Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

In 1338, An exiled Ethiopian monk and his followers visited the Nubian kingdom of Makuria where he was granted audience by its King who needed powerful allies to crush a rebellion. More than three centuries prior to the monk's visit, the king of Makuria had assisted his beleaguered Ethiopian peer in acquiring a metropolitan for his church --the monk was thus unwittingly returning the favour.

During the middle ages, the kingdoms of Makuria and Ethiopia were the pre-eminent powers of north-eastern Africa. Their rulers acted as the protectors of Christians beyond their kingdoms, they established pilgrimage centers, and created important diasporas across the eastern Mediterranean.

Evidence from official diplomatic letters to travelogues to wall inscriptions dated between the 10th and 14th centuries, indicates the two African powers were in contact for several centuries. Nubian and Ethiopian monarchs corresponded through letters, their bishops and eparchs visited each other's churches, and their pilgrims worshipped in the same monasteries at home and abroad. These contacts highlight an often overlooked aspect of African history --one in which Africans explored their own continent.

This article outlines the history of contacts and cultural exchanges between the kingdoms of Makuria and Ethiopia from the 10th century to the 14th century.

13th century fresco in the Ethiopian church of Maryam Korkor depicting a Nubian 'eparch'.

A beleaguered Aksumite king's letter to his Nubian brother

The kingdoms of Aksum and Nubia were the heirs to some of Africa's oldest civilizations. Between the 4th and 6th century, they adopted Christianity as a state religion, placing their churches under the Alexandrian Patriarchate in Egypt which appointed their archbishops/metropolitans. By the 7th century, Egypt was conquered by the Muslim armies of the Rashidun Caliphate, the first of several Muslim dynasties which controlled most of the Mediterranean world. While Nubia and Aksum had sucessfully defeated their own Muslim invasions, they were continuously faced with the threat of a declining church. This threat invigorated contacts between the two states and their mother church in Alexandria, leading to an increase in cultural exchanges between Nubia (Makuria) and Ethiopia (Aksum/Zagwe/Solomonic).

sketch of North-east africa between the 10th-14th century

The most important these contacts is found in the biography of the Alexandrian Patriarch Philotheos (979–1003 ce) contained in the historical compilation titled 'History of the Patriarchs'. In this account, an unnamed Aksumite king sent a letter to the Makurian king Georgios II (969-1002) in which he described a tragic political situation of his kingdom and asked Georgios to negotiate with the Patriarch the ordaining of a new abun. Georgios reacted sympathetically and sent a request letter to Philotheos who nominated a new metropolitan for Ethiopia.

"In his (Philotheos') days, the king of Abyssinia (al-Habasah) sent to the king of Nubia (anNfbah), a youth whose name was George, and made known to him how the Lord had chastened him, he and the inhabitants of his land.

It was that a woman, a queen of Bani al-Hamwiyah, had revolted against him and against his country. She took captive from it many people and burned many cities and destroyed churches and drove him (the king) from place to place.

That which befell him was retribution for what the king who was before him had done to the metropolitan in the days of the father Abba Cosmas as we have explained earlier, through his [i.e. the king who was before him] falsification and his fraud.

He (the king) said to him (George) in the letter which he sent to him: 'I desire that thou shouldst help me in the fatigue, for the sake of God and for the sake of the unity of the Faith, and thou shouldst write a letter on thy part to the father, the patriarch, in Misr, to beg him to absolve our lands and to pray for us, that God may remove from us and from our country this trial, and may grant to us that he (the patriarch) may consecrate for us a metropolitan (mutran), as was the custom of our fathers, and that he may pray for us, that God may remove His wrath from us. I have mentioned this to thee, O brother, for fear lest the Christian religion pass away and cease among us, for lo, six patriarchs have sat (on the Throne) and have not paid attention to our lands, but they (the lands) are abandoned without a shepherd, and our bishops and our priests are dead, and the churches are ruined, and we have learned that this trial has come down upon us as a just judgement in return for what we did with the metropolitan.'

When the letters reached George, the king of Nubia, and he learned about their contents, he sent on his part letters and messengers to the patriarch Philotheos, and he explained to him in them all that the king of Abyssinia had mentioned to him, and he begged him to have compassion on his people. He (Philotheos) acceded to his request, and he consecrated for them a monk from the Monastery of Abba Macarius, whose name was Dani'el, and he sent him to them as metropolitan. They received him with joy, and God removed His wrath from them.

And He put an end to the affair of the woman who had risen up against them."

(The Letter of an Ethiopian King pg 2-3)

From the 10th century onwards, several external sources offer some insight into the precarious political situation in Ethiopia in which they allude to a queen governing the rump Aksumite state. Just prior to this queen's rise, relations between the Aksumite state and the Alexandrian patriarchate had deteriorated. The patriarch Kosmas III (923-934) had concentrated a bishop named peter as the Ethiopian metropolitan, who was welcomed by the king. Nearing his death, the king then asked Peter to chose a sucessor to the Aksumite throne between his two sons, to which Peter chose the younger son.

Shortly after, two excommunicated Syrian monks entered Ethiopia with forged letters from Kosmas claiming that Peter wasn't the real metropolitan. The elder brother thus quickly moved to depose his younger brother, and appointed one of the monks named Menas as his metropolitan. But Menas and the new king fell out, ending with Menas' execution. However, Kosmas refused to appoint a new metropolitan after Peter's death so the new king chose Peter's secretary as acting metropolitan, the latter remained in office throughout the eras of four Alexandrian patriarchs until the abovementioned Philotheus. During which time, relations between Aksum and Alexandria were frozen, and Aksum was faced with the rise of queen Gudit.

(Ethiopia and Alexandria pg 130-132)

We now turn to Arabic sources which describe Gudit's reign in the late 10th century. In his Kitāb ṣūrat al-arḍ completed in 988, Ibn Ḥawḳal describes the situation of the region based on information obtained in Egypt during his visit in the 950s. Abyssinia was then governed by a queen who “killed the king who was known with the title of ḥaḍānī,” and ruled herself for about thirty years. An anonymous Egyptian author of the 10th century, describing a Yemeni embassy to Iraq in 969–970, noted that the zebra it offered as a gift had come “from one of the regions of al- Ḥabaša [Abyssinia] over which a woman reigns.” Gudit was thus reigning at the time the unamed Ethiopian king sent his letter through king George of Makuria.

(A companion to medieval Ethiopia pg 36)

Makuria under king George (confusing called Georgios II or Georgios III by different scholars) was undergoing a golden age that would last another two centuries. King George was in power right around the time when the Fatimid general Jawdhar seized control of Egypt. Jawdhar sent his ambassador Al-Aswani to Old dongola in 970, the latter of whom was well received and provided an extensive description of the powerful kingdom. Under King George, Makuria was near its greatest extent , establishing permanent garrisons in the southern Egyptian cities of Edfu and Achmin, which became important centers of Nubian culture with several old Nubian documents found there. The king also appears in several paintings across the kingdom including at the churches of Faras and Sonqi Tino, and in a number of documents and inscriptions.

(Day of Devastation, Day of Contentment pg 54)

Prior to its relatively cordial relationships with the Fatimids, Makuria had been in perpetual conflict with Muslim Egypt since the 7th century, with its armies often campaigning deep into Egypt.

These wars were often framed as religious conflicts in which Makuria's kings acted as protectors of the patriarchs of Alexandria and their Christian followers (who were at the time more than 50% of the population), the Alexandrian patriarchate thus became dependent on Makuria to counter the aggression of its Muslim overlords. Furthermore, unlike Ethiopian kings who had Egyptian monks appointed as their metropolitans, Makuria's kings enjoyed the right to nominate their own people as episcopal candidates. In time, the Makurian kings took on the title “absolute ruler of the people” which was followed by a list of nations over which the king claims supremacy including Alwans, Makurians, Nobadians, Dalmatai (Cyrenaica), and Aksumites.

(The Oxford handbook pg 736, 766, A Christian king in Africa pg 366)

King Georgios II's paintings in Faras and Sonqi Tino

(Royal iconography, pg 130)

There are several references regarding the correspondence between the Patriarch and the Nubian and Ethiopian kings, and the contents of many such letters survive in the 'History of the Patriarchs'. The Armenian writer Abu Salih (d. 1200) also mentions that “The fathers and patriarchs used to write letters to the kings of Abyssinia and Nubia twice in the year; and the last who did so was Zacharias the sixty-fourth patriarch [1004-1032}; for Al-Hākim forbade the practice, which ceased from that time until now”. Conversely, there is atleast one letter from Nubia addressed to the Patriarch in Alexandria. It was written by King Moses George to Patriarch Markos recommending a certain Iêsou for the consecration to a bishopric in Nubia.

(The Letter of an Ethiopian King pg4-5)

The contents of the above letter therefore reveal that Makuria's role as the protector of Christians (who included Aksumites) went beyond mere titulature, as it involved the active participation of Makuria's armies and diplomats in ensuring the survival of the faith in the face of an expansionist Islam. The unnamed Aksumite king's appeal to the patriarch of Alexandria allowed a renewal of relations with the Coptic Church and exchanges between Egypt and Ethiopia resumed. Embassies regularly circulated between the two regions, and the Ethiopian church underwent a thorough revitalization beginning with the era of metropolitan Mikaʾel in the 12th century. These renewed contacts heralded Ethiopia's Christian resurgence under the Zagwe kingdom (1150-1270) and the Solomonic state (1270-1974).

(A companion to medieval Ethiopia 39-40)

An Ethiopian archbishop in Nubia and a Nubian eparch in Ethiopia

There is fragmentary evidence that the kingdom of Makuria and the early Solomonic state were in close contact with dignitaries from both states visiting each other especially during the 13th century.

A visitor at the Makurian church of Sonqi Tino, located about 70 km south of the 2nd Cataract, commisioned an inscription which read "archbishop of the Axumites". This 13th-14th century inscription was one among several appearing on the walls of the church which also included paintings and other grafitto.

inscription by an ethiopian visitor at Sonqi Tino

Ruins of Sonqi Tino

This "archbishop" of aksum was doubtless the metropolitan, appointed by the patriarch in Alexandria to head the Aksumite/Ethiopian church. The Alexandrian patriarch’s jurisdiction over the Ethiopian church, which included his selection of its sole metropolitan, required at least periodic travel to Egypt from the time of ancient Aksum’s conversion to Christianity in the mid-fourth century. While the routes taken by the appointed metropolitans aren't described in contemporary documents, they could be gleaned from the better known trade routes which connected Makuria, Egypt and Aksum to the red-sea. These included an overland route to upper Egypt, then across the desert to the red sea ports (eg Aydhab) which then led to Aksum by sea. The other route was entirely overland through Makuria which may have shared an eastern border with Aksum.

(An Unexpected Guest in the Church of Sonqi Tino)

Another fragmentary piece of evidence for Makuria's contacts with Ethiopia comes from a painting in the church of Debra Maryam Qorqor in nothern Ethiopia, which contains many murals dating from as early as the 13th century. On one of the church's pilasters to the right of St Anthony is a painting of Nubian dignitary with a horned crown.

13th century Ethiopian painting of a Nubian dignitary from the Maryam Korkor church

Other paintings in Maryam Korkor

While the paiting hasn't been studied in detail, it has been mentioned by art historians as a paiting of a "Nubian eparch", and as similar to "the headgear of Nubian rulers". Other paintings in the church which have been studied in detail, such as the portrait of the enthroned virgin, are said to contain artistic similarities with the same figure from church murals of Makuria.

(Encyclopaedia Aethiopica pg 301, Ethiopia's Hidden Treasures pg 96, Major Themes in Ethiopian Painting pg 174-179)

The conclusion that the painted figure was a nubian is based on the frequent depictions of horned crowns and similar headgear on various elite figures in Nubian paiting. Some nubiologists have attempted to differentiate the functions of the various crowns, suggesting some were worn by Kings while others were worn by eparchs. Others suggest that the crown with horns referred to the military authority, while the crown in the stemma/diadem type symbolized the power handed over by God to Nubian kings through archangels who served as intermediaries. There are however too many types to identify and little information on each. Neverthless, the identity of the unamed dignitary at Korkor was none other than a Nubian elite from Makuria.

(Horned Crown – an Epigraphic Evidence, The Crown of the Eparch of Nobadia?)

Types of crown of Nubian dignitaries

(Horned Crown – an Epigraphic Evidence pg 327)

Painting of a nubian ruler, 12th century, Room XX. Upper Church in Banganarti

(The crown of the eparch of Noubadia pg 28)

An exiled Ethiopian monk in Nubia and the history of joint pilgrimages between Nubians and Ethiopians

Arguably the most detailed evidence of contacts between Makuria and Ethiopia comes from the 14th century, when a monk named Ewosṭatewos travelled through Makuria on his way to exile. At the beginning of the 14th century, Ewosṭatewos created a powerful, yet dissenting, movement in northern Ethiopia with his disciples about the observance of the Christian and Jewish sabath. However, the newly appointed Metropolitan Yāʿeqob deprived him from all support, and the reigning king Amda Ṣeyon (1314–1344) banished him. In 1337-8, he left Ethiopia with some of his followers, beginning a long journey which led them through Nubia, Egypt, Palestine, and Cyprus before he finally arrived in Armenia. His remaining followers in Ethiopia established themselves in local monasteries using the support of local aristocrats, and in the late 14th century, composed a hagiography of their exiled leader titled gadla Ēwosṭātēwos, (Contending of Ēwosṭātēwos).

(An Ethiopian fugitive pg 9-12, A companion to medieval Ethiopia pg 213-215)

This hagiography includes a passage about Ēwosṭātēwos' time in Nubia (presumably Makuria) where he assisted its king in a major conflict;

"They [Ēwosṭātēwos and his disciples] arrived in Nobā land (medra Nobā). When the king of Nobā heard that ʾabbā Ēwosṭātēwos had arrived, he came to meet him. Before approaching ʾabbā Ēwosṭātēwos,

the king heard that some rebels  had started to wage war against him like a bull being on heat in meadows. Sābʾa Nol sent because his name in Arabic thus means “sons of Ethiopia” (Weluda ʾItyopyā) in Geʾez. Indeed, she (the King's mother) welcomed the monks who were accomplishing the pilgrimage close to Our Lord’s Sepulchre. She would wash their feet and drank [the water blended with] theirdust faithfully, that’s why she called him Sābʾa Nol.

Afterwards, the king sent a servant to Ēwosṭātēwos telling him: “If the Lord fights with us against those infidels thanks to your prayers, when I come back, I will give you this glorious gabgeb of mine, which people are proud of, and you will wash your hands in it.”

The king met the infidels in their camps with his troops. The infidels numbered four thousand and they surrounded the Christians. He [the king] came in the battle with four horsemen and amidst them was a man who held a cross. The troops completely surrounded the Christians.

Then, ʾabbā Ēwosṭātēwos, riding a spiritual chariot, was blazing like a fire above this spiritual chariot. He helped king Sābʾa Nol who trusted the prayer of ʾabbā Ēwosṭātēwos. When he said: “Let God arise, let his enemies be scattered,” the infidels who were on the eastern side beat the retreat. Again, when he shouted: “Fight against them that fight against me,” those of the western side scattered. When he said again: “Deliver me from mine enemies,” those who stood on the north side collapsed. Once again when he proclaimed, “Who can be compared unto the Lord?” those who were on the southern side were cut into pieces.

Thus, the king killed them all from the crack of dawn to twilight. They [the king and his horsemen] took captive their people and seized their livestock. Thanks to ʾabuna Ēwosṭātēwos’s prayers, he vanquished his enemies. Moreover, because of that, the king recognized the saint’s glory when he started blazing above a chariot [flying] between sky and earth.

O of ʾabuna Ēwosṭātēwos’s unblemished virginity!

O unceasing love for God!

O unchanging faith!

Let us turn back to our main story. Then, the victorious king Sābʾa Nol took out the gabgeb [and gave it] to ʾabuna Ēwosṭātēwos. He told him: “Take this o ʾabbā to wash your hands, because we have seen your mighty prayer.”

Thereafter ʾabuna Ēwosṭātēwos left and went his way.

(An Ethiopian fugitive pg 13-14)

Folio from the Gadl of Ēwosṭātēwos, ca. 20th century., Qorqor Māryām

Makuria by the time of was Ēwosṭātēwos's visit had briefly been under Mamluk-Egypt's control with various degrees of autonomy since the reign of sultan Baybars (1260–1277) when king David attacked Aydhab in the 1270s. Christianity begun to gradually loose its predominance due to Islamic expansion as dynastic rivalries forced rival candidates of Makuria's throne to lean more towards the Mamluks inorder to guarantee their power. By 1317, Makuria's first Muslim king named Kanz ad-Dawla was in power, as attested by the conversion of Old dongola's throne room to a mosque. Kanz rebelled again his Mamluk overlord once in power but relented to paying a token tribute, thus managing to reign until he was deposed by a Christian king named Siti around 1331.

(The Oxford handbook pg 765-766)

Numerous internal documents shed light on king Siti who reigned in Makuria after throwing Kanz al-Dawla off the throne. Siti was a powerful ruler, as his royal inscriptions are arguably the furthest attested of any Makurian king. These include inscriptions at Jebel Abu Negila, which is over 200 kilometers south of Dongola, and inscriptions in the Nubian-controlled cities of Edfu and Qasr Ibrim (both in Egypt). This evidence of Nubian influence all along and beyond the middle Nile valley, as well as king Siti's various royal inscriptions in Dongola and Banganarti, gives the impression that Siti was “a powerful king of a strong and large state”

(A king of Makuria in Kordofan pg 149-155)

Banganarti church, the modest inscription of king Siti of Dotawo (Makuria) and the inscription of his official Doureré.

(The people of Banganarti pg 32, 35)

Yet, despite having been deposed, Kanz al-Dawla persisted in pretending that he was “king of Dongola” in a document dated 1333, even though Siti was the King of the entire state in a document from the same year. In his role as king of Dongola, Kanz may be the predecessor of a petty king named 'Paper' who also appears in several inscriptions at Dongola a few decades later with the same title. Kanz's claim may shed light on continuous rivalry and/or the de-centralized nature of power between the various religious and dynastic factions in Makuria in the 14th century. Such rivalries may have continued in the late 1330s and they could be gleaned from the Abu Negila inscription that describes Siti "seizing" a foe named Anenaka and/or the latter's followers. The Ethiopian monk might have been the witness of a Christian reconquest in Makuria.

(A Late Christian Pilgrimage Centre in Nubia pg 44, 58, 135-137, Émir à Assouan, souverain à Dongola, A king of Makuria in Kordofan pg 152)

As a Christian neighbor, Makuria was a place of major interest for Ethiopian monks because it is one of the stages of the pilgrimage towards Egypt and the Holy Land. There are several external references to Nubians and Ethiopians pilgrims who travelled, worshipped and lived together while in Egypt and Jerusalem. According to Abū al-Makārim, who was writing between 1160-1187, Nubians (Nūbah) shared a sacred space with other groups – Greeks (Rūm), Franks (Faranj), and Ethiopians (Ḥabasha) – whose envoys would be received at the court in Cairo where they would customarily worship alongside each other at the fountain at al-Maṭariyya.

(Nubia, Ethiopia, and the Crusading World pg 158)

Nubian and Ethiopian monks had a permanent presence in the Wādī al-Naṭrūn monastery, located in the middle of the route between Cairo and Alexandria, where they facilitated pilgrims enroute Alexandria and beyond. A 12th century polyglot manuscript of the Epistles produced at the Wādī al-Naṭrūn, that included texts in Gǝʿǝz and Greek, was probably intended for joint liturgical performances, and suggests a notable Ethiopian presence in the area, alongside other Christian diasporas most likely from Nubia. Such joint masses would have included Latin Christians, as documented by Niccolò da Poggibonsi, a Tuscan Franciscan friar in 1345-50. Wadi al-Natrun's lasting influence is reflective in the Makurian King Giorgios IV’s choice to retire to the complex in 1158.

(The medieval Nubian diaspora pg 25-26, A companion to medieval Ethiopia pg 428, Nubia, Ethiopia, and the Crusading World pg 183)

By the time Nubians were granted the cavalry chapel in Jerusalem's Church of the Holy Sepulchre around 1333, their pilgrims had been present in the old city since the 12th century. Nubian and Ethiopian pilgrimage routes overlapped, and its around 1340 that we get the first reference to Ethiopians in posession of an altar in the Holy Sepulcher. Its very likely that these communities interacted, and as noted in the excerpt above, The Nubian king's mother welcomed "the Ethiopian monks who had accomplished the pilgrimage close to Our Lord’s Sepulchre". Given the continued reference to Ethiopian and Nubian pilgrims in the 1330s and 1340s, its not too unexpected for Ēwosṭātēwos to have met a Nubian ruler during his exile in 1337, and for his followers to have conveyed a vague account of his journey throughout Nubia to the Holy lands

(Nubia, Ethiopia, and the Crusading World pg 165-166, 180-183, A companion to medieval Ethiopia pg 430)

Ēwosṭātēwos hagiographers were writing in the late 14th century when Makuria was a rather diminished power and Old Dongola had been abandoned in 1365, but it was still an important Christian kingdom with which Ethiopians were familiar, and the state would last well into the 1480s. The now powerful Solomonic state took on Makuria's mantle as protector of the Christians, with the Ethiopian King Dawit (1380-1412) leading his army as far as the Aswan region during the 1380s, where according to al-Makrizi, his attacks reportedly devastated the Arabs of the region.

The hagiographers therefore reconstructed their narrative of Ēwosṭātēwos' exile halfway between fiction and history, combining biblical models of pious kings and prophets, with a hagiographical reinterpretation of the Christian-Muslim rivalries in contemporary Makuria.

(An Ethiopian fugitive pg 18-19)

The evidence above indicates that Makurians and Ethiopians were in close contact for several centuries, each state was aware of the other's existence, and their subjects visisted each other's countries. That we know little about the extent of such contacts is due to the fact that such intra-African relationships haven't been the subject of extensive studies compared to those between African states and non-African states. But however fragmentary this evidence appears, it sheds some significant light on how much Africans knew about their own continent and explored it.

references

Nubia, Ethiopia, and the Crusading World by Adam Simmons

The Oxford Handbook of Ancient Nubia by Bruce Williams

A Companion to Medieval Ethiopia and Eritrea by S. kelly

Ethiopia and Alexandria: The Metropolitan Episcopacy of Ethiopia by S. C Munro-Hay

Day of Devastation, Day of Contentment: The History of the Sudanese Church Across 2000 Years by Roland Werner

Encyclopaedia Aethiopica: O-X by Siegbert Uhlig

Ethiopia's Hidden Treasures :A Guide to the Paintings of the Remote Churches of Ethiopia by María-José Friedlander

Major Themes in Ethiopian Painting by Stanisław Chojnacki

A Christian king in Africa by Adam Łajtar, Grzegorz Ochała

Royal Iconography: Contribution to the Study of Costume by Magdalena Wozniak

The Letter of an Ethiopian King to King George II of Nubia by Benjamin Hendrickx

Émir à Assouan, souverain à Dongola by Robin Seignobos

An Unexpected Guest in the Church of Sonqi Tino by Adam Łajtar, Grzegorz Ochała

Horned Crown – an Epigraphic Evidence by Stefan Jakobielski

The Crown of the Eparch of Nobadia By Magdalena Łaptaś

An Ethiopian fugitive Allied with a Nubian King by Olivia Adankpo-Labadie

A king of Makuria in Kordofan by Adam Łajtar

The people of Banganarti by Adam Łajtar

A Late Christian Pilgrimage Centre in Nubia by Adam Łajtar

A Note towards Quantifying the Medieval Nubian Diaspora by Adam Simmons

link

Comments

No comments found for this post.