Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

running on 2%

Files

Comments

Smoochie

If *sigh* were a face it would be Jacob in the last panel.

MrShoggoth

Dumbing of Age, Book 16: CONSIDERABLE!

Andrea Andrew

So Sarah is trying to change, and fighting against her instincts to be frustrated! I wonder if Jacob still has any feelings or if Lucy has his full attention.

Shane Wegner

Being more agreeable with deliberate effort is still being more agreeable! Isn’t that what we hold up as a standard for excellence? What’s Jacob’s underlying thesis here? “If change is hard, why bother”?

Machalt

Man, it's kind of wild how much my opinion of Jacob dropped in just these last two strips. Someone should talk with her about this, sure, but holy sweet potato on a stick it should absolutely not be him doing so, and I could not fathom why he would think it's acceptable to pry in this situation. Like seriously, you can not like someone the way they like you, and that's fine, but you don't rub your new hook up in their face and then act like you have anything resembling the moral high ground when they react strangely

Andrea Andrew

Using the Triangle smile to get into a love triangle (not a polycule this time, Joyce).

Jim Farmer

Charitably, I think he's working toward a "If it takes that much effort, it isn't really you, and you deserve to be you and be loved for being you" end point. I don't entirely agree with that, but I can see where it comes from.

C

"I'm gonna try to be more chill...BUT IT ISN'T EASY!"

Sajuuk-Khar

Blondie. Take the W, Blondie. Stop trying to spin it into an L. An earnest attempt to change on Sarah’s part is fine, and even if it worries you, you don’t get to fuss over her and take care of it, because: you decided to bang a short queen with her heart on her sleeve and a Starfire poster, on account of Sarah being a mess! You have to let her try and fix the mess herself.

Uniquitous

At some point, you can't hold that flex any longer. The muscle relaxes, and all that it was holding up comes tumbling down.

David Jackson

Counterpoint: Jacob should pick at this scab and ruin everything.

David Jackson

(idk what it is about this comic but the worse everyone is the more I like it)

Sajuuk-Khar

I mean, as a wise man once said, you can do whatever you want in life

Morgan Byrd

I don’t think he’s holding a moral high ground, I think he’s bamboozled and they have a report. He’s a straight shooter, he addresses problems head-on. He and Danny are perhaps the only well-adjusted members of this cast.

Katrina Marie Paton

Trusting and amicable? Fine, just know that life is going to shit on you at every turn whether you're trusting and amicable regardless. Cynical and distant are always going to be a better response.

Grace Serenity

Jacob, buddy, you have had a terrible record with women so far, and this sure isn't helping! You let Raidah manipulate you, Joyce manipulate you, you gave Sarah a tepid response after she opened up , and then you hooked up with Lucy later that evening! You've got no ground to stand on and demand info from her.

Bronxden

If i'm being honest Sarah heart is in the right place but not executed properly but also i think Jacob shouldn't be the one to call her out because he was the heart of the reasoning and kinda showed her that her original approach wasn't working

Phil_M

Okay, so the people were right who guessed this is simply a conscious effort by Sarah to find a more profitable way of presenting herself. BUT - it is just a facade. Full marks to the art in the last panel, which shows that this is indeed costing her a lot of effort, and it really can’t last.

Phil_M

To be fair, he has the brains to realise that this isn’t plausible, and SOMEBODY has to try to find out what’s up with her. Even if it wouldn’t be him in a better world.

Phil_M

Trouble is, he wasn’t straight-shooter enough to deal with Sarah better in the first place. He has this self-image as an honest, emotionally intelligent good guy, but he mostly just desperately wants to be liked, which makes him too weak to do the right thing when it’s difficult. Edit: he doesn’t just want to be liked, he wants to be loved. That’s why he can’t refrain from flirting with any woman who looks vulnerable, and how Lucy got into his chinos on the first date. He wants devotion.

Gale Tazzin

Hey, "fake it til you make it" actually does work! Put on a brave face of being nice and after long enough, it's just habit and just who you are!

Lisa

I don't really understand why the comments section is so mad at Jacob here. I read this as him both caring about Sarah and understanding her well enough to ask the right questions and figure out what's really going on. It comes across as much more thoughtful than "check her eye dilation because she must be having a stroke." Everyone noticed that something was off about Sarah, but Jacob is the one who's investing the time and emotional energy to check in in a meaningful way rather than a flippant way. Moreover, he's understandably suspecting that she might still be trying to win his sexual interest, and he wants to make sure he's not leading her on now that he's figured out he's definitely not interested.

Phil_M

See the strip title and the last panel. Sarah simply can’t sustain faking this till she makes it.

Smoochie

Its kind of hard to take what Jacob is saying here as caring though, beyond himself. He immediately makes it clear this is never going to win him over. Sarah responds that she realizes that but obviously if people don’t like the real her, then she has to change who the real her is, even if it eats at her mental health to get there. So now the issue for him judging by that last panel is she should be the real her but which is it? If it’s not good enough to interest people Sarah has a genuine interest in, she should just be grumpy and alone? I get that maybe Jacob is of the mind that you should be your most honest self…but Jacob also has the privilege of being a walking Adonis, conventionally attractive, a natural sunny disposition and someone people genuinely want to get to know.

Phil_M

Yep. Points to Jacob for guessing this at least. When Sarah runs out of that last 2%, the crash could be nasty (and with any luck, it’ll be Lucy takes the force of the explosion).

Grace Serenity

The person to find out what's up with her is Joyce, not Jacob.

Sajuuk-Khar

I am cross with Jacob at the moment because he has what I would call a bad habit of stepping over people’s boundaries despite knowing his own and being very firm about them. I don’t think he’s doing it out of malice, he’s a very sincere and kind guy, but like, it’s not his business to judge Sarah’s attempt to change, or even to intervene out of concern. Especially not in the current situation!

Sajuuk-Khar

Joyce, or Dina, or even Liz.

Sajuuk-Khar

I mean, *if* that’s true, and she can’t, here’s the thing: it is not Jacob’s business

CakeMageMaeve

Oh, fuck off Jacob, you self-righteous prick.

Phil_M

Jacob wants to be loved and admired. He generally does reasonably good things to achieve that, but when it comes to the crunch, being loved is more important to him than being good.

Phil_M

He’s genuinely trying to be a friend, which means he can offer to help, and he realises that Sarah’s current stress level is largely due to his thoughtlessness, which makes him feel obliged to try and help. The real trouble is that he isn’t equipped to actually help. Plus, it’ll quite likely be Lucy’s dim-witted bubbliness that pushes Sarah over the edge and makes her revert with extreme prejudice, leaving him in the middle of the ensuing carnage.

Phil_M

Dina would be fun. The others all bring their own baggage to trying to help others (and Joyce’s compulsive shipping syndrome would very likely cause a disaster), but Dina works on understanding people from first principles, by logic. If Booster knew Jacob better, they could at least point out to Sarah that she never had a serious chance with him, because she can’t offer the one thing he wants, which is unconditional love. But what Sarah actually needs is probably a patient friend who can just listen, which may make Dina the best bet. Actually, it wouldn’t hurt if she found a guy with an honest romantic interest in her, because that would provide both the listening and a certain type of stress relief that she’s admitted she needs, but there’s a shortage of candidates. Which is sad, because there ought to be one guy in this group who likes a challenge and some honesty.

Phil_M

“It isn’t easy having a good time. The muscles on my face even hurt when I smile.”

Phil_M

He never had any real feelings for Sarah. She was interesting, and offering him admiration, which is his addiction, but only Lucy offers him unconditional adoration. Why go back to the waft of smoke when you can mainline the hard stuff?

SkittleE

"Hey girl, I see you're putting a lot of effort into being a pleasant and understanding person, especially in the face of me doing you real dirty last night. Just wanted to let you know that I know you're doing it all for my D, and it's not gonna work." Oh my god Jacob fuck OFF

Shane Wegner

I agree it could well collapse, because it's not like people will suddenly become more tolerable and all of life's slings and arrows still exist. But to use a weight lifting metaphor, training until failure, resting and trying again is one of the fastest ways to increase strength.

Jay

I feel like this is a good conversation for Sarah to have (re: I want to try and be more personable/social to not drive people I like away, but also find doing so exhausting). Just not with Jacob. But I can also appreciate that Sarah might not want to have this conversation with other people in her social orbit at the moment, especially with how most of them just kinda went "well this is weird, but bye I have my own stuff" just now. And so Jacob being the only to actually try and have it with her might be better than nothing. Mostly want to wait and see where the rest of this conversation goes first.

Jeremy AR

I notice a lot of times that the comment section gets weird about Jacob, often viewing what he does or says in the most uncharitable light possible. Same things happens with Lucy. It's pretty annoying.

Jeremy AR

How did he "let" Raidah manipulate him though?

Jeremy AR

I will continue to like Jacob despite what the comments might say. It's probably going to get really annoying tomorrow.

Simon Magid

@Jeremy AR: Easy. You just blame him for not seeing through her. It is obviously his fault since he was the victim.

Jeremy AR

I really hope you are being sarcastic.

Jeremy AR

In a way that it's probably going to end with her very burned out! I think autistic people often called "masking" and it can be very exhausting.

Jeremy AR

I think it's more like "It's it takes this much effort it probably gonna be very mentally exhausting and end with you having a meltdown" which is a reasonable concern!

Jeremy AR

Okay I was kind of with you in other comments but now you are just making shit up. I do not think Jacob is "addicted" to admiration or want unconditional devotion, I don't think there ever was any evidence of that.

Jeremy AR

The best kind of right!

Phil_M

Mmm. If Sarah wasn’t acting nice, she could be acting very bitter. It wasn’t just Jacob at the party and subsequently; her so-called friends basically ignored her feelings. This attempt is her response to hitting rock bottom; trying to fight her way back up is better than the alternative.

Phil_M

He’s the victim there, but he was susceptible, for all his niceness, because he wants to be loved. It’s a flaw that makes him manipulable.

Phil_M

It’s an overly cynical way of putting it, but some degree of cynicism is a valid defence mechanism for most people. If Sarah overdoes the trustingness, she’s going to get hurt, and will likely flip back worse than before.

Phil_M

She needs to talk to Dina…

Phil_M

His behaviour towards Joyce and Sarah suggested it; the way he fell over and dumped all his supposed principles when hit with Lucy’s Luciness clarified it. The guy’s an admiration junkie. Edit: There are of course worse things to want than to be liked, and “addiction” is partly a metaphor here. But the way he completely forgot about Sarah when Lucy came on to him, not even remembering her existence until Jennifer reminded him, really was junkie behaviour.

Phil_M

In the gym, that just means you drop a few weights and maybe strain a muscle a little. In social relationships, it’d get a reputation for alternately acting nice and wigging out into screaming fits of nastiness. People wouldn’t respect you for the effort, they’d call you a psycho.

Em

Wondering how you think she should execute this, though? If she’d been bitter then people would just assume she was living down to her reputation.

Em

He’s being a self-centered dick. He’s also being self-righteous in a way that isn’t his province. “It won’t win me back.” Where the fuck does he get off?

Em

Annoying because people are going to cal him on his dickishness? He’s being an asshole. Sarah’s reasonings for wanting to make a change are valid.

Em

Why people are reading his actions as any other way is a mystery to me. Do people really hate Sarah that much as a character?

Jeremy AR

Being valid doesn't mean it is a good or healthy idea. And I am sorry but I don't think he is being as much of an asshole as everyone insist he is. I am not going to agree with you on that.

Em

He’s making assumptions that are very shitty though. At what point has Sarah ever been inclined to “emulate” someone with the express purpose of getting into Jacob’s pants? If she were that sort of person, she could have “emulated” Joyce, the one girl Jacob has shown major attraction to other than Lucy (my personal opinion is that he was lukewarm on Raidah, which is why it was no skin off his nose dumping her even though he wasn’t going to go to Joyce.) Sarah is being vulnerable here in saying that she is making a conscious shift because she realizes being closed-off and grumpy isn’t working for her. And he immediately jumps to “This is just a nefarious plot to get to my dick.” It’s an asshole move.

Em

Okay, forget Jacob then. We agree to disagree on him. I’m curious as to what you want Sarah to do. She realizes being closed-off and remote is shutting her away from opportunities she might otherwise have. Not with Jacob — that was a nonstarter from the start — but with others. Should she maybe enroll in therapy? Sure. But in the meantime, she has to live in this world with these people. If being cheerful is helping her cope, why is this more a bad idea than, say, her spiraling and punching Lucy in the face like she did Raidah?

Jeremy AR

I don't want her to do anything in particular since I don't write the story so my thoughts of what she should do are irrelevant. I just pointing out that choosing to constantly put out a image of amicability that goes counted of her usual instincts and, as she says here, requires quite a lot of mental effort to maintain is very likely to end with her burning out emotionally and worsening he'd mental health even more. And that would make for an interesting plot so I wish to see how long she will keep it up.

Em

I think this is fair. I feel that I’m just thinking that Sarah has to deploy actual skills to get her over the disappointment. Is this the best way? Probably not, but it’s a start. And maybe she’ll come to another realization that she doesn’t have to jump in with both feet. It can be a gradual thing.

Phil_M

I agree that Jacob is right to raise this issue with Sarah, but I also think that he's the wrong person to be raising it (except for the fact that none of the other kids seem to have the basic sense to do so). This fits with the general picture that's emerged of Jacob; he is, technically, a good person, but he's also deeply flawed, and his flaws are tangled up with his self-image as a good person. (Edit: Quite how much of a good person he's entitled to think he is may now be tested by how guilty he acts. It didn't even hit him until the morning that Sarah might have cause to be deeply unhappy and pissed off with him, but we can put that down to him being drunk on his infatuation with Lucy. He's now had the minimal grace to apologise, and he's realised that her reaction, while not as horrible as it could have been, is putting her under severe stress. I assume he'll do something about that realisation; the worst thing would probably be offering her sanctimonious advice, while about the only helpful thing I can think for him to do is to warn the rest of the group off making things worse for her for a while - without violating too many confidences - and in particular, telling Lucy to STFU when within a mile of Sarah, because Lucy could all too easily cause Sarah to detonate in stressed-out rage.)

Jeremy AR

I don't really understand where the whole "technically a good person" come from or that it is a self image thing and not just how he is

Phil_M

He is, as you say, naturally pleasantly, sometimes (not always) empathetic, and not mean-spirited. That's a good basis for being a "good person", somebody with those virtues can think of themselves as good, and he sometimes uses that empathy to good purpose, suggesting that he genuinely wants to be good - it's part of his self-image. But his behaviour also suggests that he enjoys being loved; he reacts to people like Joyce and Sarah flirtatiously despite that it's really playing with fire, he got into a relationship with Raidah despite the fact that he should have spotted that she's a horrible person, and he fell for Lucy's come-on like a drunken idiot, which I can only ascribe to her being so sunny and affectionate and outgoing. (Sure, he can like her, but he jumped straight into bed with her, despite his former claims to be all self-controlled.) It's either vanity or neediness, and it's what made his treatment of Joyce a bit iffy and his handling of Sarah downright horrible. It's those times that he shows that he's not entirely a good person, despite what he seems to think of himself. If he admitted that his instincts aren't automatically good, and that using other people as a source of validation can cause trouble, he might be less of a flawed character.

J R Quilcon

@Em: YES! You said perfectly what I wuz thinkin'!

Jeremy AR

I don't agree with you. I just leave it at that because I don't wanna keep discussing this.

Phil_M

(By the way, sorry that I keep posting incomplete screeds. Blame the Web page software.)

Diane

So about what I assumed, we'll have to determine later if she's truthful or just playing the long game. I do really hope she's just trying to be better though. She needs to move past Jacob. Hell, she don't need anyone imo.

Phil_M

I think she does. She needs someone she can open up to (with less baggage involved than with Jacob), because everyone needs that sometimes, and she made it pretty clear that part of her interest Jacob was sheer horniness, and she's not really the kind of person to sublimate that need for relief. It doesn't have to be a romance for the ages, just enough to give her some close human contact and occasionally get her rocks off. (It'd also save her from fixating on the feeling that she screwed up with Jacob.)

Sajuuk-Khar

@Jeremy: I agree with you on this much, even if I am currently cross with the boy, and it sucks. But I am resigned to this happening literally all the time to every character I like. Poor Dorothy is also often subject to ten billion slings and arrows, to say nothing of any time Becky is mildly annoying.

SkittleE

I mean, as far as I've seen from the comments, they absolutely do.

Bronxden

Honestly that’s a tough one and don’t get me wrong she’s a fav of mines but I just kinda hate how now Jacob is trying to call her out (not explicit yet) for being fake but it’s like dude you don’t have a good track record either and have been easily manipulated by others too.

The Aphro Chick

I want everyone to keep in mind that Jacob was with Raidah at one point. It I'd highly likely that she somewhat poisoned his opinion of her. That being said, he's still being a majorly self-centered dick right now.

Diane

Yeah, that's what I meant by need anyone, I meant romantically. Not that she needs to be all by herself. She has Joyce, for better or worse.

Diane

Ah wait, misread. Still don't think she needs romance. But that's the ace in me. Just needs someone to confide in and be open with, but no need for romance.

InkyD

Genuine question: does romance mean sex to the ace in you?

Bagge

Good on Sarah for doing an honest attempt. You know what, good on Sarah even if she's just being ironic. She can deal with shit however she wants. But I have to wonder just what kind of insult the universe will throw her way today to make her attempt at trusting, amicable and open go up in flames

Phil_M

Sarah *isn’t* ace, though, as she made clear to Jacob. She’s been feeling horny, and it’s highly unlikely that she’s got off with anyone since the strip started. At the risk of sounding like I’m saying that she just needs to get laid, she needs to get laid. She’s not the type for casual hook-ups - too many trust issues - but it doesn’t have to be a hearts-and-flowers romance; just a friend with benefits who she trusts enough to get physically and emotionally naked with would do her the world of good.

Diane

Not really. Sex is separate to me. I just have 0 desire for sex. But I get some apparently need romance to sex, Lucy seemed like one.

Girlycore

Calling Lucy "dim-witted" just because she's bubbly is wild.

Jeremy AR

You know, I am gonna say it: That felt just slightly bit racist.

Jeremy AR

This is a very weird way of viewing this situation I just wanted you to know that.

Phil_M

Girlycore: It *is* sometimes too tempting to equate bubbliness with dimness, I admit. Stereotypes like “the ditz” are a bit too pervasive. But that said, I really don’t think that Lucy is the sharpest knife in the box. Her line about being a good Christian girl and therefore only having sex on the third date suggested a lot of unexamined assumptions, just for a start. But, to be sure, half the cast are just as bad…

Phil_M

Jeremy: Uh, what?? I may be too prone to equating bubbliness with dimness, but what does her ethnicity have to do with that? Is there some weird American coding that I’m missing from the wrong side of the Atlantic?

Albi

The trick of being vulnerable (enough to create and maintain relationships) and shutting yourself off (to avoid harm) is a delicate one. I'm almost 40 and still struggle with it.