forde

Sacrifice in Africa By Luc de Heusch

Sirius, Modern Mysteries, by Holberg

Why Was the Companion of Sirius not seen prior to 1862? by Francois Wesemael and Rene racine

Griaule's Legacy : Rethinking "la parole claire" in Dogon Studies, by Andrew Apter

Dogon restudied : A Field Evaluation of the Work of Marcel Griaule by W. van Beek

Haunting Griaule: Experiences from the Restudy of the Dogon by W. van Beek

Dogon Alien “Mystery” Demystified by Isaac koi

The feedback effect in modern Dogon culture by Bocary Guindo, Petr A. Kutsenkov


link 


Comments

No comments found for this post.