Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

i'm straight on till morning, but my peter is pan

Files

Comments

Kazo

You just don't like it cause you have to acknowledge Hat Guy exists.

Andrea Andrew

Joe likes trans women and nonbinary. Good to know If Dorothy and Joyce become poly, it’ll be three bi people now, I guess.

C

Joyce will remember this.

Machalt

Joe is bisexual, time to go update the wiki and Tv Tropes

Andrea Andrew

Joyce wants Joe to be open to sleeping with Carla and other trans people. How healthy.

Ragtime

Joe should've really paid attention in gender studies, he seems to have a Fazian grasp of sexuality here.

E

The first person I kissed is a they now, apparently that doesn’t retcon me into bisexuality

Maude Reads Things

Joe, I am begging you to put away the nonchalance and go into feelings territory for a few minutes. PLEASE.

Fart Captor

I'm not gonna rag on the person who said "Boyfriend Joe is an ally" yesterday, but I *am* gonna stare directly into the camera knowingly like Jim from The Office

Andrea Andrew

So he’s even worse than Joyce (who’s still kinda closeted bisexual).

Harold

@Minzoku Bokumetsu: Easy joke, of course - it's why Willis made it, I'm sure - but I doubt Danny is attracted to his lifelong best friend/roommate. We've never seen Dan have a moment like that hilarious reveal of sweaty shirtless Jacob as Ethan's roomie.

Moonrunes

Joyce you also used to believe there was an ocean above everyone and that the earth was like, a thousand years old or some shit.

Ragtime

Walky showed up to the pizza meet-up and has said at times that he would have sex with men for the right incentive or if they were hot enough ie Jacob. He hasn't been explicitly referred to as queer in the text of the comic yet.

Sajuuk-Khar

I mean, I get what you’re going for, Joyce, but on the other hand Joe has a point that you’re kind of going “BUT WOULD YOU FUCK ‘EM, THOUGH” Like, the only real correct answer is “I’ll do better, you’re right” and I’m not even sure that’s what you’re interested in….?

Fart Captor

…And that means Joe should stop working to improve himself or how he views trans people?

Sajuuk-Khar

I’m sure Joe is deflecting with jokes from a discourse he’s really not sure about and which is laden with mines That or he’s harbored perverse sexual lust for Dumbiverse Danny for years, and who can blame him

Simon Magid

How many trans women does Joe even know? He didn’t seem to have heard of Carla. How could he distinguish between cis and trans women if he doesn’t know any trans women?

Lisa

It's interesting to see the tables turning and Joe being the one who has more to learn. Joyce was putting her foot in her mouth all over the place as recently as two strips ago, but she has the humility to work and improve, and she's a fast learner. Joe would really do well to take a page out of her book and be willing to learn. He isn't even listening when she's telling him, increasingly clearly, that he's being problematic. It's obviously a hard thing to hear. In some ways, Joyce has a head start because she's already internalized the fact that she has harmful habits that she needs to unlearn. ("I also remember that I am usually wrong" from https://www.dumbingofage.com/2020/comic/book-11/01-this-bright-millennium/uses/) Joyce has a solid history of fighting for what's right when the time calls for it. I think she'll do that here shortly. Here's hoping that Joe trusts her enough to listen. I do think she has as better chance of getting through to him than any other character.

Andrea Andrew

Yeah, all these characters have to work on their trans awareness. No wonder Joyce is still a closeted bisexual woman. She doesn’t understand LGBTQ people.

Fart Captor

Carla is loud, skates indoors, and lives in the other wing of the same floor as Joe. He's seen her around, which is all it took for anyone else to get on the list And as Joyce is noting, Carla is very publicly out

Fart Captor

No she really, really is not. Joe included plenty of women he DIDN'T want to fuck on the list So she's right, Carla's exclusion tells a story

Jayne Lindgren

The comments on this one should be fun.

Andrea Andrew

I was referring to the author, but if Walky is hoping to fit into Dorothy’s polycule, he might want to get to know Joe more intimately.

Andrea Andrew

Also, Joe was mostly motivated to change because of Joyce. As I’ve observed, he doesn’t really know half the cast and his interactions mostly stem from their friendships with Joyce.

Shane Wegner

If Carla wasn’t on the Would Fuck or the Would Not Fuck list, Joe’s stated explanation of he simply didn’t know who Carla was when making the list holds up.

Avian

This is my issue with it, I think. Genital attraction is a thing and isn't wrong, it just...is? Yeah, he could be a bit better about how he mentally categorizes women in general, but considering his background he is doing well enough for me especially if he continues to try. It mostly seems like this caught him off guard, and he has a good point about his attractions being an awful way to validate ANYTHING. Plus he has very openly admitted that everything about said list was awful and he is making steps to never be that again. Boy is making tons of progress, don't crucify him for stumbling on one issue,

Sajuuk-Khar

I’m on Aeryn’s same page, and like…Okay, so it tells a story, but…that story is a story he is trying very hard to put away? How does it relate to now, and his attitudes on trans people now, that he did not have any on the gross “fuckable” list, besides a blind spot that he should Do Better about? Which…one can intuit he might know? I dunno, it just seems like pulling off a scab with good intentions: it’s still pulling off a scab! Like, could Joe do better by trans people? Absolutely. But I’m not sure what digging into this like…helps, or is for

Shane Wegner

We don’t know how exhaustive the list is. I see two possibilities for list completion- the list had almost everyone and deliberately didn’t make a judgment on Carla, or it’s missing lots of people Joe doesn’t know or didn’t think of. If I had tried to make a list of all women even in just my dorm in college, it would have been missing lots of women. Let alone the women of the dorms to my left and right, the closest thing to wings. Then again, that calculus changes if one of them had made national headlines. Although I had dorm mates that had indeed made national news that I didn’t learn about first semester or even first year. One of Carla’s things is despite the skating people don’t know who Carla is. She’s literally felt the need to make a sign. Maybe Joe did know and is hiding that. Maybe Joe just didn’t know. We’ll see.

Sajuuk-Khar

I mean, love is a valid motivation for change

Jey Siksa

Can a Joe change all his spots? Also she is Ace

Luke T. Shumaker

Joe has also already internalized that the has harmful habits, long before Joyce did. The difference is that until very recently he didn't believe he was capable of unlearning them.

Sajuuk-Khar

In the interests of not giving Joe a free pass, I will say, despite my defense of him below, that crack about retroactive bisexuality is a bit cringe. Like, no, dude. Bad look, bad joke, edging into transphobic. Retract, Mr. Rosenthal. Retract.

Girlycore

It's transphobic to say he's bisexual for being willing to hook up with more than one gender? Malaya is nonbinary, he's accepting that they always were (including when he hooked up with them). Idk what's transphobic about that, but I'm genuinely interested to hear.

joe mcguire

This is a good portrayal of people learning. Both Joe and Joyce are trying to grow and prove their growth, and in a more poorly written story they might have just completely shifted by now and changed completely, but they’re human and humans don’t magically stop being the people they were yesterday. It’s a long grueling process full of backsliding and false starts. That’s why this comic is great, because it doesn’t hesitate to explore all of that.

Sajuuk-Khar

…Fuck! Okay, I got caught up on “retroactively” and “bisexual” and thought in binary terms. That’s stupid, and that’s on me. Now I retract.

Girlycore

Totally understandable! Hope you have a rly good day.

Kelly (they-them)

I probably should just let Willis speak for themself if they want to but eh. I remember a couple of years ago Willis wrote on Tumblr about having trouble writing Slipshines with male/male scenes because he didn't find men attractive. I don't know their current orientation. Their pronouns are he/they so presumably Willis is nonbinary

Girlycore

Some of the comments here have already veered into "Oh so I'm the villain for..." and like, all I can think is HOOBOY the site comments are going to be rough tomorrow

Fart Captor

Eat my ass, Shane. I'm not reading all that

Sajuuk-Khar

Aight I got caught up in the emotionally charged atmosphere and I forgot the whole original context was that Joyce didn’t know where he stood on trans people and her litmus test for this was The List So that’s what this was for: it was her past context. Not a great piece of context to have.

Uniquitous

Everyone's gotta learn, right? Hell, if you don't look back on your past at some point and cringe a little, have you really grown any?

Uniquitous

Which is not to say that Amber wouldn't write an extremely graphic slashfic on the topic...

Astariel

I agree with last panel Joyce. You've been doing so well, Joe. Stop fucking it up!

Seth Aaron Hershman has they/she pronouns

joyce is sure assuming a lot about joe's ability to identify a trans woman on the spot or for that matter her own ability to identify a trans woman from one of joe's descriptions

T Campbell

I suspect there's some more prosaic explanation for Joe's "do" list not including Carla than that (1) he had a tacit "no AMAB" rule when composing his "do list" (plausible, whatever you might think of it) and that (2) his trans-dar pinged Carla during the few times he saw her (much less plausible to me). We can make fun of Joyce for being the last on her hall to realize it, but she interacts with Carla every day. Joe's "Which one is Carla?" from the prior strip seems sincere (which also means he doesn't know that she made the news). Carla is in the girls' hall and seems to "read" pretty feminine, and she doesn't go around telling everyone she's trans--she goes around telling everyone she's CARLA. (And AWESOME, but that is implied by CARLA.) I doubt Joe would've looked beyond the superficial in her case. Superficiality was kind of integral to his identity at that point.

Diane

I saw this comment, went "wait, what is happening today?" Then got down there and just went "oh..."

Diane

No one has commented on the bonus text for today, and I am sad, cause it made me giggle.

Diane

We do know how exhaustive the list is. They talk about it, and how "every single one of us in this resident hall" is on the list. But we don't know for sure Carla is on there, because she wasn't sure if she'd be more pissed if she was, or wasn't on the list, and refused confirmation. Citation: https://www.dumbingofage.com/2017/comic/book-7/04-the-do-list/pissier/

Jasmijn Wellner

Yeah there's a reason I've not been in the main site comment section for a *long* time

Jasmijn Wellner

I don't think we've crossed any lines here so far, but let's maybe not speculate about real people's queerness. This is getting uncomfortably close to "bullying authors and actors into coming out against their will" territory. Willis uses he/they pronouns but as far as I know has not explicitly publicly expressed their gender identity or sexuality, let's just leave it at.

Jasmijn Wellner

(Also the confusion with Walky is part of why people usually call him "Willis" rather than "David"!)

Jasmijn Wellner

I made the mistake of reading the comments.

Sajuuk-Khar

I’m sorry to everyone, I should have considered that the point here was Joyce didn’t know where he stood on this, and her only real point of reference was the list, and viewed through that lens: very suspicious

Avian

Yeah, though her dancing around the point doesn't help, she and him are on good terms, she can just ask him how he feels about it. I'm trans myself and this is just a very common blindspot for people not used to interacting with trans people, one I often see cleared up by simply pointing it out and them going, 'oh dang, you right, I can fix that'. This feels like allyship gone too far to me, I could be reading it wrong though

Kelly (they-them)

In a surprise twist, Joe has literally never even seen Carla on campus and was not aware he had omitted a woman in Read Hall from his incredibly sketchy, sexist, and now abandoned (I assume and hope it's abandoned) To "Do" List However, within this twist, Joe absolutely would have intentionally excluded a trans woman from the list in which he ranked women from negative 0 to 11 on their fuckability because there is a part of him that does not see trans women as women.

Fart Captor

To me it feels like Joyce is doing a good thing by encouraging Joe to reflect and grow proactively. Cis people could stand to do more of it, amongst themselves and not simply waiting to screw up around trans people and make them bring it up

Phil_M

I find it unlikely that Joe hadn't even noticed Carla when he last updated the list; creepy as it was, it apparently covered every female character around the place. He'd put some work in, and as you say, Carla makes a point of being noticeable. I think it's more likely that either he'd picked up news/gossip stories about her or he has uncanny transdar -- and he simply had a "no AMAB" rule. Not very admirable, perhaps, but then the list was hardly admirable.

Phil_M

Remember that Carla's parents are apparently gossip-column-level famous. The fact that they had a trans daughter may well have entered the public domain. (Accidental comparisons to Elon Musk follow.)

Harold

It's been a long time since Willis felt the need to close down the comments section on the main site. He may need to break out the "0 DAYS SINCE EVERYBODY CALM THE FUCK DOWN" sign for this one.

Tom @ Magic Chopstick Games

Me, opening the door and walking into the comments with a huge smile on my face and a stack of pizzas in my hands

David M Willis

This one took me a long time to figure out, but no, Andrea Andrew, the bonus text under the strip is not always something I personally am saying. and even if so c'mon it'd be saying my dick is pansexual, which i'm pretty sure falls under the umbrella anyway

Maude Reads Things

Not too often that happens on this section. Tomorrow will be interesting on main

Maude Reads Things

Joyce confirms here Carla wasn't on it though. So either Joe has truly never seen her in which case no foul but I don't envy his inevitable pie-ing OR he knows of her but deliberately left her off which. Would be bad.

Moonrunes

Oh sorry, I was focusing more on the "That tells a story comment" rather than trying to oompa there was no need for growth with Joe. Obviously Joe now isn't the same Joe that was Joe in the before times, back when we had a Twitter and you could get a McDouble for a buck.

Moonrunes

I meant *imply there no oompa but I'll leave my shame for all to see

Girlycore

OR - Carla was on there and was titled something that no one pinged was Carla. Though I don't know why she wouldn't be "redhead on wheels" or something similar, it's still a possibility.

Diane

It does seem like Joyce recalls Carla not being on the list with her stating they were all cisgender women. And you know she looked through the list thoroughly as she was looking for anyone else that was a 0 minus.

T Campbell

If he'd picked up news/gossip about her, then he'd know her name. And if something's uncanny, that makes it less likely by definition. We'll see in the fullness of time, though, probably not for weeks.