Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

For over 40 years in the early 19th century, the kingdom of Merina on the African island of Madagascar was the site of one of the world's most ambitious attempts at early industrialization outside the northern Atlantic. Prior to its rise, Merina was checkered with a myriad of small polities, each ruled from hilltop fortresses. but in just fifty years from 1780 to 1830, the state was unified under a single ruler, creating a vast empire that held sway over most of the Island of Madagascar, a landmass about the size of France and Belgium combined.

Emerging at the onset of French and British imperial expansion on the east African coast, the Merina state maintained a delicate balance of power with its new hostile neighbours. The sovereigns of Merina undertook an ambitious project of economic development intended to attain self-sufficiency in agriculture and industry, and to become the only power on the island. Schools were constructed, foreign artisans and entrepenuers were encouraged to settle at the capital, and technological innovations were adopted as long as they didn't threaten Merina's sovereignty.

Merina's early industrialization heralded an era of economic transformation that was unprecedented on the east African coast. Factory towns produced rifles, cannons, gunpowder, silk and cotton textiles, glass, and tanned leather; sugar plantations and refineries sprung up across the kingdom, and tanneries supplied military equipment for the growing Merina military.

This article explores the history of Early industrialization in the Merina kingdom, from its emergence in the 1820s until its decline in the mid-19th century.

Factory building in Mantasoa, Madagascar ca. 1900, imagesdefense

Brief background on the history of Madagascar and the Merina kingdom before the mid 19th century

The island of Madagascar was settled by Austronesians and Africans (Bantu-speaking) origin since the beginning of the common era. Both groups imported social and cultural innovations from both Indonesia and Africa, and maintained political and economic links with both regions, even as the African ties increasingly became more predominant. At the turn of the 2nd millennium, Swahili city states emerged along the northern coastline of the island, and by the middle of the second millennium, small polities begun to emerge in the interior, the most significant of which was the Merina state in the central highlands.

The Merina state was founded in the early 16th century but it remained a small polity until the late 18th century during the reign of Andrianampoinimerina (r. c.1795-1810) when it expanded over 1/3 of the island. Merina's expansion continued under his sucessor Radama I (r.1810-28) and foreign alliances with the British ensured a continued flow of arms and an expansion in the domestic economy. In the late 1820s, British imperial pretensions to the island competed with those of the Merina, forcing the Merina court to reject the British alliance and free trade and adopted autarkic policies. The central tenets of autarky were state regulation of foreign trade, promotion of industry, and the creation of an island empire whose resources were to form the basis of autarkic economic development. These policies were begun during the later reign of Radama I and were greatly expanded by his sucessor Queen Ranavalona I (1828-1861).

(The Adoption of Autarky)

Expansion of the Merina kingdom in the early 19th century.

Society and Economy in early 19th century Merina

Like most pre-industrial societies, the Merina economy was primarily based on rice agriculture and animal husbandry supplemented by small scale handicraft industries. Merina rice production provided a steady surplus which supported a dense population and stocked local markets with rice, enabling the kingdom to offset seasonal shortages by moving grain between the different provinces. An average Merina family of four to five people, working 330 days a year on one hectare of land, produced from 2,000 to 2,500 kg of rice.

(Riziculture and the Founding of Monarchy in Imerina pg 289-308, An economic history of imperial madagascar pg 26)

Cloth was woven from tree bark, leaves, raffia, hemp, cotton, and silk, all of which grew locally. The weavers often used ground looms that produced a maximum cloth size of about 3 by 1 meters, that was dyed with indigo and natural red dyes. Red silk shrouds for burying the elite were woven in the nothern Merina, jewellery smiths made ornaments of gold, silver and copper alloys, while members of caste groups like the Andrianando specialized in the repair of rifles and manufacture of ammunition.

(Textile trades consumer cultures pg 316-319, An economic history of Imperial Madagascar pg 31-33)

The core regions of Merina contained several rich iron deposits with mines that went upto 7m deep and sufficient forests for fuel. Merina was home to a number of large iron-smelting sites including at Miarinarivo, Ambatolaivy, Antsihanaka and at Amoronkay. In particular, the site of Amoronkay which lay on the fringes of the eastern forest and contained rich iron ores was the main iron-smelting region of the kingdom. From these sites came iron products including agricultural implements, domestic tools and iron weapons, the latter of which were primarily used by the kingdom's armies.

(An industrial experiment pg 529, An economic history of Imperial madagascar pg 34-36)

Merina was at the center of a long-distance trade network of exchanges that fostered regional specialization. Each province had its own markets regulated by the state through stewards known as Tsiarondahy. These markets served as centers both of commercial exchange and of public address where royal edicts were published. Most transactions were facilitated by the use of Spanish silver piastres which were imported since the 17th century, as well as cloth, salt, captives, and gunpowder. These were often acquired through export trade for which the Merina sold cattle, rice, captives, and other produce to passing European ships and european colonies in the western Indian ocean.

(The Structure of Trade in Madagascar)

rice harvest in Madagascar, ca. 1945

Labour, Transport and the Education system of Merina in the early 19th century

Like all pre-industrial societies, the main factor of production driving the economy of the Merina state was labour. Human labour of all forms was a central feature of Merina's agricultural and handicraft industries; from the predominant subsistence family units working their own farms, to various kinds of corvee labour (fanompoana) working for the elites, and to captives who were retained or exported. The use of corvee labour, which primarily consisted of free merina subjects, relied on pre-existing systems of labour extraction such as the caste based labour system. Traditionally, caste based units of anywhere between 10 and 1000 men were originally used in agricultural projects with a duration of about a month, but were later expanded to include other civil and military duties, for an indefinite duration. In the 1830s under the reign of Ranavalona, the fanompoana units for skilled artisans numbered about 10,000 while the Merina army was about 20-30,000 strong.

(An economic history of imperial madagascar pg 83-85)

Captives on the other hand, were derived from internal processes of expansion, warfare between the dozens of states which controlled the island, as well punishments for crimes within Merina. Many were retained locally to serve in domestic contexts, but also in commercial activities as porters. A significant share of captives were exported to the east African coast since the mid-2nd millennium, and later to the French islands to Mauritius. However, between 1817-1820, the Merina king Radma I (r. 1810-1828) signed a number of treaties to end the slave exports from territories he controlled. As the slave exports gradually declined, most Malagasy captives were retained locally and a small minority were also imported from Mozambique.

(Madagascar and the Slave Trade)

The population Merina gradually begun to acquire skills beyond their traditional caste specializations once mission schools were established. The London Missionary Society began its operations in Imerina in 1818 and by 1822 had established atleast 3 church schools. The LMS was closely associated with Merina's diplomatic relations with the British and although they were exempted from the expulsion of foreign merchants during the period of autarky, their activities were closely regulated and they greatly depended on the royal court. From this society came the foreign entrepenuers like Laborde, Canham and James Cameron, all of whom were close associates of king Radama and Queen Ranalova.

(An economic history of imperial Madagascar pg 86-89)

The school system of Merina which was formally brought under direct state control in 1824, and expanded from three schools in 1822 to 100 schools with over 5,00 students in 1828. Besides training Merina administrators and soldiers, students also acquired craft education and were dispatched as apprentices under foreign artisans. Some merina students were sent to Britain and the Mauritius islands to learn the arts of gun and gunpowder manufacture, factory textile production, carpentry. While the formal school system was abolished in 1835, informal schools continued to operate in the chapels across the kingdom

(An industrial experiment pg 535-539)

Radama initiated improvements in internal communications in 1820 partly at the urging of the British. He constructed an "excellent road fit for a carriage" in the capital Antananarivo, and built similar roads in Mahavelona in 1822-3, as well as bridges across the rivers Ivondrona and Ikopa. The first horse-drawn carts were introduced in the early 1820s, as well as a courier service in 1821 which could relay messengers along the 200km Antananarivo-Toamasina route in just two days. Radama I also summoned large numbers of Betsimisara from the north-east of the island, to improve and extend the east coast canal system in 1827.

(An industrial experiment pg 551)

State Mission Schools in Central Imerina, 1828-32.

Plantations, Factory towns and Industry in the Merina kingdom.

The first plantations were set up in 1825 when Radama negotiated with the merchants Arnoux and Delastelle (both from the Reunionnai) for the creation of coffee and sugar plantations on the east coast. These proved highly sucessful and encouraged the establishment of more plantations across the kingdom, especially following the death of Arnoux and the takeover of his assets by the Reunionnais firm of de Rontaunay that was associated with Laborde. By the late 1840s, the firm invested over $400,000 in sugarcane cuttings, machinery and skilled personnel to establish and run the large sugar plantations at Tsarahafatra, Bakoro, Mananzara, Soamandrakiza. In all, these plantations had an average annual output of 500 tons of sugar and 2,000 barrels of rum.

Plantations of cloves, vanilla and silk work were also established. In 1835, Laborde established a clove plantation at Rianambo near Mahela which had by 1845 produced 6,610 kilograms of cloves worth $1,983 on the French market to which it was exported. Vanilla, brought from Reunion, was planted at Mahela in 1840 by Delastelle, along with other crops like palm oil and a rearing house for silkworm with an annual out put of 200 kilograms of raw silk.

(An industrial experiment pg 547-549)

Plans were made for the construction of a water-powered cotton factory with imported British sewing machines, with the aim of producing 5,000 cotton pieces a year. The LMS guaranteed half the capital, and Cameron was commissioned to construct a water-mill supplied from a canal leading from the river Ikopa. In an attempt to protect the cotton factory from foreign competition, Radama I in 1827 ordered cattle exports to be paid in cash rather than foreign cloth, but after the French invasion of the northeast coast, his sucessor Ranavalona I substituted for textiles the idea of an armaments factory. Small scale textile factories would neverthless be established by Thomas Rowlands who used simpler spinning machines.

(Textile Trades, Consumer Cultures, pg 324-327)

Arguably the most sucessful industry during this period was the manufacture of ammunition and firearms. Ranavalona I established four factories in the vicinity of Antananarivo: a gun powder mill at Isoraka under the direction of Cameron and Rainimanana (a British-trained Merina subject); a sword and bayonet factory under Chick at Amparibe; a musket factory and cannon foundry at Ilafy (later at Mantasoa), under the direction of Droit and Laborde; and three tanneries for military equipment at Ambohimandroso, Andoharano, and Vodivato, under Canham.

(An industrial experiment pg 544)

The gun powdermills that were initially under Cameron but later under indegenous management, were described as being 'on an immense scale' were in full production by 1835. The Amparibe factory of Chick produced 48,000 bayonets and swords per year in the period from 1832-1835. The musket foundry of Laborde was beset by a lack of water and fuel but still succeeded in 'manufacturing exceptionally good gunpowder and muskets' at a rate of about one a day, before Laborde shifted it to Mantasoa in 1837.

Funded by the Merina state to a tune of $100,000, Mantasoa comprised five factories containing blast furnaces, forges, hydraulic machines, and numerous craftshops all supplied with water from an aqueduct. 1,200 workmen at Mantasoa produced cannon, swords, bricks, tiles, pottery, glass, porcelain, silk, soap, candles, sealing-wax, lime, cement, charcoal, ink, dyes, sugar, rum, sulphuric acid, and lightning conductors. The tanneries under Canham were also sucessful especially after the king ordered the hides, suet and neats foot oil of all slaughtered cattle to be sent to Canham, over 16,500 hides being surrendered in 1828 alone.

(An economic history of imperial Madagascar pg 95-98, An industrial experiment pg 545-547, 541)

Mantasoa industrial complex

Mantasoa blast furnace, ca. 1914, imagesdefence

Mantasoa glass oven, ca. 1914, imagesdefense

Mantasoa porcelain kiln, ca. 1914, imagesdefense see another photo of both here

Cannon made at the time of Jean Laborde, 19th century

Stagnation and decline of early industrialization in the Merina kingdom.

In all these industrial projects, the primary challenge for Merina was the organization and productivity of labour. Factory labour used in the armaments and on the plantations was often a mixture of corvee and captives. Merina's industrial labour was thus simply an extension of traditional forms of the state's labour organization, rather than an organic transition from subsistence labour to free wage labour. Its therefore unsurprising that no significantly wealthy local entrepreneurs emerged since all surplus was absorbed by the state and the foreign entrepreneurs. This presents a stark contract to the commodities boom on the African mainland, where, despite the lack of a state-directed industrialization program similar to Merina, most profits from trade were retained locally creating a merchant class along the entire coastal stretch from Senegal to Nigeria to Somalia.

The limitations of labour in Merina's early industrialization first come to light with the abandonment of factory manufactured textiles, which in all industrialized nations was often the first sector to create significant numbers of wage labourers and grow them sustainably. In Merina society, cloth production was an ubiquitous part-time activity in the ordinary households during the off-peak agricultural season from June to August. As one observer remarked; "Every woman in the country from the King's wives to the Slaves are weavers. Most families spin and weave the whole of their own clothing. The markets are stocked with home made clothes. No cloth meets with a rapid sale... if it be not superior to their own in whiteness, fineness, brilliance of colours". This is pre-industrial subsistence labour par excellence where people make just enough for their consumption and any excess is sold or remitted as tribute.

(An industrial experiment pg 543)

Merina labour was thus optimally distributed between the two main economic activities of intensive hydraulic riziculture and cloth-making, with just enough surplus output for markets and state tribute. Therefore, without significant changes in labour productivity in either of these two main economic activities (such that less labour is needed to produce higher rice yields and more cloth), no significant surplus labour was available for other economic activities. The state made up for this labour shortfall by artificially increasing labour supply through expanding the pre-existing corvee and slave labour system. Upto 12.5% of Merina's population were drafted in the construction and maintainence of factories, clearing forests, maintain plantations and transport goods. In response, Merina workers refused to teach apprentices, absconded, revolted or simply fled from factories and settlements were abandoned to avoid labour drafts.

(An industrial experiment pg 553-557, The State and Pre-Colonial Demographic History)

Compounding the labour challenges was a poorly maintained network of tracks and bridges, and a transport system which depended on human porterage. This doubtlessly delayed the procurement of resources needed to run the factories, and also slowed down the rate at which they could be exported or redistributed throughout local markets. Its therefore unsurprising that despite the cheap labour, Merina produce could find no significant market domestically nor globally. An example of this is Thomas Rowland's textile factory which was running at only 25% of capacity by early 1824, as Merina spinners couldn’t provide him with a reliable supply of cotton.

(An economic history of imperial Madagascar pg 73-74)

As one foreign entrepreneur commented: “The demand for native cloth and manufactures, which is sold at a price materially lower than the purchaser of the raw article can afford, does not admit of his attempting a competition in weaving.” But it wasn't just local cloth that was cheaper, even foreign cloth was more affordable than local factory produced cloth. For example, Manchester cottons sold cheaper in Antananarivo at about $3.5-4.0 a piece in 1826, than the equivalent produced by Thomas Rowlands whose cheapest cloth retailed at $6 a piece.

The challenges weren't restricted to cloth trade but also to sugar; from 1834 to 1845 the de Rontaunay plantations produced 1,555 tons of sugar for export to France, but found competition intense. Conversely, rum manufactured on the east coast plantations at $26.4 a barrel, failed to meet domestic demand as large quantities of rum from Mauritius continued to be imported into Madagascar. And Canham forced to ask $2 for each pair of shoes he produced, which effectively restricted their sale to the local luxury market, whose clients preferred to import their goods from abroad.

(An economic history of imperial Madagascar pg 75-79)

The Merina's nascent industrial sector was thus dependent on the ability of the state to provide labour and the foreign entrepreneurs to provide the capital and skills. However, The latter's contribution was greatly undermined following the mass expulsion of foreigners in 1835 and 1857 which briefly paralyzed foreign trade. Again, between 1845 and 1854 foreign commerce was greatly restricted due to an official ban on British and French nationals trading in Madagascar in retaliation for a combined Britanno-French bombardment of the Merina port town of Toamasina.

(An industrial experiment pg 552)

By the mid-1850s, the Merina industrial experiment had all but faltered, and after Laborde’s expulsion from the island in 1859 for political intrigue, production at the factory town of Mantasoa ended. Eventually however, the Merina economy recovered in the 1860s and 1870s, benefiting from an expanding international and regional economy, but this time it exported traditional commodities rather than industrial goods.

references:

Textile Trades, Consumer Cultures, and the Material Worlds of the Indian Ocean edited by Pedro Machado

An economic history of imperial Madagascar by Gwyn Campbell

Riziculture and the Founding of Monarchy in Imerina by Gerald M. Berg

An industrial experiment in Pre-Colonial Africa by Gwyn Campbell

The Adoption of Autarky in Imperial Madagascar by Gwyn Campbell

Madagascar and the Slave Trade by Gwyn Campbell

The Structure of Trade in Madagascar by Gwyn Campbell

The State and Pre-Colonial Demographic History by Gwyn Campbell

link

Comments

No comments found for this post.