Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

In the early 19th century, an ailing patient in the city of Zaria wrote a letter to his physician complaining of an illness and outlining its symptoms. The physician, based in the city of Sokoto, responded to his patient that "From the description and symptoms of your ailment as contained in the letter, I think you suffer from a kidney problem.”

He then proceeded to describe the problems associated with the kidney, prescribed the drugs to be taken and the methods of administration. This African physician was Muhammad Bello, one of several scholars from the region who wrote on the topic of medicine.

West Africa has a rich history of Medical writing dating back to the emergence of the region's written traditions and intellectual cultures. For centuries, west African scholars composed some of the continent's oldest and most comprehensive collections of Medical manuscripts, which included pharmacology, classification of diseases, surgery, and anatomy.

The contents of these manuscripts, especially regarding scientific experimentation and discovery, attest to the level of intellectual development in the region and Africa's contribution to the field of medicine.

This article explores the history of Medicine in Africa, focusing on the medical manuscripts of four west African scholars from the 15th to the 19th century.

The Shifāʼ al-asqām al-ʻāriḍah (Book on curing external and internal illnesses) by the 17th century scholar Ahmad al-Raqqadi, at Timbuktu's Mamma Haidara Library.

Background on medical writings in west Africa and the history of medicine in the Islamic world.

Medicine is today understood as the science and art of dealing with the maintenance of health and the prevention, alleviation, or cure of disease. But for most of the pre-modern era, medicine was a much broader term that included not just preserving good health and curing diseases but also, hygiene, nutrition, psychology, divination and astrology, among others.

Keeping with the broader term for medicine as it was known in the pre-modern times, the west African medical works studied here refer to the composite body of knowledge of exact works which deal with the challenges of human existence, not only with regard to the more immediate problem of maintaining physical health and combating disease, but also the problem of guaranteeing success, and avoiding misfortune.

Many of the extant medical manuscripts from west Africa can be subdivided into three broad genres based on their approach to solving human challenges. First is the "traditional" medicine, which utilizes plants and mineral-based substances to treat problems related to physical health, it includes both the classical medicine of the Greco-Roman, Persian and Indian thought, as well as additional discoveries by Islamic physicians (including Africans) in their various local contexts. Second is theological medicine, which mostly utilizes Quranic teachings and hadiths to solve both physical and spiritual ailements. Lastly is esoteric medicine, which uses talismans and amulets to offer protection against malevolent spirits and people, as well as to grant the user good fortune.

(The Social Basis of Health and Healing in Africa pg 179-180)

West African physicians/doctors/healers of all kinds combined knowledge of all the above forms of medicine to treat their clients’ diverse health and spiritual problems. Their methods of healing and protection such as herbal remedies, dietary changes, ad hoc surgery, Greeco-Roman humoral medicine, and Qur’ānic recitation, have often coexisted as clients sought help from a variety of experts both Muslim and non-Muslim. It is in this context that medical manuscripts were produced by west African scholars not long after the emergence of the region's intellectual communities.

(The History of Islam in Africa pg 478-483, Invoking the invisible pg 7-8)

the west african empires of the middle ages

The medical manuscripts of west African scholars are primarily based on the works of the Islamic physicians of the golden age such as the Abbasid era Persian scholars; Abu Bakr al-Razi (ca. 865-925) and Ibn Sina (980-1037). These two wrote extensively on medicine and diseases, greatly improving upon the works of classical physicians of the Greco-Roman era such as Galen (d. 59BC) and Hippocrates (fl 500BC). According to this theory all things were composed of four elements (arkan): fire, air, water and earth. The mixture of the elements was called temperament (mizaj).

Life was maintained by the innate heat (harara ghariziya), which was contained in the heart. The innate heat was nourished by four spirits, pneumata (arwah). Illness was defined as a state of humoral imbalance, the purpose of treatment was to restore the balance, and maintain health by balancing their temperament. In this context Muslim physicians also explored various theological and esoteric thoughts of classical cosmology that offered treatments and protection for various ailments, both physical and supernatural. Their pragmatic approach at accepting and improving upon scientific theories from non-Muslim scholars would however become a source of contention among the Muslim elites of the post-Abbasid era, especially in Mamluk Egypt.

(The Social Basis of Health and Healing in Africa pg 181, The prophet's medicine pg 44-46, Avicenna's medicine, Harmony in Healing pg 64-67)

The strongest criticism of the older works of Abbasid pyscians came from the Mamluk-Egyptian scholar Ibn al-Nafis (1213-1288) who famously adhered to strict religious strictures and traditionalist dogmas. Ibn al-Nafis was characterized by his supporters as an "orthodox" physician to rival Ibn Sina, and was co-opted for the emerging genre of Tibb al-nabi (ie: Prophetic medicine). The tibb al-Nabī, was a harmonization of the Graeco-Islamic medical tradition with the Qur'ān and the ḥadīth, in order to attract more “orthodox” Muslims to medicine. But it was perceived by most traditionalist Muslim scholars as a rival medical system to that of Galen that had been popularized by Ibn Sina. Medieval Islamic medicine had long been dominated by non-Muslim physicians, but after the political upheaval following the Mongol sack of Bagdad (1254) and failed attack on Egypt, many traditionalists called for the removal of non-Muslim elites from positions of power in Mamluk realms. This carried over to medicine where

Christians and Jews were barred from serving as doctors or receiving treatment in the state hospitals. It was in this context that the tibb al-Nabi was created. However, the ideological rivary between the two schools of thought continued several centuries after Ibn al-Nafis' death and their teachings were propagated beyond the Islamic heartlands.

(Science and Religion in Mamluk Egypt)

Folio's from a 16th century copy of Ibn Sina's canon, Library of Congress.

The medical writings of a 15th century Timbuktu scholar; Muhammad al-Kabari.

In West Africa, the medical writings of pyscians such as Ibn Sina and Ibn al-Nafis were transmitted through both primary and secondary sources, and were interpreted based on the theological leaning of a given scholar. As mentioned earlier, there was oftentimes no clear distinction between "traditional" medicine for treating physical diseases, and "theological"/"esoteric" medicine for 'treating' or 'protecting' from misfortune.

For example, what is arguably the earliest extant manuscript from Timbuktu, is a treatise on theology and esoteric sciences by Muhammad al-Kābarī (c. 1450) titled Bustān al-fawā’id wa-l-manāfiʿ (“The Garden of Excellences and Benefits”). Al-Kabari, who was among the celebrated sudani (ie: 'black') Soninke scholars from Kabara mentioned in the Timbuktu chronicles, was one of the most significant scholars of the period, having taught several prominent families of the Mali and Songhai era. his text indicates how to use the Islamic esoteric sciences such as letterism and numerological squares to heal physical illness and protect a community from misfortune.

(Invoking the invisible pg 55-57)

Al-Kabari's work on esoteric sciences was part of a broader genre which combined theology, ḥadith commentary, and esoteric sciences. Al-Kābarī begins with reference to various prayers for healing, fertility and love, as well as prayers for protection against tyrants, enemies, enviers, sorcery. All of these prayers were meant to be written on paper and worn on the body as talismans or amulets, or were to be written on a surface with charcoal ink and consumed. These practices and esoteric sciences were the subject of another early manuscript from west Africa dated to 1493, in which a west African theologian asked the Mamluk-Egyptian polymath Jalāl al-Dīn al-Suyuti about their permissibility. In responding to the letter, al-Suyuti deemed them to be blameless practices, thus sanctioning their popularization.

(The Islamic intellectual tradition of Sudanic Africa pg 62-69, Invoking the invisible pg 58-60)

Bustān al-Fawāʾid wa l-Manāfiʿ by Muḥammad b. Muḥammad b. Abū Bakr b. ʿAlī b. Mūsā al-Kābarī

The Medical writings of a 17th century Timbuktu scholar, Ahmad al-Kunti.

This regular correspondence between west African scholars and the rest of the Muslim world is emblematic of the back-and-forth exchanges between the intellectual centers on both ends of the Sahara. Al-suyuti had also written extensively on medicine (both traditional and prophetic) as well as esoteric sciences. His writings, along with the writings of west Africans like Al-Kabari, influenced the development of medicinal traditions in the region. One of the earliest works of traditional and prophetic medicine in west Africa was written by Ahmad al-Raqqadi al-Kunti (d. 1684). Al-Kunti was an important scholar who directed a Zawiya (sufi lodge) in Arawan, just north of Timbuktu, and was a prominent member of the city's Kunta scholary family.

Al-Kunti authored a 600-page medical treatise titled; Kitāb Shifāʾ al-asqām The Book on curing the external and internal illnesses to which the body is exposed. It is an encyclopedic compendium of medicine that offers a general audience a holistic approach to physical, mental, spiritual and even political afflictions. Its therefore a combination of Galenic humoral medicine, prophetic medicine, and traditional medicine.

(Livre de la guérison des maladies internes et externes affectant le corps by Floréal Sanagustin)

The first volume is largely composed of a discussion of the medical benefits of the recitation of specific Quranic suras mixed with traditional medicine. The second volume covers the remedies from Galenic medicine, which focus on the importance of a proper diet, an extended discussion of humors and a long list of substances that possess specific medical properties. The text then turns to the virtues of vegetal and mineral drugs/cures as prescriptions for specific illnesses. The third volume is a continuation of the second, that includes a description and cures of leprosy, and a lengthy account on sexual health, sexual maladies. The manuscript then concludes with therapeutic advice for particular health disorders, organized from head to toe.

Al-kunti cites several prominent scholars of medicine including the Greek physicians Hippocrates and Galen, as well as the Arab physician Al-Harith ibn Kalada (d. 634), Ibn Sina, among others. His various remedies include; using arsenic to cure hair loss, head ulcers, and hair lice. Applying cinnamon to wounds, using garlic, ghee and honey as general laxatives. Using dry ammonia for some respiratory issues, using natron for some skin ailments, drinking rose oil and sheep's milk to increase brain function, etc. He describes various medical conditions including comas, eye and ear diseases, nasal and dental diseases, chest and stomach ailments, limb diseases, etc, with cures for each.

Some of the scholars who analyzed the text assert that it bears testament to the decline of "secular"/ "rational" science in the broader Islamic world and that al-Kunti wished to minimize the influence of classical philosophy on Islamic medicine. But other scholars have urged caution, pointing to the continued co-existance of classical philosophy and science among Islamic scholars across all time periods, and arguing that one text is insufficient to make broad assertions on field of Islamic science.

(Kitāb Shifāʾ al-asqām, review by Cristina Álvarez Millán, An intriguing medical compendium by Justin Stearns)

Shifāʼ al-asqām al-ʻāriḍah fī al-ẓāhir wa al-bāṭin min al-ajsām by Ahmad al-Raqqadi al-Kunti

https://w3id.org/vhmml/readingRoom/view/534502

The medical writings of 18th and 19th century scholars; al-Fallati and Abdullahi Fodio in Bornu and Sokoto.

Indeed, as far as West African medicine is concerned, it appears that the purported decline of "secular"/traditional medicine in favor of the prophetic medicine is non-existent, as the 19th century scholars of medicine continued to draw from both and make their own innovations.

Several West African scholars wrote extensively about medicine in the 18th and 19th century. The earliest work known so far is a text on the treatment of haemarrhoids that was written by al-Tahir b. Ibrahim al-Fallati of Bornu around 1745. More detailed medicinal manuscripts were written by in the 19th century, especially by the scholars of the Sokoto empire in what is now northern Nigeria.

(ALOA Vol 2. pg 13)

The 19th century was as the golden age of Islamic Education in west Africa, largely precipitated by the emergence of the 'revolution' states across the region, the largest of which was the Sokoto empire. The major contributors to educational and intellectual renaissance of this period was the Sokoto founder Uthman Fodiyo (d. 1817) his brother; Abdullahi Fodiyo (d. 1829), his son Muhammad Bello (d. 1837) and his daughter Nana Asma’u (1864). These four have left a combined total of nearly 500 books on all subjects including medicine, the latter of which was a particular interest of Abdullahi Fodio and his nephew Muhammad Bello.

The medical writings of Abdullahi Fodio display his knowledge of classical Islamic texts on medicine derived from Galenic humoral theory. One such text written by Abdullahi Fodio that is titled Masalih al-insan al-muta’alliq bil-adyan wal-abdan (An important consideration for Man relating to religion and Health), in it, he outlines the influence of environmental factors on health and identifies the principal cause of sickness as an imbalance between heat, cold, dryness and moisture in the body. He also discusses the ethics of medical practice such being kind and hospitable to patients, and not practicing medicine solely for profit.

Another work titled Diya’ al-umma (The light of the community) includes advice on good dieting, treatments for snake bites and scorpion stings, as well as prohibitions on the use of alcohol in treatments. Some sections in both of these works were cleary influenced by the works of Ibn Sina which emphasize the balance of the four elements of material existence: fire (naar), air (hawaa), water (maa’) and earth (turaab) to enable good health and physical wellbeing. This was inturn ultimately based on the Humoral system of Greco-Roman thought, but in Abdullahi's work, it was moderated by the influences of prophetic medicine.

(Arabic medicinal manuscripts of northern Nigeria by Mukhtar Umar Bunza pg 92- 93, Scientific Education among Muslims in Northern Nigeria pg 10-12)

The medical writings of a 19th century Sokoto scholar: Muhammad Bello.

The medicinal manuscripts of Muhammad Bello display a much deeper knowledge of classical Islamic texts on medicine as well as a more "rational" approach through scientific experimentations. He expressed strong disapproval of almost all kinds of fortune/protection seeking and 'magic' that had been rather popular among contemporary Muslim scholars both in west Africa and in the Islamic heartland.

Bello was more keenly interested in medicine than his uncle, he was familiar with surgery and recorded several experiments of his own. When the British explorer Captain Clapperton visited Bello's capital in 1825, he gifted his host a copy of one of Ibn Sina's works, most likely the al-Qanun (Canon of Medicine ca. 1025) upon Bello's request. He also gave Bello an Arabic translation of Euclid -the ancient Greek mathematician.

(A note on attitudes towards the supernatural, pg 8, The Meanings of Timbuktu by Shamil Jeppie, pg 158)

In his text Musuj al-lijayn, Muhammad Bello explains the reason for studying medicine that, “only under healthy atmosphere or condition of the body some cardinal principles of Islam like prayers and fasting can be performed properly”. Therefore, knowledge of preservation of health, is by implication adding to the knowledge of worship of God. And in his Kitab al- Rahmati, Bello writes that "the study and practice of medicine had reached the position of Fard Ain, or specific obligation, due to the neglect of subject by the majority of Muslims. And their dependence on either pagan system of healing or the systems of the Jews and Christians".

While he was quoting a remark made in an older text, the concern over the stagnation of studies in medicine by Muslim intellectuals posed a real ideological challenge across the Muslim world on the eve of colonialism, as Muslim patients from across Arabia, North Africa and even the west African coast sought out treatments from European (Christian) pyscians, as well as "pagan" doctors. Bello was thus keen to respond to requests for effective prescriptions from his subjects, conduct his own experiments and documented his clinical research, and sought advice from visiting European explorers.

(Scientific Education among Muslims in Northern Nigeria pg 13)

In the Kitab al-rahmati, Bello compiles atleast 100 of his personal experimentations and observations of disease causation, symptoms and cure. He emphasizes that he tested each of the treatments that he recommends, and established their medicinal efficacy. This text was likely influenced by similar works by prolific writers on Islamic medicine such as Jalal al-Din al-Suyuti (d. 1505).

In contrast to his uncle, Muhammad Bello (d. 1837) had a more pragmatic approach to consulting non-Muslim sources of medicine, pointing to the fact that, some amongst the Ummayad and Abbasid Muslim Caliphs employed the services of non-Muslims physicians and even appointed them as their special advisers on Health. Bello also preferred the more scientific form of writing popularized by Ibn Sina than the more theological kind of the prophetic medicine genre. Bello's medical writings were influenced by the classical Islamic physicians, as atleast three of his works titled; Kitab Adwiyat lil-Uyun, Kitab al-Tibb al-Muhini, and Musgh al-Lijain, cited the works of Ibn Sina and al-Razi.

(Scientific Education among Muslims in Northern Nigeria by Mukhtar Umar Bunza, pg 11- 17)

Three other significant medical texts by Bello were the; Kitab al-tibb al-mu‘in almusamma bi-tibb al-‘ayn, the Kitab al-adwiyat lil-‘uyun, and the Musuj al-lijayn almusamma bi-tibb al-‘ayn; all of which deal with the treatment of eye diseases. Bello lists the different types of eye diseases, followed by the recommended treatments, many of which are lotions and drops derived from indegenous medicine. Besides these texts is the Risalat al-amrad al-kilyah wa ‘ilajiha, which deals with treatments for kidney complications, the Nubdha fi adwiyat al-didan, which deals with worm diseases, the Al-qawl al-mant hur fi adwiyat illat albathur, which deals with the treatment of piles, the Kitab al-qawl al-sinna, which explores the medicinal uses of the plant commonly known as cassia senna, and the Al-mawarid al-nabawiyya fi al-masa’il altibbiyya which deals with 'prophetic' medicine. All these texts are explored in some detail by the sources added below.

(Arabic medicinal manuscripts of northern Nigeria by Mukhtar Umar Bunza pg 93- 95)

Copy of the Kitab al-qawl al-sinna by Muhammad Bello, digitized by the endangered archives program

https://eap.bl.uk/archive-file/EAP535-1-4-1-10

Conclusion: Medicine in Africa's intellectual history.

More west African scholars composed writings on Medicine and pharmacopeia that constitute the majority of the extant "secular" manuscripts in the various libraries across the region. Many of these texts by anonymous authors contain descriptions of locally available medicine for treating diseases that affect both people and animals (especially horses), they also contain translations of classical Islamic medical writings intended to be read by a local audience unfamiliar with Arabic.

This brief overview of the Medical writings of four west African scholars should serve as an introductory text to the still nascent study of Africa's manuscript collections. It moves beyond the simple recognition of the presence of writing in Africa to instead focus on the contents of the documents composed by African writers inorder to gain further insight on the continent's intellectual history, that included not just history and the arts, but also sciences like Medicine.

Composite work on medicine titled Kitab al rahmati by Sheikh Abie Zaid Abduraman ban Nadar, Sokoto, 19th century.

https://eap.bl.uk/archive-file/EAP535-1-2-23-2

manuscript on dieting, by anonymous author, Timbuktu 1833.

https://w3id.org/vhmml/readingRoom/view/162098

Recipes for sexual health, anonymous author, Timbuktu, 18th-19th cent.

https://w3id.org/vhmml/readingRoom/view/161308

References:

The Social Basis of Health and Healing in Africa by Steven Feierman, John M. Janzen

The History of Islam in Africa by N. Levtzion

Livre de la guérison des maladies internes et externes affectant le corps by Floréal Sanagustin

Invoking the invisible in the Sahara by Erin Pettigrew

ALOA Vol 2. Arabic Literature of Africa Vol. 2 By John Hunwick

The Prophet's Medicine: A Creation of the Muslim Traditionalist Scholars by Irmeli Perho

Avicenna's Medicine: A New Translation by Mones Abu-Asab

Harmony in Healing: The Theoretical Basis of Ancient and Medieval Medicine By James J. Garber

Science and Religion in Mamluk Egypt by Nahyan Fancy

The Islamic intellectual tradition of Sudanic Africa by Zachary V. Wright

Kitāb Shifāʾ al-asqām, review by Cristina Álvarez Millán

An intriguing medical compendium by Justin Stearns

Arabic medicinal manuscripts of northern Nigeria by Mukhtar Bunza Scientific Education among Muslims in Northern Nigeria by M. Bunza

A note on attitudes towards the supernatural by M. Last

Link

Files

Previews only

Comments

No comments found for this post.