Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The island of Madagascar became detached from the African continent 150 million years ago and its population today shows strong linguistic and cultural links to Southeast Asia, But Madagascar's political history and recent research on the genetic ancestry of its population reveals that its inhabitants received a significantly large contribution from the African mainland as well.

Madagascar was part of a broad political and cultural zone of the East African coast often called the "Swahili world"; an area stretching from southern Somalia to Mozambique, including the offshore islands of Comoros and Madagascar. This region was dotted with small-scale urban based polities described as city-states, that had for long integrated themselves into the Indian Ocean world using the complimentary systems of regional transshipment trade and long distance trans-oceanic trade.

Beginning in the late 1st millennium, dozens of urban settlements were established along the North-western coast of Madagascar. Their populations, known locally as Antalaotse/Antalaotra, spoke Swahili and other Bantu languages, and their political and cultural institutions were similar to those found in the Swahili city-states. The Antalaotse settlements grew into large city-states by the mid-2nd millennium through extensive trade with the East African coast, and were later transformed into important entreports for the emergent kingdoms in the predominantly Malagasy-speaking interior of Madagascar into which they were gradually integrated.

This article explores the history of the African settlement on Madagascar focusing on the Swahili city-states that were founded on the North-western coast of the Island, to explain why the Swahili language and its Bantu peers eventually declined in modern times in favor of Malagasy.

17th century mausoleum in the ruined city of Mazalagem, Antsoheribory Island, Madagascar.

Map showing the location of modern Swahili-speakers

The first permanent settlements by Africans on the island of Madagascar: the founding of Mahilaka. (8th-14th century)

The east African coast was one of the last wings of expansion of the Bantu-speaking groups at the turn of the common era. These Bantu-speakers were involved in trans-oceanic trade linking the east African coast to the western half of the Indian ocean world, and by the mid-1st millennium had created a "Swahili culture" that extended from Gezira in Somalia to Chibuene in Mozambique, and incorporated the Comoros islands and northwest Madagascar, as well as the African hinterland. Prior to the arrival of the Bantu speakers, the Comoros archipelago is likely to have served as a route for African hunter-gatherers to travel to Madagascar more than 4,000 years ago, although these settlements were impermanent.

(The Swahili world pg 6-7, Stone tools and foraging in northern Madagascar, A critical review of radiocarbon dates)

Major debate surrounds the first human settlement of Madagascar. Its however certain that while the earliest settlements were ephemeral, more permanent settlements were established around the late 1st millennium by groups of Bantu-speakers from the African continent, and Austronesian speakers from south-east Asia. These early settlements at sites like Mahilaka and Nosy Mangabe in the northwest are dated to the 8th-10th centuries. African crops eg sorghum, cowpeas, groundnuts, and animals such as Zebu cattle, wild bush-pig, sheep and goats were introduced by Bantu speakers and retain their original names. These were grown and kept alongside Asian crops and animals like rice, taro, chickens, that were introduced by the Austronesian-speakers.

(Early exchange between Africa pg 214-216,  Africa and the Indian ocean world pg 127-130, The Swahili world pg 109-112)

By the early 2nd millennium, Madagascar became increasingly integrated into the entire Swahili trading network, especially its northwestern coast which became home to important centers of regional trade all connected to the Swahili cities of Kilwa, Malindi, and Mombasa.  Hierarchical societies were established by Swahili  political and commercial elites who were known locally as “Antalaotse" (Ie; “Anti-Alaoutsi”  ‘people of the sea’), the Antalaotse towns were mostly situated in the region from the Bay of Boina to the Bay of Ampasindava. They shared all the notable features of the Swahili civilization, including an adherence to Islam, the Swahili language, superficial "Shirazi" traditions, and a similar political and material culture.

(The worlds of the Indian ocean pg 559-560, Africa and the Indian ocean pg 131)

The oldest of these towns was Mahilaka on the northwest coast. Described as a "Swahili town" by archeologists, it developed into a large urban settlement covering an area of about 70 ha, surrounded by a wall 1.5 km in length and about 600 m wide. Its inhabitants, who numbered between 5,000 and 10,000 people, constructed stone buildings such as fortresses, mosques, and a dam, but mostly resided in wood and wattle constructions, they engaged in regional and external trade, importing Islamic and Chinese products. The site shows architectural and material similarities with Swahili and Comorian cities in East Africa showing that it was part of the greater Swahili world.

(The Swahili world pg 285-290)

The ruins of Mahilaka, including the main mosque and the city-wall

Map showing the location of Mahilaka and other Antalaotse cities mentioned below

Trade and the rise of the Antalaotse city-states: from Langany to Mazalagem (15th-16th century)

Between the 12th-15th century, many urban settlements grew on the north-western coast of Madagascar, with more than 40 archeological sites discovered sofar. Trading ports were created during this period include Kingany, Nosy Manja (Langany), Nosy Makamby (from the Swahili kãmbi, “camp enclosed by a fence, fortified precinct”), and Kingany (from the Swahili -kinga, “to shelter, to form an enclosure”), located in the Bay of Boina. The new trading ports were strongly influenced by the East African coast, with substantial coral architecture used for religious and domestic buildings, carved coral tombs very similar to the Swahili tombs.

(The worlds of the Indian ocean pg 557)

By the early 16th century, major settlements, some with populations of 6,000 to 10,000, existed near river mouths and in major bays along the west and northwest coasts. Their exports included rice, livestock, soapstone, gum copal resin, and coral stone to the Swahili cities; mangrove poles, rice, tortoise shell, crystal quartz, and possibly gold, silk, and spices to the Persian Gulf and Arabia; slaves to the Middle East and Indonesia. Imports included Cambay beads and cotton and silk cloth; Middle Eastern pottery, glass vessels, silver and gold; Chinese ceramics, jewellery. Further migrations from the East african mainland to north-western Madagascar are recorded during this period, especially from the cities of Pate and Kilwa

(Africa and the Indian ocean pg 131, The Swahili world pg 524)

In the late 16th century, the political position of Langany was supplanted by the city of Mazalagem Nova on the island of Antsoheribory.  "Mazalagem Nova" was the Portuguese name for the town at the mouth of the Mahavavy River known locally by its Antalaotse name Manzalājī. Mazalagem was very prosperous during the 17th century and attracted most of the maritime trade in the area. Various external accounts mention the location of the Antalaotse cities; according to João de Barros "The Muslims of Langany were more civilized and richer than those who inhabited other points of the coast; their mosque and most of their houses were made of stone and lime, with terraces, like the buildings of Kilwa and Mombasa". According to Diogo do Couto: "The Moors of the coast of Malindi, who have come to Madagascar for a long time, have founded two cities there, where their descendents still live today under the authority of shaiks; one of these cities is built on an island located in the middle of a bay named Manzalage . . . And the other is on the northeastern coast in another bay called Bimaro" And according to Luís Mariano, Mazalagem was a Muslim city with a  population of 6,000 to 7,000, that was engaged in trade with the east African coast and Arabia. “Almost all the inhabitants are Muslims, first of all the notables, such as King (Samamo)… The Muslims are not well instructed in their religion, they practice it so badly that it is possible to say that all they have is the name of Muslim". On this last observation, the Portuguese were surprised at the degree of sexual freedom enjoyed by the king’s daughters and nieces.

Mazalagem's inhabitants spoke both the language of “the Malindi coast,” (that is Swahili itself) and “Buque/Buki” language (the Swahili name for Malagasy language). Other Antalaotse towns also engaged in the coastal trade during this time, such as Sa‘da, Kingany (Anāmil), which were competing with Mazalagem.  All Antalaotse city-states shared very similar institutions to their Swahili peers, they were ruled by a "sultan" whose powers were greatly limited by a council of elders/patricians.

(The worlds of the Indian ocean pg 558-559, 612-615)

ruins of a Tomb in Langany

The ruins of Mazalagem, showing the royal mausoleum and the main mosque (last photo)

Between the Indian ocean and the interior: the Antalaotse's contacts with European traders and the kingdoms of Madagascar. (17th-18th century)

European ships arrived on Madagascar in the early 16th century, and while their influence on the mainland had been exaggerated in earlier scholarship, their trade nevertheless constituted a significant source of economic and political capital for the commercially oriented Antalaotse city-states. In contrast to the much of Madagascar's coast that was marginal to European trading activities, the north-western ports that were connected to the Comoros archipelago and were important ports of call just like Nzwani (see my earlier article on this). While the bulk of economic activity in the Antalaotse cities was no doubt largely agro-pastoral, there was a substantial export trade in essential food supplies for ships such as rice, maize, cattle, and water, as well as other trading items such as cloth, sandalwood, timber, and slaves. The Portuguese who sacked the city of Langany in 1506 carried away many trading items including "a great deal of cloth, silver and gold …from Melinde and Mombasa" but the most significant trade item was rice "Such was the quantity of rice  that twenty ships could not carry it"

(Africa and the Indian ocean pg 174, The worlds of the Indian ocean pg 612-614)

Merchants of the Antalaotse cities attimes traveled to the highlands for trade, but the major trade was brought by interior merchants rather than coastal traders moving inland. Relations were sometimes antagonistic as shown by Father João Gomes in 1620: "When I asked a negro from Mazalagem if his fellow-countrymen used to go and trade at Vua [Uva, the Merina country], he replied that the people from Mazalagem no longer go there since the people of Vua, who are very wicked, had stripped them of their wares and their silver and had killed a great number of their people". Over the 17th century, Mazalagem would nevertheless be gradually transformed from a classical transshipment port with limited interactions into the interior, into one of the terminal ports for the rice, cattle and slave trade brought by the Malagasy of the emergent states in the interior. As one visitor wrote;  "Some Buki slaves are led from the kingdom of Uva, which is located in the interior of the island, and they are sold at Mazalagem to Moors from the Malindi coast”.

(The worlds of the Indian ocean pg 560-561)

Map showing the modern Malagasy dialects (including Talaotra) and the route of the Zaframinia migration that is associated with the establishment of the Merina kingdom

Further Bantu and Austronesian migrations, the emergence of centralized kingdoms, and the conquest of the Antalaotse city-states.

The appearance of these interior states, often ruled and populated by Malagasy speakers (who were nevertheless of equal African and Austronesian ancestry) would significantly affect the Antalaotse city-states at the coast. The rise of the Guinguimaro kingdom along the western coast of Madagascar to conquer the city of Sa'da, may have also precipitated the collapse of Mahilaka in the late 15th century. Despite the antagonistic relationship between the Antalaotse cities of Mazalagem and Sa'da with the Guinguimaro kingdom, the latter's kings often had quarters in their capital for Muslims from Mazalagem who succeeded in converting many Malagasy-speakers and built mosques.

The western coast just south of the Guinguimaro kingdom was also inhabited by Bantu-speakers from the coast of Mozambique who had only marginal contact with their bantu-speaking peers in the Antalaotse cities. They established kingdoms whose kings shared power with priestly figures called maganga (Bantu-derived name for priestly figures), and dominated much of the western coast. As one visitor remarked;

"The entire coast between Mazalagem and Sadia speaks a language analogous to those of the Cafres, that is to say the language of the countries of Mozambique and of Malindi, while the inhabitants resemble in pigment and in culture the Negroes from Africa from whom they apparently derive. But, in the immediate hinterland of this coast, as well as in the interior and other coastal sections, only the Buque language is spoken, one quite special to local inhabitants and totally different from the African tongues and very similar to Malay"

(The worlds of the Indian ocean pg 563, 578-585)

Over the early to mid-2nd millennium, further migrations occurred from Southeast Asia to Madagascar that brought the ancestors of the Merina people and other groups who moved into the central Highlands. Gradually, socially stratified small-scale polities centered on fortified political capitals appeared in the interior beginning in the 15th century as a result of demographic increases and the expansion of rice agriculture and pastoralism. The process on the eastern coast was
just as culturally syncretic as that on the western coast, with a mixed Bantu-speaking and Malagasy-speaking elite credited with the founding of the Antemoro kingdom whose institutions had a major influence on the later states. The Antemoro kingdom was also ruled by elites calling themselves "Antalaotra" similar to the Antalaotse above, which is seemingly confirmed by Carpeau du Saussay, who in 1663 claimed that Africans feeing the “tyranny” of the ruler of Kilwa had settled in Anosy, in the southeast of Madagascar.

(The worlds of the Indian ocean pg 591-598, The role of Kilwa pg 119)

The expansionist wars that characterized the formation of the large interior states would lead to an increase in tradable goods; primarily cattle, rice and slaves, that were sent down to the coastal cities, initially in the north-west, and later in various port cities all around the Island. The majority of slaves sold were derived from the highland region populated by relatively recently-arrived Austronesian speakers. As Luis Mariano, wrote in 1613 "The natives show noticeable differences in their physical aspect and the color of their skin: some are black and have curly hair, like the Cafres from Mozambique and Angola; others are also black, but they have smooth hair; others again have a dark complexion like the mulattoes, whereas others are almost white-skinned and can be compared with the palest half-breeds; the latter are the people who have been brought from the kingdom of the Hova; this kingdom is in the very center of the island; these [Hova] people are sold at Mazalagem [Boina] to the Arabs of Malindi".

This particular quote, and data from slave voyages that increased after the French established plantations on the island of Mauritius and Reunion,  invalidate the previously widespread opinion that ancient African immigration to Madagascar was primarily linked to a slave trade, On the contrary, the Malagasy were carried away by Arab and Swahili ships. But it should be noted that like on the African mainland, external slave trade was an after-effect rather than the cause of the expansionist wars of the interior, although unlike the African mainland, the imports (primarily silver) acquired in exchange for the food and slave exports were however slightly more significant in the kingdoms' domestic economies.

(The worlds of the Indian ocean pg 614, Tom and Toakafo pg 440-442, Feeding Globalization pg 140-154)

The rise of the Sakalava and Merina empires, and the absorption of the Antalaotse populations. (18th-19th century)

the empires of Madagascar in the 19th century

Over the 17th century, the western coast of Madagascar saw the rise of the Sakalava kingdoms that arose in the southern half of the island. These kingdoms, which had a predominantly Malagasy-speaking population, eventually spread northwards to conquer the Guinguimaro kingdom and advance further north to conquer the Antalaotse city-states including Mazalagem Nova, which was taken in 1685 by the Sakalava kingdom of Boina. The cities thus came under the direct political control of the interior kingdoms, and were gradually integrated into their predominantly Malagasy-speaking society of the Sakalava.

(Tom and Toakafo pg 445, Feeding Globalization pg 60-70)

The city of Mazalagem was gradually displaced in the mid-18th century by  Mahajanga/Majunga which became the capital of the emerging Sakalava empire. Mahajanga was populated by 6,000 Swahili and Indian merchants at its zenith in the late 18th century, a visiting English captain described it in 1764 as  inhabited by native Muslims and people from Surat (India), Nzwani (Ndzuwani) and the Coromos islands (Grande Comore). The Antalaotse of Mahajanga were largely displaced after the Merina conquest of 1824, and the population was reduced to just 700-800 families, with the majority moving inland to join the Malagasy-speaking Merina society. The Antalaotse came to be valued by the Merina administration for their political and economic expertise, and came to play the same roles as they had to the Sakalava, including marrying into the royal families and influencing them to adopt Islamic customs. Mahajanga remained a major trading port, the Merina governors instructed visiting ships to conduct their business using Swahili and Indian traders, the latter of whom were stationed across several north-western towns such as Ampasindava, Tambohorana, Marovoay, Baly Bay, Makomba and Anoro tsanga. visiting merican and European ships were supplied with rice, cattle, hides and water, especially after the decline of slave trade in the late 19th century.

(Feeding Globalization pg 70-72, Yankees in the Indian Ocean, An Economic History of Imperial Madagascar pg 48-70)

Today, North-western Madagascar remains the only region of the island where many inhabitants can speak both Malagasy and Swahili, even after the widespread propagation of the Malagasy language during the Merina era and French colonial era. These bilingual Bantu-Austronesian populations are the most visible remnants of the legacy of the African settlement on Madagascar.

Mazalagem ruins, see album here

References

Early exchange between Africa and the wider Indian ocean world by G Campbell et al.

Africa and the Indian ocean world from early times to circa-1900 by G Campbell

The worlds of the Indian ocean Vol.2 by Philippe Beaujard

Feeding Globalization: Madagascar and the provisioning trade by Jane Hooper

Yankees in the Indian Ocean by Jane Hooper

An Economic History of Imperial Madagascar by G Campbell

The Swahili world by Stephanie Wynne-Jones et al

Stone tools and foraging in northern Madagascar by R. Dewar and C. Radimilahy

A critical review of radiocarbon dates by Kristina Douglass et al

The role of Kilwa in the Indian ocean by G. Campbell

Tom and Toakafo: the Betsimisaraka Kingdom and State Formation in Madagascar by Stephen Ellis

link to folder here

Comments

Isaac Samuel

I did come across some fragmentary references to Mogadishu's probable links to Madagascar. I still think its plausible that Mogadishu may have played a role in the emergence of city-states in N,W Madagascar (I think I read this in Philippe Beaujard's book) the only challenge is that we would need to match the evidence with what is available from the Madagascar side (hence the books by G. Campbell, Marie de Chantal Radimilahy, and Ricardo Teixeira Duarte) to combine the documentary record describing 16th-17th century Madagascar and the Comoros islands (eg from the Portuguese), and the archeological record (from Mahilaka, Mazalagalem, etc), which is difficult to match with that from Mogadishu because the latter's early history is, unfortunately, understudied and not well known. Yet, it was during this period when it was at its height. On the other hand, I think the exact nature of political control this far south was a lot looser than the one on the mainland, eg we know that Ajuran exercised real territorial control and established some form of centralized administration over a vast region of southern Somalia, including Mogadishu itself, yet its clear that the coastal cities were militarily weak, because we also know that despite multiple documented claims of Kilwa's control of sofala for example, the actual coastline was never really under any direct political influence from Kilwa https://www.patreon.com/posts/dynamics-of-gold-111163742 so if Kilwa couldn't exercise any significant control of an otherwise small series of coastal towns not far from it, its difficult to see how Mogadishu, which was already under Ajuran's suzerainty, could exercise any significant control of an island nearly the size of Somalia populated by numerous small-scale societies that were constantly at war. (going by the example of Aksum's control of Arabia https://www.patreon.com/posts/ethiopian-ruler-78169632, it would take hundreds of thousands of soldiers, and these would have to come from Ajuran, and would doubtlessly leave a significant archeological record of their presence). Its thus more likely that Mogadishu merchants confined their interests to the commercial sphere; buying slaves and produce from Madagascar and exporting it northwards.