Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

the hierarchy of ethics in the dumbiverse is about to change

Files

Comments

Misty Rose

Lol yeah Dorothy that would make you worse, but it's ok your just bisexual 😉 probably

C.T. Phipps

Honestly, Joe is 100% right here and Dorothy carrying around that kind of hidden disdain for him was never healthy.

Crunchos cereal

Dorothy, you know that is not very good reasoning. Embrace the attraction (and Joyce)!

Sajuuk-Khar

It’s true, Joe, but you maybe shouldn’t say it. 🤣

Jeremy AR

Funny how amongst her reason she can't be into Joyce she doesn't mention "I am straight".

Amanda Miller

"the hierarchy of ethics in the dumbiverse is about to change" -- this is the best, hope it's actually true and Dorothy and Joe sort through this

C

Look, refusing to self-reflect even slightly during this whole scenario is probably the crux of why you're in this mess. Denial ain't gonna fix this. While a conversation with Joyce needs to happen eventually...perhaps this moment is best spent truly contemplating things.

Tim

Joe, I love you 😂

Andrea Andrew

Wow. Amazing. Another rule of three, and this time, it’s not funny (in a good way). To be fair, Dorothy, you told Joyce and Joe to get together. I agree, Dorothy. Why did you get back together with Walky while you’re falling for Joyce.

IAmDeltaS

Lmaooo Joe isn't wrong!

C

It feels like Dorothy's just refused to even allow herself to consider that to be a possibility.

Samantha Becker

Wow honestly I forgot about her and Walky, that's probably not a great sign for them

ArchineerLock

At least Joe seems to be handling this with startling maturity.

Harold

Joe is... helping?

ArchineerLock

Also what's funny is that even if Dorothy finally accepts her own feelings, we still can't even be certain Joyce would reciprocate (although I think it's likely)

C

Yeah...this is going to be quite the mess to untangle. She's gotta tell Walky something (and either end things with him so she's not further treating him this way, or not send boob pics while in a relationship). Of course, Walky might almost welcome breaking up if it meant all his months of teasing were in fact accurate and that he could induldge in the most smug "I told you so" in history.

Julian Williams

Joe might be a bit of a bastard, Dorothy, but self-awareness gets you ahead in some ways!

Sky Starlight

Probably the same reason she told Walky to ask out Lucy.

Andrea Andrew

Joe is being very very understanding of this. Then again, they both are in love with Joyce. They can very much relate on that front.

Harold

Dorothy is either going to turn around and punch Joe as hard as she can, or dissolve into helpless laughter over the absurdity of the situation. Possibly both.

crufl

lotta reckonin' going on today

Jayne Lindgren

I hate Joe. I can't stand him, and I hate every moment he's "onscreen." I find it very annoying that he's become such a central character, and that so much of my favorite characters' (Joyce, Dorothy) stories have come to revolve around him. This isn't a problem with the writing. I buy his growth, and I think he's a genuinely more interesting and good character than he used to be. But that doesn't mean I have to like him, or want to see more of him. And he's very popular, which further makes me feel like the asshole because I'm like "Ugh, Joe" while almost everyone else is going "Yay, Joe!" Which ironically puts me in the same place as Dorothy, who's made pretty clear she wouldn't associate with him if she had the choice. Which she's allowed to do! You can think she's being unfair, but he was, until very recently, a huge misogynist asshole, and women aren't jerks for not wanting anything to do with men like that - even after they improve. (Becoming a better person still doesn't entitle you to demand women's attention, folks.) Unfortunately for Dorothy, Joe is now an important part of the life of someone she's close to, so she has the impossible choice of putting up with someone she doesn't like or losing an important relationship. It's not fair, and maybe there's a perfect way to navigate it, but I feel like she's done her best even as she's dealt with her own mental health struggles. And this isn't even some stupid shipping war thing. Yes, I think Dorothy and Joyce are cute and I'm pleasantly surprised we're actually addressing it rather than just having it be cute subtext. But I don't hate Joe because I think he's standing in the way of a couple I'd prefer, I hate Joe because I hate him. And shit like this, where he's kicking Dorothy while she's down (I don't care if he's meant to be teasing here, I think it's still a huge dick move) is part of it.

Ragtime

Didn't Dorothy criticize Joyce for having an "I'm better then everyone" kind of atheism?

C

Definitely feels like it's easier to see other people's issues than one's own at times.

Noelle Eve Palmer

heartbreaking: worst person you know keeping it in their pants

Tom @ Magic Chopstick Games

I feel like Dorothy is half a panel from having her mouth widen so much that the top half of her head separates and floats away, Bill-Plympton-style

Maude Reads Things

Oh god. This is getting stressful for her. XD Y'know, Dorothy, if you acknowledge whatever feelings may be there it may be easier to process them and consciously decide not to act on them if that's what you want

Ouri Maler

There's a qualitative difference between "I'm better than everyone who doesn't subscribe to my views" and "I'm better than this one specific asshole I've had to put up with since high school".

Inquiring Raven

Honestly, as much as this can feel like a kick her while she’s down moment… Dotty really needs something to force her to be introspective and evaluate what she wants to move forward in. Dotty needs an Uncle Iroh moment “who you are and what you want” and oddly enough Joe just might be the person that grew enough to offer it. (After all, Iroh was leading a crusade to conquer a nation and oppress a people before he grew as a person…)

Rob McBobson

Oh yeah, I've been there... The feeling in my head saying "Hey, you know this person you feel superior to morally? Did you ever consider that you're actually committing less good actions, and more bad actions, than they are? In other words, do you have any actual reason to consider yourself morally better than them?"

Phil_M

I don't think Joe is meant to be deliberately kicking Dorothy while she's down there. I think that his mouth ran ahead of his superego's control, which is a recurrent problem for him. Lack of self-control when there's an obvious, easy, and wrong option is more or less his central flaw. And "Having to put up with people you dislike or despise for the sake of associating with people you value" is pretty much a stock theme of this comic. I'm not sure that's deliberate so much as something inherent in the comic's basic idea; a campus full of characters with a huge diversity of flaws and peculiarities, who keep making bad decisions. (Which is not to say that I think anyone should feel obliged to associate with people they dislike. Being able to choose your social group is one of the benefits and pleasures of adulthood. Though you do still tend to end up associating with some people you dislike, because the alternatives somehow seem worse and life is messy. Hey ho.)

Mark

It was never hidden.

Phil_M

Yeah, I did like Joe's line in panel 2.

Phil_M

Trying. (Very trying for Dorothy. *rimshot*)

Phil_M

Honestly, Dorothy and Walky has never looked like a romance for the ages. They already broke up once; Dorothy only went back to him as an act of more or less conscious self-destructiveness, and Walky agreed because he's a lazy little sod who likes the sex and is awestruck by Dorothy. (Note: I may be biased here. I think that Dorothy is a likable, relatable character, and Walky is a pratt. I'm with Booster on this.)

Andrea Andrew

I think she does want to act on them, but she feels she can’t.

Phil_M

Given what Dorothy said to Booster when he pointed out that she was too good for Walky, I think that she only when back to him because it's a subtler and cheaper form of self-destruction than booze or drugs.

Andrea Andrew

Oof. That’s a harsh blow to Walky, but probably accurate.

Phil_M

She's more or less skated straight over the question of whether she might be bisexual and got straight onto angsting about the ethics of her actions and her self-image. Given her sociopolitical position, she couldn't actually admit to worrying about whether she might be, even if it did actually cause her any stress or confusion. (Of course, implying that being bisexual might automatically imply pursuing relationships with two people simultaneously would also be Wrong, because it might suggest that bisexuals are automatically unfaithful.)

Phil_M

To be fair to Dorothy on that one, the problem isn't so much that Joyce thinks her atheism makes her better than other people, than that she's so rude and silly about it. If you cornered Dorothy, she'd probably have to admit that she thinks that atheism is smarter than faith - but she doesn't go round snarking at believers with no provocation.

Phil_M

I dunno. If someone told me I was as much fun as booze or drugs, I'd probably take it as a compliment. On the other hand, yes, I'd hope that I was less destructive than either of those.

Andrea Andrew

I recently found an edible brand called before sex. Make of that what you will.

Andrea Andrew

Apparently, her declaration to Danny was something she already rethinked.

Wednesday Sophia

but seriously babes yall should maybe close the door

Jeremy AR

It's less she thinks she is better that everyone and more that she holds herself to unreasonable standards.

Jeremy AR

If you don't want to look like the asshole you could just, not mention it?

Michael-Erik

but that would prevent shenanigans

Phil_M

Reminds me of the comment I once saw: "Haagen-Dazs is the ice cream you eat while having sex. Ben & Jerry's is the ice cream you eat instead of having sex".

Railway Series Book Club

i know what joe means when he says "i've yet to send anybody else dick pics" but that wording leaves open the implication that he may have already sent some to Joyce? which, if that has in fact happened, would be a such a funny plot point to just gloss over that i hope that is what's happened (even though looking at the actual timeline there's probably no room for that to have happened, rip)

Astariel

I wish one of them would close the door. Dorothy doesn't need the whole hall listening to her meltdown. I can just see Becky showing up in the doorway right as Dorothy finally admits that she's into Joyce.

Joe360

Considering the behavior of Joe until recently, the disdain was rather warranted.

Jay Bee

I appreciate that Joe's growth doesn't stop him from being petty

Erin Jonaitis

oh my god Dorothy's faces!! I hope you had SO MUCH FUN drawing this

Kelly (they-them)

That last panel is the kind of needling you only get in long term friendships

Jey Siksa

He...he's a cartoon... A drawing my friend

Jayne Lindgren

@Jey Siksa Suspension of disbelief is a pretty old concept. I'm not sure how you enjoy fiction, but I generally like to react as if it's real within the context of the story. I kind of assumed that was the point. Feel free to disagree with my opinion, but please don't imply I'm crazy for having one.

Sumit

Give yourself some grace, Dorothy.

Sam G

Tbh considering that Dorothy was hitting on his monogamous girlfriend, I'd say that Joe is handling this with a ton of grace. & the "no better than you" comment was kinda out of line? considering the circumstances? Joe is handling things pretty well

Jeremy AR

I don't think that what suspension of disbelief mean.

Jasmijn Wellner

Interestingly, she's not hiding behind "im straight" anymore

Dan Rabin

She said in the oft-linked strip in which she declared herself to be totally straight that this could change. Now that Joe has punctured her habitual self-image, she has moved on quickly.

Rob McBobson

Jeremy: Yeah, "suspension of disbelief" is generally used to mean "accepting fictional things that don't quite make sense but make for an interesting story". Like, if I read a paranormal romance story about two werewolf women in love, it's suspension of disbelief when I accept that werewolves are real in the story, but it's not suspension of disbelief if I get mad at one of them for doing something bad.

Jayne Lindgren

I don't think it's limited to just sci-fi, but all fiction. Fiction in general requires you to treat its subjects as real people with agency, rather than just sock puppets for an author. That's what I mean by suspension of disbelief. It's the difference between criticizing a character for an act vs. criticizing the author for writing that act.

Bronxden

The Joe arc and lore is crazy but also more shocked he never sent mini selfies

Rob McBobson

All I can say is, in my experience "suspension of disbelief" is usually used to mean "accepting unrealistic plot elements," though it's true that doing that can be required in any and all genres of fiction.

Jayne Lindgren

Which is fine. I genuinely don't care what the technical definition is, what I meant is that it seems silly to question treating these characters as real people to have opinions about when that feels like the entire point of this comic and most fiction in general. Especially in such a rude and condescending way. (Not you, the original person) Some people have offered very thoughtful responses that I genuinely appreciate. But at this point I feel like I'm being criticized by a few comments for feeling anything at all, much less having the audacity to post about it in a comment section. (Including a deleted comment that was basically "Shut up") I'd be lying if I said I wasn't at least a little suspicious that of all the comment threads here taking the characters very seriously, it's the one where someone criticized the man where they chose to make a stand. But that might just be my general bad mood and paranoia at... everything that's happening right now in the world coloring things. So, sorry for getting emotional I guess.

Avian

He can be a little petty, as a treat. He has been trying to get better for a while, largely successfully, it's about time the characters in universe at least acknowledged it??

Lea

For what it's worth: I hear what you're saying. And (in my book) you're totally allowed to dislike or outright hate Joe. I think you're allowed to express that dislike. I personally hate who Joe represented, but I'm glad to see how Joe has grown. I have a close-ish friend who is similarly divisive (although having nothing to do with his relationship with women). Some people like spending time with him. Some can't stand him. I can especially understand this, given I've had a few 1:1 with him in which he's shared his extreme self-loathing and depression to the extent of "Once my son hits 18, the world doesn't need me anymore, so then I don't have to be in the world anymore, because the world clearly doesn't want me around." But in public, he covers with a self-confident, self-assured air that protects his vulnerable self. I see someone who's struggling with his sense of self, and who I hope to be able to help with that struggle...just like someone else invested in me when I was struggling. I don't assume anyone has a responsibility to help him this way - and he's never asked anyone to. But that's something I want to put out into the world - to pay forward the investments other have made into me. In the meantime, I host several small community events. And he's always welcomed to those events, whether they're in public, or in my house. And if someone who hates him wants so badly to not be around him that they don't want to attend my events that he's invited to...that's 100% their choice. I will never judge them for that. But I don't have time in my life to manage multiple 1:1 relationships with every person who might want to spent time with me, but doesn't want to tolerate the other people in my life. If he (or anyone else) were insulting, bigoted, condescending, or putting anyone down, that person would no longer be invited in my space. I insist that my spaces be SAFE. But I can't make every space be COMFORTABLE for everyone's individual preferences. I can kindly remind people to lower their voices, to give other people time and opportunity to speak, to value each others' perspectives. I can offer people earplugs and multiple small groups. But I can't maintain some perfect balance where every one of 5 people get exactly 20% of the talk time, or all use exactly the same volume. Everyone likes to talk about themselves, their experiences, and their perspectives. Someone in my orbit might not like that I'm investing in Person D, thus "forcing" Persons A, B, and C to be around them to be around me. But...the truth is...at some point, Persons A, B, and C were all people other people in my life didn't like being around. But I gave them the opportunity anyway. It's their choice to give that up to avoid Person D and to honor their own values. But I'm not going to give up my own values because of it. Sometimes we just can't have everything we want. And that sucks. But it's not necessarily anyone's fault.

Lea

Also... on the "I'm pretty sure that makes you worse than me": Dorothy has JUST said "If this is true, that's made me no better than you!" She's coming at this from a "You're worse than me, but this might make us - UGH - EQUAL! How insulting and inconceivable!" which is pretty insulting toward Joe (deserved or not). And Joe's response is honestly pretty laid back and easy going in response. (edited to more accurately reflect the directionality of Joe and Dorothy's messages)

Jeremy AR

Yeah she give great hugs.

Grace Serenity

I think she'd rather give herself some Joyce!

Grace Serenity

I think the biggest problem is we've been watching Joe get more mature for years, but it's only been a month or two in universe. Not to mention Dorothy has YEARS of resentment built up because of Danny.

Girlycore

Not "never" just "not while with Joyce"

Girlycore

yeah "I can't be" isn't a strong defense, Dotty.

E

Or Becky appears, with her acute lesbian-senses tingling

Grace Serenity

Joe may have been a sleazy hornball, but I'm pretty sure he's only been with women that are single.

Taffy

It's everything (Dorothy-related) I ever wanted.

Girlycore

I think this is all totally fair, and I'm not sure why people are acting like you're crazy tbh. The whole "omg it's just a comic" or "you shouldn't talk about it then" can really be flipped right back at the people critiquing you: If you don't like this person's opinion, or you don't think it's that serious, then... just don't say mean things to them? They're allowed to hate Joe, it does no harm for them to have feelings about art.

Taffy

Unbeknownst to all of us, Joe and Joyce have been sending each other crotch pics ever since the Macaroni Incident. Like every chance they get.

Dan Rabin

Brief visual comments first, then character/plot. Visuals: Nice symmetrical layout, with a very pivotal borderless panel in the center as Dorothy puts together a correct map of the situation in terms of Dorothy-nature. Willis drew nice little tufts of hair where Dorothy's hands grip her head. She's not just doing the "my head hurts" gesture—she's doing it *hard* The four Joe faces and the five Dorothy faces are all different. Dorothy starts with crossed arms (defensive against the message), then fists (aggression against the messenger), then her head hurts as she moves to super-effective introspection. Character/plot: Joe returns to his initial question, which was NOT "are you a lesbian?" but specifically, "are you into Joyce?". In other terms not "how shall I classify you?" but "what is your side of this particular situation that concerns me and Joyce?" And Dorothy comes around to confronting the real question. "It can't be!" is a response to the ethics of the situation, in core-Dorothy terms. Whether Joe had this in mind or not, part of Dorothy's depression has been her failure to value core-Dorothy values amidst the loss of her superficial-Dorothy ambitions and behaviors. Her head hurts, but it's the head of the Dorothy that Joyce will always love, and I hazard a guess that she will move forward as this Dorothy, not as the blurry swirling depression-impaired Dorothy of late. She might even feel some gratitude towards Joe, as might Joyce—but I'm extrapolating too far ahead for this unfolding situation. Another emerging loose end is whether Joyce will be shown the picture in question. It's really up to Dorothy: Joe will not now proceed without her permission (IMHO). This a brilliant sequence. I don't feel a need for the usual how-much-do-I-pay-for-TWO-days-ahead request: it's very rewarding having the time to savor each strip as it drops.

Girlycore

Unfaithful or polyamorous, but yes still incorrect as an assumption. I doubt sincerely that her "sociopolitical position" is playing into her feelings about her own personal sexuality. You can believe that everyone deserves rights and that there's nothing wrong with any sexuality while still panicking about your own.

Taffy

The most Becky would do is say "Aha! I knew it!" and razz her a little bit. She wouldn't even tell Joyce if Dorothy asked her not to.

Uniquitous

If Dorothy did manage to steal Joyce away, that'd be pretty much the ultimate burn on Becky.

Kazo

which is why I think Becky hates sexual fluidity so much

C

A part of me thinks Becky could almost bond with Dorothy over their shared Joyce crush...so long as Dorothy doesn't actually succeed...though, even then, I feel like Becky would try to get over those hurt feelings for Joyce if nothing else.

Uniquitous

I think she falls into the same kind of trap with sexuality that Walky does vis-a-vis masculinity. That there are all these dumb little rules and qualifications. Hell, that's pretty much the premise of the strip: realizing that all these shitty little expectations are bullshit that keep you from being happy.

Shane Wegner

It would also mean giving trusting, vulnerable, barely-ready (but consenting) Joyce not so much as a nudge, but a shove towards the Washing Machines Incident had overtones of self gratification bordering on predatory. Joe took things slower and more carefully with Joyce, having her set the pace, than you did Dorothy, if you want another comparison. I know a lot of people ship Dorothy really hard, but I'm potentially willing to believe she really is straight or straightish as she described herself.

holdinglines

Gotta say I’m really loving Joe and Dorothy’s dynamic. It’s not like GOOD in a sense (as in Dorothy clearly has an image of Joe she won’t let him move away from) but it’s good in a drama sense. Them having known each other for so long hasn’t been touched on all that much and it’s REALLY FUN seeing it now

C.T. Phipps

Denial is not just a river in Egypt.

Maude Reads Things

Hence "if that's what you want". If not, that's something to figure out

Bagge

Fine, Joe has earned that one

PaperRabbits

Same. I think this is her turning her care towards joyce into something self destructive as opposed to actual desire/interest in Joyce in that sense.

PaperRabbits

I mean, she arguably shouldn't. Joyce is in a committed monogamous relationship with Joe, and Dorothy is with walky.

PaperRabbits

> nd shit like this, where he's kicking Dorothy while she's down (I don't care if he's meant to be teasing here, I think it's still a huge dick move) is part of it. Your bias against him is showing here. Dorothy has known him for years yet is clearly mis-representing him here to make her feel better to some degree about not liking him. Joe as we've seen so far has always been open about not wanting commitment and has never cheated on a partner. Not only that but she's openly saying to his face exactly how little she thinks of him, when she IS actively being worse than him here. If Dorothy was a dude, this entire thing would be wayyyy more criticized.

Phil_M

I’m sure that he’d point out that there was nothing “mini” about them.

PaperRabbits

> I'd be lying if I said I wasn't at least a little suspicious that of all the comment threads here taking the characters very seriously, it's the one where someone criticized the man where they chose to make a stand. Again, you're conflating two things. You're railing against Joe for making a slightly teasing remark to someone who just essentially admitted to sending his monogamous (HIS FIRST EVER) girlfriend tit pics because she maybe could be into his GF. He's taking it on the chin all things considered.

SkittleE

@Alacrity Don't you have some grotesques to define, Dorothy?

Phil_M

He may have done, but given how unsure he is how “proper” relationships work, and how he’s been tiptoeing around Joyce’s virginal sensitivities, I doubt that he’d risk it. If and when he and Joyce do the deed, and Joyce makes her interest in Little Joe 100% clear, he may start showering her in them hourly, of course.

Smoochie

I’ll be honest. I don’t want Walky to take it well. At all. I want more than anything, that THIS is Walky’s breaking point. Not that Dorothy realized she’s attracted to women, or one specific person, not that Dorothy even sent a boob pic for whatever Walky/Dorothy define under their relationship as cheating, not even that their relationship goes down in flames after getting back together made him look like a whole jerk without any concept of direction beyond ‘you have boobs, I must obey’. I want Walky to not take it well simply because it’s Joyce. Joyce never approved of their relationship, Joyce admonishes him more often than not, he and Joyce’s relationship is perpetually only neutral acceptance-adjacent each other when they aren’t needling one another, one of the few things he put a little effort in for (the comic) Joyce snatched up. Walky can say something grossly immature and everyone shows him disdain. Joyce does and because she’s innocently insensitive, everyone treats it as a teaching moment (as they should). I want this to be thing that breaks him because in a lot of respects, Joyce is to Walky, what Walky growing up was to Sal. The sibling who can do no wrong and is in some odd respects insulated and worried on. I don’t know what a Walky embittered looks like but with Sarah happy because of Tony, everyone in wholesome experiences save for Billie? I want to see it.

Pangab

Omg it’s finally happening

Smoochie

Does this count as Joyce handing Walky yet another L?

Andrea Andrew

Joyce: Dorothy left Walky for me? Nice!

Seth Aaron Hershman has they/she pronouns

i mean becky has all but admitted at this point that the reason sexual fluidity worries her is because she's had a serious lack of stability in her life this last half-year and any change is scary

Leon

I would be inclined to agree if we weren't an inch short of being directly told she has actual desire/interest in Joyce in that sense repeatedly.

PaperRabbits

I mean, I don't see it as kicking her while she's down much given she's spent the last few comics trying to turn this around on him, somehow and also came onto his gf, and also puts the washing machine incident into a new light.