Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The year is 2023! Walky has just taken Amber to dinner with his parents to be his fake girlfriend! Ethan just ran through snow to put his mouth on Asher's mouth! And Joyce has just told Joe that yesterday, she and Dorothy did laundry together, ultimately pulling Joe away to put their mouths on burgers instead of each other's non-mouth body parts.

And instead of showing Joe and Joyce out getting burgers, with Joe demonstrating the gentle burger smashing he is capable of delivering, there was almost a strip where Joe instead asks Dorothy if she's into Joyce.

It's a bold strategy, Cotton! Let's see if it pays off!

   After half-finishing the fourth strip in the sequence, I decide.... nope! Doesn't pay off at all! I need to put these four strips in the trash.

1) I don't even like what these characters are saying! I'm trying to have a big Joe Asks Dorothy If She's Into Joyce without it actually paying off in any way. I try to hedge Dorothy's responses in ways that she can keep on being noncommittal about it later. I'm trying to have a big moment while keeping the status quo.

2) But I can't keep the status quo. Look, once Dorothy is told, hey, you're acting like you like Joyce, and once that's something she considers, I basically can't have fun shipteasing moments where they both go out and get drunk and are accidentally super gay on each other. It's no longer accidental now! I'm removing the capability to do one of my favorite things to do.

3) I am murdering the Joe/Joyce relationship in its crib. They've been dating for no more than a few hours at this point and already I'm throwing a Dorothy bomb in there. That's not fun! And Joe's reasoning at this point makes little sense. If he's going to step aside for Dorothy because Joe's "corrupted" Joyce in any way, Joyce... has to have been actually visibly corrupted. She's not dropping F-bombs yet or even touched a dingdong. She's basically the same as she was yesterday. Joe would first need any ammunition at all for his self-destructive step-aside suggestion.

So I shelve the entire sequence, and don't do any "unused strips" posts on here about them in the meantime because, you know what, I'm probably going to use some of this later. And I did. Sort of. It's quickly very different, as you have seen.

And y'all get this strip instead:

 because goddamn let them have one (1) meal together

And as a result, in the meantime, we were able to have:

-Dorothy's super gay dream about riding a horse with Joyce

 -Dorothy fixing Joyce her favorite meal, for Reasons

 -Dorothy displaying incredible levels of gay pining she doesn't understand yet in the exercise room

 -Ruth and Jennifer taking Dorothy out to karaoke her sexual frustrations

 -Joyce taking Dorothy out to get drunk so Dorothy can lovingly run her finger up and down her arm

 -Dorothy making her rebound with Walky be all about Joyce for some reason

-Dorothy... helping Joyce chart out her sexual experiences with/for her

-Dorothy sending back a photo of her tiddies, for joke reasons

-and probably way more i'm forgetting just now

 got two years of some primo stuff cuzza shelving those four strips when i did

we were almost robbed

Files

Comments

Girlycore

This is actually wildly helpful to see as an aspiring author. Thank you for sharing not just your unused strips, but the thought processes that led you to drop them and the outcome instead!!

Noelle Eve Palmer

With the Joyce/Dorothy relationship, I really do appreciate having Daisy practically say to the screen "it will be addressed" when she's reviewing Joyce's comics. It alleviates a lot of the typical worries with this kind of thing for queer subtext!

Dan

OK the horse dream one is absolutely hilarious

Jey Siksa

Yeah, as much as Joe is scared of himself and messing up with Joyce, he isnt gunna talk her like a commodity to be traded or taken off his hands by Dorothy

Packy Anderson

I keep saying it: I love process posts.

Packy Anderson

But it's good that he's acknowledged Dorothy's obvious (to everyone but Joyce) attraction. He's not trying to steer her away, but also not stepping aside. If Dorothy were to pursue Joyce that way, the decision would be up to Joyce.

Jey Siksa

@Packy Anderson "Im here to offer to step aside from, Joyce if..if you want her" Second strip fifth panel in the alternate timeline

C

Man, it definitely was a net benefit to build towards this even more than just jump right there. That said, I'm looking forward to seeing Dorothy's journey when it comes to other women.

Andrea Andrew

I knew that stare in the gym was Dorothy being super gay!

Andrea Andrew

Well done! This is very inspirational for a writer.

Sajuuk-Khar

I’m glad you dropped ‘em and glad you brought them back in a more complete form! AND ALSO, THE OT3 POTENTIAL WAS THERE EVEN BACK THEN

Packy Anderson

Ah, but will bonus strips of Mike still cuddle me in the spoon position? 😁

Andrea Andrew

Joyce/Dorothy (in Thanos voice): I am inevitable.

PaperRabbits

Holy shit, seeing how you almost Nuked Joe/Joyce gave me HEART PALPITATIONS omfg

Andrea Andrew

I guess you could say Joe/Joyce almost ended up being Ethan/Danny.

Kelly (they-them)

Yeah, and when Dorothy first said "I love you" to Joyce she also wanted to just be friends. Give process posts a couple of traumas and a big time skip and we'll see if they still just want to be friends

Vivian

I don't think I noticed the finger tracing along Joyce's arm at the bar, that scene was already really intimate but wow

Populuxe

I’m just an idiot reader going “hurr hurr tiddies” so it always amazes me how much thought goes into writing these, and how much better it is because of it.

Vivian

Oh my gosh, that's so good! At some point I'll have the disposable income to have DoA on my shelves 😤

Jasmijn Wellner

I definitely appreciate that we didn't get Dorothy deadass going "joyce's crush on me is useful". That would have been so cold and calculating, it doesn't feel like her at all. Not to mention that the comment sections would have been such a bloodbath I would have to stop reading the comments on here for a month.

Railway Series Book Club

My favorite moment we would have missed out on had these cancelled strips come to pass is actually right before the wordless strip of Exercise Pining, where when Joyce is telling her she's happy Joe said she's a hot chick, Dorothy is like "finding you, Joyce Brown, sexually attractive, is a low bar to clear, and anybody would think that". What a heterosexual thought to put out there into the world, Dotty!

Grace Serenity

I love those "There is no straight explanation for this" things!

PaperRabbits

I would cry, I've been begging for jo/joyce since ancient willis times.

Andrea Andrew

It seems, however, that Joyce/Dorothy will happen.

Dan Rabin

This comic almost always wins by having long-running Chekhov's guns, such as the still-untriggered Jordan Brown. I think a long-running novelistic entertainment needs these to give the author many options for keeping the entertainment running long.

Crunchos cereal

Oh! I had almost forgotten Joyce’s comics! The attraction seems to be mutual, too, so this is not just Dorothy. (Well, there are other things than just the comic strip pointing in this direction…)

Berry

... please don't tell me this bodes badly for Joe/Joyce because I love these two together. They balance each other out so well.

Alexandra Falk

Oh geez. Oh man. Thanks for making the choices you've made so far... and for giving us this level of behind-the-scenes!

Giant Speck

Edging us for two years really paid off. In all seriousness, thank you for not having Joe immediately give up on Joe/Joyce. Him being in his first committed relationship is as important to his growth as it is to Joyce's, even if it means it will eventually end.

Julian Williams

I'd say "I didn't notice the obvious gay urges on display" but I think I got so used to implied jokes about Dorothy and Joyce being gay together that when it actually transitioned into Dorothy acting gay by making her favorite meal (which Joe did a few chapters later), constantly talking about how pretty she is, and that extremely ambiguous and open series of panels where Dorothy expresses jealousy over Joe and Joyce flew right by me as "that's just how she acts."

E

Yeah it flew right by me too. It’s so obvious now that it’s all in one place, goddamn

PaperRabbits

When it becomes clear Jo/Joyce is going to sink, I'll likely dip out beforehand. It's the one ship I don't want sinking. Literally any other one I could deal with lmao

Andrea Andrew

So you’re hoping for a polycule?

PaperRabbits

I'm hoping for Amber/Dotty and Jo/Joyce LMAO

Andrea Andrew

But Joyce/Dorothy seems inevitable. The author seems to confirm they will happen and Joe/Joyce is a journey/starting point to there, and considering Dorothy/Joyce starting earlier would’ve ended it earlier...

PaperRabbits

Eh, if it's inevitable I'll be hoppin off the webcomic train when Jo/Joyce sinks. I am very aware that two characters having chemistry doesn't always mean they'll get together either (stares at ethan/danny) But Jo/Joyce is a ship I've been on since ancient times, and I finally have it. I'd love if Dorothy ends up w/ Amber cuz it fits a billion dif ideas in my brain that I've liked in this comic. But this isn't me arguing for one or another, just an acknowledgment I'll likely dip out once Jo/Joyce sinks.

Karel P Kerezman

You made the spectacularly best choice here. Dang, sir, it's almost like you know what you're doing.

Elise

Wait, Ethan and Asher first kissed TWO YEARS AGO?? I’m withering to dust. Also Joe/Joyce are my favorites so thank you for giving them time to breathe 🙏🏻

areyoshi

Legendary collection of strips tbh. It's really nice to have this look back on some of the many hints! I really enjoy JoJo as a couple AND all the potential of Dorothy and Joyce (DoJo?), so I'm in the 'fingers crossed for poly' camp. Joyce's mother would surely hate it very much and that adds to the appeal. And I always love seeing the unused strips, process posts are rad.

Michael Steamweed

Whoo, boy! Those unused strips would have taken the entire story in way different directions than we got. I am glad we got the stuff we did. But it is nice to see what could have been. If only to appreciate the now all the more.

Karl Gallagher

Some real potential for the DorJoJo triad shippers out there.

Sporkaganza

You didn't mention it here, but another thing about these unreleased strips is that Joe and Dorothy are deeply unlikable in them. Not that it's necessarily bad for characters to be like that – Jennifer has been like that from day one to a lot of success and you even sometimes want to root for her in spite of how trash she is – but the way that Joe jumps straight to bargaining over Joyce as if she was an object, and how little resistance Dorothy puts up before accepting that premise, really taints both their relationships with Joyce that the narrative has spent so much time and effort creating.

Sporkaganza

I get what you're saying, but I think Dorothy can be very calculating. She's subtly manipulated Joyce for her own benefit many times. However, she usually uses the self-justification that it's for Joyce's own good because she hates the idea of hurting her, so the way she jumps straight there without any hesitation or guilt would have definitely been OOC. So this is basically a long-winded way of agreeing with you

zaratustra

Well before it was a more general "Dorothy mothers the people she cares about" and now it's a very specific "Dorothy mothers the people she is hornt for"

Stathis N.

I really prefer how it turned out. Great choices. :) That reveal happening 2 years ago would have changed the storyline way too much and really killed an interesting momentum that now exists in the comic.

Robin Garcia

It's hard because for us we see only a few days in a year, so seeing some gay subtext every few months feels negligible. Meanwhile, in the world of the strip, Dorothy is making huge parts of her day about being with Joyce and exploring her feelings that she can't admit to herself. It's not every few months, it's every few hours.

Silas Murray

The "crude naked drawing of Joyce next to paper that says 'fingering'" might be my single favourite joke in the comic. That had me HOWLING.