Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

The collapse of Songhai in 1591, after a battle in which west African horsemen and archers were defeated by Moroccan musketeers led by a European slave-soldier, was once perceived to be a precursor to the European colonial invasions of the 19th century. The battle of Tondibi was seen as a war that pitted a technologically underdeveloped west African army against a technologically advanced Moroccan force, in what was thought to have been similar to the gun-totting colonialists who overran African warriors supposedly armed with spears and arrows.

This view has since been thoroughly debunked, as not only was west Africa a major importer of firearms since the 16th century, African kingdoms used the same firearms they had bought to keep out the Europeans. The academic debate on the history of firearms in Africa has since shifted to their effectiveness in pre-colonial warfare, especially with regards to the quality of both the guns and the gunmen firing them.

The first guns used in African warfare were acquired the empires of Portugal and the Ottomans, the two global powers of the 16th century. The African kingdoms of Benin, Kongo and Ethiopia acquired firearms from the Portuguese during the first half of the 16th century. Since gun technology was relatively new, these firearms were handled by Portuguese musketeers who were recruited into African armies as a special unit of the infantry.

On the other hand, Bornu acquired its firearms from the Ottomans in the second half of the 16th century. And just like Morocco, the gunmen of Bornu included European slave-soldiers who served directly under the command of Bornu's military generals. The effectiveness of firearms in the military of Bornu has been a major subject of debate in the wider discourses on African military history. Conversely, the presence of European captives in west Africa is an overlooked topic in the study of human exchanges between west Africa and the Mediterranean.

This article explores the history of firearms in the Bornu empire, and the presence of European captives in pre-colonial west Africa.

1788 painting depicting an Ottoman mufti sprinkling cannon with rose water at the opening of the campaign. 

Background to the arrival of Firearms in Bornu: Conflict and diplomacy between the Ottomans and Bornu from 1551.

During the 16th century, the eastern Mediterranean was dominated by the Ottoman empire, one of the three gunpowder empires of the Islamic world. The Ottomans were the global leader in the production and use of firearms, manufacturing the largest amount of guns, cannons, ammunitions, and gun powder in the old world. The Ottomans begun using firearms during the reign of Sultan Murad II (1421-1451), and by 1532, most of the Empire’s janissaries had guns. By the time of Sultan Murad III (1574-1595), the Ottomans had greatly expanded the amount of firearms within the janissary corps and all janissaries were equipped with firearms.

(Guns for the Sultan pg 24, 48, 91)

The Ottoman presence in Africa begun with the conquest of Mamluk Egypt in 1517. Their forces then undertook an extensive campaign across North Africa, taking Algiers in 1533, Tripoli in 1551, and Tunis in 1569. They then made bold attempts into crossing the Sahara, beginning with their occupation of the sai island (3rd cataract region, Sudan) in 1529, and a failed attempt to advance further south in 1576 where they were routed by the Funj kingdom. However, their advance into the Fezzan region of southern Libya in 1574 was relatively successful, ending with the expulsion of the Awlad rulers from their capital at Murzuk and its occupation by an Ottoman garrison.

(Du Lac Tchad pg 32)

Map of North and West Africa during the 16th century.

Bornu was aware of the Ottoman conquest of Tripoli in 1551, as the city was the most important terminal of Bornu's exports to the Mediterranean world. Bornu's rulers had sent embassies to Tripoli, including during the decades just before the Ottomans when the city was under Christian rule (Spain in 1510 and Knights of Malta in 1535). In the same year of Tunis' Ottoman conquest, the ruler of Bornu, Dūnama bin Muḥammad (1539-1557), sent an embassy to establish trade relations with the new occupants. The donation of firearms by the sovereign of Tripoli strongly marked the court of Bornu since they'd later play a role in the victories of Idris Alooma. The embassy of 1560/1561, sent by 'Abdallāh bin Dūnama (1557-1564) confirms that the Sultanate of Bornu remains the main player in trade with the northern Sahara.

(L'esclave, le savant, pg 489-490, Du lac Tchad pg 31-32)

The Ottoman expansion into the Sahara begun during the reign of Sultan Murad III, whose counterpart in Bornu was Mai Idris Alooma. (1564-1596). While Bornu had lost control in the Fezzan to the Awlad dynasty around 1550, it retained some political relationship with the Awlads and there was a significant presence of people from Bornu in the region.  In response to the Ottoman threat, the Idris Alooma sent embassies to Murad in 1574 led by the Bornu envoy Yusuf Ali. The delegation of Yusuf Ali included five Bornu companions, and it passed through Tripoli on its way to Istanbul. The delegation returned in 1578 with a representative of the Ottomans and a response to Bornu's request for the transfer of the Fezzan. But while the Ottoman Sultan refused to cede the Fezzan to Bornu, he gave strict orders to the Ottoman governors of the region to maintain good relations with the ruler of Bornu, and gave Bornu's ruler gifts of firearms and horses.

(Du lac Tchad, pg 35, Firearms in the central Sudan, pg 216)

After its request to repossess the Fezzan was rebuffed, Bornu turned to the Moroccans to counter the Ottomans, sending two envoys to the court of Sultan al-Mansur (r.1578-1603), in 1581 and 1583. Both of these were led by Idris Alooma's ambassador Yusuf Ali, and were ostensibly meant to request firearms to fight against the unbelievers, but retaking the Fezzan was most likely the main objective. Between 1582-1585, the Ottoman garrison in the Fezzan was massacred and the Moroccan Awald dynasty which had previously ruled the region, was reinstalled with Bornu support. Idris had taken advantage of the conflict between Murad III and Al-Mansur to solve a local problem. Despite expelling the Ottomans from the Fezzan, Bornu thereafter sought to restore its ties to Ottoman-occupied Tripoli. In 1586, Idris Alooma sent an embassy to the governor of Tripoli which was well received. The embassy requested firearms, a request that was fulfilled by the Pasha.

(Le esclave le savant pg 493-495)

The 16th century castle of Murzuq

I have explored the conflict between Morocco, Songhai, Bornu and the Ottomans in greater detail here. 

European slave soldiers and captives in west Africa during the 16th and 17th century.

The increase in diplomacy between Bornu and Ottoman-Tripoli, combined with the rise in the number of firearms, janissaries, mercenaries in North Africa, explains the presence of "Turks" in Bornu's military. The majority of internal and external accounts on Bornu date the introduction and use of Turkish musketeers to Mai Idris' reign, often described as being mercenaries or adventurers. According to a Spanish-Moroccan account of 1590, Bornu acquired Turkish musketeers as captives after a failed invasion of Bornu by the Ottomans. But the captives were treated hospitably in Bornu that they stayed, thus enabling Bornu's ruler to acquire 500 blunderbussmen.

(Firearms in the central Sudan pg 215-216)

While this account is the only contemporary reference to gunmen travelling with their guns to Bornu, its not immediately supported by other accounts which say nothing about such a large Ottoman campaign to Bornu involving 500 musketeers. Its more likely that the Turkish musketeers were either slave soldiers who were gifted to Bornu along with their guns, or were mercenaries who came under Idris Alooma's service. The possibility that they were slave soldiers is briefly hinted at in the 1576 account of Idris Alooma's wars recorded by his chronciler Ibn Furtu. It mentions that "Among the benefits which God conferred upon the Sultan was the acquisition of Turkish musketeers and numerous household slaves who became skilled in firing muskets".

(The first twelve years pg 33)

But while this reference is unclear on whether the 'household slaves' were the same as the Turkish musketeers, there are later references from the 17th century which indicate that the gunmen in Bornu were almost exclusively foreign slaves acquired via diplomacy. After a series of diplomatic exchanges in the late 1630s, about 50 young European slaves and several muskets were sent to Bornu in 1635 and another batch of European slaves were sent to Bornu by the Pasha of Tripoli in 1665. Both of these exchanges also involved the sending of muskets and horses to Bornu from the Ottomans in exchange for gold and slaves from Bornu.

( The Ottoman World, the Mediterranean and North Africa pg 49, Du lac Chad pg 183, The Penetration of Africa)

Compared to the numerous European captives in north Africa (including those who served in the Moroccan conquest of Songhai), European captives were relatively few in west Africa. There's atleast one exceptional account of a Belgian slave in Agadez in 1687, who had been captured by north African pirates. This Belgian, named Pieter Farde had a French foreman, and he adds that there were several European (Christian) slaves in Agadez including another Frenchman named Louis de la Place, as well as some Jewish slaves. These European captives in Agadez fared poorly compared to their peers in Bornu whose satisfactory performance in battle was such that the Bornu sultan sent another embassy to Tripoli requesting for more.

( A seventeenth century Belgian pg 76-83)

Agadez street scene in 1930, quai branly

When they arrived in Bornu, the European slaves and their (Muslim) 'Turkish' companions weren't differentiated in local accounts but were collectively known by the collective ethnonym of "Turk". The naming of captives after their country of sale was a common practice in both the Old world and in the Atlantic world. These 'Turks' only appear twice in the account of Ibn Furtu. First was from the passage quoted above, which continues that "Hence the Sultan was able to kill the people of Amsaka with muskets, and there was no need for other weapons, so that God gave him a great victory by reason of his superiority in arms". The other was the mention that in a campaign against the tribe of Dankir, Bornu was victorious in defeating the enemy and that none of Bornu's soldiers were hurt, "save that one man, a Turk, called Ali Ghar, was killed"

(The first twelve years pg 33, 72)

The brief mention of a "Turkish" casualty in battle follows a standard writing theme of Ibn Furtu, in which the chronicler downplays Bornu's losses while exaggerating its victories. Similar examples include; the battle with the Tuaregs at Agalawa, where he mentions than "none of the Muslims (ie: Bornu's soldiers) died except Nasr ibn Sakali." and in the battle with the N'gizim town of Bani, where he mentions that "none of the Muslims were hurt save one man, namely Barbuma ibn Abdulahi of the Magumi Milima"

(The first twelve years, pg 76, 92)

In the abovementioned quote about the conflict with Amsaka, Ibn Furtu is careful in crediting the technological advantage of firearms only to the victory at Amsaka, but not for the entirety of Idris Alooma's campaigns nor Bornu's army in general. The effectiveness of gun technology in Bornu's military during the 16th century, has for long been important in the wider debate in African military history about the decisiveness of firearms in pre-colonial warfare. The next chapter looks at descriptions of the use of musketeers in several campaigns by Bornu's armies.

Gunpowder technology Vs fortified towns in 16th century west Africa.

Firearms appear several times in Ibn Furtu's account, often associated with the campaigns against fortified towns of Asmaka and the N'gzim, both of which were located on the frontiers of Bornu. The people of Amsaka are described as living in a well-defended "stockade" surrounded by a deep ditch. Amsaka was apparently so impregnable, the two neighboring rulers attacked all towns except Amsaka because of the "power of its inhabitants in war and their stout defense of their town". Mai Idris also mounted an attack on the town, but it too was repulsed.

(The first twelve years, pg 57-58)

Another enemy of Bornu that firearms were used against were the people of N'gizim. Their towns, such as Mawa, Agham, Bani and N’gajimbana, were described as "fortified with a wall of great strength". Ibn Furtu adds that the N'gizim "had a false idea of their own strength by reason of two things. Firstly their numerous archers, who used poisoned arrows, and secondly the strength of their walled towns. These two factors induced them to be rebellious and hostile". The descriptions of the battles that followed between Bornu and these fortified towns leave little doubt that this was an accurate assessment of the latter's capacity to repel the former's attacks.

(The first twelve years, pg 85)

Ibn Furtu uses the word ‘Shokiya’ to mean a 'stockade’ according to Palmer's notes. Furtu also applies this description to Bornu's capital Ngarzagamu during the reign of Sultan ‘Ali ibn Ahmad (ie: when the capital had just been founded), but he later describes all towns in Bornu as 'Birni' that are surrounded by a clay wall. The term 'Birni' (which could thus be translated to mean city) is only applied to Bornu's urban settlements, while the rest are refered to as 'towns' with walls or stockades, including Amsaka and Kano. In the centuries after Ibn Furtu, the Hausa would adopt this term from Bornu to describe their walled cities.

(The first twelve years, pg 31)

However, both the Kano chronicle and archeological surveys around Kano prove that there was a wall around Kano by the 16th century. Kano is therefore unlikely to have been defended using a simple stockade (of raised poles) as Ibn Furtu describes but by a high clay wall. The same applies to the walls of the town of Amsaka, which were later described by Ibn Furtu as being repaired using mud. Palmer conjectures that the Bornu historian was probably unwilling to admit the existence of another Birni outside Bornu, and so called other towns stockades.

(The first twelve years, pg 156-157)

While the above explanation may suffice for Kano, its unclear how it applies to the walled towns of N'gizim, which Ibn Furtu doesn't describe as stockades. Its perhaps relevant to note that Ibn Furtu appears to use the terms stockade and walled town interchangeably, especially with regards to Kano, where he mentions a "walled town" of Kai whose trees were cut down "just as those of the stockades we have mentioned". Considering that Amsaka's stockade was repaired with mud, and its defenders stood on the "pinnacles of the walls", its more likely that Ibn Furtu was describing a type of mixed construction of defensive walls made of clay and tree poles, which defies the binary definition of "stockade" and "walled" town.

(The first twelve years, pg 59, 68)

Aerial photo of Gulfey in the early 20th century, while many of the walled towns mentioned in Ibn Furtu's text were later abandoned, the towns of Kotoko in the lake chad region such as this one would have resembled the towns sacked by Bornu.

I covered the Kotoko towns here including their relationship with Bornu. 

Operations of the Musketeers in capturing the fortified towns.

In December 1575, the Bornu army invaded the town of Amsaka. The town's forces mounted the wall, "and fired arrows and darts like heavy rain" such that no Bornu soldier would approach without being struck by the arrows and stones. Amsaka's forces also set fire to thatched roofs and threw them at the Bornu army camped below, they threw everything at the Bornu attackers including poisoned arrows, "pots of boiling ordure", hard clay, as well as short and long spears. The walls of the town were surrounded by a dry ditch which the Bornu army tried to fill with maize stocks but to no avail as Amsaka's forces would remove the stalks. Even when Bornu's army sucessfully breeched a small section in the wall, the Amsaka forces quickly repaired it with mud.

(The first twelve years, pg 60-61)

Mai Idris therefore ordered his army to build three platforms on three sides of the walls using large trees, "so that the gunmen could mount on them and easily shoot at the enemy inside". They also begun to fill the ditch using soil and maize stalks rather than using the stalks alone. Having finished, they then begun to break the town walls, as the gunmen shot Amsaka's archers such that the latter ran out of arrows just as Bornu's forces were breaking through their walls. Amsaka was eventually defeated, its walls were levelled and its forces were annihilated.

(The first twelve years, pg 62-64)

Bornu's army also used gunmen in taking the N'gizim town of Mawa. When the two armies met for battle, Mawa's archers "pelted our men with darts and arrows without ceasing". But Bornu's army stood firm and "The gunmen opened on the enemy with a volley, and poured a hot fire into them before they had time to array themselves or make ready their defenses", forcing them to retreat but their flight into the safety of the walls was cut off as Bornu's army surrounded them.

Ibn Furtu describes the decisiveness of firearms in this engagement, writing that:

"All who were hit by gun fire died, even the animals and oxen and horses. The men on the other hand split into two parties. Some stayed near the gate or opposite to it, fighting on till they were killed by gunshot instantaneously, as if they had drunk poison. How fierce was the fire of the guns!. All whom they hit were mortally wounded and died, their members broken. Thus all the leading warriors were killed in this place as soon as they came forward. The cowards and weak kept in the background, and concealed themselves so that the gunmen should not see them and kill them as they had killed the brave among them"

(The first twelve years, pg 87-88)

The same mode of fighting was repeated in the N'gizim town of Agham, whose forces chose to come out and fight Bornu's army in the open. Initially, the forces of Agham "seized their weapons and shot poisoned arrows". The gunmen, however, "made things hot for them, and broke them by their fire." After learning of Agham's fate, the forces of the neighboring town of Bani chose to stay within their town walls once Bornu's army approached. Bornu's shield-bearers and musketeers advanced towards the town, with the former protecting the latter. And in response, Bani's forces "let loose a fire of arrows as thick as a cloud of locusts or like a rain storm". But the well-shielded musketeers kept firing and pushing the enemy back until the latter were trapped into a small corner of the town. Bani's forces were then defeated by Bornu and the town was sacked.

(The first twelve years, pg 89-92)

The Bornu army then marched on to N’gajimbana, in what would be the last gun-battle described in Ibn Furtu's account. The town was divided between a peace faction which was ready to negotiate with Bornu (so it moved out of the town) and a war faction that stayed in the town and prepared to fight. Bornu's general named Idris ibn Haruna, who had led the attack on the other N'gizim towns, also led this campaign. He is said to have "sent forward the shieldmen, in front of him, and placed the musketeers behind them. He then took up a position with his horsemen by the side of the musketeers or behind them facing the town but not going up to it, so that he should not have any casualties, and advanced". N’gajimbana's forces pelted Bornu's forces with arrows, so Bornu's forces halted in one place, the shield-bearers protected the musketeers as the latter fired continuously on the enemy forces. Bornu's army was victorious, and surrounding towns resubmitted to Sultan Idris' authority.

(The first twelve years, pg 93-95)

Ibn Furtu's mention of siege platforms (towers) set against walled cities, defenders pouring pots of boiling ordure onto the attackers, and the attackers breaching the walls of the city, recall the classical siege battles and strategies used all around the world since antiquity. For example this 19th century illustration of the siege of Rhodes in 305BC

Conclusion: On the effectiveness of Fire-arms in Bornu's army.

While Ibn Furtu mentions the use musketeers in capturing some of these towns, guns never appear anywhere else across the rest of Idris Alooma's many battles. For example, the towns of the N’gafata were taken by various methods, none of which included the use of musketeers. The campaign against the kingdom of Kano, and its various stockade towns also didn't involve the use of musketeers. The campaigns against the towns of the Tatala, the Tuaregs, the Barbar, Sansana, and the Mandara kingdom, also didn't involve the use of musketeers. Muskets first appear about half-way through the chronicle in the campaign against Amsaka. Ibn Furtu explains that they were only employed because the earlier attempt by Bornu to capture the city had failed and its second attempt was nearly failing before they used guns as a last resort. Out of the 78 Manuscript folios, gunmen only appear in 6 manuscripts; MS 33, 39, 56, 57, 59, 62, and even then, they aren't the only unit engaged in significant battle.

Humphrey Fisher's conclusion that "Alooma's general military success may have owed more to other devices than to guns"is justified. Neverthless, the introduction of firearms to Bornu, was an important chapter in African military history for more than just the few victories they offered. The firearms accentuated Bornu's cosmopolitanism and contributed to its legacy as a major African power. While the diplomatic engagements which brought the firearms were primarily intended for other objectives, they resulted in the arrival of European slave soldiers in Bornu, challenging our understanding of human exchanges across the Sahara. Unlike the Portuguese musketeers who had a rather mixed record in Benin (where they were eventually expelled), the European and Turkish soldiers in Bornu's army appear to have constituted an effective fighting force that was integrated into Bornu's society, and credited with contributing to the empire's success.

References:

History of the First Twelve Years of the Reign of Mai Idris Alooma of Bornu by Ahmed Ibn Fartua (Translated by H. R. Palmer )

Guns for the Sultan: Military Power and the Weapons Industry in the Ottoman Empire by Gábor Ágoston

Du lac Tchad à la Mecque by Remi Dewiere

The Ottoman World, the Mediterranean and North Africaby Colin Heywood

The Penetration of Africa : European Exploration in North and West Africa to 1815 by Robin Hallett

L'esclave, le savant et le sultan : représentations du monde et diplomatie au sultanat du Borno by Remi Dewiere

Firearms in the central Sudan by Humphrey J. Fisher and Virginia Rowland

A Seventeenth Century Belgian Visitor to Agadez and the North of Nigeria by Joseph Kenny

The Slave and the Scholar: Representing Africa in the World from Early Modern Tripoli to Borno (N. Nigeria) by Rémi Dewière

link 

Files

Previews only

Comments

GhostofOkello

During mali's peak in the 14th century, it was noted that they were acquiring Mamluk slave boys and girls from Egypt, and about 50 mamluk armed men were reported to have been seen serving as slave guards in the palace in Mali. They might also count as european slave soldiers. There was also another case in the coastal kingdom of Bissua, in the 16th century, if i am interpreting what I think is on page 7 of "Ethiopia Minor and a geographical account of the Province of Sierra Leone" the king enslaved a Portuguese captain of a ship & his crew, having them in his service, seizing their ship which he added to his own fleets ( after his marines attacked & looted it with french pirates) & I am inclined to believe that he used them to operate the ship he added to his armed fleets of watercraft to repel bijago naval attacks and incursions on his waters.

Isaac Samuel

im not sure about the slaves of Mansa Musa, i think they mention that they came from Damascus, but the story about the Portuguese is very interesting, ill definitely read more about it

GhostofOkello

I think the damascus reference is from Battuta, when talking about the place of origin of one of the female servants he found in the service of a Malian scholar. The reference on the mamluks serving in the palace in Mali comes from al Umari when writing about what is to be seen/ what happens when the Malian king is seated in his palace