Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

"Although the modern practice of racial identification is intended to be neutral and descriptive, it easily slides, in the case of ancient Egypt, into a concept of ancestral homelands… Today, these are troubled waters which most people who write about ancient Egypt from within the mainstream of scholarship tend to avoid"

-Barry Kemp

There's no topic in modern historiography more fraught with controversy than the question of race in ancient Egypt. Ever since the creation of modern Egyptololgy in the 19th century during the height of colonialism, theories about the development of ancient Egypt and its relationship with neighboring societies have been invariably tied to the political and cultural biases of the scholars engaged in reconstructing its history. While the more outlandish theories on cultural diffusionism were discredited in recent times by more professional Egyptologists, and question of ancient Egyptians' race was deemed irrelevant, the essentialist discourses on "ethnicity" continue to dominate contemporary analysis of ancient Egyptian society and its interactions with foreigners. In particular, Egypt's relationship with ancient Nubia is often implicitly framed within modern racial and colonial constructs in which the two civilizations are perceived as culturally and racially distinct societies, whose differences most scholars claim can be seen in archeological and genetic records.

In this article, I explore the social construct of "ethnicity' in ancient Egypt with a particular focus on Egypt's interaction with its southern neighbor; Nubia in order to answer the question of whether ancient Egypt was "black".

The sequence of topics begins with investigating whether the Neolithic societies that developed into Egypt and Nubia were culturally dissimilar; followed by how ethnicity was defined in ancient Egypt, followed by how Egypt's foreigners were given distinct ethnonyms, followed by whether it's possible to identify acculturated foreigners in Egypt, followed by the history of 'scientific racism' in Egyptology, and I conclude with the answer to the question 'were ancient Egyptians black?'

"Nubian" elites in the tomb of Ramesses III, 12th century BC


An almost indistinguishable Neolithic "cultural spectrum": the Naqada and A-Group cultures.

The state of ancient Egypt developed in the final era of the Naqada neolithic in the region of "upper Egypt" around 3200BC, and thereafter expanded its territory to include "lower Egypt". In the course of its history, ancient Egypt managed to establish and later lost control over different neighboring regions such as Lower Nubia (1st-2nd cataract), upper Nubia (2nd to 6th cataract), and the Levant (Syro-Palestine). The term "Egyptian" in this article refers to the diverse groups of people that occupied the abovementioned regions that were politically dominated by ancient Egypt to varying degrees from the 4th to the 1st millennium BC. The state of ancient Kush/Kerma developed around 2500BC out of several Neolithic cultures in lower and upper Nubia, most notably the "A-group" culture, early Kerma culture and C-group culture. The name Kush is used to refer to the kingdoms centered at Kerma, Napata, and Meroe as a continuous political and cultural entity (dominated by Meroites, ie; "Meroitic" speakers), with each period of the Kushite kingdom being designated by the name of its capital city. The term "Nubian" is more accurately used to refer to speakers of the Nubian language who were also present in the kingdom of Kush since the 3rd century BC and later founded the medieval Christian Nubian kingdoms after the 5th century AD, But the term "Nubian" in this article refers to the diverse groups of people who occupied the geographic region of ancient Nubia (1st-6th cataract) from the 4th to the 1st millennium BC.

Two of the main Neolithic cultures along the Nile valley in the 4th millennium BC


One observation that frequently shows up in studies of north-east African societies during the Neolithic (late stone-age era) is how archeological material recovered along the entire stretch of the Nile from southern Egypt to Khartoum in central Sudan, is fairly uniform well into the 5th and 4th millennium BC. In particular, the broad similarity of the A-Group culture (3800-3000BC) in Nubia with that of the Naqada culture (3900-3000BC )in Egypt, should be seen in this context of a shared Neolithic tradition and its regional variations. In both traditions, there was an increased in reliance on domesticated plants and animals (goats, sheep, cattle and pigs) rather than hunting and gathering (which instead acquired a more symbolic/ritualized meaning), there was some long distance trade (wine, ivory, ebony and copper) particularly with other regional cultural groups but also distant ones (the Levant, red sea, central Sudan), and both cultures buried their elites in elaborate graves with luxury grave goods, which indicated greater social stratification and the emergence of incipient states at defined capitals (eg Hierakonpolis and Qustul), and the material culture all across the Nile valley was fairly homogenous.

(The politics of trade pg 27-36, The oxford handbook pg 290-291)

Cultural exchange between the Naqada and Nubian cultures appears to have been determined by geographic distance so much that both cultures tended to blend into a spectrum that's almost indistinguishable at the center; the material culture of the northernmost A-Group sites contains a significant number of Naqada imports versus the southernmost A-Group sites. The volume of these Naqada imports to local goods on a north to south gradient in A-Group Nubia suggests that the nature of exchange was mostly localized between "next-door" neighbors and rarely "commercial" type conducted between foreign groups. A focal point in this cultural spectrum was the A-group capital at Qustul, where a form of reciprocal gift-giving occurred between its elites and those based at Naqada. This relationship was likely predicated on the presence of "shared traditions and cultural practises, denoting power" between the two societies, and led to the production of the Qustul burners with their syncretic iconography. The A-group inturn, exported some Nubian manufactures into Naqada territory, especially at Elephantine, where 20% of pottery was imported from A-group Nubia, and in less significant amounts at Hierakonpolis and several other sites. However, the bulk of goods exported to Egypt from A-group Nubia were likely commodities.

(The politics of trade pg 53-5, 64, 139, 165-6, 202-10, 213-17, 310-311)

incense burner from Qustul, ca. 3200BC, oriental institute of chicago


In summary:

Having explored the observably similar traditions and cultural practices between the societies of Naqada and A-group Nubia, the question now is why and how were these very close societies separated ideologically, that we eventually come to perceive them as different entities, or even as different "ethnic groups".


Origin of the term "Nubian": State development and the emergence of ethnic identities

Among the earliest depictions of "foreigners" in Egyptian art are the 'victory inscriptions' carved on a rock in the region of lower Nubia at Gebel Sheikh Suleiman (near Buhen, 2nd cataract) that have been dated to the reign of Pharaoh Djer or Djet around 3000BC. They depict bound war-captives labeled Stj (Nubia) with one attached to the prow of a boat, while another shows a scorpion flanked by armed attendants and dragging a bounded prisoner. The stylized nature of these bounded prisoners however makes it unlikely to be identified as similar to the stereotyped figures of Nubians that would be used in later Egyptian art. This is especially relevant considering the similarity of this inscription in lower nubia with another victory inscription at Gebel Tjauti in upper Egypt, which depicts an invasion of a lower Egyptian chiefdom by the Naqada-based kings, using the same scorpion figure dragging bounded captives.

(The politics of trade pg 217-222, Gebel Sheikh Suleiman pg 131-132)


Other depictions of Nubian war captives include; a "year-label" found at Abydos and dated to King Aha (c. 3050BC) that appears to depict a prisoner who is identified by the Stj, and is named Ta-Seti ‘the land of the bow’ (using the name of the southernmost province/nome of Dynastic Egypt). There is also a 2nd dynasty stela found at Hierakonpolis depicting a kneeling figure with a bow on his head. These two figures testify to developing ideas of ʻusʼ versus ʻthem, but at this stage, they only contain the ethnonym of what would later become part of the "stereotypical" iconography of a vanquished foreign enemy, in this case, a Nubian (stj). Conversely, there is one piece of inscriptional evidence not far from this time period that points to direct and cooperative contact between Old kingdom Egypt and ancient Nubia, its a 3rd dynasty (2670-2613 BC) stela found at Helwan belonging to a man named Sisi, who has been identified as 'Upper Nubian' (presumably from early-Kerma?) that was resident in Egypt.

(The politics of trade pg 235, 226, 227, Ethnic Identities pg 3-4 )

The appearance of a discernable "self" versus "other" in the material cultural record of the interactions between the two emerging polities of Egypt and Nubia points to the emergence of a kind of "ethnic" identity that's vaguely identifiable in archeological record. In a broad sense, the concept of ethnicity is based on commonalities such as ancestry, language, cultural practices and territory. Ethnicity is fluid, overlapping and mutable and is in constant flux of inclusion and exclusion ("self" versus "other") contingent on prevailing political and social circumstances. In ancient Egypt, the concept of the "ethnic self" remained largely localized despite the development of a centralized state, as Gerald Moers writes; "forms of identity relating to Egypt as a whole (that is ‘ethnic’, ‘cultural’, or even ‘national’ Egyptian identity) do not seem to play a very signifcant role even for the inter-regionally operating elites". A person in Egypt expressed their identity in relation to their family, village, or town, and also engaged in "other-ing" people who were living inside Egypt but not from his local region (and whom we today would consider "fellow Egyptians"). Importantly; neither of these two people had the concept of being an "Egyptian national" as their primary self-identification. As one ancient Egyptian who composed the Story of Sinuhe 1875 BC, describes his time in the Levant that "it was like a Deltan seeing himself in Elephantine, like a man of the marshland in Nubia" To him, a person from the Nile Delta was as foreign in the Egyptian city of Elephantine as someone from Nubia, even if the first two regions are firmly located in ancient Egypt. Yet despite the predominance of this localized identity however, there emerged an "imperial identity" among the Egyptian elite who engaged in "othering the other" in the context of trans-regional politics (eg military conflict and conquest), these elites created categories of ethnic foreigners based on pre-existing dynamics of othering within Egypt. This elite didn't represent a cohesive whole but also included people whom we would consider "Egyptianized foreigners". For this reason; anyone was considered "Egyptian" if they "inhabited the urban zones of the Nile Valley, spoke Egyptian language, worshipped Egyptian gods, and was loyal to the Egyptian state"

(Fuzzy Boundaries pg 693-701, Wretched kush pg 1-3,10-19, Ethnic Identities pg 10)


In summary;

As Egypt expanded, the secondary and very politicized sense of an "imperial self" was further reified, against the "imperial other" (ie foreign enemies/competitors such as Nubians, Lybians, Syro-Palestines) that had to be "vanquished". The period around the 1st dynasty marks the first appearance of the geo-political entities of Egypt and Nubia (Ta-Seti). Importantly, Ta-seti's origin as the name of the southernmost province of Egypt, that was later used as an ethnonym for the people near that province, provides further evidence for the political rather than "ethnic" origin of the ethnonyms used to describe those who were considered "imperial others" in ancient Egypt, and also underpins the emergence of later terms for Nubians such as "Nehasyu" and "Kush".


Origin of the terms "Nehasyu" and "Kush": Warfare and Politics on the Nile between Middle kingdom Egypt, C-group Nubia and Kerma.

Middle kingdom Egypt, C-group and Kerma kingdom in the 3rd millennium Bc


The archaeological evidence of the A-Group disappears with the beginning of the 1st Dynasty in Egypt, possibly due to a combination of climate change and Egypt's control of the trade system from which the A-group chieftains derived their power. The A-group response to this decline in wealth (but not necessarily physical conquest) was a change in settlement patterns, some moved to Egypt with one wealthy A-group Nubian settlement identified at Armant near Luxor, and others to the eastern desert at El-Arib. A-Group Nubians therefore neither disappeared nor completely lost their socio-political complexity, but adjusted to the social-economic realities with some moving into Egypt and some staying in Nubia. During this time, other Nubian neolithic cultures continued to flourish beyond the 2nd cataract including the pre-Kerma culture which would became the nucleus of the Kerma kingdom, but it wasn't until 2500BC that lower nubia was re-occupied by a different Nubian polity; the C-group culture.

(The Oxford Handbook pg 136-138, 145)

The C-group Nubians, who likely constituted remnants of A-group Nubians, Kerma Nubians and the eastern Sahara, inhabited lower Nubia between 2500 to 1500 BC, they established their unique form of political organization. By 2500BC, the 5th dynasty Egyptian Pharaoh Snefru claimed to have attacked the land of Nehes, the latter being a toponymn later used to construct the ethnonym Nehesy for the people of Lower Nubia, and later came to include include nomads in the Eastern desert and even people from Punt. The term Ta-Nehasyu simply meant ‘Land of the Nubians’, and these appear among several other "vanquished foreigners" in the pyramid complexes of several Egyptian kings of the 5th and 6th Dynasties, yet these depictions only reflected an ambition to control Nubia rather than the actual reality on the ground as no conquest had been achieved at this stage. In his autobiography, the egyptian official Weni of the 6th dynasty (c. 2350-2170BC) describes putting together an army of mercenaries composed of men from Wawat, Irtjet, Yam, Medja and Kaau in which he uses the term Nehasyu when naming each group, and similar Nehesy mercenaries appear in ancient Egyptian art as allied foreigners resident in Egypt. Some of these toponyms were also used in the autobigraphy of Harkhuf ( 2290–70 BC) and they corresponded to the C-Group polities that would by the time of his third expedition in 2280BC, be united under one name; Wawat, but the ethnonym Nehesy remained in use to describe the inhabitants of this unified polity.

(The oxford handbook pg 157-175)

The Middle kingdom Egyptians invaded and thereafter occupied Lower Nubia from ca. 1938 to 1725 BC, in response to the spectacular emergence of the kingdom of Kerma (initially referred to as Yam in the Middle kingdom texts mentioned above). Ancient states like Egypt did not expand into neatly bounded territorial zones, but instead grew through a complex mosaic of direct and hegemonic control that depended on the establishment of frontier zones according to the strength of rival states. In this case of the Egyptian expansion into Lower Nubia, this involved the construction of massive forts which served on the one hand a purely military role in support of punitive campaigns further to the south (with the ultimate objective of conquering Kerma) and also as; static defense, as well as to administer the local population and control riverine trade. The Middle Kingdom names of the Nubian forts present the threatening face of a formidable conqueror, even if this wasn't reflected in reality, names like “Overthrowing the Nubians” (Askut), “Curbing-the-Foreign-Countries” (Shalfak), “Subduer-of-the-Seti-land (or: SetiuNubians)” (Semna South). It's in this context of aggression that the name Kush (KAs) was found at the fortress of Buhen in a stela dated to 1830BC, this stela contained a list of prisoners presented to pharaoh Senusret I, and "Kush" thereafter remains the predominant ethnonym of Nubian populations used in Egyptian texts.

(Between two worlds pg 87-89 wretched Kush pg 75-78)


In summary:

For both Nehesy and Kush, we again encounter the creation of ethnonymns based on political contexts rather than "ancestral origin". The "Nubians" called Nehesy didn't encompass the A-group Nubians that were by then assimilated into Egypt, but they instead referred to the "foreign Nubians" within the still independent C-group kingdom that Egypt wished to subdue. When this region was conquered, the main etnnonym used became Kush rather than Nehesy, to refer to the inhabitants of the still-independent Kerma kingdom further south that the Egyptians wished to subdue. That the additional term "wretched-Kush" that was only used for Kush (and related to a similar one used for "Vile Asiatics") but was never used for A-group and C-group Nubians might reflect the relative autonomy that persisted in Kush even after its conquest in 1500 BC, with the last recorded rebellion happening in 1208 BC.

As Susan Cohen writes about the "Vile Asiatic" term in Egyptian texts; it

"functioned primarily as defensive or preventative magic, serving to uphold the ideological trope of Egyptian superiority and control over foreign places and their peoples, but which may not necessarily have reflected a contemporary factual reality" (Not so vile pg 86),

similarly Laszlo Torok writes that "Wretched Kush” was a powerful stereotype connoting inferiority. While it was used magically in the context of ritual acts and representations in order to forestall the success of eventual Nubian rebels, it does not seem to have governed the everydays of Egyptian-Nubian coexistence on the Middle Nile.

(Between two worlds pg 20)


Identifying "Nubian populations" in the New Kingdom provinces of Lower and upper Nubia: Askut, Tombos and the curious case of Hekanefer

Political maps of Egypt and Nubia in the Middle Kingdom, Second IntermediatePeriod, and New Kingdom


By the 17th century BC, the armies and people of Kerma moved into Lower Nubia upto the 1st cataract, not in a violent conquest as has often been suggested, but by coopting the old Egyptian infrastructure of fortress-settlements. Archaeologically, Kermans are attested in small numbers in Lower Nubia through their distinctive burial practices, but the colony was run using a hegemonic strategy coopting Egyptian administrators like Ka and Sepedhor of Buhen, the descendants of Egyptian settlers who had established the Middle Kingdom fortress system over a hundred years before. Their stelae indicate clearly that they had shifted their allegiance from Pharaoh to the Kerman ruler of Kush.

(Wretched Kush pg 79-83)

Resurgent under the militaristic Pharaohs of the New Kingdom, the Egyptian state reconquered Lower Nubia, defeated the Hyksos and conquered Syro-Palestine, they then sacked Kerma itself in 1500 BC and had permanently incorporated its entire territory by the late 15th century BC. The administration of Nubia was placed under the Viceroy of Kush, who had two “deputies,” one in charge of Wawat and the other in charge of Kush. Nubians rose as high as the rank of “deputy,” and filled many of the posts in the Egyptian administration, with princes administering the countryside, and mayors in urban centers. Now subjects of Egypt, the Nubians became acculturated but this was greatly determined by geographic distance, with lower nubian elites being more "acculturated/egyptianized" than upper nubian elites, and the southernmost extent for "Egyptian settlers" was restricted to the 3rd cataract and even then limited to small settlements within the pre-existing "overwhelmingly Nubian" in population. New Kingdom Egypt's imperial policy that encouraged local autonomy in Nubia was also used in Egypt's conquered territory of Syro-Palestine with light settlements and acculturated vassals.

(Wretched Kush pg 84-96)

In the study of cultural-histories, essentialist interpretations that viewed material cultures as representing distinct ethnic groups/diasporas have since been discarded by recent research showing that there is a considerable degree of variability in the archaeological correlates expressing ethnic identity, even within a putative ethnic group. Scholars now consider historical, social, and archaeological context of the artifacts inorder to understand how they might function as an expression of ethnic identity. In other words; "A pot is not a person".

(Wretched Kush pg 30-32)


Despite this academic shift however, attempts at identifying the Nubian population in archeological record of New kingdom Egypt's nubian provinces have proved contentious, an example is presented by recent archeological digs in Askut and Tombos lower and upper Nubia. Both sites show a predominately Egyptian material culture and architecture, but with a significant number of Nubian cookpots in the former, and possible Nubian burial practices in the latter, that have been interpreted as an expression of Nubian identity by the acculturated Nubians in an Egyptian cultural setting. Yet even this interpretation is contested, as a more plausible interpretation for the increased use of Nubian cookpots at Askut "does not necessarily reflect a change in ethnic identity, but rather the change in habitus" and the evidence presented for Tombos burials has been considered inadequate .

(Wretched kush pg 197-201, Ethnic identities pg 32-33, 41-42)


It was in the New kingdom era (ie; after 1650 BC) that "imperial otherness" was firmly defined among the Egyptian elite, with some texts such as the Hymn to Aten composed in the 14th century BC, stating that "You created the world in your fashion, Of all the foreign lands, from Syria to Nubia and the land of Egypt, Their tongues (ns.w) are separate in speech (md.t) and their natures (ḳd=sn) as well; Their skins (jnm=sn) are distinguished, as you distinguished the foreign peoples". The three main ethnic “others” outside Egyptian territory, included the Libyans to the north and west, Asiatics to the north and east, and Nubians to the south. Their ethnic identities were constructed with unambiguous symbols of identity (ie stereotyping) that were depicted through differences in physical features, language and dress. This "otherring" only served to legitimate elite power to an internal Egyptian audience vis-a-vis the foreign states and their newly acculturated/Egyptianised subjects. However, it wasn't used to organize social order/categories and was thus unlike "racism"/racial segregation in which racial  "otherness" corresponded to a fixed social category (especially in American slavery). Ethnicity in ancient Egypt therefore never became a social/legal disability to the acculturated "foreigners" who could therefore rise to important ranks in Egypt. Nevertheless, the emphasis on the "otherness" of the acculturated foreigner (Nubian or otherwise) demonstrated the Pharaoh's ability to pacify foreign threats, despite the irrelevance of foreign "ethnicity" in Egyptian social orders.

(Ethnic Identities pg 5-15, wretched Kush pg 21-24, 171-173, 187)

Whenever the New kingdom Pharaoh made a public appearance, his own surroundings emphasized his role as the defender of order against the foreign enemies of Egypt, with ceremonies such as the “viewing the tribute” that were depicted with dramatic scenes showing processions of contrite foreigners presenting their tribute, and below statues of the king. For this reason, the Nubian prince Hekanefer, whose family had been acculturated for well over a hundred years, is depicting wearing his "foreign" Nubian costume and kneeling before Pharaoh inorder to represent the latter's ecumenic dominion over foreign lands. Hekanefer's depiction as a tribute giving "Nubian" stands in sharp contrast to his completely Egyptian depiction in his own tomb, and he would not have been identified by archeologists were it not for the similarity in the names accompanying the two paintings. For the same reason, even high-ranking elites from Egypt's rival powers such as Babylon and Hyksos are depicted in a similarly subservient manner, and paintings of military conflicts with them greatly exaggerated Egypt's might.

(Wretched kush pg 183-184, 173-174, Ethnic identities pg 47-50)

Tomb of Huy, Thebes,1353–1327 B.C 

Hekanefer (one of the figures kneeling on the extreme right of the first half of this photo) leading a procession of Nubian tribute bearers and bowing before Huy (the standing figure facing left towards him) the latter of whom viceroy of Nubia under Tutankhamun (seated figure on the extreme right).

Hekanefer as a typical Egyptian in his damaged tomb in Toshka, lower Nubia


But the stereotypical depictions of foreigners should not be immediately compared to modern racial /phenotypical thinking, because while the "Egyptians" depicted themselves in reddish colours, and showed foreigners such as; Nubians as brown/black, Syro-Palestinians as yellowish and Libyans as whitish-yellowish; they also depicted other foreigners like Aegeans and Puntites as reddish, indicating that the latter shared something with Egyptians that first three don't. Considering the peaceful relationship that the Aegeans and Puntites had with Egypt (given their distance from Egypt) this "something" they shared with Egypt was likely dictated by politics and cosmology. Even more confusingly as shown in the case of Hekanefer, an individual Egyptian's foreign ancestry can be invisible in documents especially if the name is Egyptian,  their "foreign ancestry" could be completely omitted for reasons of decorum, status, or profession. Even the Egyptian term "foreigners" is never used for peoples of actual foreign origin in an Egyptian sociocultural context but was reserved for those foreigners outside of Egypt. Stereotyped foreigners in ancient Egyptian art were therefore only those who were real incomers

(Ethnic identities pg 13-14)

Depiction of the King and Queen of Punt in Deir el-Bahri (1473-1458 BC), Aegean Islanders in the Tomb of Rekhmire ca. 1479–1400 B.C,

Compared it with the bottom painting, depicting Egyptians stringing and Drilling Beads, Tomb of Rekhmire ca. 1504–1425 B.C.


In summary, the example of Heqanefer, and the disputed interpretations of archeological record coming from New kingdom Nubia is instructive in understanding the elusive nature of identifying a distinct "Nubian" identity in ancient Egypt. Without a chance discovery that matched the name of Heqanefer with the stereotyped depiction of a Nubian in the very selective political context of tribute-giving, we would have not been aware of his Nubian ancestry, and we know even less about the ancestry of the people in Askut and Tombos despite our conviction that the population of New kingdom Nubia is unlikely to have moved out after its conquest. We are therefore confronted with a reality that contradicts our preconceptions, depictions of stereotyped brown/black Nubians weren't portraying the "ethnic makeup" of Egypt, but a highly ritualized form of political propaganda, yet they also represent implicit evidence for the acculturation of Nubians into ancient Egyptian society, not as a mixture between two "pristine" ethnic groups, but a cumulative political union set above what was an already ancestrally and ethnically diverse society.


Identifying "Nubian Diasporas" in the core of New kingdom Egypt through archeology and ancient DNA: is a pot, a person? And are human remains ethnic markers?

As introduced above, the primitivist view of ethnicity --in which ethnicity was perceived as fixed and uniform social group with a shared set of beliefs handed down in a continuous tradition, and that ethnic migration as the prime mover in explaining cultural change--, was a central feature of the methodology of culture history including in Egyptology. In this essentialist approach, "archaeological cultures” were equated with bounded and immutable ethnic units, and culture was understood normatively, meaning that cultural practices tend to conform to prescribed norms of behavior. But recent research has shown that "archaeological cultures were not simply there to be found by archaeologists, They were found because they were looked for, and they were looked for by using a particular historically contingent classification method"

(Wretched Kush pg 14-19, Nubian Archers pg 700-702)


One of the long held beliefs in Egyptology was that the presence of Kerman pottery, beakers and arrowheads in the city of Avaris definitively pointed to the existence of Nubian archers presumably in the army of Ahmose. To support this argument, some scholars claimed that the individuals buried just outside the walls of the city “show negroid physical features". But both arguments were grounded in inconsistent evidence, as not only is there no textural record of such Nubian archers in Amhose's army, neither was the supposed Kerman material culture found within the same stratum (ie; not of the same dating), nor are they even related to the burials found outside the walls, and the supposed "negroid" features were never explained. The scholars simply used a circular argument based on their preconceived notions of "negroid" features, which they then correlated with "Nubian/Kerman" cultural markers (arrowheads) to associate two very unrelated phenomena that's also unrecorded.

(Nubian archers pg 707-708)

While there are unlikely to have been Nubian diaspora at Avaris, there's unambiguous evidence of a C-Group diaspora at Hierakonpolis between 2080-1700BC during the Middle Kingdom. Its distinctive C-group nubian tumuli-style burial, with C-group material culture and adornment marks it out distinctively as the most northerly physical presence of the C-Group Nubians thus far discovered in Egypt. Their rich burials in monumental tombs associated with wealthy Egyptian elite In a discrete cemetery adjacent to contemporary egyptian burials shows that the C-Group Nubians had access to the same privileges (if not more) as their Egyptian peers despite the seemingly antagonistic rhetoric towards C-Nubians in official Egyptian documents of the time. By the late occupation phases, the cemetery was still in use but the material became less identifiably Nubian despite isotopic analysis pointing to their continued existence at the site, strongly suggesting an acculturation of the original C-group Nubians.

(The Nubian cemetary at Hierakonpolis pg 57-62)

Related to what has been mentioned above, is the recent hype about ancient DNA and isotope analyses. These new forms of study are mostly based on grouping the ancient remains of individuals sharing genetic traits (derived from inherited haplotypes) that are closer with each other among group members than with those from other groups. And while the analytical methods used might be state of the art, the way the data is sampled and the samples are interpreted is often anything but. Ancient DNA runs into the same problems and limitations as archeologists especially when it comes to determining whether a small sample of human remains represents an entire population group in a given time period, and often times the definition of the "population group" uses the same essentialist criteria explained above, assuming that ethnicities are fixed social groups whose migrations bring about cultural change. For example some studies of ancient DNA from 1st millennium BC Egypt are premised on the presumption that foreign rule in Egypt (by Libyans, Nubians, Persians, Greeks and Romans) necessarily meant that large migrations of people into Egypt who were supposedly not living in Egypt before, worse still was that the actual DNA recovered spanned 2,000 years from just 166 samples, a hopelessly small sample for an society that numbered over 1 million people. Even more problematic are the underlying hypothesis that precedes these studies. In one case, an official named Maiherperi was assumed to be of Nubian identity solely because there is one depiction of him with dark-brown skin and curly hair, and ancient DNA analysis was proposed as a solution to the question of his. The researchers clearly grounded their assumption on racial thinking about what Egyptians and Nubians should "look like", rather than analyzing the historical context and social practices of Maiherperi.

(Ethnic identities pg 53-60)


In summary:

The reason why archeology and ancient DNA analysis alone, fail to provide definitive answers to the question of ethnic identity is that the latter is socially constructed while the former rely on physical and biological realities; in other words; a pot is not a person and human remains aren't ethnic markers. Nevertheless, the existence of a distinctive C-Group community in Middle kingdom Egypt, proves that a multi-disciplinary and critical approach can be used to in a few selected contexts to identify not just the appearance of small communities in a given time period, but also trace their eventual acculturation into the larger society. This provides us with some answers explaining the apparent "disappearance" of acculturated foreigners in archeological data, and attests to the diverse cultural profile of ancient Egypt.


Scientific racism in Egyptology and Nubiology

The modern concept of “race” in which the world was divided into ambiguously defined population groups; caucasiod, mongoloid and negroid, with their biological differences being defined as clear, primordial and unchangeable, was created in the the 19th and 20th century as the culmination of centuries of racial ideas called scientific racism, that had been developing since the Enlightenment. Colonial discourse at the same time constructed the colonized as "degenerate" racial types in order to justify conquest, and scientific racism mirrored the colonial world order with its hierarchy of races in which the white race was considered to be at the top and others races were judged and ordered by their degree of affiliation to it.

(Ethnic identities pg 15-16)

Archaeologies of Egypt and Sudan were also developing in colonial contexts with modern racism and colonialism mutually creating and sustaining each other. Early archaeologists in Egypt and Sudan understood race as directly connected to culture and that some races and their cultures are inferior. Egyptology was (still is) affected by biased and racist beliefs; beginning in the early 20th century with arguments that the ancient Egyptian civilization was the result of a "Dynastic Race" of conquerors from the Near East , a view advanced by founder of modern Egyptian archaeology Flinders Petrie (1917), the "Great White race" theory (by H. Breasted 1926), or that the cultures south of Egypt were inherently inferior because of the presence of "negroid" blood which accounts for a supposed degradation of the material remains (G. Reinser, 1923 C.M. Firth, and W.B. Emery). Pioneering egyptologists used pseudo-scientific methods such as craniometry and eugenics, they also reified pre-existing theories of "race" such as the Hamitic myth and selectively chose stereotypical depictions of foreigners in ancient Egyptian art that fit into their essentialist ideas of race; the most (in)famous of these is the "races of Egypt" painting. Images of vanquished nubian captives were also decontextualized and purposely misinterpreted by American segregationists such as Egyptologist Samuel George Morton who used them to defend black subservience, stating that "the Negro has remained unchanged in Africa, above Egypt, for 8,000 years"

(Nubian Archers in Avaris pg 698-700, Ethnic Identities pg 16-20)

In spite of an extensive anthropological and sociological literature exploring the inherent complexities of ethnicity, and the discrediting of scientific racism, there is a tendency for archaeologists to gravitate, explicitly or implicitly, towards an essentialist perspective of interpreting ancient Egyptian representations of foreigners, especially in art. Contemporary scholars such as Bruce Trigger and Donald Redford occasionally include interpretations of ancient Egyptian art that correlate the different skin colors of stereotyped Nubians with their status and/or origin. In interpreting the plantation scene painting shown below, Trigger surmised that brown Nubians were serfs from lower Nubia while black Nubians were slaves from upper Nubia. In his book "from slave to Pharaoh", Redford argues that the Nubians recognized the inherent superiority of Egyptian imperial administration and sought to replicate it.

(wretched kush pg 202, Decolonizing historiography pg 34-38)


Plantation scene from the tomb of Djehutyhotep, Debeira-East in lower Nubia, c.1500BC

Ancient Egyptians did not have any concept of "race", they barely had a concept of "national identity" and mostly defined themselves in rather localised terms, their attitudes towards peoples were based on cultural status and not on the "racial" categories we recognize today from our immediate past. "The concept of race, although paramount for Egyptology of the early 20th century, has no scientific credibility in modern scholarship". Depictions of alternating brown and black Nubians were not representative of actual phenotypical differences, but were instead optical effects that avoid the visual blending of figures of the same colour. (A similar style appears in medieval Ethiopian art among other examples). And as Jeremy Pope has recently shown, the political structure of imperial Kush (25th dynasty) was not established based on Egyptian models of bureaucracy but on "sudanic models" of a segmentary state

(Ethnic identities pg 8, 23, The Double Kingdom Under Taharqo)



Were ancient Egyptians "black"?

"Egyptian ideology reflects the tendency of individuals to define ethnicity in essentialist terms. Egyptologists tend not only to believe these ideological categorizations, but also actively to subscribe to them because the Egyptian definition of distinctive, bounded groups meets our own expectations"

In trying to answer the question on whether ancient Egyptians could be considered black, we are again confronted with the fluid, contextual nature in which we define "race" in the modern times. A person in the United states is "black" according to a different criteria than that used in Brazil, which is in turn even more different from that used in Sudan. I hope the readers of this article are intuitively familiar with these differences, because explaining them would make it unnecessarily long.

We have seen that individual agency weighs more heavily than the dictates of administrators and ideologues in the day-to-day interactions that characterize ancient Egyptian society. We have also seen that the stereotypical and ideological representations of foreigners in ancient Egyptian texts and iconography are a reference to the process of self-definition and do not target the inhabitants of Egypt of "different descent", as long as they are loyal to the Pharaoh.

So whether we consider that the original inhabitants of the Naqada and A-group Neolithic cultural spectrum included people whom we may consider "black", or whether it was people from C-Group and Kerma that were progressively assimilated into Egypt and "disappeared" from archeological record, that we may also consider "black", or whether it was the stereotypical representations of "foreign" Nubians in Egyptian administration that were depicted as "black", The answer to the question of whether ancient Egypt was "black" is Yes; a section of ancient Egypt's population was by the modern definition "black", in the same way that populations of modern United states, Brazil and Sudan are "black" in varying proportions.



List of references: (underlined books and articles listed are available for download below)


The Politics of Trade: Egypt and Lower Nubia in the 4th Millennium BC by J Roy

The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Nubia by Bruce Williams

Ethnic Identities in the Land of the Pharaohs by Uroš Matić

Wretched Kush by Stuart Tyson Smith

Between Two Worlds: The Frontier Region Between Ancient Nubia and Egypt by László Török 

The Double Kingdom Under Taharqo by Jeremy W. Pope

Gebel Sheikh Suleiman by Claire Somaglino

Fuzzy Boundaries, Festschrift für Antonio Loprieno II, Egyptian identity by Gerald Moers

“Nubian” archers in Avaris by Uroš Matić

De-colonizing the Historiography and Archaeology of Ancient Egypt and Nubia by Uroš Matić

Rhetoric and Reality in Egyptian-Levantine Relationships in Sinai during the Old and Middle Kingdoms by Susan Cohen

The Nubian cemetary at Hierakonpolis by Renée Friedman


link to download folder 

Comments

No comments found for this post.